AFR Grading Sheet


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Ranger's Hawk	C+	C
3	You're Ambushed on the Road	C	C-
4	Plus 2 Mace	C-	C+
5	Dawnbringer Cleric	D+	D+
6	Delver's Torch	C-	C+
7	Dwarfhold Champion	C	C+
8	Paladin's Shield	D	D
9	Potion of Healing	D	D
10	Steadfast Paladin	C+	C+
11	You Hear Something on Watch	C+	C+
12	Celestial Unicorn	C	C
13	Gloom Stalker	C-	C
14	Minimus Containment	B-	B-
15	Priest of Ancient Lore	C	B-
16	Arborea Pegasus	C+	C-
17	Half-Elf Monk	C-	C
18	Veteran Dungeoneer	C-	C
19	Devoted Paladin	C+	C
20	Planar Ally	C	C+
21
22	Cleric Class	BA B	B-
23	Monk of the Open Hand	D+	D
24	Portable Hole	D+	D+
25	Divine Smite	C	SB
26	Dragon's Disciple	D+	C-
27	Ingenious Smith	SYN C+	SYN C+
28	Keen-Eared Sentry	D+	D+
29	Blink Dog	C-	C+
30	Cloister Gargoyle	BA B-	B-
31	Moon-Blessed Cleric	SYN C+	SYN C+
32	Plate Armor	BA B-	B
33	Rally Maneuver	B-	C
34	White Dragon	B-	B
35
36	Paladin Class	B-	B
37	Dancing Sword	B	B+
38	Loyal Warhound	C+	C+
39	Flumph	D-	F
40	Oswald Fiddlebender	C	C
41	The Book of Exalted Deeds	BA B	BA B+
42	Guardian of Faith	B+	C+
43	Nadaar, Selfless Paladin	B+	B
44	Grand Master of Flowers	B+	BA B
45	Icingdeath, Frost Tyrant	A	A-
46	Teleportation Circle	BA C+	BA B-


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Secret Door	C-	D+
3	Silver Raven	D+	D
4	You See a Guard Approach	D	D
5	Arcane Investigator	C	C+
6	Mordenkainen's Polymorph	D+	D
7	Pixie Guide	SYN C+	SYN B-
8	Shocking Grasp	C	D+
9	You Come to a River	C	C
10	Bar the Gate	C	C
11	Charmed Sleep	C+	C+
12	Clever Conjurer	C+	C+
13	Scion of Stygia	C	C
14	Soulknife Spy	C	C+
15	You Find the Villains' Lair	C-	C-
16	Contact Other Plane	C	C
17	Djinni Windseer	C+	B-
18	Shortcut Seeker	C	C-
19	Rimeshield Frost Giant	C-	C
20	Air-Cult Elemental	C	C+
21
22	Fly	SYN D+	C
23	Trickster's Talisman	C+	C
24	Wizard Class	B-	B-
25	Guild Thief	C-	C+
26	Ray of Frost	C	C+/SB+++
27	Displacer Beast	C+	C+
28	Eccentric Apprentice	B-	B-
29	Feywild Trickster	BA B+	BA B
30	Power of Persuasion	D+	SYN C+
31	Aberrant Mind Sorcerer	B-	SYN B
32	Split the Party	B	C
33	Sudden Inisght	C-	C
34	Blue Dragon	C-	C
35
36	The Blackstaff of Waterdeep	SYN D	BA B
37	Yuan-Ti Malison	B	B-
38	Dragon Turtle	B+	B
39	Grazilaxx, Illithid Scholar	B	B
40	Tasha's Hideous Laughter	D-	F
41	Demilich	BA B	BA B
42	Iymrith, Desert Doom	A	A
43	Mind Flayer	A	A
44	Mordenkainen	A-	A
45	True Polymorph	C-	BA D
46	Wizard's Spellbook	B	BA C+


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Devour Intellect	SB	D+
3	Feign Death	D+	C
4	Shambling Ghast	C	D
5	Deadly Dispute	C-	SYN C+
6	Fates' Reversal	C-	D+
7	Hired Hexblade	C-	SYN C+
8	Hoard Robber	D+	SYN C-
9	Sepulcher Ghoul	C+	SYN C
10	Thieves' Tools	D+	SYN C-
11	Precipitous Drop	B-	C+
12	Vampire Spawn	C-	C
13	Yuan-Ti Fang Blade	C	C+
14	Clattering Skeletons	C-	C
15	Grim Bounty	B-	B-
16	Manticore	C	C-
17	Herald of Hadar	D+	C
18	Zombie Ogre	C	C+
19	Baleful Beholder	D+	D+
20	Eyes of the Beholder	D+	C-
21
22	Dungeon Crawler	C-	C+
23	Ray of Enfeeblement	C+	C
24	Reaper's Talisman	C+	B-
25	Warlock Class	C	C+
26	Check for Traps	C	C-
27	Grim Wanderer	C+	B-
28	Lightfoot Rogue	C+	C+
29	Power Word Kill	B+	B
30	Demogorgon's Clutches	D+	C-
31	Skullport Merchant	B	B
32	Death-Priest of Myrkul	BA B	B-
33	Drider	D	C
34	Black Dragon	C+	C
35
36	Forsworn Paladin	B-	C+
37	Vorpal Sword	B	B
38	Sphere of Annihilation	B-	C+
39	Wight	B	B-
40	Acerak the Archlich	BA B+	BA A-
41	The Book of Vile Darkness	F	F
42	Ebondeath, Dracolich	A-	A
43	Gelatinous Cube	A-	A-
44	Lolth, Spider Queen	A	A
45	Westgate Regent	B+	A
46	Asmodeus the Archfiend	BA B+	BA B-


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Boots of Speed	SYN C	D+
3	Dueling Rapier	D+	D+
4	Goblin Javelineer	C	SYN C-
5	Kick in the Door	C	C-
6	Armory Veteran	C+	C
7	Brazen Dwarf	SYN C+	SYN C
8	Dragon's Fire	B	B
9	Hobgoblin Captain	C+	C+
10	You Come to the Gnoll Camp	C-	C-
11	Improvised Weaponry	C+	C
12	Plundering Barbarian	C-	D+
13	Price of Loyalty	SYN C	SYN C+
14	Valor singer	C	C
15	Hoarding Ogre	D+	C-
16	Jaded Sell-Sword	C	C
17	Unexpected Windfall	SYN C	C-
18	Farideh's Fireball	C-	C
19	Swarming Goblins	C	C
20	Earth-Cult Elemental	D	C
21
22	Barbarian Class	BA B-	BA B-
23	Battle-Cry Goblin	C	C+
24	Burning Hands	C+	C+
25	Critical Hit	D	C-
26	Goblin Morningstar	B-	B-
27	You Find Some Prisoners	C-	D
28	Hulking Bugbear	C+	C+
29	Magic Missile	B-	B
30	Rust Monster	B-	C+
31	You See a Pair of Goblins	C-	D+
32	Chaos Channeler	B-	B-
33	Tiger-Tribe Hunter	C+	C
34	Red Dragon	B-	B
35
36	Minion of the Mighty	F	BA D-
37	Orb of Dragonkind	F	F
38	Flameskull	B+	B+
39	Hobgoblin Bandit Lord	BA C+	SYN C+
40	Wish	F	F
41	Meteor Swarm	A	A
42	Xorn	BA B-	BA B
43	Delina, Wild Mage	C+	B-
44	Zariel, Archduke of Avernus	B+	B
45	Zalto, Fire Giant Duke	B-	C+
46	Inferno of the Star Mounts	A	A


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Neverwinter Dryad	C+	C+
3	Bull's Strength	C	C-
4	Compelled Duel	D	D
5	Gnoll Hunter	C+	C
6	Plummet	SB	SB
7	Ranger's Longbow	D	C
8	Scaled Herbalist	D+	D
9	Underdark Basilisk	C	C
10	You Find a Cursed Idol	C-	SB
11	Circle of the Moon Druid	C+	C
12	Dire Wolf Prowler	D+	C
13	Find the Path	SYN C	C+
14	Spoils of the Hunt	C+	C+
15	Sylvan Shepherd	C-	D+
16	Bulette	C-	C-
17	Inspiring Bard	C+	C
18	Elturgard Ranger	C-	C
19	Owlbear	C+	B-
20	Hill Giant Herdgorger	C	C+
21
22	Wild Shape	D+	C-
23	Druid Class	SYN C+	D+
24	Intrepid Outlander	B-	C+
25	Prosperous Innkeeper	SYN C	D
26	Choose Your Weapon	C-	D+
27	Lurking Roper	SYN B-	SYN C+
28	You Happen On a Glade	C+	C
29	Hunter's Mark	C+	B-
30	Wandering Troubadour	B	B-
31	You Meet in a Tavern	C	C+
32	Loathsome Troll	C+	C+
33	Green Dragon	C+	B-
34	Purple Worm	B-	B
35
36	Instrument of the Bards	F	F
37	Ochre Jelly	B+	B
38	Ranger Class	B+	A-
39	Werewolf Pack Leader	B	B+
40	Circle of Dreams Druid	D	C+
41	Long Rest	BA B	C+
42	Varis, Silverymoon Ranger	B+	B
43	Ellywick Tumblestrum	B	B-
44	Froghemoth	B+	B-
45	Old Gnawbone	B-	B
46	The Tarrasque	D	BA B


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Greataxe	D	D-
3	Leather Armor	D	D-
4	Spare Dagger	SYN D+	D
5	Spiked Pit Trap	C-	C
6	Mimic	D	D-
7
8	Bag of Holding	C+	B
9	Fifty Feet of Rope	D	C+
10	Dungeon Map	B-	C+
11	Iron Golem	C	C
12
13	Eye of Vecna	C	D+
14	Hand of Vecna	B-	D+
15	Treasure Chest	D	D+
16	The Deck of Many Things	B+	A-


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Barrowin of Clan Undurr	B	B-
3	Bruenor Battlehammer	B+	B
4	Farideh, Devil's Chosen	BA B+	B
5	Gretchen Titchwillow	B+	B-
6	Hama Pashar, Ruin Seeker	C+	B
7	Kalain, Reclusive Painter	C+	C+
8	Krydle of Baldur's Gate	C+	B-
9	Shessra, Death's Whisper	C+	C+
10	Targ Nar, Demon-Fang Gnoll	B	B-
11	Trelasarra, Moon Dancer	BA B	B-
12
13	Adult Gold Dragon	A	A
14	Bard Class	F	F
15	Drizzt Do'Urden	A	A
16	Fighter Class	C	BA B
17	Minsc, Beloved Ranger	C	C+
18	Monk Class	B	B-
19	Orcus, Prince of Undeath	A-	A-
20	Rogue Class	B	B-
21	Skeletal Swarming	B+	B-
22	Sorcerer Class	D	BA C+
23	Tiamat	BA A	BA C
24	Triumphant Adventurer	B+	B
25	Volo, Guide to Monsters	A-	BA B+
26	Xanathar, Guild Kingpin	A-	A


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Evolving Wilds	C	C+
3
4	Temple of the Dragon Queen	C	C+
5
6	Cave of the Frost Dragon	B-	C+
7	Den of the Bugbear	B-	C+
8	Hall of the Storm Giants	B-	C+
9	Hive of the Eye Tyrant	B-	C+
10	Lair of the Hydra	B-	C+
11	Treasure Vault	D+	C+
12	Dungeon Descent	D	D


1	CARD	Cost	CMC	Kills	Speed	Rarity
2	Divine Smite	1W	2	Exiles Black Permanent	Instant	U
3	Portable Hole	W	1	Exile Nonland Permanent MV 2 or less	Sorcery	U
4	Minimus Containment	2W	3	Permanent becomes a Treasure	Sorcery	C
5	You Hear Something on Watch	1W	2	Deal 5 to Attacking Creature	Instant	C
6	Charmed Sleep	1UU	3	Tap creature, doesn't untap	Sorcery	C
7	Ray of Frost	1U	2	Enchanted Creature doesn't untap (tap if it's red)	Instant	U
8	Eyes of the Beholder	4BB	6	Target creatures gets -11/-11 until EOT	Instant	C
9	Grim Bounty	2BB	4	Destroy a Creature or planeswalker	Sorcery	C
10	Power Word Kill	1B	2	Destroy non Angel/Demon/Devil/Dragon	Instant	U
11	Precipitous Drop	2B	3	-2/-2 or -5/-5 if dungeon complete	Sorcery	C
12	Ray of Enfeeblement	B	1	-4/-1 until EOT or -4/-4 if White	Instant	U
13	Burning Hands	1R	2	2 to a creature or PW, 6 if green	Instant	U
14	Dragon's Fire	1R	2	Deal 3 to Creature or PW	Instant	C
15	Farideh's Fireball	3RR	5	Deal 5 to C or PW	Instant	C
16	Improvised Weaponry	2R	3	Deal 2 to any target	Instant	C
17	Magic Missile	1RR	3	Deal 3 damage divided	Sorcery	U
18	Hunter's Mark	3G	4	Plus 1/1 until EOT and Punch	Instant	U
19	Spoils of the Hunt	2G	3	Plus 1/0 for each treasure and punch	Instant	C
20	Spiked Pit Trap	1	1	5 T: Sac Deal 5 to a creature	Instant	C
21			52


1	Card	Color	Cost	Effect	Rarity
2	You're Ambushed on the Road	W	W	Choose 1: Bounce a creature you control or target creature gets +1+3 until eot	C
3	You Hear Something on Watch	W	1W	Choose 1: Creatures you control get +1+1 until eot or deal 5 damage to target attacking creature	C
4	Paladin's Shield	W	1W	Flash. When ~ etbs, attach it to target creature. Equipped creature gets +0+2. Equip 3.
5	Rally Manuever	W	2W	Target creatures gets +2+0 and first strike until eot; another target creature gets +0+2 and lifelink until eot	U
6	You See a Guard Approach	U	U	Choose 1: Tap target creature or target creature you control gains hexproof until eot	C
7	You Come to a River	U	1U	Choose 1: Bounce a nonland permanent or target creature gets +1+0 and can't be blocked this turn	C
8	Shocking Grasp	U	1U	Target creature gets -2-0 until eot; draw a card.	C
9	Modenkainen's Polymorph	U	1U	Until eot, target creature becomes a Dragon with base power and toughness 4/4 and gains flying	C
10	Scion of Stygia	U	2U	Flash. 2/1 When Scion of Stygia etbs, choose target creature then roll a D20. 1-9 = Tap that creature. 10-20 = Tap that creature and it doesn't untap during it's controller's next untap step.	C
11	Feign Death	B	B	Until eot, target creature gains "when this dies, return it to the battlefied tapped with a +1+1 counter"	C
12	Ray of Enfeeblement	B	B	Target creature gets -4-1 until eot. If it's white, it gets -4-4 instead.	U
13	Grim Wanderer	B	1B	Flash. 5/3. Cast this spell only if a creature died this turn.
14	Manticore	B	3B	Flash. 2/1 Flying. When Manticore etbs, destroy target creature an opponent controls that was dealt damage this turn.
15	Dueling Rapier	R	R	Flash. When ~ enters the battlefield, attach it to target creature. Equipped creature gets +2+0. Equip 4.
16	Critical Hit	R	1R	Target creature gains double strike until eot. If you roll a nat 20, return Critical Hit from gy to hand	U
17	You Come to a Gnoll Camp	R	1R	Choose 1: Up to two target creatures can't block this tuirn or target creature gets +3+1 until eot	C
18	You Find Some Prisoners	R	1R	Choose 1: Destroy target artifact or Exile the top 3 cards of opponent's library. Choose 1 to cast until end of your next turn.	C
19	You See a Pair of Goblins	R	2R	Choose 1: Creatures you control get +2+0 until eot or Creature two 1/1 red Goblin creature tokens	U
20	Wild Shape	G	G	Choose 1: Until eot, target creature you control is: 1/3 turtle w/ hexproof, 1/5 spider with reach, or 3/3 elephant w/ trample	U
21	Bull's Strength	G	1G	Target creature gets +2+2 and gains trample until eot. Untap it.	C
22	Choose Your Weapon	G	2G	Choose 1: Double target creature's power and toughness until eot or Deal 5 damage to target creature with flying.	U
23	Spoils of the Hunt	G	2G	Target creature you control gets +1+0 for each mana from a treasure used to cast this spell. Then deal damage = power to target creature.	C
24	Hunters Mark	G	3G	Costs 3 less to cast if it targets a U permanent. Can't be countered. Target creature you control gets +1+1 until eot then deals damage = power to target creature or planeswalker	U


1		Commons	Uncommons
2	White	1. Minimus Containment	1. White Dragon
3		2. Steadfast Paladin	2. Plate Armor
4		3. Devoted Paladin
5
6	Blue	1. Charmed Sleep	1. Feywild Trickster
7		2. Djinni Windseer	2. Wizard Class
8		3. Clever Conjurer
9
10	Black	1. Grim Bounty	1. Power Word Kill
11		2. Precipitous Drop	2. Skullport Merchant
12		3. Sepulcher Ghoul
13
14	Red	1. Dragon's Fire	1. Magic Missile
15		2. Hobgoblin Captain	2. Goblin Morningstar
16		3. Armory Veteran
17
18	Green	1. Spoils of the Hunt	1. Purple Worm
19		2. Owlbear	2. Wandering Troubadour
20		3. Gnoll Hunter


1	White Commons	White Uncommons
2	1. Priest of Ancient Lore	1. Plate Armor
3	2. Steadfast Paladin	2. White Dragon
4	3. Delver's Torch
5
6	Blue Commons	Blue Uncommons
7	1. Soulknife Spy	1. Feywild Trickster
8	2. Djinni Windseer	2. Aberrant Mind Sorcerer
9	3. Charmed Sleep
10
11	Black Commons	Black Uncommons
12	1. Grim Bounty	1. Power Word Kill
13	2. Precipitous Drop	2. Skullport Merchant
14	3. Yuan-Ti Fang-Blade
15
16	Red Commons	Red Uncommons
17	1. Dragon's Fire	1. Magic Missile
18	2. Hobgoblin Captain	2. Red Dragon
19	3. Armory Veteran
20
21	Green Commons	Green Uncommons
22	1. Owlbear	1. Purple Worm
23	2. Spoils of the Hunt	2. Hunter's Mark
24	3. Neverwinter Dryad