MKM Grading Spreadsheet


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Novice Inspector	B-	B-
3	Auspicious Arrival	DR C	C
4	Marketwatch Phantom	C	C+
5	Seasoned Consultant	D+	C
6	Due Diligence	D	D
7	Inside Source	C+	C+
8	Makeshift Binding	B-	C+
9	Make Your Move	DR C	SB
10	Griffnaut Tracker	C-	D+
11	Museum Nightwatch	C+	D+
12	On the Job	SYN C+	D
13	Haazda Vigilante	D	D
14	Defenestrated Phantom	D	D
15
16	Forum Familiar	SYN C	D
17	Krovod Haunch	C+	SYN C
18	Wrench	D+	SYN C-
19	Call a Surprise Witness	SYN C-	SYN C+
20	Case of the Gateway Express	SYN C+	B-
21	Case of the Pilfered Proof	SYN C-	SYN B-
22	Neighborhood Guardian	C+	SYN B-
23	Not on My Watch	C+	SYN C+
24	Perimeter Enforcer	B-	BA B
25	Sanctuary Wall	D+	C-
26	Case File Auditor	BA B	BA D
27	Karlov Watchdog	SYN C	D+
28	Absolving Lammasu	C	C+
29	Essence of Antiquity	D+	D+


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Behind the Mask	D	D
3	Bubble Smuggler	C	C
4	Deduce	C+	SYN C+
5	Jaded Analyst	D	D
6	Reasonable Doubt	C-	C
7	Unauthorized Exit	C-	DR C-
8	Crimestopper Sprite	C-	C+
9	Dramatic Accusation	C+	C
10	Projektor Inspector	C	C
11	Cold Case Cracker	C+	C
12	Out Cold	DR C	C
13	Benthic Criminologists	D+	D
14	Hotshot Investigators	C	C
15
16	Candlestick	C-	D
17	Case of the Filched Falcon	C+	BA B
18	Curious Inquiry	D	C
19	Mistway Spy	C+	C-
20	Burden of Proof	SYN C-	C+
21	Eliminate the Impossible	C+	C
22	Exit Specialist	B	B-
23	Fae Flight	B	B-
24	Forensic Researcher	C+	C
25	Furtive Courier	C	C
26	Sudden Setback	D+	C-
27	Surveillance Monitor	BA B-	BA C-
28	Living Conundrum	BA OMG	BA B
29	Agency Outfitter	BA C	BA C


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Slice from the Shadows	C+	C+
3	Snarling Gorehound	C	SYN D+
4	Toxin Analysis	C+	C
5	Extract a Confession	C+	B-
6	Repeat Offender	C-	C-
7	Unscrupulous Agents	C+	C+
8	Alley Assailant	C	C
9	Cerebral Confiscation	D+	D
10	Murder	B	C+
11	Macabre Reconstruction	DR C	DR C
12	Rot Farm Mortipede	C	C
13	Agency Coroner	SYN C-	D
14	Basilica Stalker	C	C-
15
16	Case of the Gorgon's Kiss	B-	SYN C
17	Festerleech	C+	B
18	Lead Pipe	D+	D
19	Leering Onlooker	B-	B
20	Long Goodbye	C+	B-
21	Presumed Dead	C	C
22	Clandestine Meddler	C	C
23	Nightdrinker Moroii	B	D
24	Slimy Dualleech	D+	SYN B-
25	Soul Enervation	C+	C+
26	It Doesn'tAdd Up	C	C+
27	Polygraph Orb	D	BA C
28	Undercity Eliminator	B+	B
29	Persuasive Interrogators	BA C	C+


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Felonious Rage	C-	D+
3	Goblin Maskmaker	D-	D-
4	Shock	C+	C+
5	Demand Answers	C+	C+
6	Galvanize	B+	B-
7	Innocent Bystander	D+	D+
8	Red Herring	C	C
9	Gearbane Orangutan	BA B	C
10	The Chase is On	D	C
11	Person of Interest	C	C+
12	Offender at Large	D+	D
13	Rubblebelt Braggart	D	D+
14	Suspicious Detonation	SYN C	SYN C-
15
16	Convenient Target	C+	B-
17	Frantic Scapegoat	D	SYN D+
18	Knife	D+	SYN C
19	Torch the Witness	B+	B
20	Concealed Weapon	C	C
21	Expose the Culprit	D	D
22	Reckless Detective	C-	D+
23	Vengeful Tracker	C	SB
24	Case of the Burning Masks	C	B
25	Crime Novelist	SYN C	SYN B-
26	Harried Dronesmith	SYN C+	SYN C+
27	Caught Red-handed	SYN C	D
28	Cornered Crook	B+	B
29	Bolrac-Clan Basher	C+	C


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Pick Your Poison	SB	SB
3	Rubblebelt Maverick	C	SYN C+
4	Fanatical Strength	SYN C+	C+
5	Nervous Gardener	C+	C+
6	Tunnel Tipster	D+	C
7	Vitu-Ghazi Inspector	SYN C+	SYN C+
8	Airtight Alibi	DR C-	D+
9	Slime Against Humanity	BA F	BA D-
10	They Went This Way	D+	C-
11	Bite Down on Crime	C+	C
12	Loxodon Eavesdropper	C+	C
13	Vengeful Creeper	D+	C-
14	Topiary Panther	SYN C+	SYN C+
15
16	Get a Leg Up	C+	SYN C+
17	Hard-Hitting Question	B	B
18	Hedge Whisperer	D	D+
19	Rope	D	D
20	Aftermath Analyst	SYN C-	SYN C-
21	Flourishing Bloom-Kin	BA C+	BA B-	MONO GREEN???
22	Case of the Trampled Garden	SYN C+	B-
23	Pompous Gadabout	C-	D+
24	Sample Collector	D	C-
25	Chalk Outline	BA C	BA B-
26	Greenbelt Radical	C+	C+
27	A Killer Among Us	C	D+
28	Culvert Ambusher	C	C
29	Glint Weaver	C-	B


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Crowd-Control Warden	C-	C
3	Dog Walker	B	B
4	Faerie Snoop	B	B-
5	Gadget Technician	B	B-
6	Granite Witness	C+	C+
7	Rakish Scoundrel	D+	D+
8	Riftburst Hellion	C+	C-
9	Sanguine Savior	B	B-
10	Shady Informant	D	D
11	Undercover Crocodelf	D+	C-
12
13	Break Out	F	D+
14	Buried in the Garden	C+	B-
15	Cease // Desist	SB	SB
16	Coerced to Kill	B+	B
17	Curious Cadaver	C-	C
18	Deadly Complication	B+	B
19	Detective's Satchel	C	BA B
20	Evidence Examiner	B-	B
21	Flotsam // Jetsam	C+	C
22	Fuss // Bother	B	B-
23	Gleaming Geardrake	B+	B
24	Hustle // Bustle	C-	C+
25	Insidious Roots	BA C-	BA B
26	Kraul Whipcracker	C+	C+
27	Lightning Helix	B+	B
28	Meddling Youths	B-	B-
29	No More Lies	C+	C+
30	Private Eye	B	B
31	Push // Pull	C+	B-
32	Repulsive Mutation	C	C+
33	Rune-Brand Juggler	B-	C+
34	Soul Search	SB	D+
35	Sumala Sentry	B	C+
36	Tin Street Gossip	C+	C+
37	Wispdrinker Vampire	B	B


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Thinking Cap	SYN C+	SYN C+
3	Gravestone Strider	D	D+
4	Sanitation Automaton	D+	D
5	Magnifying Glass	D	D
6
7	Case of the Shattered Pact	BA C+	B
8	Lumbering Laundry	C-	D+
9	Magnetic Snuffler	SYN C	SYN C-


1	Card	Ethan's Grade	Ben's Grade
2	Escape Tunnel	C	C+
3	Public Thoroughfare	BA B	C+
4
5	Branch of Vitu-Ghazi	C-	C+
6	Scene of the Crime	SYN C+	C+


1	CARD	Cost	MV	Kills	Speed	Rarity
2	Case of the Gateway Express	1W	2	1 Damage to target creature equal to your creatures	Sorcery	U
3	Makeshift Binding	2W	3	Exile target creature	Sorcery	C
4	Not on My Watch	1W	2	Exile target attacking creature	Instant	U
5	Dramatic Accusation	2U	3	Tap a creature keep it tapped (UU shuffle it away)	Sorcery	C
6	Sudden Setback	2UU	4	Target Nonland Permanent on top or bottom	Instant	U
7	Extract a Confession	1B	2	Sac a creature	Sorcery	C
8	Long Goodbye	1B	3	Destroy creature with MV 3 or less	Instant	U
9	Murder	1BB	3	Destroy target creature	Instant	C
10	Slice from the Shadows	XB	NA	Target creature gets -x/-x until EOT	Instant	C
11	Soul Enervation	3B	4	Target creature gets -4/-4 until EOT	Instant	U
12	Case of the Burnings Masks	1RR	3	Deal 3 to target creature	Sorcery	U
13	Galvanize	1R	2	Deal 3 to target creature (5 if you've drawn a second card this turn)	Instant	C
14	Shock	R	1	Deal 2 to any target	Instant	C
15	Suspicious Detonation	4R	5	4 to target creature	Sorcery	C
16	Torch the Witness	XR	NA	twice X Damage to target creature	Sorcery	U
17	Bite Down on Crime	3G	4	Plus 2/0 until EOT and bite	Sorcery	C
18	Hard Hitting Question	G	1	Creature bites another creatures	Sorcery	U
19	Coerced to Kill	3UB	5	Steal a thing it's a 1/1 with deathtouch	Sorcery	U
20	Deadly Complication	1RB	3	Destroy target creature	Sorcery	U
21	Buried in the Garden	2GW	4	Exile target nonland permanent until this leaves	Sorcery	U
22	Lightning Helix	RW	2	3 to any target, gain 3 life	Instant	U
23	Push of Push //Pull	1 W/B	2	Destroy target tapped creature	Sorcery	U


1	Card	Cost	Effect	Rarity
2	Auspicious Arrivial	1W	Target creature gets +2+2 until end of turn. Investigate	C
3	On the Job	2WW	Creatures you control get +2+1 until end of turn. Investigate.	C
4	Behind the Mask	U	Collect Evidence 6. Until eot, target artifact or creature becomes a 4/3 artifact creature. If evidence was collected, it's a 1/1 instead.	C
5	Eliminate the Impossible	1U	Investigate. Creatures your opponents control get -2-0 until end of turn. If any of them are suspected, they're no longer suspected.	U
6	Out Cold	3U	Can't be countered. Tap up to two target creatures and put a stun counter on each of them. Investigate.	C
7	Sudden Setback	2UU	The owner of target spell or nonland permanent puts it on the top or bottom of their library.	U
8	Unauthorized Exit	1U	Return target nonland permanent to it's owner's hand. Surveil 1.	C
9	Presumed Dead	1B	Until eot, target creature gets +2+0 and gains "When this creature dies, return it to the battlefield under its owner's control and suspect it."	U
10	Slice from the Shadows	BX	Can't be countered. Target creature gets -X-X until eot.	C
11	Toxin Analysis	B	Target creature gains deathtouch and lifelink until eot. Investigate.	C
12	Expose the Culprit	1R	Choose 1 or both. 1. Turn target face-down creature face up. 2. Exile any number of face-up creatures you control with disguise in a face-down pile, shuffle and cloak them.	U
13	Felonious Rage	R	Target creature you control gets +2+0 and gains haste until eot. When that creature dies this turn, create a 2/2 white and blue Detective creature token.	C
14	The Chase Is On	2R	Target creature gets +3+0 and gains first strike until eot. Investigate.	C
15	Fanatical Strength	1G	Target creature gets +3+3 and gains trample until eot.	C
16	Get a Leg Up	G	Until eot, target creature gets +1+1 for each creature you control and gains reach.	U
17	Repulsive Mutation	UGX	Put X +1+1 coutners on target creature you control. Then counter up to one target spell unless its controller pays mana equal to the greatest power among creatures you control.	U
18	Hustle//Bustle	U/R or 4R/GR/G	Target creature attacks or blocks this turn if able. Sorcery Creatures you control get +2+2 and gain trample until eot. You may turn a creature you control face up.	U
19	Fuss	2R/W	Put a +1+1 counter on each attacking creature you control	U
20	Airtight Alibi	2G	Flash. Enchant creature. When Airtight Alibi enters the battlefield, untap enchanted creature. It gains hexproof until eot. If it's suspected, it's no longer suspected. Enchanted creature gets +2+2 and can't become suspected.	C
21	Burden of Proof	1U	Flash. Enchant Creature. Enchanted creature gets +2+2 as long as it's a Detective you control. Otherwise, it has base power and toughness 1/1 and can't block Detectives.	U
22	Fae Flight	1U	Flash. Enchant Creature. When Fae Flight enters the battlefield, enchanted creature gains hexproof until eot. Enchanted creature gets +1+0 and has flying.	U
23	Soul Enervation	3B	Flash. When Soul Enervation enters the battlefield, target creature gets -4-4 until eot. Whenever one or more creature cards leave your graveyard, each opponent loses 1 life and you gain 1 life.	U


1		Commons	Uncommons
2	White	1. Novice Inspector	1. Perimeter Enforcer
3		2. Makeshift Binding	2. Neighborhood Guardian
4		3. Inside Source
5
6	Blue	1. Deduce	1. Exit Specialist
7		2. Dramatic Accusation	2. Fae Flight
8		3. Cold Case Cracker
9
10	Black	1. Murder	1. Undercity Eliminator
11		2. Extract a Confession	2. Nightdrinker Moroii
12		3. Toxin Analysis
13
14	Red	1. Galvanize	1. Torch the Witness
15		2. Gearbane Orangutan	2. Cornered Crook
16		3. Shock
17
18	Green	1. Nervous Gardener	1. Hard-Hitting Question
19		2. Loxodon Eavesdropper	2. Greenbelt Radical
20		3. Bite Down on Crime
21
22	Multicolor	1. Dog Walker
23		2. Gadget Technician
24		3. Faerie Snoop


1	White Commons	White Uncommons
2	1. Novice Inspector	1. Perimeter Enforcer
3	2. Marketwatch Phantom	2. Case of the Gateway Express
4	3. Makeshift Binding
5
6	Blue Commons	Blue Uncommons
7	1. Crimestopper Sprite	1. Fae Flight
8	2. Cold Case Cracker	2. Exit Specialist
9	3. Out Cold
10
11	Black Commons	Black Uncommons
12	1. Extract a Confession	1. Leering Onlooker
13	2. Unscrupulous Agent	2. Festerleech
14	3. Slice from the Shadows
15
16	Red Commons	Red Uncommons
17	1. Galvanize	1. Case of the Burning Masks
18	2. Person of Interest	2. Torch the Witness
19	3. Shock
20
21	Green Commons	Green Uncommons
22	1. Nervous Gardener	1. Hard Hitting Question
23		2. Glint Weaver
24	3. Loxodon Eavesdropper
25
26	Multicolor Commons
27	1. Gadget Technician
28	2. Dog Walker
29	3. Faerie Snoop
30	HM: Sanguine Savior