1 | MANUFACTURER | SWITCH | BOTTOM-OUT WEIGHT | PRICE (USD) | LINK | NOTES | RECOLORS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | KTT | Akko CS Whatever | Varies | $0.24 | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002490268117.html | Great price to performance ratio. Very smooth for a cheap switch. Midrange sound. You've already had some YouTuber recommend them in a GK61 build, haven't you. | Matcha Green, Vintage White, Pink, Rose Red, Radiant Red |
3 | KTT | Kang White ("Kangbais") | ~60g | $0.27 | https://dangkeebs.com/products/ktt-kang-white | Classic PC top, nylon bottom, POM stem combination at a good price. Damn smooth stock. Honestly, the same goes for any KTT winglatch linear. Some will even have dry lube applied from the factory! Find those! | Mallo, Sea Salt, Grapefruit, Peach, Rose |
4 | KTT | Strawberry | 62g | $0.40 | https://dangkeebs.com/products/ktt-strawberry | Mmm, strawberries. PC top and bottom with a 4 pin top. Factory lube? Springs need lube. | |
5 | TTC | Gold Pink | ~45g (long) | $0.48 | A reputation of being extremely smooth, even if the spring in this one is lighter than most. | ACE | |
6 | Gateron | KS-3 Yellow | ~63.5g | $0.25 | Full nylon housing. Generally considered to be smoother but worse-sounding than KS-3x47. | Red, Black | |
7 | Gateron | KS-3x47 Yellow | ~63.5g | $0.25 | https://paramountkeeb.com/collections/switches/products/novelkeys-gateron-linear-switches-milky-yellow-black https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002511539824.html | The classic PC/Nylon mix "Milky" top and nylon bottom. Generally considered to sound better than KS-3. wow cool thocky budget linear thock thock thock thoc thock | Red, Black |
8 | Gateron | Cap Milky Yellow | ~63.5g (long) | $0.34 | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002873027106.html | Good budget alternative to other deep linears. Uses a different pole & spring than traditional MX switches. | |
9 | Gateron | "Pro" KS-9 Yellow | ~63.5g | $0.23 | PC top, nylon bottom, cutout for RGB. Stem retool to reduce wobble and factory prelube make these decent stock. | Red | |
10 | Gateron | "Pro" KS-9 Speed Silver | ~45g (long) | $0.35 | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002692952291.html | Speed stem? Light spring with 2 stage option? Actuate fast? SMD cutout with clear top? Perfect for gamers! | |
11 | JWK | JWICK | 45g (White) 60g (Red) 65g (Yellow) 58.5g (Black) | $0.24 | https://bit.ly/3B1eju2 https://paramountkeeb.com/collections/switches/products/jwick-reds-pack-of-10 https://divinikey.com/products/jwk-jwick-linear-switches | Every JWK PC top Nylon bottom POM stem recolor, minus the recolor price. | White, Black, Red |
12 | JWK | JWICK Nylon Black | 58.5g | $0.30 | Full nylon housing with a 58.5g spring. Top sounds a little thin. | ||
13 | JWK | JWICK Yellow Pro | 65g | $0.25 | JWICK with Improved factory lube! | ||
14 | JWK | JWICK Ultimate Black | 58.5g | $0.38 | https://thockeys.com/shop-all/jwk-ultimate-blacks/ | Supposedly top housing improvements. Recommended by Issey: "Not so bad after all, after lubing that is". | |
15 | Cherry | Desoldered MX Blacks | 80g | $0.20 | https://paramountkeeb.com/products/cherry-mx-blacks | To old to be a retool, too young to be vint. Good source for Cherry tops, or if you just plan on embracing the scratch as-is. | |
16 | Cherry | Hyperglide Black | 80g | $0.45 | https://novelkeys.com/products/cherry-switches https://dangkeebs.com/products/cherry-hyperglide-black https://3dkeebs.com/collections/switches/products/cherry-mx-black | Retooled in 2020, they're back to being scratchy. Cherry nylon has a distinct sound that has its diehard fans. Stock springs crunchy, please lube or replace. | Red |
17 | Momoka | Frog | 62g (long) | $0.48 | https://mkultra.click/momoka-frog-switches/ | Standard PC top nylon bottom POM (dustproof) stem. Long spring, factory lube, smooth press respectable wobble. Sax is a big advocate for them, go bug him about it. | Flamingo |
18 | Haimu | Sea Salt Lemon | 60g | $0.30 | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/3256804335270341.html | Smooth. Good enough to run stock. | Geon Haimu Linear |
19 | |||||||
20 | SILENTS SILENTS SILENTS | ||||||
21 | Outemu | Silent White | 65g | $0.27 | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000903885289.html | Most Outemu switches are known to be pingy stock. Be sure to lube the spring and leaf. Heroically silent for the price. | Silent Peach |
22 | Haimu | Heartbeat | 65g | $0.30 | Smooth. Bottom out comparable to Outemu silents. Can probably run these stock. | Geon Haimu Silent Linear Glacier Silver/White Sea Salt Lemon (Silent) | |
23 | |||||||
24 | Credit to V1 of list by milo#3939 | Please be considerate that this listing of switch recommendations is limited by the writers (helpers) own experience, unspoken preferences and budget. We don't have the money to try every switch, and our links tend to link to US-based vendors more often than not because we're Americans. But, we hope this is still a fairly comprehensive overview of what switches you can consider as viable options. If you can't find a switch you want in your country, don't give up hope! The other switch options here are all solid! | |||||
25 | rev. 2 written by zhol#0777 | MOST SWITCHES CAN BE FOUND ON WEBSITES OTHER THAN THE ONES LISTED; THEY ARE JUST RECOMMENDATIONS | |||||
26 | IF A LINK IS DEAD, PLEASE USE GOOGLE TO FIND ANOTHER VENDOR SELLING THAT SWITCH, I BELIEVE IN YOU! | ||||||
27 | FOR MORE TRUSTED REGIONAL VENDORS, VISIT https://mechkeys.me/VENDORS.html OR THOCSTOCK | ||||||
28 | |||||||
29 | PLEASE NOTE THAT MOSTLY SWITCHES WITH APPROXIMATELY 60-65G WEIGHTS ARE MENTIONED IN THIS DOCUMENT. THE OTHER VARIANTS | ||||||
30 | ARE ALSO FINE, IT WOULD JUST BE REDUNDANT TO INCLUDE THEM ALL | ||||||
31 | FOR EXAMPLE, GATERON KS-3 YELLOWS AND BLACKS ARE THE SAME, WITH DIFFERENT SPRING WEIGHTS. IF YOU WANT | ||||||
32 | HEAVIER SPRINGS, CHOOSE BLACKS INSTEAD | ||||||
33 | DM zhol#0777 for complaints or revisions | ||||||
34 | |||||||
35 | |||||||
36 | Tecsee | Carrot | 67g | $0.40 | Full PME housings make this a decently priced, smooth, deep and muted switch. Long pole. | Blue Velvet, Kingfisher | |
1 | MANUFACTURER | SWITCH | BOTTOM-OUT WEIGHT | PRICE (USD) | LINK | NOTES | RECOLORS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | KTT | Akko CS Lavender Purple | ~52g? (long) | $0.28 | Come get your Akko CS switch! Bigger bump, but slighter springs than MX Browns | Orange, Ocean Blue | |
3 | JWK | JWICK Tactile | 67g | $0.29 | https://paramountkeeb.com/collections/switches/products/jwk-c-black-v2-tactiles https://thockpop.com/product/jwk-black-v2-nylon-tactile-switches/ | Budget JWICK with T1 stem and leaf. Top housing may be PC or nylon, check with vendor. This is your Durock T1 minus the Durock price. | |
4 | Gateron | KS-3 Brown | 55g | $0.25 | Full nylon, very light tactile. Not for those who want a strong or sharp tactility. | ||
5 | Gateron | KS-3x47 Brown | 55g | $0.25 | Milky top, light tactile. Some say milk top makes it more thocky, others, more plasticky. | ||
6 | Gateron | Cap Brown Milky/Golden | 55g (long) | $0.34 | Milky light tactile that uses a different pole than traditional MX switches. Long spring makes them feel a bit heavier at the top. | ||
7 | TTC | Bluish White | 55g (long) | $0.48 | https://bit.ly/3kfN2gB | Moderate but distinct ("like HP (holy panda)") tactility, dampened bottom out. 55g long spring. | |
8 | Huano? | Feker Panda | 67g | $0.35 | Scratchy and pingy stock, but they've got the big meme bump you're hungry for. Look like holy pandas minus the nameplate. | ||
9 | |||||||
10 | SILENTS SILENTS SILENTS | ||||||
11 | Outemu | Silent Grey | 65g | $0.27 | https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000903885289.html | Standard Outemu switches are known to be pingy stock. Be sure to lube the spring and leaf. Heroically silent for the price. | Silent Lemon |
12 | Haimu | Whisper | 65g | $0.44 | Big round bump. A little scratchy. Not extremely silent, but definitely better than nothing. | Glacier Rose Red Geon Haimu Silent Tactile | |
13 | Haimu (?) | WS Brown | 55g | $0.35 | One of the few readily available long pole light tactiles. Pretty decent stock lube job. | ||
14 | |||||||
15 | |||||||
16 | |||||||
17 | |||||||
18 | |||||||
19 | |||||||
20 | Tecsee | Tecsee Purple Panda | 68g | $0.37 | Strong, rounded tactility similar to other Panda-style tactiles. PME housing, refer to notes on Tecsee Carrots in budget linears. | Blue Velvet, Coffee Chip | |
21 | |||||||
22 | |||||||
23 | |||||||
24 | |||||||
25 | |||||||
26 | |||||||
27 | Credit to V1 of list by milo#3939 | Please be considerate that this listing of switch recommendations is limited by the writers (helpers) own experience, unspoken preferences and budget. We don't have the money to try every switch, and our links tend to link to US-based vendors more often than not because we're Americans. But, we hope this is still a fairly comprehensive overview of what switches you can consider as viable options. If you can't find a switch you want in your country, don't give up hope! The other switch options here are all solid! | |||||
28 | rev. 2 written by zhol#0777 | MOST SWITCHES CAN BE FOUND ON WEBSITES OTHER THAN THE ONES LISTED; THEY ARE JUST RECOMMENDATIONS | |||||
29 | IF A LINK IS DEAD, PLEASE USE GOOGLE TO FIND ANOTHER VENDOR SELLING THAT SWITCH, I BELIEVE IN YOU! | ||||||
30 | FOR MORE TRUSTED REGIONAL VENDORS, VISIT https://mechkeys.me/VENDORS.html OR THOCSTOCK | ||||||
31 | |||||||
32 | PLEASE NOTE THAT MOSTLY SWITCHES WITH APPROXIMATELY 60-65G WEIGHTS ARE MENTIONED IN THIS DOCUMENT. THE OTHER VARIANTS | ||||||
33 | ARE ALSO FINE, IT WOULD JUST BE REDUNDANT TO INCLUDE THEM ALL | ||||||
34 | FOR EXAMPLE, GATERON KS-3 YELLOWS AND BLACKS ARE THE SAME, WITH DIFFERENT SPRING WEIGHTS. IF YOU WANT | ||||||
35 | HEAVIER SPRINGS, CHOOSE BLACKS INSTEAD | ||||||
36 | DM zhol#0777 for complaints or revisions | ||||||
1 | MANUFACTURER | SWITCH | BOTTOM-OUT WEIGHT | PRICE (USD) | LINK | NOTES | RECOLORS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | Aflion | PC Top Nylon Bottom Recolor | 60-63.5g | $0.55-65 | man you already know | PC top. Nylon bottom. Extended pole stem makes for medium clack. Consistently overdone pre-lube. Cute name makes for good marketing. | pink robin, matcha latte, tropical water, blue sky |
3 | JWK | C3/Equalz Tangerine | 62g/67g | $0.65 | https://thocstock.com/switches/tangerines | This is mostly a meme material content creator clout switch, but if I didn't put this here, I'm sure more 12 year olds would complain High pitched "UHMWPE" (lab tests suggest its UHMWPE mixed into PC) housings. Very smooth, very overhyped. Generally OOS from TKC. If out of stock internationally, please look into the other JWK linears on this list - they're just as good. | |
4 | JWK | Durock Alpaca | 62g | $0.55 | https://www.primekb.com/products/alpaca-linears | Classic PC top, nylon bottom, POM stem combination. Full travel (not long pole). Smooth. A little high pitched. Films help. | Durock L, Too many to list oh god |
5 | JWK | Durock Lavender | 65g | $0.65 | JWK linear with full nylon housing and POM stem. Slightly lower in pitch than JWKs with PC tops. | Korby | |
6 | JWK | Durock Lupine | 62g (long) | $0.70 | https://dangkeebs.com/collections/in-stock-items/products/durock-lupine https://divinikey.com/collections/new-arrivals/products/durock-lupine-linear-switches | PC top, nylon bottom. Punchy bottom out. Spring could use a little lube. Don't film winglatch housings. | Wuque Onion, JWICK Ginger Milk |
7 | JWK | Durock POM | 63.5g | $0.70 | Full POM housing meme. Mystery plastic mix ("P3") stem makes this smoother than Kailh Creams. Go for Cobalts for LONG 63.5g spring. | Cobalt, Cherry Blossom | |
8 | JWK | H1 | 78g | $0.68 | https://prevailkeyco.com/products/h1-switches | Heavy (78g) switch modeled after Vintage Black switches. Deeper sound signature. Throw Cherry tops on if you're wild. | |
9 | SP-Star/Leopold | Polaris Grey | 67g | $0.60 | Full PC, factory lubed linear. Solid and smooth. Yanyus and Red Blues should just be recolors of these. | Yanyu, Red Blue, Marble Soda OG | |
10 | SP-Star/Leopold | Meteor White | 57g | $0.58 | Clacky nylon linear. 57g. | Ayara, Marble Soda Melon, Sacramento | |
11 | Gateron | Kinetic Labs Hippo | ~63.5g | $0.52 | https://kineticlabs.store/switches/kinetic/hippos | UHMWPE stem fights against scratchy full nylon housing. Annoyingly, the sound does live up to the Youtubers' hype. Might need a bit of lube still. | |
12 | Gateron | X | ~63.5g | $0.57 | https://cannonkeys.com/products/gateron-x-switch | Premium version of Milk Top Yellow. Stem retool to reduce wobble, new molds for bottom housing. | |
13 | Gateron | Oil King | "80g" (60g?) | $0.65 | Nylon top, ink bottom. Probably sounds on the deeper side. Currently the popular girl at school. Lots of oil, smooth enough. | ||
14 | Leobog | Nimbus | 45g (long) | $0.60 | https://www.newegg.com/p/32N-000V-00182 | Impressively smooth stock, possibly smoothest I've used. Has a bit of an odd cushion-y feeling on bottom out, but I like this about them. A hidden gem. | |
15 | |||||||
16 | SILENTS SILENTS SILENTS | ||||||
17 | Outemu | Gazzew Bobagum (Silent) | 55/62/68g (fast) | $0.65 | https://www.gazzew.com/ | A beloved go-to silent linear switch. Comes with a clear top or pink top with slot. Whisper quiet. Soft bottom-out. | |
18 | JWK | "Silent Linear" | 62g/67g | $0.70 | Silent Alpaca recolors. O ring dampener wraps around slider instead of silicone built into rail like with Outemu. Less soft bottom out. Lube springs. | Dolphin, Daybreak, Coral | |
19 | Gateron | Kinetic Labs Gecko | 57.5g (long) | $0.60 | Very firm bottom out. Very smooth. Great factory lube application. Worth running stock. | ||
20 | Kailh | Midnight Pro v2 (Grey) | ~50g? (long) | $0.55 | Very firm bottom out. Still quite smooth. Uneven factory lube, but greased springs. Press from top has a little scratch to it. | ||
21 | |||||||
22 | |||||||
23 | |||||||
24 | Please be considerate that this listing of switch recommendations is limited by the writers (helpers) own experience, unspoken preferences and budget. We don't have the money to try every switch, and our links tend to link to US-based vendors more often than not because we're Americans. But, we hope this is still a fairly comprehensive overview of what switches you can consider as viable options. If you can't find a switch you want in your country, don't give up hope! The other switch options here are all solid! | ||||||
25 | rev. 2 written by zhol#0777 | MOST SWITCHES CAN BE FOUND ON WEBSITES OTHER THAN THE ONES LISTED; THEY ARE JUST RECOMMENDATIONS | |||||
26 | IF A LINK IS DEAD, PLEASE USE GOOGLE TO FIND ANOTHER VENDOR SELLING THAT SWITCH, I BELIEVE IN YOU! | ||||||
27 | FOR MORE TRUSTED REGIONAL VENDORS, VISIT https://mechkeys.me/VENDORS.html OR THOCSTOCK | ||||||
28 | |||||||
29 | PLEASE NOTE THAT MOSTLY SWITCHES WITH APPROXIMATELY 60-65G WEIGHTS ARE MENTIONED IN THIS DOCUMENT. THE OTHER VARIANTS | ||||||
30 | |||||||
31 | ARE ALSO FINE, IT WOULD JUST BE REDUNDANT TO INCLUDE THEM ALL | ||||||
32 | HEAVIER SPRINGS, CHOOSE BLACKS INSTEAD | ||||||
33 | DM zhol#0777 for complaints or revisions | ||||||
34 | |||||||
35 | |||||||
36 | Tecsee | AEBoards Raed | 58g | $0.65 | https://bit.ly/3y5RmUF | Unique long pole stem made of a material similar to UHMWPE. | |
1 | MANUFACTURER | SWITCH | BOTTOM-OUT WEIGHT | PRICE (USD) | LINK | NOTES | RECOLORS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | Momoka | Shark | 65g | $0.63 | Medium intense bump, sharp shape, full 4mm travel. | ||
3 | Outemu | Gazzew Boba U4T | 62g/68g | $0.65 | https://www.gazzew.com/ | Also available with clear tops, though most people prefer the white material. Strong, rounded bump, pole bottom out. Their persistent popularity is well-deserved. | |
4 | JWK | Durock Light Tactile | 67g | $0.55 | https://bit.ly/3yaiqlR | Bump a bit bigger and rounder than MX Brown, but with JWK smoothness. PC top nylon bottom. More reliably in stock than Pewters. | Cotton Candy (full nylon) |
5 | JWK | Durock Medium Tactile | 65g | $0.55 | https://bit.ly/3sFnaPd | Ergo clear stem. Comparable with a Zealio v1. Ceruleans are a recolor of these. | Cerulean |
6 | JWK | Durock T1 | 65-67g | $0.55 | Halo stem clone with a leaf that makes it feel closer to a Zealio v2. Go Sunflowers for POM housing + long pole, Dark Amber T1 for full nylon. | Dark Amber T1 (full nylon), Lilac (PC/Nylon top) | |
7 | JWK | T1 Long Pole Recolor | T1 bump, tactile leaf, long pole. Sunflowers are POM, Anubis is Nylon, Moyu Black is PBT. | Sunflower, Moyu Black, Anubis | |||
8 | SP-Star | Polaris Purple | 67g | $0.55 | Medium-high tactile like T1. Polycarb top and bottom that has its fair share of fans. | ||
9 | SP-Star | Meteor Orange | 57g | $0.60 | Light tactile. SP-Star nylon is pretty clacky. Lighter tactile like MX Browns, but smoother and cleaner. | Duck | |
10 | SP-Star | Magic Girl | 67g | $0.65 | Full nylon housing, but bigger bump stem like the Purples. | ||
11 | |||||||
12 | SILENTS SILENTS SILENTS | ||||||
13 | Outemu | Gazzew Boba U4 (Silent) | 62g/68g | $0.65 | https://www.gazzew.com/ | The silent version of U4T switches. Big round bump and profoundly quiet. Best left stock. | |
14 | JWK | Shrimp/Silent T1 | 67g | $0.70 | https://dangkeebs.com/products/durock-silent-t1 | T1 stem with the JWK silencing O ring placed around the slider. | Blue Macaw |
15 | Kailh | Midnight Pro v2 (Yellow) | 60g? | $0.54 | |||
16 | |||||||
17 | Credit to V1 of list by milo#3939 | Please be considerate that this listing of switch recommendations is limited by the writers (helpers) own experience, unspoken preferences and budget. We don't have the money to try every switch, and our links tend to link to US-based vendors more often than not because we're Americans. But, we hope this is still a fairly comprehensive overview of what switches you can consider as viable options. If you can't find a switch you want in your country, don't give up hope! The other switch options here are all solid! | |||||
18 | rev. 2 written by zhol#0777 | MOST SWITCHES CAN BE FOUND ON WEBSITES OTHER THAN THE ONES LISTED; THEY ARE JUST RECOMMENDATIONS | |||||
19 | IF A LINK IS DEAD, PLEASE USE GOOGLE TO FIND ANOTHER VENDOR SELLING THAT SWITCH, I BELIEVE IN YOU! | ||||||
20 | FOR MORE TRUSTED REGIONAL VENDORS, VISIT https://mechkeys.me/VENDORS.html OR THOCSTOCK | ||||||
21 | |||||||
22 | PLEASE NOTE THAT MOSTLY SWITCHES WITH APPROXIMATELY 60-65G WEIGHTS ARE MENTIONED IN THIS DOCUMENT. THE OTHER VARIANTS | ||||||
23 | ARE ALSO FINE, IT WOULD JUST BE REDUNDANT TO INCLUDE THEM ALL | ||||||
24 | FOR EXAMPLE, GATERON KS-3 YELLOWS AND BLACKS ARE THE SAME, WITH DIFFERENT SPRING WEIGHTS. IF YOU WANT | ||||||
25 | HEAVIER SPRINGS, CHOOSE BLACKS INSTEAD | ||||||
26 | DM zhol#0777 for complaints or revisions | ||||||
27 | |||||||
28 | |||||||
29 | Tecsee | Neopolitan Ice Cream | 63.5g (long) | $0.70 | https://bit.ly/3kipDuX | Strong tactility modeled after Zyko frankenswitches; the bump takes up a large portion of the keypress. | |
30 | |||||||
1 | MANUFACTURER | SWITCH | BOTTOM OUT WEIGHT | PRICE (USD) | LINK | NOTES |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | There are not many good clickies, so I've chosen to consolidate them all into one sheet. | |||||
3 | Gateron | Zeal Clickiez | 40g (73g click), 75g (95g click) | $1.50 | https://zealpc.net/products/clickiez | Clickleaf like Alps tactiles and clickies. |
4 | Kailh | Box White | 55g (55g click) | $0.34 | https://novelkeys.xyz/products/kailh-box-switches | Thinner click bar. Less tactile than Box Pinks and Box Jades. |
5 | Kailh | Box Jade | 65g (75g click) | $0.34 | https://bit.ly/3mmRBbV | The quintessential clicky. Strong, sharp tactility thanks to a thick click bar. Crystals are PC bottom. Buy Navies for heavier spring. |
6 | Kailh | Box Pink | 55g (65g click) | $0.34 | https://novelkeys.xyz/products/novelkeys-x-kailh-box-pinks | Like if Box whites had the thick clickbar. |
7 | Kailh | Speed Bronze | 75g (50g click) | $0.37 | https://amzn.to/3sDUnKT | Feels relatively different because of shorter travel. Uses a click bar. |
8 | TTC | Golden Blue | $0.60 | https://bit.ly/2WiSkjs | A good option for those who like the feel of clicky switches, but want a comparatively quieter experience. They're still pretty loud. | |
9 | Outemu | Phoenix | $0.65 | https://bit.ly/3D6uAzN | Unique click mechanism (aristotle clone), clicks on press and return (similar to click bars). | |
10 | ||||||
11 | ||||||
12 | Kailh | Mute Jade | 82g (75g click) | $0.34 | https://novelkeys.com/products/kailh-box-switches | Intense clickbar noise is muted with the clickbar hitting a silicone dampener. Still on the loud side. |
13 | ||||||
14 | Please be considerate that this listing of switch recommendations is limited by the writers (helpers) own experience, unspoken preferences and budget. We don't have the money to try every switch, and our links tend to link to US-based vendors more often than not because we're Americans. But, we hope this is still a fairly comprehensive overview of what switches you can consider as viable options. If you can't find a switch you want in your country, don't give up hope! The other switch options here are all solid! | |||||
15 | MOST SWITCHES CAN BE FOUND ON WEBSITES OTHER THAN THE ONES LISTED; THEY ARE JUST RECOMMENDATIONS | |||||
16 | IF A LINK IS DEAD, PLEASE USE GOOGLE TO FIND ANOTHER VENDOR SELLING THAT SWITCH, I BELIEVE IN YOU! | |||||
17 | FOR MORE TRUSTED REGIONAL VENDORS, VISIT https://mechkeys.me/VENDORS.html OR THOCSTOCK | |||||
18 | ||||||
19 | PLEASE NOTE THAT MOSTLY SWITCHES WITH APPROXIMATELY 60-65G WEIGHTS ARE MENTIONED IN THIS DOCUMENT. THE OTHER VARIANTS | |||||
20 | ARE ALSO FINE, IT WOULD JUST BE REDUNDANT TO INCLUDE THEM ALL | |||||
21 | FOR EXAMPLE, GATERON KS-3 YELLOWS AND BLACKS ARE THE SAME, WITH DIFFERENT SPRING WEIGHTS. IF YOU WANT | |||||
22 | HEAVIER SPRINGS, CHOOSE BLACKS INSTEAD | |||||
23 | DM zhol#0777 for complaints or revisions | |||||
24 | Credit to V1 of list by milo#3939 | |||||
25 | rev. 2 written by zhol#0777 | |||||
26 | ||||||
27 | ||||||
28 |
1 | SWITCH | NOTES | CLOSEST ALTERNATIVES |
|---|---|---|---|
2 | THESE ARE SWITCHES WITH KNOWN ISSUES. BUY WITH CAUTION, YOUR MILEAGE MAY VARY. | ||
3 | Any switch a youtuber said was "thocky" | Thock is not real, especially within the Cherry MX platform, which suffers from various limitations, be they tactility range or sound. The sound of a board is not defined by its switches, but the combination of materials in the case, the plate, the mount style, the cutouts in the plate, the cuts in the plate, pcb and plate thicknesses, room inside the case, and so on. Now just shut up shut up shut up shut up shut up about thock already | Shut Up/Topre |
4 | Youtuber Frankenswitch #50 | These are going to be funny because the youtuber who recommends them probably won't point out that these won't go together without some stupid combination of bending the pins to secure the leaves, finding un-retooled switches that aren't produced anymore, sanding the top housings, and cherry picking ones that work versus ones that don't work. Frankenswitches are made by people with too much money and too many switches. If you are reading this, are neither of these people. Odds are, you will crash and burn without experience. Of course, it's your money. | Don't make frankenswitches if you don't know what you're doing |
5 | Cherry MX Clear | Clear stems stretch keycaps out. This appears to by design, to keep factory-installed keycaps on extra tight, and will not show mercy to your rare, limited run group-buy keyset. Why content creators don't bring this up, I couldn't tell you. Ergo Clear stems were not retooled to accommoate for this. Buyer beware. | Zeal v1, Durock Medium Tactile |
6 | Kailh Box Tactiles | Click noise starts to develop as factory lube wears off - https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=96672.0 Based on Shamb's experience with Fried Eggs, this may also occur with Kailh box linears as well. | |
7 | NovelKeys Cream | Very scratchy due to POM on POM friction &or scratchy molds. Stem retool means these aren't useable for frankenswitching anymore. | Durock POM, Akko POM? |
8 | Tecsee Carrot/Purple Panda | PME flaking on earlier revisions, questionable QC, and die-off rate for other helper (6/70 over a few months) leaves us too suspicious to wholly recommend Tecsee switches | |
9 | Tecsee Ruby/Sapphire/Grape | UHMWPE mix stem shrinking makes the stem wobble pretty noticeable. V2's improve on this, but not by much. | |
10 | Tecsee Lychee | See above | |
11 | Tecsee Diamond?Jadeite | Tecsee UHMWPE tops come off much easier than they should. | |
12 | Tecsee/Aeboards Raed/Naevy v1.5 | Tecsee PE mix stems have been known to snap off into a keycap on rare occasions, when a keycap is pulled at an off-angle | |
13 | Tecsee/Aeboards Blaeck | Brittle nylon means the legs of the switch top have been known to snap off on occasion | |
14 | Gateron North Pole v2 | Silicone dampener in stem pole hole to quiet bottom out, turns it into half-silent. This is not advertised, for unknown reasons. | |
15 | Boba LTv2 | In early revisions, X axis of stem crucifix seemed to be excessively thick, lead to stretched/cracked keycaps. Unsure if retool has since fixed this, buyer beware. | |
16 | |||
17 | LEGACY WARNINGS | NOTES | CLOSEST ALTERNATIVES |
18 | Everglide (JWK) Aqua King/ Water King | Inconsistent lubing, tolerance issues in earlier versions. Later versions claim to solve tolerance issues, but factory grease can still be very heavy. Clear stem isn't going to make your RGB go through MEGA EPIC COOLNESS | Gateron Pro KS9, Gateron North Pole |
19 | Gateron Ink * v2 | Previous history of QC issues/bad batches. Applies to all Ink v2 switches. | Durock Lavenders, Oil Kings |
20 | Zeal Tealios | Overpriced. There are better options for half the price. | Any JWK Linear |
21 | Zeal Zealios v2 | Overpriced. Should only be purchased if you are looking for the EXACT type of tactility that it provides, without compromise. | Durock T1 |
22 | Early 2021 Batch TKC/C3 Kiwi/Tangerine/Dragonfruit/Pewter | Previous batch has had leaf issues; may have bad ping or may not work at all. | Durock T1/Medium Tactile/L Series/Light Tactile |
23 | Early 2021 Batch C3 Dragonfruit | Less tactile than the Ergo Clear stem makes it out to be. Also all the UHMWPE housing issues that JWK experienced that one time. | Durock Medium |
24 | Old Batch Monokei Pinoko | Crunchy springs. | Any JWK Linear |
25 | Old Batch Monokei Okomochi | Crunchy springs. | Durock T1 |
1 | MATERIAL | NOTES | MANUFACTURER | NOTES | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | Polycarbonate | higher pitch, tends to be smoother | Cherry | cherry nylon sounds good, everyone is saying this | |
3 | Nylon | lower pitch. thock? thocky switch? get youtube view? lends itself to scratch sooner | JWK | Decent bottoming out sound, tops tend to produce thinner sound - hence why some people like to Cherry-top their H1's. | |
4 | PC/Nylon mix | mixed bag, all over the place depending on mix composition and manu. Gateron (between milky and ink housings) seem to get a lower pitch out of these, JWK I'm not so sure. | Gateron | nylon maybe slightly higher pitched than cherry. ink sounds low. pom is midrange sound | |
5 | UHMWPE | Depends on manu. c3 (via jwk) very high pitched, tecsee (for housing) not so much | SP-Star | Nylon somehow clackier/higher pitched than usual, possibly even over their own PC. | |
6 | POM | "Clackier", prone to stickslip on pom stem. mostly meme material, but durock poms do have a well-deserved popularity | Outemu | Springs/leaves are pingy stock, except for Gazzew switches. | |
7 | "Boba" | would be lower more on the side of nylon than pc if it weren't for the smd cutout on the bottom housing | Tecsee | nylon sounds close to cherry, only somehow more inconsistent when it comes to scratch. |