Reconsideration Requests of Library Materials List.xlsx

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H
1	Book Title	Author	Status	Decision Date	Decision	Rationale	Appeal Date	Appeal Final Decision
2	Slaugterhouse Five	Kurt Vonnegut	Review Complete	9/28/2023	Retain	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book does not contain sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been retained in school library circulation.	10/1/23	Retain (1/24/24)
3	Tilt	Ellen Hopkins	Review Complete	10/31/23	Restrict to 12th Grade Only	The review committee made the determination that the book would only be appropriate for 12th grade. The committee emphasized the value of some real-life experiences in the book that may or may not have merit to older and limited audiences.	11/10/23	Remove (1/24/24)
4	The Handmaid's Tale: The Graphic Novel	Margaret Atwood	Review Complete	4/24/24	Restricted (check-out with parent permission only)	The review committee made the determination that the book will be restricted and only checked out with parent permission. Some of the material may not be appropriate for students and would like parents to determine that for their child.	5/14/24	Restricted (check-out with parent permission only) (9/10/24)
5	The Handmaid's Tale	Margaret Atwood	Review Complete	3/27/26	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-208, or 76-5c-207. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
6	Living Dead Girl	Elizabeth Scott	Review Complete	5/15/24	Retain	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book does not contain sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been retained in school library circulation.	5/20/24	Remove (9/10/24)
7	The Freedom Writers Diary	Erin Gruwell and The Freedom Writers	Review Complete	8/8/24	Retain	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book does not contain sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been retained in school library circulation.
8	Me and Earl and the Dying Girl	Jesse Andrews	Review Complete	6/26/24	Retain	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book does not contain sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been retained in school library circulation.	7/10/24	Restrict to grades 9-12 (check-out with parent permission only) 6/10/25
9	Water for Elephants	Sara Gruen	Review Complete	12/20/24	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
10	Looking for Alaska	John Green	Review Complete	3/5/25	Retain	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book does not contain sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been retained in school library circulation.	4/24/25	Remove (2/10/26)
11	Lucky	Alice Sebold	Review Complete	4/7/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
12	Tricks	Ellen Hopkins	Review Complete	2/19/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
13	A Crown of Gilded Bones	Jennifer L. Armentrout	Review Complete	4/7/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
14	One Last Stop	Casey McQuiston	Under Review	11/24/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-207, 76-5c-101, or 76-5c-102. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
15	Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West	Gregory Maquire	Under Review	11/24/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-207, 76-5c-101, or 76-5c-102. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
16	The Perks of Being a Wallflower	Stephen Chbosky	Under Review	11/24/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-207, 76-5c-101, or 76-5c-102. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
17	Storm and Fury	Jennifer L. Armentrout	Review Complete	9/30/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
18	Sold	Patricia McCormick	Under Review
19	Nineteen Minutes	Jody Picoult	Under Review	1124/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-207, 76-5c-101, or 76-5c-102. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
20	Identical	Ellen Hopkins	Review Complete	9/19/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
21	Kingdom of Ash	Sarah J. Maas	Review Complete	9/25/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
22	Perfect	Ellen Hopkins	Review Complete	9/30/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
23	The Gift	Danielle Steel	Review Complete	9/25/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
24	Thirteen Reasons Why	Jay Asher	Review Complete	9/19/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
25	Last Night at the Telegraph Club	Malinda Lo	Review Complete	9/30/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
26	People Kill People	Ellen Hopkins	Review Complete	9/19/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
27	Traffick	Ellen Hopkins	Under Review
28	Blood and Honey	Shelby Mahurin	Under Review
29	Love on the Brain	Ali Hazelwood	Review Complete	9/19/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
30	Serpent & Dove	Shelby Mahurin	Review Complete	9/30/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
31	Kingdom of the Cursed	Kerri Maniscalco	Review Complete	9/30/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
32	Gods & Monsters	Shelby Mahurin	Review Complete	9/19/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
33	Bag of Bones	Stephen King	Review Complete	9/25/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
34	The Brightest Night	Jennifer L. Armentrout	Review Complete	9/30/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
35	Loathe to Love You	Ali Hazelwood	Review Complete	9/30/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
36	Every Summer After	Carley Fortune	Review Complete	9/25/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-10-1227, 76-10-1201, or 76-10-1203. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
37	Bronxwood	Coe Booth	Under Review	11/6/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-208, or 76-5c-207. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
38	Rabbit & Robot	Andrew Smith	Under Review
39	Lonesome Dove	Larry McMurtry	Under Review	11/6/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-208, or 76-5c-207. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
40	Brave New World	Aldous Huxley	Under Review
41	Kingdom of the Feared	Kerri Maniscalco	Under Review
42	Eat, Pray, Love	Elizabeth Gilbert	Under Review	11/6/25	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-208, or 76-5c-207. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
43	Here We Are: Feminism for the Real World	Kelly Jensen	Under Review
44	Suicide Notes: A Novel	Michael Thomas Ford	Under Review	1/29/26	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-208, or 76-5c-207. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
45	Suicide Notes from Beautiful Girls	Lymmn Weingarten	Under Review
46	Running with Scissors	Augusten Burroughs	Under Review	1/29/26	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-208, or 76-5c-207. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
47	Different Seasons	Stephen King	Under Review	1/29/26	Remove	The review committee reviewed the book in its entirety and the book contains objective sensitive material as defined in Utah Code 76-5c-208, or 76-5c-207. Therefore, according to Utah law the book has been removed in school library circulation.
48	An Abundance of Katherines	John Green	Under Review
49	Romeo and/or Juliet	Ryan North	Under Review
50	Every Last Breath	Jennifer L. Armentrout	Under Review
51	Lady Chatterley's Lover	D.H. Lawrence	Under Review
52	Crowntide	Alex Aster	Under Review
53	Grace and Glory	Jennifer L. Armentrout	Under Review
54	All This Twisted Glory	Tahereh Mafi	Under Review
55	Firefly Lane	Kristin Hannah	Under Review
56	Queer, There and Everywhere	Sarah Prager	Under Review
57	When It's Real	Erin Watt	Under Review
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100