1 | Data Element | User Type (e.g. parent, student, teacher) | How is the Data Collected and who is the source? | What is the purpose for the collection? | How will the data be used? | Security Measures | Where is the data stored? | 1st Party (LL) Collecting from School | 1st Party (LL) Collecting from Parents | 1st Party (LL) Collecting from Student | Zearn (access to data from school rostering tutors as authorized users, not passed directly to LL) | Amplify (access to data from school rostering tutors as authorized users, not passed directly to LL) | Included in LL Passport Platform (collected directly, passed to or uploaded from access by authorized users) ) | Incuded in LL Tutoring Database (collected directly, passed to or uploaded from access by authorized users) | Accessed or Passed to Researchers under FERPA Studies Exemption | Remind (access to data from parents and teachers who sign up for accounts) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | First and Last Name | parent, student, teacher | tutoring on-line registration Passport on-line registration shared by school | communication | Used for email and SMS communication between Learning League and families about the program and how they can supplement tutoring and in-school learning at home. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | yes | |||
3 | Individual's Postal Code | student | tutoring on-line registration Passport on-line registration shared by school | evaluation | Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served in geographic regions of Colorado. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | no | |||
4 | Individual’s Phone number/mobile number | parent, teacher | tutoring on-line registration Passport on-line registration shared by school | communication | Used for phone and SMS communication between and families regarding tutoring and program services; Used for emergency contact. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | yes | |||
5 | Individual’s Email address | parent, teacher, student | tutoring on-line registration Passport on-line registration shared by school | communication | Used for email communication between Learning League and families regarding tutoring and program services. Used for email communication between Learning League and teachers regarding tutoring and student progress. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | yes | |||
6 | Social network or other login credentials | parent, student, teacher | Google OAUTH account registration Clever account registration | account management | Alternate to specifying an email address and password for login for 3rd party and 1st party services | tokens have expirations | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | no | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
7 | Password | parent, student, teacher | Passport on-line registration | account management | Used for secure login to 1st and 3rd party digital platforms | passwords are stored salted and encrypted | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | no | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
8 | Teacher names | student | shared by school shared by parent through Passport account | service delivery | Learning League Navigators may reach out to students teachers to align in-school and tutoring efforts. Parents may prompt teachers through Academic Passport to provide recommendations for ways parents or out-of-school providers can supplement in-school learning. | Data provided in Passport is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm Data provided by schools and third party platforms to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | yes | |||
9 | Communications (online communications that are captured (emails, SMS) | parent, teacher | Tutors and Learning League staff will be communicating with teachers and parents using Google hosted Learning League accounts and SMS. | service delivery | Email and SMS communications are used by Learning League to communicate with teachers and families in order to better align in school, after school and at home learning | Google hosted email is encrypted using TLS. The Remind platform is compliant with FERPA, COPPA, TCPA and GDPR. | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | yes | |||
10 | Demographic and Special Indicator Data – specify what fields are collected | See data elements below | |||||||||||||||||
11 | Age/DOB | student | tutoring on-line registration Passport on-line registration shared by school tutor onboarding | evaluation service delivery | Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served by age. Used to recommend parents age appropriate out-of-school opportunities and online services. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | no | |||
12 | Ethnicity/Race | student | tutoring on-line registration shared by school | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served by gender. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
13 | Gender | student | tutoring on-line registration shared by school | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
14 | Grade | student | tutoring on-line registration Passport on-line registration shared by school | evaluation service delivery | Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served by age. Used to assign students to grade relevant tutoring groups. Used to recommend parents age appropriate out-of-school opportunities and online services. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | Yes | no | |||
15 | Special education status | student | shared by school tutoring on-line registration | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | no | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
16 | Language information (native, preferred or primary language spoken by a student) | parent | tutoring on-line registration | service delivery | Used to communicate with parents in their primary language. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | Yes | no | |||
17 | English language learner status | student | shared by school tutoring on-line registration | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
18 | Low income status (Economically disadvantaged status) | student | shared by school tutoring on-line registration | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | no | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
19 | Academic Data and Academic Assessment Data – specify what fields are collected | See data elements below | |||||||||||||||||
20 | Student ever retained status | student | shared by school tutoring on-line registration | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | no | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
21 | Academic achievement status | student | shared by school tutoring on-line registration | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | no | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
22 | Tutoring subject area (Math or Literacy) | student | shared by school tutoring on-line registration | evaluation service delivery | Used to ensure our program serves the needs of all groups equitably. Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | Yes | yes | |||
23 | School name | student | tutoring on-line registration Passport on-line registration shared by school | evaluation service delivery | Used to report in aggregate on the number of students being served at specific school sites. Used to coordinate delivery of tutoring at multiple physical school site locations. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | Yes | yes | |||
24 | Local (school district) ID number | student | shared by school tutoring on-line registration | service delivery | School and district ids will be used to lookup and store curriculum and assessment standards. These will be used to inform academic supplements recommended by Passport and when possible align them to what is happening in a students school Used to report in aggregate the number of participating students by school or district. | Registration data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm. Data provided by schools to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | no | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | no | |||
25 | Vendor/App assigned student ID number | student | shared by school automatically generated by platforms during registration | account management | Used to maintain data relationships (foreign keys) between data tables and external systems. Used to add an additional layer of anonymity to customer interactions. | account data is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | no | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | no | |||
26 | Grades | student | shared by school shared by parent through Passport account | service delivery evaluation | Used to provide simplified assessment guidance to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic supplement recommendations to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic out-of-school provider recommendations to parents in Passport. | Data provided in Passport is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm Data provided by schools and third party platforms to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | Yes | no | |||
27 | Academic profile (combined data elements provided to create Academic profile) | student | shared by school shared by parent through Passport account Combination of data elements including: Standardized test scores, Platform student academic assessments, Platform student progress data, Age/DOB, Grade, Language information | service delivery | Used to provide simplified assessment guidance to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic supplement recommendations to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic out-of-school provider recommendations to parents in Passport. | Data provided in Passport is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm Data provided by schools and third party platforms to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | No | no | |||
28 | Standardized test scores | student | shared by school shared by parent through Passport account | service delivery evaluation | Used to provide simplified assessment guidance to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic supplement recommendations to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic out-of-school provider recommendations to parents in Passport. Used to report in aggregate student proficiency and tutoring impact. | Data provided in Passport is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm Data provided by schools and third party platforms to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | yes | Yes | no | |||
29 | Platform student academic assessments | student | Amplify literacy assessment platform MAP Growth assessments Other assessment data shared by schools | service delivery evaluation | Used to provide simplified assessment guidance to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic supplement recommendations to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic out-of-school provider recommendations to parents in Passport. Used to report in aggregate student proficiency and tutoring impact. | Data provided in Passport is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm Data provided by schools and third party platforms to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | no | |||
30 | Student tutoring session attendance data | student | recorded by tutor at beginning of sessions | service delivery evaluation | Used to report in aggregate student tutoring attendance. Used to flag and communicate with families to encourage consistent attendance in tutoring. | data will be collected via a secure form into the AES-256 encrypted database | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | no | no | no | no | no | no | yes | Yes | no | |||
31 | Platform student progress data | student | Amplify Reading platform Zearn Math platform | service delivery evaluation | Used to provide simplified assessment guidance to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic supplement recommendations to parents and providers they choose to share with in Passport. Used to inform individualized academic out-of-school provider recommendations to parents in Passport. Used to report in aggregate student proficiency and tutoring impact. | Data provided in Passport is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm Data provided by schools and third party platforms to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | yes | no | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | no | |||
32 | Student Work (student generated content; writing, etc.) | student | Amplify Reading platform Zearn Math platform | service delivery | Tutors will review student work and provide feedback in sessions | Data is not stored by Learning League | no | no | no | yes | yes | no | no | No | no | ||||
33 | Student wellbeing response data | student | recorded by tutor at beginning of sessions | service delivery | Shared with parents in situations where wellness is a consistent barrier to tutoring. | data will be collected via a secure form into the AES-256 encrypted database | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | no | no | yes | no | no | no | yes | No | no | |||
34 | Survey Data – specify what fields are collected in surveys and if free form fields are included | See surveys below | |||||||||||||||||
35 | Student Monthly Survey (anonymous) | student | Secure online form. See "Example Student Survey" here: https://studentsupportaccelerator.com/tutoring/data-use/measures-data-collection/examples-data-collection-tools#surveys | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | data will be collected via a secure form into the AES-256 encrypted database | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | no | no | yes | no | no | no | yes | No | no | |||
36 | Parent Monthly Survey | parent | Secure online form. See "Example Parent Survey" here: https://studentsupportaccelerator.com/tutoring/data-use/measures-data-collection/examples-data-collection-tools#surveys | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | data will be collected via a secure form into the AES-256 encrypted database | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | no | yes | no | no | no | no | yes | No | no | |||
37 | Teacher Monthly Survey | teacher | Secure online form. See "Example Teacher Survey" here: https://studentsupportaccelerator.com/tutoring/data-use/measures-data-collection/examples-data-collection-tools#surveys | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | data will be collected via a secure form into the AES-256 encrypted database | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | no | no | no | no | no | yes | No | no | |||
38 | School Administrator Monthly Survey | school administrator | Secure online form. See "Example School Administrator Survey" here: https://studentsupportaccelerator.com/tutoring/data-use/measures-data-collection/examples-data-collection-tools#surveys | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | data will be collected via a secure form into the AES-256 encrypted database | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | no | no | no | no | no | yes | No | no | |||
39 | Net Promoter Score (single survey question rating likelihood user would recommend service to a friend or colleague). | parent, teacher | Passport application | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | data will be collected securely over HTTPS and stored in an encrypted Amazon RDS | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | yes | yes | no | no | no | no | yes | No | no | |||
40 | Automatically Collected Data or Device Data and/or Metadata | See categories below | |||||||||||||||||
41 | IP Address | parent, teacher | recorded by platform analytics tools and server logs | service delivery | Used to prevent attacks on the service platforms. | Access to analytics and server logs are tightly controlled and limited to developers and network IT staff | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
42 | Geolocation data (non-precise) | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
43 | Browser Type of logged in user or website visitor | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
44 | Access time of logged in user or website visitor | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
45 | Time spent on site of logged in user or website visitor | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | yes | yes | yes | no | No | no | |||
46 | Page Views of logged in user or website visitor | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
47 | Referring URLs | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
48 | Clicks of logged in user or website visitor | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
49 | Click paths of logged in user or website visitor | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
50 | Active/engagement time of logged in user or website visitor | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | yes | yes | yes | no | No | no | |||
51 | Search history | parent, teacher | Google analytics is installed on all platforms | service delivery | Used for continuous improvement of the product. Used for reporting in aggregate on application usage. | Access to Google Analytics is limited to key staff and reports presented to wider teams are in aggregate | Google, https://www.google.com/about/datacenters/locations/ | yes | yes | no | no | no | yes | no | No | no | |||
52 | Program or application performance (e.g. typing program – student types 60 WPM, reading program- student reads below grade level) | student | We or the Third-Party Platform will track product events and progress within a particular function for internal product usage analysis | internal product usage analysis | Curriculum platforms track student performance in their applications in order to assess progress. | Data provided in Passport is encrypted in-transit over HTTPS and encrypted at rest in a database using the AES-256 encryption algorithm Data provided by schools and third party platforms to Learning League will be encrypted in-transit via SFTP and imported over SSL to a database encrypted at rest using the AES-256 encryption algorithm | Encrypted Amazon Relational Database, United States Region Google Workspace | no | no | no | yes | yes | yes | yes | Yes | no |