labour of love judging results


1	Team name	Remixer(s)		Beatmapper(s)				Storyboard/video creator(s)

2	Bowkutoly Encore	Raytoly		Raytoly	gokugohan12468			Agent Encore	BowLL	Raytoly
3	Daniel Gaming	Sooph		Tocorn	phyr			Malishiosu
4	Dolbit Normalno	DestoppeD		NeilPerry	Sing	Mirash		Tommy Phelps
5	Down	Down		Down				Down
6	extremely valid	BilliumMoto	Shinwoir	Mao	DeviousPanda	Realazy		Mao
7	humilde	pm04034		Megafan	ohm002			ohm002
8	Incoherent Sound	takehirotei		Kardshark	[MY]xArief	[-Chocola-]		GhostFY
9	le fishe au chocolat	-Tochi		Acylica	J1_	Lince Cosmico	-Tochi	-Tochi
10	Lovers	XenjeS		XenjeS	adioni	Delette		PantyDev
11	Moyai	SAMString		Aistre	Patrick Cake	Seolv		TheDuckMask
12	Pentangle of Ambivalence	Maemi no Yume		Kalindraz	Sakura Airi			K4L1
13	schoolboy fans	Shadren		Shmiklak	Shadren	Daycore	wajinshu	Shmiklak
14	Team Name	Absolute Zero	Thievley	Gordon	Cheri			Fluffy91021
15	Team Red but Blue	Redside	Noffy	Noffy	Chompy	Zer0-G		Noffy	Tofumang
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
704
705
706
707
708
709
710
711
712
713
714
715
716
717
718
719
720
721
722
723
724
725
726
727
728
729
730
731
732
733
734
735
736
737
738
739
740
741
742
743
744
745
746
747
748
749
750
751
752
753
754
755
756
757
758
759
760
761
762
763
764
765
766
767
768
769
770
771
772
773
774
775
776
777
778
779
780
781
782
783
784
785
786
787
788
789
790
791
792
793
794
795
796
797
798
799
800
801
802
803
804
805
806
807
808
809
810
811
812
813
814
815
816
817
818
819
820
821
822
823
824
825
826
827
828
829
830
831
832
833
834
835
836
837
838
839
840
841
842
843
844
845
846
847
848
849
850
851
852
853
854
855
856
857
858
859
860
861
862
863
864
865
866
867
868
869
870
871
872
873
874
875
876
877
878
879
880
881
882
883
884
885
886
887
888
889
890
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
914
915
916
917
918
919
920
921
922
923
924
925
926
927
928
929
930
931
932
933
934
935
936
937
938
939
940
941
942
943
944
945
946
947
948
949
950
951
952
953
954
955
956
957
958
959
960
961
962
963
964
965
966
967
968
969
970
971
972
973
974
975
976
977
978
979
980
981
982
983
984
985
986
987
988
989
990
991
992
993
994
995
996
997
998
999
1000
1001


1	Musician panel		Mapping panel		Overall panel		Community vote

2	extremely valid	46	extremely valid	55	extremely valid	74	Team Red but Blue	1379
3	Pentangle of Ambivalence	34	Dolbit Normalno	35	schoolboy fans	45	extremely valid	1079
4	Team Red but Blue	26	le fishe au chocolat	29	Dolbit Normalno	42	schoolboy fans	1054
5	Incoherent Sound	20	Moyai	11	Incoherent Sound	39	Pentangle of Ambivalence	963
6	Moyai	18	schoolboy fans	10	le fishe au chocolat	38	Dolbit Normalno	843
7	schoolboy fans	12	Pentangle of Ambivalence	9	Team Red but Blue	33	Incoherent Sound	833
8	Daniel Gaming	10	Incoherent Sound	8	Moyai	31	le fishe au chocolat	643
9	Lovers	8	Team Red but Blue	8	Pentangle of Ambivalence	30	Moyai	430
10	le fishe au chocolat	4	Lovers	7	Lovers	15
11	humilde	2	humilde	4	Daniel Gaming	10
12	Dolbit Normalno	0	Daniel Gaming	1	humilde	2
13	Team Name	0	Down	0	Down	0
14	Bowkutoly Encore	0	Team Name	0	Team Name	0
15	Down	0	Bowkutoly Encore	0	Bowkutoly Encore	0
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
630
631
632
633
634
635
636
637
638
639
640
641
642
643
644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686
687
688
689
690
691
692
693
694
695
696
697
698
699
700
701
702
703
704
705
706
707
708
709
710
711
712
713
714
715
716
717
718
719
720
721
722
723
724
725
726
727
728
729
730
731
732
733
734
735
736
737
738
739
740
741
742
743
744
745
746
747
748
749
750
751
752
753
754
755
756
757
758
759
760
761
762
763
764
765
766
767
768
769
770
771
772
773
774
775
776
777
778
779
780
781
782
783
784
785
786
787
788
789
790
791
792
793
794
795
796
797
798
799
800
801
802
803
804
805
806
807
808
809
810
811
812
813
814
815
816
817
818
819
820
821
822
823
824
825
826
827
828
829
830
831
832
833
834
835
836
837
838
839
840
841
842
843
844
845
846
847
848
849
850
851
852
853
854
855
856
857
858
859
860
861
862
863
864
865
866
867
868
869
870
871
872
873
874
875
876
877
878
879
880
881
882
883
884
885
886
887
888
889
890
891
892
893
894
895
896
897
898
899
900
901
902
903
904
905
906
907
908
909
910
911
912
913
914
915
916
917
918
919
920
921
922
923
924
925
926
927
928
929
930
931
932
933
934
935
936
937
938
939
940
941
942
943
944
945
946
947
948
949
950
951
952
953
954
955
956
957
958
959
960
961
962
963
964
965
966
967
968
969
970
971
972
973
974
975
976
977
978
979
980
981
982
983
984
985
986
987
988
989
990
991
992
993
994
995
996
997
998
999
1000
1001


1	entry	DTM9 Nowa	Garden	Icekalt	Kalibe	Luscent	Mordred	NyarkoO	Sonnyc	Uberzolik	xbopost	Zelq	yaspo	Aquestion	Celektus	Dictate	VINXIS	Will Stetson	Kuba Oms

2	Down	Is this entry impressive? You could say so with the one man army of Down. I would consider this to be impressive in some sense. Do I like the outcome though? Not really. The remix is one-dimensional and a bit unsettling in some sense however if the verses were a bit more interesting instead of just using the same rhythm and effects all the time, it could actually work really well because the chorus is still pretty cool. Storyboard is what it is, I didn't really like it. Mapping is good but pretty bland at times.	no comment	no comment	contact for comments	huge meme entry, I appreciate the fact that he has done everything though	I'd expect a bundled map to have a spread regardless of length (applies to all entries that don't have a full spread, just putting this in the first row because yea); sb is funny but the remix is not it; map is pretty basic but ig that's because the remix doesn't allow for too much	Down (4694602) Can't say that I expected much from a meme entry. The song gets incredibly annoying/repetitive after a few listening sessions. I have no clue what Pippi gulping a bunch of Chili Peppers in the Storyboard has to do with anything LOL Down (4694602) the map is just about the type of average mapping that you'd expect on songs like this. I have no clue how Down mapped all 4:19 minutes of this, but I seriously respect him for that LOL	Nice mash up between Korean music and My Love. I can see the main focus was on creating an interesting gameplay based on flow choice. Those intention was well done mainly with the slider velocity & curve rate choice. While the map felt fun to play, it felt way too repetitive at the same time. Each combo felt too similar to capture the detailed layer of the music. Showing more interpretation towards the song by using multiple pattern combinations would make this more interesting expression wise. Overall, it kinda feels like somewhere between a funny entry and a serious mapping attempt. I think the map needs a clearer identity than now.	Weird storyboard, I expected it to follow up more on the gag in some form. Maybe I don't really get its' context, I dunno. Map itself was really dull and repetitive though, which is a bit expected given the remix.	Funny, but I dont think contest with such a big prizes is proper place for a jokes. Map looks boring: primitve patterns, poor aesthetics, no contrast between parts of the song and the resulting weak representation of song. Even in a gameplay wise it's just a comfortable map, but i dont think its enough to claim victor. Overall hard to say. Looks like meme entry.	>Good meme did laugh but didn't put anywhere	Unfortunately the chili peppers in the storyboard are about the spiciest thing here. Remix-wise there's only one new melody introduced which sounds very offtune with the vocals. As result there's not much to offer mapping-wise, it rarely feels like the maps actually changes its design notably alongside the song. Especially intensity changes are straight-up missing. There are some rhythm changes but honestly they contribute very little into improving the map's design. It's a nice effort but, even if it had a spread, compared to your insane competition this falls below the bar :< The storyboard is .. something else and changes just as little I just hope pippi will be okay after eating all these peppers	キムチ感のある曲になってました。	Remix quality: Very basic repetitive song, seems to be out of key which does not really fit the vocals in terms of mood. Production and mix are decent although there's basically only 3 synths. Mapping quality: Very basic mapping with slightly arbitrary rhythms and hyper consistent spacing. Overall decent to play, but very boring and represents the song ok. Overall: Has a basic hand drawn storyboard, overall very basic and relatively cohesive... also the song is literally a korean meme so lol good one https://youtu.be/HDktg4yN4-o	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
3	Team Name	I'd like to like these kinds of amateur covers but I need to be real when it comes to judging like this and say that it's absolutely holding the entry back. There are some nice features in the mapping and in the simple storyboard but nothing outstanding which I would be looking for in the entries. Spreadwise hard has a lot consistency issues when it comes to spacing usage and having stupidly intense "calmer" sections. How do you end up mapping the beginning about 87 times as intensely as the main chorus? The 1/4 rhythm usage is a bit too much in both drop sections for this diff level I think. Additionally 01:42:952 (4,5,6) - 01:42:952 (4,5,6) - these patterns in a hard diff wouldn't get ranked any day. Normal seems nicer but has a really tough second drop(?) and this 02:25:702 (1,2,3) - stuff isn't really fitting either.	no comment	no comment	contact for comments		00:38:667 (8,1) - etc not a fan of those at all; lyrics go offscreen on every resolution that isn't the max; not a fan of the remix either, especially 01:07:917 - 02:30:202 - these parts; the map itself is ok tho aside from the combo colors	Gordon (7856835) This entry is quite funny to me, personally. Although it has a full set, the mapset isn't all that interesting, and the music production in both the instrumental and vocals is so amateur that it somehow makes it endearing. Overall the music video is quite cool, but the amateur production and bland mapset really brings this down. Gordon (7856835) This entire mapset is in general very bland, and while the rhythm choices and gameplay is fine, there's basically zero creativity to be found here.	The way how the vocal sounds created some emotional mood, which was nice to listen. Cool background art as well. About the map, I can see that you put a lot of effort on creating a smooth playability. It worked well, but I think the map didn't offered anything beyond that. The map is playable, but that was it. If you can focus more on the musical feature that only this song has and show them in the map, it will be more representative for this song. Also Normal has some experimental spacing choice, which was highly questionable.	Cute video! I really like what you did but it's a bit of a shame that osu! screws up the video quality. Set itself was really unremarkable though. The Insane feels really incohesive (you can really easily tell its a collab due to how wildly differently designed the sections are), and a huge chunk of it winds up being a rather dull distance snap map. Hard and Normal are fairly standard, but they're nice. Not much else I have to say.	Nothing to say here. Looks like a novice's map. No strucrue, no patterns, no ideas, but the main issue is song representation. I mean most of the interested moments in song was mapped in a generic way. 01:07:917 - 01:35:345 that part can be mapped more intersting. Even if your goal was to map an Insane diff as top diff there is still too much different ways how to make that part more creativity — reverse slidershapes progression, spacing progression, variatvity of shapes but not a just straight sliders with a boring flow. Also remix itself is too quiet and hitsouds overlap song that affect a lot to an overall impression. Other difficulties fit spread and its good but in mapping wise it's difinitely not a winner's entry. Overall: Amateur map. Compare to other entries mapping and storyboard ideas seems not imperssive at all.	>The remix doesn't sound too dope >Top diff isn't too cohesive >Hitsounding should be polished for sure >Interesting BG >But not so much the mapping itself :c >Personally like adding own vocals instead	Very cute everything here Pretty happy that the lower diffs incorporate some of the more complex rhythm to fit the track and overall have a basic but working design. Similarly for the Insane, though I feel like a lot of ideas here are left unfinished. Especially the chorus seems to try to make itself stand out, but without an increase in intensity or complexity it comes across as pretty flat. For an Insane it also doesn't really match the nuances of the song enough for me. Refer to 01:33:631 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - lacking build-up intensity, 02:49:060 (1,2,3) - not bringing out the wubz in any way or 02:37:060 - being boringly distance snapped. ALSO don't copy paste choruses in a huge contest entry D: ! You could frame this as the Insane not being well polished .. or just the set lacking some kind of Expert difficulty. Missed potential, imagine if 01:07:917 - wasn't just reverse sliders. Hitsounding follows a similar trend, workable but basic, at least a custom kick would've been nice. I do really love the storyboard, changing the iconic-feeling background to follow along the song fits very well while also not being distracting. Especially helps enhance the idea of the song switching from sweet and innocent to rather complex. Also a quick mention to how sick it is that this entry has its own vocalist. While on paper an obvious idea to try, -actually- doing it makes the entry 1000 times more personal and unique. In the overall picture I do really feel like the different parts don't really come out on their own right, so they don't enhance each other either. Cool work, but it's not in the race for me.	ボーカルが素晴らしかったです。間奏のボーカルチョップの部分が好きでした。	Remix Quality: Relatively basic EDM song with somewhat decent vocals. Production and mixing could improve a lot, vocals and some specific sounds are way louder than everything else and the vocal chops I think don't really think fit with the singers voice being otherwise not edited at all. Mapping quality: Rhythms of the top diff are a bit arbitrary, they mostly follow the vocals, but there are some unfitting/overmapped ¼ rhythms. Otherwise relatively low consistent spacing, somewhat inconsistent visual spacing etc.. Hard diff might be a bit too rhythmically dense for AR7, there’s too many arbitrary consecutive ½ jumps. Normal diff has some patterns where the order of objects for newer players is going to be confusing. Overall very basic and somewhat rough. Overall: Somewhat below average, but the participants put in some effort which is noticeable. The addition of a singer was somewhat unique.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
4	Pentangle of Ambivalence	Mapping is rather good in this entry and I'd like the storyboard as well if it wasn't for the overbearing amount of hearts and flashes. Spreadwise there are some mistakes in my eyes in the lower difficulties. The remix certainly feels to be the worst part in my opinion with the really high pitched vocals and instrumentals, it does not sound nice to listen to. And as a note you seem to be continuing the trend with specific sliderarts from the aspire 2018 entry which is not a good thing in my books even though this time you won't waste the whole intro into that idea. Diff names also hurt me internally	no comment	no comment	contact for comments	well done	I literally can't hear the hitnormals; if you like this kinda music that's cool but imo sb, remix, and map are all too overdone, sometimes I can't even see what's going on in the map because the sb is so flashy	K4L1 (11334594) An incredibly cool Future Bass Remix with a great spread and a cool Storyboard. One thing that's bothering me quite a bit about the Remix is how quiet the Custom Hitsounds are, kinda making it hard to follow the songs, especially at 00:24:052 with this chord progression. The chords are done in such a way that they don't ACTUALLY start on the tick, they fade into it, making it very hard to follow. K4L1 (11334594) The Chord Progression here at 00:24:052 is really bad at communicating the rhythm to the player, making it quite confusing to play around that part. The chords are done in such a way that they don't ACTUALLY start on the tick, they fade into it, making it very hard to follow. Apart from that, the entire mapset is SO well mapped. It oozes with creativity and the gameplay is fantastic.	Liked how the pitch shifts in the remix. Overall, I've got a feeling that the map was trying to be visually appealing. Individual objects are cool, but somehow it wasn't as impressive as a whole map.Thinking deeper about the actual difference in combo design would make something more interesting.	Very nice storyboard. Doesn't get too in the way in gameplay and works really nicely to match the mood of the song (as well as the song itself). The set itself is quite decent; it's a very slider and sv heavy design and I feel for the most part it manages to be tasteful but some of the 1/3 designs were just really poor (especially during transitions) and some of the difficulty balance was really off (like having spaced sliderstreams etc). Honestly my biggest concern would actually be that the Insane is quite a jump up from the Hard. Overall though, the set goes really well together and provides a nice audiovisual experience, even on the low diffs. (Those owo and uwu sliders were pretty forced though ngl)	Actually really hard to "judge" that map. I defenitely like song's representaiton, but visual seems a bit random I guess. I mean interesting ideas (like that part 00:35:699 - 00:52:287, I like it so much) mixed with a things that I hate the most in "woob" mapping (random shapes like this 00:53:699 (1) - 00:59:346 (1) - 01:16:287 (1) - ). Too much different aesthetics in one map. It's affect a lot to creativity in positive way, but consistency is an important aspect too. But you continued that idea with different aesthetics in other diffs and it's fine. Intersting flow = intersting gameplay so its ok in gameplay aspect for me. P.S. 01:00:581 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - (https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/1061072#osu/2221502), 03:16:287 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/519256#osu/1103732 Pretty common storyboard, good hitsounds, song represented well.	>Really weird HSing >Remix is pretty meh >Simple but cool storyboarding >Could use any other BG cuz this one is already ranked? (minor but it's not fresh) >The progression between the diffs isn't too good :c >03:37:111 (1,2,3,1) - on top - they didn't check it properly before submitting :c >Gameplay doesn't feel as impactful even if the rhythms are overly nice	Banger set anyone ? The first thing I'd complain about unironically is the background, it works but isn't memorable at all. Silly background-comments aside, this goes really hard but still has very solid lower difficulties. Insane and Hard are very detailed and varied in their own right, yet fit well within convention. The set ends up feeling built up pretty well. Maybe some spacing changes on Hard would've been nice though, considering the complexity of Insane. In terms of the higher difficulties, I think they're great but sometimes it does feel like there's too many visual bells and whistles that ultimately hurts the mapping a bit. There's an abundance of big and "special" slidershapes. Since there's a different shape for every single synth, other purposes slidershapes like 02:12:758 (1) - 03:31:816 (1) - 02:20:522 (1,1) - 03:39:581 (1,1) - feel like they're part of the idea. Even sliders like 01:19:816 (1) - seem too fast without any real meaning related to the song. Especially feels true for the final section 03:47:346 - , where the map tries to finish strong but kinda bulldozes over the song that way instead. This kind of overly visual approach also ends up creating a lot of incoherent-feeling changes in spacing and intensity. There's patterns with huge spacing like 01:05:346 (1,1,1,1,1,2,1,2,3,4,1) - going into much much smaller ones 01:09:934 (1,2,3,1,1,2,1,2,1,2,3,4,1) - back into big spacing 01:13:111 (1,1,2,3,1) - . Sections like these end up rather unbalanced as a result, it's a lot of looks but not a lot of feel. Lastly, the same for New Combos. If you split up everything into 1-2 note combos then it's hard to really recognize the patterns in your mapping. eg. 01:28:640 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - are there really 3 groups of 2 or just 1 group of 6 ? It's just telling the player "there's a lot of sounds" and not conveying information of the song. The storyboard is pretty insane, there's so many small details that I keep finding every time I go through. What's not so great to me is all the bright flashing that goes on, they're not just distracting but to me they grew genuinely painful to look at. Nonetheless it works great with the song, there's always something going that grab the player's attention. Overall this makes the final product a real spectacle on the surface. Though when you take a deeper look it does make some hefty compromises to accomplish that. A double-edged sword, but I don't hate it.	サビが最高にエモかったです！	Remix Quality: Very decent production, a little more sub and less super highs would make the mix a bit fuller. It's not a incredibly unique song, but there's some interesting changes between section in terms of drum rhythms and I think there's even some modulation (key changes) going on. I wish there could've been more substantial variation in terms of composition, otherwise solid. Mapping quality: Gameplay wise a somewhat mediocre entry. The mapping style fits the type of song pretty well, but it's arguably not very unique and the execution is lacking compared to other entries. The top diff seems somewhat overdone, many of the sliders don't seem to consider slider leniency, the rhythms are mostly ok although there's some disagreeable patterns lastly there isn't much differentiation in terms of intensity between section with the exception of 2:28 maybe. Many criticisms equally apply to the Extra and Insane, particularly the rhythms on the Insane. The Hard with some questionable stacking and combination of spaced and stacked ½ rhythms is somewhat below average, would've been nice if there was more effort put into making it gameplay wise introduce SV changes like in the higher diffs. Overall relatively decent, the style fits, the execution of said style is about average and might be good fun for many people. Overall: With a nice remix, better than average mapset, anime background and cute SB the set overall gives a nice impression.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
5	Incoherent Sound	Surely held back by unclean mapping if anything along with the clear spread issue (maybe even some things in the insane where the concepts do not really fit the frame of an insane really with some of the hard-to-read patterns). Generally a good experience where all the elements still work together well, especially the Remix + SB. A bit more diverse storyboard effects on specific sections would've made it even better though.	no comment	no comment	contact for comments	laggy sb but also super cool, map is great as well	remix is kinda pog but everything else about the map tries way too hard imo, feels like you tried to throw in as many things as possible (tbh that even applies to the remix)	Kardshark (4724315) Placing one step above XenjeS' entry, this entry has an incredibly cool Rhythm Game-type Remix and the SB is SO COMPLEX that it actually murders my framerate, and for a good reason; This SB is Insane! Has two diffs that are both well mapped. Kardshark (4724315) I have to say that while this song offered so many ways to map this in a really cool way, it felt like a lot of it was underwhelming or just didn't express the song well enough. The rhythm choices and gameplay is fine, but it was a little bit lacking in creativity.	I really like how each section of the music plays significantly different in the map. It gives me a good impression both in music reflection, and level design. The biggest complaint would be there isn't enough low diffs for full player range to enjoy, but still this is pretty much interesting mapping wise.	Forgot combo colors :< Also this really doesn't constitute a full spread, but I was told to assume it does. About the storyboard, I'll be honest: I don't think it works very well with this song. The effects are cool, and some of them fit well, but a lot of them just feel like a lot of flashy effects thrown together for the sake of it; visually impressive but little actual direction to make it go together with the song to convey something. As for the map itself, specifically the top diff, the sections themselves don't really mesh that well; sections can range from really simplistic designs to SV heavy slider spam, and while there is some degree of progression, the change is still very sharp in comparison (also honestly, using 1/4 slider spam to try to make the drop more intense doesn't really work that well when you're doing lots of 1/4 cutstreams and high spacing 1/4 beforehand). As for the insane, the difficulty progression was a lot nicer (the way 02:15:465 - gets mapped in the insane works much better as a payoff than in the top diff) but the rhythm choices in sections like 01:08:265 - felt really lackluster and often didn't really convey the song very well. Overall though, the entry is quite decent; the storyboard is still fun to watch and the map itself is alright to play (my poor hands suffered a bit on the streams, but that's my punishment hah)	no comment	>2* gap kinda bad >SB isn't optimalized at all, I can't have good FPS rate in editor :CCCCC https://i.imgur.com/rmNdNuC.png >Map itself seems clean but nothing outstanding what would shock me >Cool remix >Insane is rather average	Default combo colours?! First thing I'll really say is that I'm obviously missing a difficulty (or two) here. The gap between the 5* Insane and 7* top diff is enormous, so the players inbetween don't get to scratch their itch with this. I think the Insane is a proper insane but it does some underlying issues that hurt the experience. It often lacks good playfield usage because the mapping often just strings objects together, creating a rather linear and cramped experience. Best shown with stuff like 03:15:465 - through 03:27:465 - which is 10 seconds of being stuck to the center in one of the most intense sections. Especially if you start comparing sections this way, it's often only rhythm that changes and no other aspects of intensity. Luckily the song has a lot of rhythmically different sections so it's not completely ruined. On the highest difficulty this is also present but less of an issue. Subjectively I'd say that sections like 01:27:465 - would be more energetic if the jumps weren't always built around the sliders. For 03:13:065 - it does stand out to me that the player will just noodling around all the time, which is a shame for a climax. Other sections are lots of fun though and generally the map feels decently well-balanced for being this high in star rating, barring some silly spikes in difficulty. What this map does really excel at to me is having lots of unique feeling sections and enhancing that through the storyboard, playing through felt with storyboard really made me feel immersed. I think it's a combined credit of keeping the map reasonably simple to understand and making the storyboard just Epic. Combine this with the track going absolutely ham, I felt like I was on a trip through the galaxy with this one - holy, really cool. The whole is quite a bit more than the sum of its parts .. or it would be, if it wasn't missing a part between the two difficulties.	疾走感抜群で音ゲーらしいリミックスになってました！ベースドロップなど展開に工夫があって聞いてて楽しい曲でした。	Remix Quality: The production is a little rough, the song overall is too compressed, the 2 khz range could be cut a bit and some of the synth sounds could sound cleaner etc. In terms of composition the song is somewhat basic although it's very energetic and has a lot of variation. What was missing the most in my opinion were more calm sections or build-ups to make the song feel more meaningful and break up the constant high pace. Mapping quality: The spacing and overall management of intensity on boths diffs is rather rough, especially on the top diff spacing changes and angles seems somewhat arbitrary, spacing out of sliders especially while stream spacing is often times way too high compared to the intensity of other parts. I appreciate the attempt at making somewhat more interesting patterns (especially in the lower diff), but sadly the inconsistent execution makes them lack, patterns like at 2:10 end up being rather unpredictable difficulty spikes. Overall: Interesting set, the remix has a nice rhythm game vibe to it even if a little rough, the best part is arguably the SB (although I'm not an expert so I can't see if it's say just some basic stuff or not), the unrankable spread is an issue, but besides all that ok entry, hope people enjoy it.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
6	Daniel Gaming	Would've probably been a surprising contender if this had a better storyboard. The map seems to be above average most of the time and the remix is really nice for the top diff, the insane is certainly not an insane at times even if the map is cool. Also aside the other general issues in hard the AR 9.3 is kinda XDD	no comment	no comment	contact for comments	rip particles in sb…. fine map overall	your hard diff is literally ar9.3 od9.2; cs6 alt maps are not it; insane diff has some really questionable patterns; giga unfitting bg; remix is ok tho	Malishiosu (12521528) Very solid entry with a mapset that I quite dig, the mapping itself is sick. The Remix is okay, and the SB is very simple. Overall a quite inoffensive entry. Malishiosu (12521528) A cool mapset with good rhythm choices, good creativity, and gameplay. Quite standard.	I appreciate the effort to make things feels special, as I can see there were multiple intentions placed behind each objects. However, identifying the main feature of each section was a bit vague to make those intentions actually work. Viewing the map and the song in a larger view would help delivering your intention more effectively.	Why is Reimu in the bg?? Storyboard is very simple, doesn't really relate to the song though. Top diff doesn't really use the screen very well, feels like lack of experienced combined with cs6 making it increasingly obvious. Suffers a lot from repetitiveness as well since every section winds up mapped with the same sort of movement and sv usage. Needs better intensity management. Insane has some interesting rhythm usage and is quite well done, but there might be some sections that are quite a bit too hard for an Insane, still fun though. Hard diff on the other hand feels like it took too many cues from the Insane diff without considering that downscaling them doesn't work nearly as well; the lack of rhythm density just makes the Hard diff confusing and not very engaging in sections like 01:42:411 - . Normal has way too much goofy slider usage, feels like the mapper doesn't really know very well what elements are actually difficult and relevant in a Normal.	I like flow on top difficulty. Aesthetics and structure solid as well, but some patterns seems a bit rough for me (01:02:411 (1,2,1,2) -, 01:00:011 (1,1,2) - , 01:13:211 (1,2) - ). Can't say I like Insane diff as much as top, because you used absolutely different slider shapes (01:44:011 (1) - 01:44:411 (2) - 01:46:811 (2,3,4,5) - ), pattering and flow, but anyway I gonna put it to my top 5 list. On Hard diff rhythm choice in that part (02:40:011 - 03:05:611 - ) seems boring for me. It is one of the most active part in song and you decided just spam 1/2 sliders for a 20 seconds. P.S. It didn't affect on my opinion about that map, but I still want to mention it. Background is important for overall perception of beatmap and I don't understand why you decided to put touhou girl that already was used in a ranked set.	>Touhou BG on non-touhou song - no need to say more, go next! >Jokes aside then why is SBer hosting it? Should be one of mappers. >Map isn't too special >Remix is fairly simple but actually cool	The inevitable horror of Touhou making it to this stage I usually write quite a bit, but the way basically everything here is fleshed out makes that hard to do so. "Solid but underwhelming", there's nothing that really catches the eye or draws me in. As an every-day ranked set I'd give a huge thumbs up but in context of the contest it just falls flat unfortunately. Phyr's love doesn't stand out much, the small circle size is cool but also forces the mapper to hold back it seems. The design choices aren't really harmed by the circle size but also not enhanced. It's there. Spread works out okay though has some kinks here and there. Storyboard is .. well I feel like I've already seen this, many times. The track is a bit of the culprit in my eyes. Getting hit with 00:32:011 - into 00:38:411 - when playing kinda just sucks all the momentum away and I don't think anything mapping-wise could fix that. Even though the track has really nice chorus sections, they kinda just happen and don't feel like they're being built up to. So, yeah, you get my internet cookies with this but you're not really reaching for the top	綺麗な曲でした！	Remix Quality: Decent song, it's somewhat unique among the other entries, but lacks production and composition wise. The sub is actually way more compressed than the rest of the frequency spectrum although within a EQ it's going to look like everything is roughly as loud in terms of dB it's not in terms of perceived loudness, besides that more variation between sections and some different synth sounds would've made it more interesting. Overall nice though. Mapping quality: I like the idea of the high CS theme and the execution of it is rather good. The changes in intensity between sections fit the song (although a bit slight), the rhythms consistently reflect the instrumental track with some occasional triples on vocals maybe. The differences between the two mappers are somewhat noticeable with respect to rhythm density and pattern difficulty which makes the set overall feel a bit less like a coherent project and more like a collab between people. The lower diffs are better than average which is nice to see. Reflects the song pretty well and has well thought out gameplay with a few little creative things, not incredible, but good. Overall: While gameplay wise pretty good and with a decent remix, I believe what could've elevated the set a lot would've been if the song writer and mappers might've communicated more on how to add more rhythmic or intensity based variety. The SB and BG are simple basic additions. Overall nice gameplay, but otherwise not very outstanding.	no comment	no comment	no comment	great drop!
7	extremely valid	This if anything is just limited so much with that storyboard. The mapping is the best by a long shot and having the whole set together like that is a really positive sight. Spread on normal->hard->insane is quite rough and to be honest I think the normal to hard is way too much to be rankable with the much faster sliders and harder concepts in hard. I could rag on some things though in the more intense sections where you could've done a lot more things for the harder difficulties	no comment	Top Diff: Overall pretty well mapped. The buildups (00:42:487 - / 01:26:373 - ) are kinda weak compared to the rest. Overall the map uses too high SV which feels sometimes out of plays and doesnt really give a great player experience (examples: 02:51:230 (1) - /02:55:516 (3) - / section at 00:45:230 - and 02:56:887 - ) Spread: Very well made. Imo the Exteme is a better map than the top difficulty since it uses the SVs better for gameplay. The rest of the spread is also well made and correlates (visually and pattern wise) with each other. The SB is too simple tho, other entries were way more impressive with that	contact for comments	amazing job especially mapping wise, would be so much better with actual sb but I guess this takes my #1 even without it	I hate tech maps but at least this one looks like it was meant to be played	Mao (2204515) This entry is great. The fact that the Remix was done by BilliumMoto was enough to indicate that this is going to be a very high quality entry. This Remix is definitely the best out of this entire contest, having the most professional mix and being the most creative, and all of the diffs are incredibly well made, although it is a VERY big shame that the SB couldn't have been any more complex. The SB is fine, but it definitely feels like wasted potential to really bring out the power behind the song. The lack of Custom Hitsounds is a very big shame too, which really puts this entry down by quite a lot. So much wasted potential here. But the fact that this has a full set is enough to place it in the Top 5 for sure. Mao (2204515) It's definitely very high quality in it's overall mapping quality. All of the difficulties have a very consistent structure in every diff, and the rhythm choices & gameplay is just about as good as it can get. My main problem is that I probably won't be remembering this mapset for the maps themselves, but for the incredible Remix, and nothing else, since it lacks a Storyboard or Custom Hitsounding.	Nice mapping quality as usual. However the remix feels more like an independent dubstep & electronic music to me, instead of having something to do with the original song "My Love". I just personally expected something more special for this contest.	Storyboard is very simplistic, which is a shame. I feel like this could've been elevated quite a lot by a fancier storyboard. Set itself is quite wild. I'm not really a fan of 00:45:230 - on the top diff, but everything else is pretty fun. I do wish that the map had more "break" points, feels like super intense the whole way through which is a bit grating. Having these SV changes on the Normal and Hard diff is really daring, but they are integrated in an interesting way, sketchy but interesting. I honestly don't have much to say about the difficulties; this is super well done in every aspect including spread.	Very solid entry. Rhythm choice, clean structure, pattering — hard to find an issue here. Consistent idea goes through a whole map and I can't dislike it, except shapes like this on Insane difficulty (01:01:687 (3) - 01:16:087 (1) - 02:36:316 (1) -, but I think its fine). At the same time that consistency put a spoke in your wheel, because hard to say that entry shines creativity. Most of all I don't like that you follow this stupid trend and put slider shapes like this (01:29:459 (1) - 01:34:345 (1) - 01:34:945 (1) - ). Creative feature will not work if people just gonna spam this on every single map (yeah, some entries used it too). I am not saying it's bad, just expected from you something more interesting. Overall it's most consistent beatmapset on that contest. I like remix, but storyboard don't impressive at all.	>That's some massive contestant >Remix is stunning >Really simple yet effective SBing >It's sooooooo fun (maybe except some small sections but it's so nitpicky) >Awesome diff spreading >No need to say more, this entry is "My Love"	Going Mode I super appreciate how polished this is as a set, even at this song length the lower difficulties are polished and interesting. Good contrast between sections, both visually and otherwise, and details like 03:16:087 (1) - even on Easy are epic. Makes not just the difficulties good but helps the set come alive stylistically. The Hard is a ton of fun as well thanks to including the complex rhythms. As for the higher difficulties .. I'm having a hard time because usually I'll criticize mistakes but this is the type of mapping I generally view as "Good". Lots of motion variety with good emphasis, fitting and interesting rhythms, never a dull moment in the map and most importantly for me: every section feels very balanced to play. I will say though, when going from Expert to Our Love some of the different choices are -very- striking. Mainly referring to 02:56:887 - , Expert has a very simple idea that fits the longer synths while on top diff I'm just getting everything thrown at me at the same time. Especially 03:06:316 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - I think nobody is ready for. "Our Love" ends up trying to bring out everything and brings out forward / tries to do too much, in my eyes. Similarly for 03:18:830 - the highest difficulty doesn't really map in a way that feels anywhere near closing, leaving a bit of an unfortunate impression when it meets its inevitably end. Also have to say that the spacing at 01:18:145 - on Expert is just weird and obnoxious to me. Otherwise I feel like I could stare at these for hours and only find minor nitpicks. Storyboard though .. eh. It has some lyrics, there's a cool background and some fades, but really doesn't enhance the experience. Personally I even found the flashing to be rather distracting rather than really adding something meaningful during gameplay. Compared some other entries I find this a significant downer. The song's a banger with sick breakcore parts though and the map does much more than just match it Overall, definitely one of the most polished sets here but the storyboard really hurts my overall impression. It wouldn't be very surprising if I equal this to something with a better storyboard.	ベースドロップがとてもカッコよく作られていて聞きごたえのあるリミックスでした。	Remix Quality: Whatever I'm writing should be kind obvious I guess, just an amazing remix. Production is really good (the stereo sub at 2:13 might be a bit incompatible for people with subwoofers, but it sounds good on headphones I guess lol). I especially like the structure of the song with the somewhat different first two drops and the then extended bridge into the last section Mapping quality: Besides the superb remix the set is packed full with high quality diffs from up all the way down. The thick buzzy slider kink is there in all diffs, the slider design besides that also consistent through all diffs, rhythms are reflecting the song well while being varied. I personally believe on a few diffs like the top one there's some sliders where slider leniency abuse is ignored to fit the kind of mapping style the mappers where going for, but those are rather rare. Overall the pattern choice is daring and well executed which is nice to see. It's possible that the set could've been even more perfect, but what the mappers made as a team is very significant. Overall: The mapset overall is a very professional package on the level of a official rhythm game chart, the design of the background is very unique and simple, the song is extremely high quality and has a very meaningful structure which is reflected very well in the mapping. The spread is above what most ranked maps have to offer with some aesthetic themes going all the way to the Easy diff and in general the quality of said diffs is higher than average (as to be expected form Mao I guess). The only thing which some entries might've done better would be the Storyboard, but overall the entry is a near perfect package.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
8	humilde	Whyyy would you waste time on a beginner difficulty easy diffs are already big enough of a plague /s. Realistically though the mapping is decent and while the remix is rather simple it's still cool. Spread is rather off for normal -> hard gap + there are really long object chains in normal but aside that things work out pretty well. Only that voice crack at the preview point drives me crazy god damn. Storyboard is a bit too simple for my liking and you have your storyboard elements fucked at times since there are hitobject highlights following things from other diffs (all diffs from normal to insane follow easy's patterning) but that's what happens to the best of us. Diff names could preferrably go though.	no comment	I dont think cs2 was the best idea for the topdiff since the map doesnt utilize it with big 1/4 spacing or more harder patterns which coudnt be equaly made with cs4	contact for comments	sounds like classic dnb remix	keysounds don't fit; remix could've been ok if not for the hihat spam; lowest diff should be deleted no idea why it's on the set...	Megafan (6632605) This entry was in a very close Top 5 spot, but I think there's something to be proud of by holding a Top 6 spot! A melancholic DnB Remix with a quite cool spread, and while the SB is fairly simple, I think it captures the intensity of the song just right. Wonderful entry. Megafan (6632605) Really really nice mapset that expresses the song really well in it's rhythm, and while the map stays relatively simple with it's shapes, it finds interesting ways to shake it up. Gameplay feels very smooth.	Looks like the main focus was on the playability. Not bad, but I also expect something more interesting idea wise. 01:39:340 - The expression here at Insane was interesting, but other combos weren't as impressive to create a connection with the song.	Very basic storyboard. Top diff suffers from every section being designed effectively the same way, leading to it being quite dull/repetitive due to the constant rotation spam. It's also quite odd how the Insane winds up with better rhythm than the top diff, but it suffers from the same issues of lacking any form of contrast or anything too memorable in the map in general. Actually, pretty much all of the diffs suffer from this >.>	Actually I like it. Amazing flow on top diff (this part 02:51:064 - 03:07:616), generic, but consistent visual, cool rhythm choice, but imo you ruined it with that sliderart 03:07:616. Anyway I still like it and gonna put it to my top 5 list. Others diffs fit main concept as well, good hitsounds, but storyboard and remix itself doesn't seems unique or at least interesting for me.	>That heart in SB is big indeed - maybe little too big >Simple yet really fun top diff >Interesting spreading >Simple remix >Low diffs are fairly boring tho (ex. a lot of 1/1 sliders in a row for normal)	Cute diffname idea Unfortunately I feel like in terms of mapping .. the diffnames and Big Heart Expert being CS2 are the most memorable parts. No idea why there is a Beginner difficulty, it feels like it has 1 really boring rhythm and doesn't really beat the Easy at introducing the game's objects. The Easy existing in concept is alright, but it's not much less boring. Normal and Hard are more or less the kind of templates I'd expect in an everyday spread - workable but not really contest material. Skipping to the highest difficulty, CS2 was a surprise but quickly became dull. Most of the mapping doesn't really take the large circle size in mind, creating a map that is much too lenient to aim and doesn't make up for it otherwise. Take 01:39:340 - for example, the sliders look like the main idea but you can follow them blind-folded so it's hardly meaningful. Aside from this section 02:51:064 - the map ended up being really forgettable to me. It'd have appeal if there were a notable attempt at implementing CS2. Following from that the Insane is actually my favorite difficulty since it doesn't have these issues. It's simple but at least I can enjoy it. The keysounding also seems nice, but it's rather hard to notice here, so this too I don't really find a memorable feature Storyboard much in the same boat, it's nice for what it is but it has very little presence so it's easy to just forget about its existence. At least all this more or less matches the simple but nice DnB, so at least there's an attempt at reaching an overarching vibe. While on paper this mapset could have been a lot of cool things, unfortunately it doesn't stick in any capacity. I'd love to give credit to a simpler, relaxing experience but some entries here do that so much better.	リズムが気持ちいい曲で音が綺麗でした。	Remix Quality: In terms of composition the song is a bit more varied inbetween drops compared to some other songs, but overall it's somewhat repetitive and basic which carries over into the rhythm of the map. Production wise it's ok, the mixing overall could be a bit improved (more sub, less in the 300 hz range, more in the 5k+hz range etc.) and the samples like drums or the piano (FL keys I'm guessing) are a bit low quality, especially the kick could stand out more (maybe there's no sidechain). It's ok overall. Mapping quality: Well executed set although rather unremarkable. The top diff has a few interesting repeating ideas and is actually a rather decent execution of CS2 mapping, sadly the other diffs within the set largely drop attempts at unique kinks or patterning and mostly focus on consistent execution, on the lowest diffs the execution drops off slightly as well. Overall: With a large amount of well executed diffs, a somewhat basic song, basic SB and one a little more interesting diff the entry overall is a fun package, but misses to stand out among other entries.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
9	Dolbit Normalno	Really great sounding remix and mapping seems to be solid as well. Knowing the people working on this I sincerely think you are held back by the remix being rather simple. If you were to do an additional harder diff I think you could've really popped off all around since while the remix is simple, there is still more potential than this. However the spread is really solid all around. The only thing that didn't really fit were some stacks under sliderends in hard I think. SB is otherwise cool but seeing things (=Lyrics in chorus really) not get faded out properly or even transitioned out drives me off for some reason. Also please fix your kerning in sb.	no comment	Topdiff: Overall pretty good. I think its a missed opportunity that you didnt do as much with active 1/4 rhythm in the kiai like you did in later parts. For example for this part 00:39:343 - you only use 1 main pattern for the 1/4 across the section (00:48:249 (1,2,1,2) - ). Same goes for the buildup at 01:31:843 - where you chose to mainly use kicks where you could do way more. Thats the reason i like the later parts more than the prior. The Insane is definitly better with using more different 1/4 patterns. The rest of the spread does its job	contact for comments	simple but neat sb, though I've expected something more than this from these mappers	sb lyrics are way too big wtf; solid otherwise	Mirash (2841009) I feel like I'm placing this entry way too low, but it can't be helped when basically all of the entries are so good. The mapset itself is fine, but a little bit uninteresting, and while the SB has some really cool design techniques, it lacks variety. Custom Hitsounds are ok too. Mirash (2841009) A well made mapset that unfortunately doesn't lie down many ideas on it's plate. I like the focus on representation of the synths and it's very fun to play, but it isn't all that creative.	Rhythms focusing at the main instruments of the song gave a nice synergy with the remix. I also liked the mood of the lyric storyboard. Simple, yet original design.	Neat storyboard. I kinda wish it had more song-related visuals rather than lyrics and particles, but the high motion still makes it very fun to watch. Don't have much to say about the set in general; pretty much every diff here is solid and well-designed, but none of them are particularily memorable. It still works out really well in combination with the storyboard + remix though, so it's definitely a very strong entry.	Solid structure, clean visual and smooth flow. I defenitely like top difficulty. Simple aesthetics fit others difficulties, but flow, rhythm choice, angles and pattering completly different. Overall I like remix (probably the best), hitsounds, storyboard, but consistency between top and others difficulties is main problem of that entry.	>Cool storyboard >Nice diff progression >Not outstanding but very comfy mapping >Kinda disappointed in the kiai for top diff, could be both more polished and astonishing (feels rather boring) >Nice remix >Fun to play but too repetetive with some patters (is too coherent actually)	Wow, simple done well It's almost law-breaking to me how by executing simple ideas so well it ends up becoming something very special. In the midst of a lot of entries that try to push to be interesting this one is super refreshing and I love every part of it. In terms of actual mapping, I'd only note to be a bit more careful with 1/4 spacing on Extra, things like 00:51:882 (5,1) - 01:59:968 (1,2,1,2) - stood out as large to me and the distance-snapping + stacks 03:02:780 (1,2,3) - 03:06:530 (1,2,3) - felt a bit lacking. Those are super nitpicks though. The storyboard too, even though this is nothing revolutionary it works as a perfect match for both the song and map. Everything being super polished really sells it. I love the custom background as well tbh, helped the map both match and exceed my expectations. Ofcourse this all matches the song without a flaw to spot. Overall just I'm just blown away, didn't expect to find a hidden gem but I'm glad I did	前半がFuturebassで、後半は4つ打ちにリズムが変わるのが好きでした。	Remix Quality: Somewhat decent song, overall there's too little variation, besides the drum rhythms in the drops and the build-ups there is very little change and the production is rather rough. The mix could've been improved a lot by differentiating things a bit more stereo wise, having a stronger kick (or more sidechain) and adding some more high-end to the synths maybe. Mapping quality: Very well done set mapping wise. I appreciate that there was a bit more effort put into the lower diffs (even if the normal has a few questionable patterns in terms of new players being able to tell the order of objects). Personally not a big fan of the rhythm choice on the insane, but I understand what the mapper was going for and in that regard it's consistent although being inconsistent with the top diff. Besides that the insane has some nice enjoyable patterns and reflects the intensity of the songs different sections quite well while still being engaging. The top diff is equally enjoyable although has a noticeably different style and less variation or interesting patterns. Overall: Cute set. The remix is decent, the set might have the best storyboard and overall a clean well designed background, the mapping is very well done although something which could've made the entry really stick out would have been some more coherent interesting things throughout all difficulties.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
10	Team Red but Blue	BG video is a huge plus on this one. Such cool effects, would be a near top contender for me if it was less repetitive, I think. Mapping seems to be nothing to write home about really but it works. Something I kinda disliked is that the song is really undermapped and underrepresented for my liking when it comes to the top diff. Hard diff is quite a lot at times for hard when it comes to rhythm complexity and handling different kinds of gaps & some overlaps do not feel too good for the normal but the blue tick rhythms are a really good addition. A banger extra would've been such a nice cherry on top. Also miku English sounds duuuuuuuuumb, Japanese translation of the lyrics would've been more fitting for her I think. Regardless the vocaloid is a nice twist when compared to the other remixes.	no comment	cute video, but map lacks on the creative side	contact for comments	why does hatsune miku have to be in here??	I feel like this needs a diff between the "insane" and the hard; the miku part is a cool idea but I think it's a bit out of place with the rest of the song; 02:20:640 (4,5,6) - isn't this kinda stuff in normals literally unrankable; the set would be good as a bundled map though	Noffy (1541323) God this Remix is amazing. The map is very cool, the video is very cute, and the BG's artwork is way too good. I think that this mapset would be perfect to introduce to new players to this game. I'm placing this in the Top 5 is because I think it would be a popular set between beginners. Noffy (1541323) A mapset that I'm sure is going to be very nice and friendly towards the newcomers. Great job! Rhythm choices and Gameplay is ok, I quite like the ending parts in the top diff.	Interesting touch in mixing vocaloid and My Love. Nice background art as well. However, I think the map was too universal to show the originality of the song.	One of my favorite videos/storyboard, just in terms of sheer presentation. I still think it's kinda a lot of random visuals but it's really well done so I can't flame it! The insane diff is a bit incohesive when it comes to collab parts, but it is still very enjoyable. On the other hand, I have to admit that the Hard diff makes very little sense to me, especially rhythm-wise it seems very unintuitive for both new players and even more experienced ones. The normal is better, but it still irks me a bit. Overall though, very cool presentation and enjoyable diffs!	Imo main problem of that entry is inconsistency between parts of collab. For example: 00:45:015 - in that and 01:00:015 - that parts you are mostly use simple slider shapes, but in next part 01:30:015 - there is much sliders that doesnt fit main aesthetics of map at all (01:31:421 (4) - 01:34:702 (1) - 01:38:921 (3) - ). And that issue consistency repeats through all beatmapset. Actually I have no idea why you decided to put these sliders (04:26:265 (1) - 04:27:085 (1) - 04:27:671 (1) - 04:31:421 (1) - 04:33:765 (1) - ). Without a proper context its only ruin your concept. Next problem is music relevance. In addition to incosistent visual we are getting meager emphasis of melody in that part 02:07:515 - 02:35:640 - . Personally i'd map it with circles and higher SV to make contrast to others part. I am not a big fan of vocaloids but this remix sounds more unique than others entries. Overall I don't think that entry is good enough to get top 5 in my list.	>It's probably the cutest entry >Good video and other visual elements! >Would be even better if it had an extra where it pops off :c >Great remix! >Some parts on all diffs could be polished but it's rather okay >Rhythm choice on normal is fairly weird	I wanna be your .. girl? I've been trying to avoid namedropping in my comments but "Noffy made the vocaloid entry" (generalized) makes it all the more iconic to me, hah Nice low diffs, solidly representing the changes in the song through rhythm and patterns. Especially Hard has some fun and spicy arranges for the bpm range, I appreciate that. As for the Insane, I think it's done fairly solidly but lacks a bit of impact. For example the ends of sections sometimes don't feel very emphasized, 01:12:202 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - 01:43:140 (1,1,1) - both fit in too well with the rest of the section to tell the player things are changing. Otherwise there's the occasional drop of pace that feels very halting in gameplay compared to its surroundings. Patterns like 02:13:140 (1,2,3) - 02:20:640 (1,2) - 04:17:358 (3,1) - etc all feel like big slow downs, often due to holding back 1/2 spacing a bit too much. The collab nature of this set does really come across more than in most entries though, every mapper has their distinct style and purpose in the mapping. Most outstanding to me is the video though, I love the changing atmospheres and the general quality of the editing and assets. The custom art is awesome! Really feels like I'm spending the night out alongside Miku and pippi .. which regrettably is the most weeb thing I'll ever say The choruses are intense though, really adding a layer of enjoyment to the gameplay and fitting the cool melodic drops. Overall, I feel like the video really contributes most to the experience by tying the other pieces together, which is really cool. Isolating the pieces however doesn't convince me much.	オシャレでかわいい楽曲にリミックスされていました。ミクの声もとても可愛くて良かったです。	Remix Quality: On second look actually better I thought at first. I especially like this song composition wise since almost every section is different yet the song overall stays cohesive, particularly the long bridge section with the somewhat unexpected (but actually hinted at 1:31) Hatsune Miku vocals transitioning into the build-up of the last drop. Production wise it's pretty good although it could be slightly improved with a bit more stereo separation of the mids, a little more sub, maybe less in the 300 hz range, maybe making the clap quieter and the some other high-end elements louder etc. Overall very good. Mapping quality: Well done set, the mapping is somewhat simple although there are a few nice quirks and it's well crafted. The low diffs are nice even if there are some patterns which are questionable like the pattern at 3:59 on the hard and the very inconsistent use of stacks on the normal diff, in general the use of stacks on the lower diffs is odd. Even with a few interesting patterns there aren't many elements which are highly unique and personally at this BPM I would've preferred some more movement. Quite good. Overall: Very nice set, three well done collab diffs, a well made video, cute background and for some reason a overall Hatsune Miku related theme with a very well made remix lol.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
11	Moyai	SB aesthetics are really cool with the original song's context but the outcome is still really underwhelming when compared to some other contenders. The mapping is decent in general but the spread gets plagued by spread issues (holy fuck the hard to insane gap is so off & the insane is barely fitting under the insane label in my eyes-_-). Remix is fine, not my style though in general.	no comment	no comment	contact for comments	hey this map is pretty good actually, I think the sb was a bit underwhelming but cool entry overall	remix is too out there imo; map is ok; sb is so basic that I'm not sure why it's even there to begin with	Patrick Cake (11266329) Didn't expect someone to make a Psytrance Remix that actually slaps this hard, not to mention how well mapped it is. Remix is stellar, all of the diffs are super solid making it a full set and the SB has some incredibly cool design. I think it definitely deserves this spot. Patrick Cake (11266329) Incredibly solid, I don't think I can say anything else apart from the fact that the mapping is absolutely on-point. Both the Insane and Top Diff have a bunch of very cool ideas and play incredibly well, and the rhythm choice is perfect.	Amazing remix. Instrument samples are slightly different from the original song, but I can clearly tell this is "My Love". The beatmap would've been more interesting if the mapping contrast between different sections were stronger than now. Still, the overall remix and storyboard concept surprisingly fits the original song nicely.	I'll be honest, I don't really like the presentation of this storyboard, it feels cluttered in a really odd way that I can't quite pinpoint (and the black bars are quite odd). Top diff is way over the top, definitely the kind of map that's far more frustrating than it is fun. I'm honestly not really sure if this spread works that well, the insane still has a lot of rather awkwardly placed difficulty elements. The hard is actually quite alright, but the normal is very poor at actually representing anything in the music. Oh well.	Mixed feelings about this one. It's consistent beatmapset and I can't dislike it, but ideas that you are reapet doesn't seems intersting for me. I mean your aesthetics more complex than most of the others entries, but personally I am not a fan of this. For example overlaps like this (00:38:911 (1,2) - 00:40:459 (1,2) - 00:45:104 (1,2,3,4) - 01:32:524 (1,1) - ), stacks (00:40:653 (3,4) - 01:38:427 (1,1) - 01:40:653 (1,2,3) - ) or slider shapes itself (01:29:427 (1) - 01:48:007 (1) - 01:56:137 (1) -). It would be fine, but messy structure in that and others diffs as well ruin whole impression of that entry. Overall stroyboard looks nice, but its pretty common compare to others entries.	>I don't like the remix at all :c >Uhhhhh hard -> insane gap is so huuuuuge >Nice SB >Hitsounds are highly questionable at some spots like 01:22:072 - >Top diff isn't even fun to play :c >Feels overdone overall >Overall fairly cohesive throughout each diff on its own	This REALLY makes my heart beat .. if I ignore the lower difficulties at least. To me each difficulty has its own set of issues and that ends up compromising the set as a whole. The Normal I simply I can't distinguish from your average normal. With a song this unique and lenient bpm this is way too bland. Wubs like 01:29:427 - not having any sort of cool sliders really diminishes what this normal can do as well. 01:28:266 - circling around counterclockwise for the entire kiai doesn't help either. Hard incorporates more of the song and has better gameplay, but is generally still very comparable to your everyday ranked difficulty. Insane just doesn't introduce enough of the gameplay elements in "Our Love", so there ends up being a huge gap between them even if the star rating doesn't look like it. It also does a lot of weird things like adding this 00:43:556 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - 1/6 or filling the calm section with rather dense rhythms 00:55:749 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5) - 01:05:234 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - . Some sections like 01:53:233 - seem rhythmically unintuitive because they mix layers in an unclear manner. It's a lot more interesting in accordance with the song, though. Highest difficulty is really sick to play but a mixed bag design-wise. Mainly taking issue re-using the same patterns for different groups of sounds like 00:38:911 (1,2) - vs 00:26:524 (1,2) - etc, breaking the idea you established. These rhythms 00:54:685 (1,2,3,4,1) - really are too copy pasted and don't feel fitting with the song. Surprisingly I do like the general slider design visually, really suits the tense nature of the song. I do think 01:46:459 (1) - lacks contrast against 01:44:524 (1,2) - and that due to object placement the difference between 01:55:749 (2,1) - isn't really felt. The storyboard.. well it's there. For the most part when playing the map it felt more like a backdrop than something that's supposed to really add to the experience. It's nicely made but it doesn't do a whole lot with the song aside from visualizing the strongly felt heartbeat. Seems very well planned out with the remix at least, the track is really tense and an interesting twist on "my love". So, I think there's some cool ideas at play here but as a whole I can't rate this entry highly. There's too many things going in the wrong direction.	雰囲気のいいSynthwaveでした！	Remix Quality: Potentially the most unique and solid track production wise. Very interesting bass lines, orchestral sounds, atmospheric use of the original vocals. My only gripes would be that the song in terms of structure doesn't tell as much of a story as some of the other entries, like it's well made banger, but it doesn't go beyond that. A less substantial issue might be that the track is overall a bit too compressed (it fits in the drop sections, but not so much in the transitory parts). Besides that very good. Mapping quality: Probably the most unique and interesting to play entry out of them all. The use of many very short 1/8 and 1/4 sliders with still distinct bulky looking shapes close to each other does fit the very glitchy sound design and odd rhythmic patterns the song is going for. The rhythms and spacing mostly fit, slider leniency is considered rather well for something in this kind of style (with the exception of this 01:38:717 (1) - maybe). In my opinion the use of NCs is a bit excessive, but I guess it's expectable for something with this kind of mapping style (still not a fan). Sadly the Insane ultimately ends up lacking the same level of care, especially when it comes to slider leniency being taken into account and in general the insane is messier. The Normal and Hard end up being very basic. Taken all that into consideration we have a interesting ok somewhat well done top diff among rather mediocre lower spread. Interesting, but had more potential. Overall: Very interesting, very well produced remix, simple yet effective SB and a pretty creative top diff. Sadly the rest of the set is lacking in quality and the competition is very strong.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
12	Bowkutoly Encore	Really don't know what is going on in the sb half the time and I feel like the mapping is lacking at times. The remix is really sweet though even if it could've used one or two a bit more different sections to really make the experience outstanding.	no comment	no comment	contact for comments	quite good remix, map and sb are kind of mediocre but they're ok	not really the kinda map I'd want to see bundled, not a big fan of the remix either	Raytoly (8121109) This entry was quite a confusing one. A lot of the SB sprites have different design styles that look quite messy when mixed together, and a lot of the visuals are quite confusing at trying to express the vocals through visuals. A lot of them just didn't make sense and felt random. The map itself and Custom Hitsounds are good either way. Raytoly (8121109) Good map, but the fact that this slider at 03:31:591 goes the other way around made quite literally every player sliderbreak, which is not good. Other than that, the map is good, with good rhythm choice.	Neat storyboarding. I can see the effort to create an alternator style with a smooth flow choice. Still I think the map could've utilized more rhythm variousity. The rhythm chain for each section felt the same over and over, which made me feel the map a little flat in design.	I can't bring myself to say anything bad about this storyboard, it has that sort of amateur home-made feel that I find cute. Sadly, the map itself isn't very compelling to me, as it just constantly spams this rotation motion with rather dissapointing rhythm choices.	Can't say much about this one. Monotonous circular flow makes that map boring in gameplay aspect. Pretty generic visual, random sliderarts on that part 00:28:433 - 01:00:012. But main issue is song represent. You are mostly focus on vocal and its ok but I couldnt see contrast between "melody" part (01:37:906 - ) and "vocal" part (02:03:169 - ). Overall I liked your remix, but storyboard dosen't seems unique so I can't put your entry to my top 5.	>Boring >Only one diff, sad it's not new-players-friendly >Isn't too polished at all and there are some unrankables left (so doesn't seem to be too prepared) >Basic SB which doesn't really offer too much	What does the BRP slider art stand for help A 5 minute song is a clever workaround for the required spread but it's a workaround nonetheless. In a way it's unfortunate that you wouldn't make your Epic Remix of OSU Classic available to the greater audience. Regarding the mapping itself it's kinda .. repetitive? Playing through the map goes like this (exaggerated): 00:03:170 - rotational ideas with 1/4 and 1/2 sliders 01:00:012 - rotational ideas with 1/4 and 1/2 sliders 01:37:906 - ... rotational ideas with 1/4 and 1/2 sliders There's a sense of build-up alongside the song at 02:03:169 - 02:15:801 - etc which is nice, but essentially ideas aren't built on - only repeated. The slow sections don't really improve on this, it's just long slow sliders and more long slow sliders and then there's this monstrosity 03:31:591 (1) - . Following and holding a slider for 12 measures isn't fun in any capacity. Then there's the ending 04:53:696 - where you just click 1/1 beats for 16 measures straight .. coming out of 04:28:433 - which is nearly the same. Combine this and you get a map that feels like it's constructed out of 2 patterns and some slow sections. You can turn of your brain and vibe to it but beyond that it's just Meh. How I feel about the storyboard is for some parts summed up by the question-mark at 02:43:531 - . I like the ideas of "the singer says Start so we'll put a finish line" but for a lot of the lyrics early on this is hard to catch on to. It'd be better if these were framed some way to make it obvious that they correlate to the song. I do like the visuals in the chorus, as least they match the kindof vibing nature of the map and song. The background seems custom drawn which is epic, then again it could be less empty too. Overall just a chill experience, but overdoes that aspect for me and ends up feeling lacking instead	明るくて楽しいトランスになってました。	Remix Quality: Decent song with room for improvement. It might be kinda normal for a trance song to have this much repetition and go on for so long, but I think in the context of this contest that may not have been the best idea since it doesn't lend itself well to mapping and makes it hard to stand up to some of the other tracks. The sound design for this kind of genre seems pretty decent although the mix is lacking a lot of sublows, there could be more stereo separation, the song is a little too compressed and there too much white noise or something (it's very audible). Mapping quality: Somewhat overly basic alternator style mapping, the rhythms are following the song pretty well, spacing and intensity more generally reflects the different sections of the song, somewhat sloppy visual spacing. There really isn't much to say about the map beyond that, it fails to stand out among other entries. Overall: Well done, decent remix, a good SB with some basic alternator style mapping. As a overall package the entry isn't really bad, but every part of the package has ultimately very basic elements, it isn't highly creative or unique and neither is anything exceptionally well crafted. It's OK.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
13	schoolboy fans	In general I would consider this to be a good package with a nice remix and a cool storyboard. Hard didn't really feel right at times with the really confusing rhythm and unnecessary usage of 1/4 slides all the time + normal -> hard is kinda off with that rhythm stuff in my opinion. I really feel like the experience is ruined by that long break + message in my opinion (Yea I'm really cynical but I think those should be left into map description / end of the map since just slapping a long ass break in the middle is so boring) and maybe because that the top diff is a bit too much for this kind of a song. And lastly I must say the you know what wasn't too nice either when it comes to the ethics and nature of the contest.	no comment	Pretty nice entry. This has definitly my favorite storyboard with how it is fitting to the theme of the remix. The top diff well made, tho i think the 1/4 spacing used seems often times pretty random or forced. Also some of the more reading-heavy patterns dont really play intuitve and feel out of place (like 03:20:907 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,1) - ) and act as a unexpected diff-spike (also 03:00:621 - and 01:03:764 (3,1) - feel like, they havent been playtested enough since these pattern play really bad gameplay-wise. Overall the difficutly tries to get the most out of the song what it can what is a +-point. The spread overall is good, the only thing i can point out is that 00:17:193 (2,3,4,5) - in the normal could be prety confusing to newer players since they could easily get the playing order wrong	contact for comments	best sb in terms of 'representing the song', map is kinda mediocre unfortunately	boring remix; sb has some cool parts like the intro but the rest is kinda eh; map is ok	Shmiklak (5504231) Very cool entry that I think deserves it's place. The Storyboard is incredibly well done and pays a very cute homage towards osu! and it's community, which I think is a touch that all of the entries forgot to do. The mapset is great, the remix is cool, what else is there to say? Shmiklak (5504231) A really cool mapset that finds very interesting ways to map such a dense song without making it feel overmapped, I like it. Rhythm choices are just fine, it gets quite creative with it's patterns, and plays fine.	Seems this is the only entry that fits the theme of this contest, "labor of love". I can see all the tribute towards the game itself, great respect for the storyboard concept. The beatmap quality itself feels a bit unimpressive in contrast. Looks like the map was mostly focusing too much on individual moments. I think you can create something more interesting if you can view the music in a broader perspective, so the similar parts of the song feels more similar in the map, and different parts feel more different.	By far my favorite storyboard/video in the contest. It really is a love letter to the osu!community. Top diff is actually pretty nice, nothing too special but it does a really good job at just getting you in the mood with the song. Hard and Normal are pretty average, not too offensive but nothing remarkable. They work alright as spread. I feel like a lot of the Easy doesn't really fit well for the difficulty, though.	In a gameplay and rhythm wise it's a very solid beatmapset. Unfortunetly, thats all. Imo but incosistency visual on top diff ruins my opininon about whole entry. First of all, sliders like this (01:02:907 (1) - 01:31:193 (3) - 01:37:764 (5) - ) is "overload" aesthetics and doesn't fit others "liquid" sliders. Its ok to use them for a speical sounds in song, but here it looks inappropriate. From contest map I except more unique or at least interesting flow and patterning, but here it looks like a common ranked map. Overall I think its first actually conceptual cohesion between remix and storyboard and I really liked it.	>Fairly fun to play >Great SB >Nostalgic-styled remix >Good diff spread >Some parts (top diff) could pop off more though >Cool entry!	Didn't expect anyone to go below the original bpm The entire picture does such a great job at selling the vaporwave theme, this is really impressive Mapping-wise it's hard to really criticize Hard and Insane, they do a great job at being chill and accessible but still are engaging to play through. Simple but solid stuff. Normal and Easy however are a bit more repetitive for my tastes. Especially Easy feels like it only has 1 rhythm, both difficulties tend to go around the screen kinda aimlessly like 03:05:193 - on Normal and visually there's been attempts at representing different sections but not much of it comes across. I think it'd have been great to just use more long 2/1 sliders in general rather than only sticking to the smallest possible rhythm gap. Biggest issue for me is the 20s break that's used for your very wholesome message. This is neat but really puts a dent in how replayable the mapset is, on the second pass you know the message and it's just a waiting room. Might have been better to plan this out for the outro instead so it can be skipped. Storyboard is awesome. Every second of it just oozes the atmosphere that was intended, even the transitions are just ideal. The homage to both osu and it's iconic maps is also a nice touch, you could say this was made with love. Ofcourse the song fits in flawlessly, the team really seems to have worked together on this idea. Similarly here though, I think the 1.5 hypermeasure break hurts play experience inherently. But yeah, overall this is the full package and I really appreciate that. It's like you're saying "osu! is My Love" <3	とても深みのあるベースが気持ちよかったです。楽曲の雰囲気に合ったドロップになっていました。	Remix Quality: Was really surprised by this one, very interesting idea to make a 80s style synth pop song. The chorus/drop sections because of the genre choice I guess tend to be somewhat similar which makes the song (and the mapset as a whole maybe) lack a bit in comparison to some other entries, besides that most other sections have a decent amount of variation and everything fits very well in accordance with the style. Mixing wise I would've boosted the super highs a bit more (even if the song is supposed to have more of a lo-fi vibe), it would've been good if the sub was stereo for compatibility with subwoofers (it's good on headphones though). I personally think this is the most unique of the entries and maybe ironically the one with the best mix. lol Mapping quality: Nice mapping wise. On the top diff the rhythms are sometimes a little arbitrary I believe, but overall there's a good amount of rhythmic variation and the song is represented well enough. The spacing and movement on the top diff is overall nice while not particularly special and repeating idea of overlapping 1/4 sliders for the 80s style toms fits very well. Besides that the spread is well, each diff is made with care. Overall: While the mapping isn't super special the set overall sticks out as having a very unique carefully made overall theme with the music, storyboard and background all fitting together. The storyboard in particular might be the best among all others.	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
14	le fishe au chocolat	Surprisingly simplistic SB from the two most potent storyboarders. Whole thing still works such smoothly, and I'd say this is the one where all the three aspects of the contest come together and create something great. Rightfully my favourite entry overall as the whole package even if I was a bit disappointed with the simple sb. Mapping would've been better if you either tried to do something with the red node spam sliders since they feel really inconsistent when rest of the mapping is "normal" and the gimmick barely gets used aside from select few occasions. Insane has some annoying double / 1/2 rhythm readability issues along with few general unnecessary readability issues with overlaps (unsure would these sliders 02:19:199 (1) -02:23:313 (1) - on I even be rankable with that unclear shape). Hard has some annoying mistakes and readability things as well like god some of these feel bad to look at 01:16:799 (3,4,1) - 01:11:313 (3,4,5) - and other sliderend overlap things but otherwise really cool.	no comment	Top Diff: Big fan of the section starting at around 0:25. In general could use more active, maybe even adaptive rhythms instead of kickslider into kickslider since right now its lacking music relevance. Not fan of the longer-slider section since all the long sliders feel really forced and dont really try fitting to each individual sound. The Insane is fine but im not too big if a fan of the hard difficulty since i think there could be put more effort into it, also ar 7 seems too low. The normal is actually pretty problematic since it has multiple unrankable spinners which are also impossible to hit for new players and it features too big 1/2 chains like 03:20:570 (2) - with 12 objects in a row what is way too much. The SB is also one of my favorites.	contact for comments	good sb & map overall, I failed to get the plot(?) of the sb though	this doesn't even sound like the original	-Tochi (3664366) I have to say that I didn't know up to this point that -Tochi did music production, but wow this Remix is awesome. Liquid DnB is always appreciated! Storyboard is just about what you'd expect under -Tochi's name, and all of the diffs are incredibly well mapped. One nitpick is that some of the choices in custom hitsounding is very questionable and sometimes sticks out like a sore thumb. But overall, it makes a super solid package. -Tochi (3664366) I don't have much to say apart from that all of these diffs are incredibly well done. I'll definitely remember this one. Rhythm choices are on-par, with a bunch of well thought out patterns and great playability.	After taking a multiple look, I can get why it's called Atmospheric Remix. The remix, slider usage, SB fits well together. I think there were too many variations happening in the map to understand the music though.	Man, I don't know how to feel about this entry. I don't really like how the original song is almost unrecognisable, but it's still a very well done entry in pretty much every aspect. Don't really have much to say about the lower diffs either, but also at the time of writing I'm near the bottom of the entry list and totally exhausted : 3 3 3 3	Probably my favourite entry. Good song representation, variative rhythm. Hitsounds perfectly fit remix. Imo, but you could do more expressing contrast in slider's aesthtics between that part (01:07:885 - 01:29:827) and other map (on top diff). For example make more complex slider shapes for this sounds (01:08:570 (1) - 01:10:627 (1) - 01:13:370 (1) -). To be honest I don't like Insane difficulty as much as top. The main issue here is visual inconsistency in that part (01:07:885 - 01:29:827). There is absolutely different visual and rhythm and it's affect a lot to consistency in my opinion. I'd get it if it would be Hard diff, but I think Insane allow to make similar shapes as on top difficulty.	>Really good storyboard >Not a big fan of lower diffs - they seem rushed (esp. normal has lots of 1/2 chains :c) >Top diff is really fun to play >Diff spread is nice >Some patterns feel unpolished >Cool hitsounding >Great music representation	osu.technology There's a lot of entries that try to impress with their sliders, but "Exit This Love's Atomosphere" really manages to take the cake with simplistic yet unique slidershapes. Things like 01:10:627 (1) - are very cool to play and accompany the song pretty well. The controlled nature of all the ideas creates a smooth play experience which fits the theme of the mapset really well. It also plays really well with a storyboard, easily predictable yet varied and fun. There are cases where the play experience is a bit too smooth though, specifically the Hard diff feels very linear. Constantly the same flow with the same rhythms really only leaves the map without much progression aside from 01:07:885 - . Even the climax 02:57:599 - struggles at making something that's more engaging than the rest of the map. Insane is similar in the sense that the base spacing for the climax 02:57:599 - is introduced too early, spacing building up from here 00:34:970 - means by the end of the map it'll feel normal and maybe a bit underwhelming. This section 01:07:885 - is hurt by lack of slidershape changes as well, combine both musical expectations and what the other diffs do and you end up with the same circle 01:08:570 (3) - 01:10:627 (1) - being used for everything being really boring. Those issues are more or less offset by really purposeful use of pattern and rhythm changes in the rest of the map though, everything feels intuitive yet meaningful. The storyboard and song combine for the same chill yet kind of coooool vibe, the combination of the two really hits a bit different than what I'd expect from dnb. It's really cool to see subtle use of the layer above hitobjects here as well, seeing gradients appear on the circles really helps sell the atomosphere. Overall this mapset really combines into a relaxing yet unique experience that goes unmatched in its own way. Proof that a high degree of polish can get you far.	音が綺麗に作られていて美しい曲でした！ドロップもかっこよかったです！	Remix Quality: Parts of the song are pretty good while others are oddly lacking production wise. For example the overall DnB style, the drums, many of the synths, the vocals etc. are very well done, but then other things like the bass sounds don't fit into the mix at all the way they are made, they seem to lack their own sub and other elements in the mix are too loud relative to them. There also doesn't seem to be any sidechaining happening which is important for this style of music. Composition wise there's actually a lot going on compared to a standard DnB style song which fits very well, but besides that there are very few calmer sections to change up the pace of the song. There's some potential here which could be further realized. Mapping quality: Mapping wise the entry is ok, but with some disagreeable design choices. In terms of rhythm I think most diffs have some headroom for improvement when it comes to following certain layers more consistently, often there's switching between rhythmic emphasis on drums and vocals, some diffs like the top diff put good emphasis on some 3/4 synth rhythms while others don't. The rhythms are nice to play, but I think they could follow the song even better. Overall on most diffs there isn't a very noticeable difference in terms of intensity between different sections of the song like through varying rhythm density or spacing. Slider leniency abuse isn't very well considered on the top diff in my view, but the design of most shapes fits the song. Spreading wise most of the diffs besides the normal are rather good, the hard with it's high amount of variation between stacked and spaced 1/2 plus some other overlaps is pretty daring, but I believe it works out. The normal in comparison with many patterns where the order of objects can be unclear to newer players and with some odd overlaps doesn't work out very well. Overall: Enjoyable set with some setbacks. The song is a mix of good and bad production with interesting composition, the mapset is decent with some semi-minor flaws and the storyboard is ok although some of the effects and background choices seem somewhat cliche... also I really don't like those growl hitsounds STOP! (jk it's not that bad)	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment
15	Lovers	I had such bipolar feelings for the remix in general, like the 2nd chorus is absolutely top notch along with the bridge between that and the last chorus but the distrorted parts didn't really hit home at all which was unfortunate. A bit too much off for the remix. Storyboard slaps HARD and works real nicely with the remix even if I find the heart chase to be a bit dumb. Mapping is real sweet and complements other aspects of the entry as well.	no comment	no comment	contact for comments	the remix was a bit jarring for me and I think it completely ruined the original song, sb is good tho	solid but no spread	XenjeS (10166905) This entry has definitely left the biggest impression on me overall, all aspects of the map are wonderful. The map is well made, the storyboard is excellent, oozing in amazing design, and the remix is fun and creative. The remix is quite competently made too. This entire package has lots of charm, which I think makes it stand out from all of the entries. One downside is that this map doesn't have a full spread, and while it's understandable that a full spread for a 5 minute song is a lot of work, these maps are going to be bundled in clean osu! installs, so having a full spread is very important. XenjeS (10166905) Really fun map that expresses the Remix very well, I'm overall very satisfied. Rhythm choices are good, lots of creative patterns and sliders (although it's missing an obligatory heart slider).	The map is offering some interesting challenge based on a trance remix. Impressive storyboard, the motion graphics fit well with the overall mood. Individual combos were well organized in neat placements. Mapping style fit well with the remix, but I think it was a little hard to understand the overall context of the music based on the map as the connection between the song and the pattern was a bit weak.	Um... is this on the wrong key...? Oh well. Storyboard fluctuates a lot between really epic and being super cluttered, still overall cool though. Not much of a fan of the map itself, feels like it misses the mark quite a lot in terms of making it actually fun and a lot of the patterning doesn't have very satisfying payoffs.	Good storyboard. And thats all positiv signs in entry. I can't say I don't like map itself (03:23:682 - 03:34:976 that part is pretty cool), but something is missing. In creativity wise hard to say it's something impressive for me. Common visual, flow and patterns. Yeah map is consistent and good structured,but in that aspects there is more better entries.	>Really weird remix, kinda spooky >(Am biased towards full set) it's limited for better players only >Clean mapping but some parts stand out way more than others >Good hitsounding >Would probably be 6th best for me if we had more slots .-. unlucky	I wanna be your M̸̪̐A̵̯̚N̵͔͒ I've said it on a different entry so I'll say it here too, don't think it's all that great to make a 5 minute entry of the Epic OSU Classic and leave out a majority of the game's playerbase :< Anyways, as for the mapping it's a bit double for me. On paper this is generally a really well made map, but it doesn't really hit the spot for me. It has a lot to do with expectations, like I can hear the preview so when the build-up ends in something distorted 00:52:623 - I expect something of similar nature mapping-wise. The sections after are just .. fairly vanilla though. That really courses through the map for me, the most intense sections are cool-ish but overall just too standard compared to the track you're mapping. Otherwise it's just missing emphasis or inconsistent with it. To give some examples: 01:06:741 (1,2,1,2,1) - the blip sound just blends into the increasing pattern. 01:15:388 (2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - rhythm notably changes in the song but is skipped to keep the pattern, same 03:34:270 (2,1,2,1) - . 02:15:917 - Rhythm here basically changes every measure so different ideas start clashing. Slidershapes and how objects are placed after sliders influences this as well. Despite using similar Slider Velocity ideas some sliders are a lot less intense than others eg. 04:04:623 (1,2) - vs 04:00:388 (1,2) - . 01:08:152 (1,2,3,4,5) - patterns like this basically don't feel like they exist. Placing the next object right at the slider-end for every object kills a lot of potential engagement because everything becomes the same slow straight slider in practice. So just the combination of all of these small design decisions, especially the kind of "over-variety", make it so the map doesn't come across to me as interesting or really "fitting" The storyboard surprisingly feels very similar to the mapping, there's a lot of different effects but aside from the lyrics they don't actually do much with the song or the mapping. I do like this part 01:27:917 - into 01:39:211 - , having some sort of narrative and creating a relatable mood is a lot more effective than putting video games in the background. I do like details like the black boxes around the text, making the lyrics more readable is a good play. For the most part this is very playable even with 0% dim, so I'll give you credit there So, I think all the components are solid and it's a cool track, but even when combining all the elements I can't seem to be wow'd by it.	前半のノリの良い楽曲から、後半はで盛り上がって楽しい曲になっていました。	Remix Quality: Very interesting song, I think I've never even really heard electronic music quite like this although sadly the uniqueness comes with some problems. Something which makes the track quite odd is that I believe the original vocals and the remix are using very different scales (maybe their even in a different key, can't really tell), it actually sounds kinda interesting to me personally, but I'm not sure whether it really fits (especially with the lyrics). Structure wise the song develops a quite a lot which lends itself somewhat well to mapping. The sound design is mostly good although the main bass sound potentially stand out a bit too much and the sub is a bit too loud, a bit more stereo separation of mids and highs would also help. Mapping quality: Good map. The rhythms fit relatively well even if following the vocal layer on this song is a bit tricky, there's a good amount of rhythmic variety, different sections have noticable differences in intensity and mapping style. I think if there's some issues one would be that the spacing can seem somewhat arbitrary at times and in a few sections is unnecessarily large. Otherwise the mapping is decent although it lacks anything special to make it stand out. Overall: At first I was a bit unsure about this entry, but the song although a bit odd is actually well made and the same goes for the map. The storyboard especially is really well designed, even if parts of it like the band with the girl don't seem to really fit the tone of the song lol	no comment	no comment	no comment	no comment


1	entry	total	Aquestion	Celektus	Dictate	VINXIS	Will Stetson	Kuba Oms	DTM9 Nowa	Garden	Icekalt	Kalibe	Luscent	Mordred	NyarkoO	Sonnyc	Uberzolik	xbopost	yaspo	Zelq

2	Down	0	Pentangle of Ambivalence	extremely valid	extremely valid	Incoherent Sound	Pentangle of Ambivalence	Daniel Gaming	le fishe au chocolat	Dolbit Normalno	schoolboy fans	extremely valid	extremely valid	Dolbit Normalno	Moyai	schoolboy fans	extremely valid	le fishe au chocolat	Dolbit Normalno	extremely valid
3	Team Name	0	Incoherent Sound	Dolbit Normalno	Incoherent Sound	Team Red but Blue	extremely valid	Lovers	Incoherent Sound	le fishe au chocolat	extremely valid	le fishe au chocolat	Incoherent Sound	extremely valid	Team Red but Blue	Moyai	Team Red but Blue	Dolbit Normalno	le fishe au chocolat	schoolboy fans
4	Pentangle of Ambivalence	30	Moyai	schoolboy fans	schoolboy fans	extremely valid	Moyai	Moyai	Lovers	Incoherent Sound	Dolbit Normalno	Lovers	Pentangle of Ambivalence	Team Red but Blue	le fishe au chocolat	Dolbit Normalno	schoolboy fans	extremely valid	schoolboy fans	Team Red but Blue
5	Incoherent Sound	39	extremely valid	Team Red but Blue	Pentangle of Ambivalence	schoolboy fans	le fishe au chocolat	schoolboy fans	Dolbit Normalno	schoolboy fans	le fishe au chocolat	Dolbit Normalno	Moyai	Moyai	extremely valid	le fishe au chocolat	le fishe au chocolat	humilde	Team Red but Blue	Dolbit Normalno
6	Daniel Gaming	10	Team Red but Blue	Pentangle of Ambivalence	Team Red but Blue	le fishe au chocolat	Dolbit Normalno	Incoherent Sound	extremely valid	extremely valid	Team Red but Blue	Pentangle of Ambivalence	schoolboy fans	Lovers	schoolboy fans		Dolbit Normalno	schoolboy fans	extremely valid	le fishe au chocolat
7	extremely valid	74
8	humilde	2
9	Dolbit Normalno	42
10	Team Red but Blue	33
11	Moyai	31
12	Bowkutoly Encore	0
13	schoolboy fans	45
14	le fishe au chocolat	38
15	Lovers	15
16
17	General criteria
18	Overall impression of the full beatmap package, including: - Song remix - Beatmap - Background visuals - Cohesiveness (how the elements above fit together) Note that the overall winner will be bundled with new installations of the game.