| A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | No | Student | Supervisor | Head of i-Kohza | Title | Presentation | Rinkoh | Report | |||||||||||
2 | Name | Metric Number | Department | Name | i-Kohza | Examiner 1 | Examiner 2 | Non SV | SV | Non SV | |||||||||
3 | Name | Examiner's overall comments and suggestions | Examiner's overall comments and suggestions | Examiner's overall comments and suggestions | Examiner's overall comments and suggestions | Examiner's overall comments and suggestions | |||||||||||||
4 | 1 | AHMAD ASYRAF BIN SHAHRUL AMIN | A20MJ0147 | ahmadasyraf@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NORHASNIDAWANI BINTI JOHARI (TS. DR.) | norhasnidawani@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | Durability-Optimized Nanocoatings for Long-lasting Marine Pipeline Corrosion Protection | Good | Objectives are too big for FYP. The material was not available to start the analysis. Please reconstruct the project objectives & scope accordingly. | Excellent | revise based on comment | Marked Report Link | Good | Marked Report Link | |
5 | 2 | AHMAD FAIZ BIN HAKIMI | A20MJ0122 | afhakimi@graduate.utm.my | MPE | FARAH LIANA BINTI MOHD REDZUAN (DR.) | farahliana@utm.my | WIND | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | Fabrication of Bi2Te3 Thermoelectric Thin Films Using Resin 3D Printing | Okay | To swap RO1 and RO2 to match the methodology. Review the objectives & research flow. In FYP2, I suggest making a comparison for the three types of mixtures (40:60. 50:50, 60:40) instead of choosing only 1 mixture. | The student displays great understanding of the research topic. All the best for FYP2 | The student showed a lot of effort for his overall research work but maybe lack of focus and efficiency. The report was submitted last minute hence thorough check and discussion was not done prior to final submission of report draft. Expecting significant improvement in FYP2. | Marked Report Link | Okay | Marked Report Link | |
6 | 3 | ALANG HAFIZ USSAMA BIN ABDULLAH | A20MJ0007 | alanghafizussama@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SHAHIRA LIZA BINTI KAMIS (DR.) | shahiraliza@utm.my | TriPrem | KANAO FUKUDA (PROF. DR.) | fukuda.kl@utm.my | Development of a Bilayer Coating on Lightweight Metal Alloy | Okay | The research is done accordingly, but the student does not know where to apply the output. | Please separate your result and literatures | (1) abstract content 4x research objectives (2) no literature review on hexagonal pattern (3) preliminary results are not discussed well | Marked Report Link | 1) Poor abstract 2) Check the citation format in the text 3) Excessively using repeated terms in the thesis (for example: aims, Laser Surface Texturing (LST), coefficient of friction (COF)). Introduce once only! | Marked Report Link | |
7 | 4 | ANG JING JIE | A20MJ5008 | ang.jie@graduate.utm.my | CAIRO | USWAH BINTI KHAIRUDDIN (DR.) | uswah.kl@utm.my | CAIRO | ZOOL HILMI BIN ISMAIL (IR. DR.) | zool@utm.my | Visual enhancement for underwater images | Okay | Important slides are not visible due to colour selection. Graphs are not labelled, hence difficult to understand. | Need to work on problem statement and objective as well | Good reporting | Marked Report Link | 1) The cover page wrongly stated the faculty & department 2) How to highlight the Mechanical Precision element in this research? 3) Avoid using OUR, WE in the thesis. 4) Flow chart has no decision making activity. 5) Chapter 4 is full with pictures but not so much explanation on each picture. | Marked Report Link | |
8 | 5 | CHEAH WEI ERN | A20MJ0012 | cheahern@graduate.utm.my | MPE | TAN LIT KEN (DR.) | tlken@utm.my | Takasago | YUTAKA ASAKO (PROF.DR) | y.asako@utm.my | River Debris Detection and Classifications using Deep Learning | Good | Overall is good. | Few justifications in methodology are missing -- purpose of collecting data at Klang river and purpose of using certain drone. However, student delivers a good presentation and has wide knowledge in his FYP. | Refer to report. Need to add more in Literature review | Marked Report Link | Good project. However, research gap is not included in the report, references are limited, and student should double check the report's format. There are a lot of mistakes in numbering references, etc. | Marked Report Link | |
9 | 6 | CHONG WEN CHENG | A20MJ0013 | chong.cheng@graduate.utm.my | MPE | LEE KEE QUEN (IR. DR.) | lkquen@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Flow uniformity Improvement using honeycomb for water tank | Performance criteria not clear. Objective can be better written to answer problem statement | Clarify what're being comment. | ok | comments refer to the thesis | Marked Report Link | Good project. Please refer to the report for comments and annotations. | Marked Report Link | |
10 | 7 | CLIFF MEERZAN DFERNANDO MATHEW | A20MJ0015 | cliff@graduate.utm.my | MPE | LEE KEE QUEN (IR. DR.) | lkquen@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | machine learning in predicting the floating litter at Klang river | Novelty not clear. Presented literature also uses machine learning to predict VIV. Difference between presented work and literature should be highlighted. | Clarify what's is being comment. | 0k | refer the comments in thesis | Marked Report Link | Good project. Please refer to the report for comments and annotations. | Marked Report Link | |
11 | 8 | DANIAL HAKEEM BIN SAFARIHAIROL | A20MJ5020 | danialhakeem@graduate.utm.my | MPE | WIRA JAZAIR BIN YAHYA (ASSOC. PROF. DR) | wira@utm.my | Advance Vehicle System (AVS) | FAUZAN BIN AHMAD (DR.) | fauzan.kl@utm.my | Emissions of crude palm oil diesel blended emulsion fuel | Good. However, Performance criteria not clear. | Overall is good. | Student shows interest and sufficient understanding. However, needs to learn to be a bit more independent. | Good performance | Marked Report Link | In overall, the report is very good. | Marked Report Link | |
12 | 9 | DEANNA JANE LAURENT BINTI MUHAMMAD ARIFF | A20MJ0112 | deannajanelaurent@graduate.utm.my | MPE | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | WIND | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | Experimental Assessment of Cross-Ventilation Effectiveness of Idealized Model with Different Opening Configurations | Good. However, comparison of the 5 cases seems not fair and need more explaination. Example, Case A exit (iii) and Case B exit (iii). | Overall is very good. | Good student - needs to explore the research subject more elaborately | Improvement: Detailed explanation of method & critical analysis of results | Marked Report Link | In overall, the report is excellent. | Marked Report Link | |
13 | 10 | DURATUL ATHIQAH BINTI MOHD FAUZIL | A20MJ0020 | duratulathiqah@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NOOR FAWAZI BIN MD NOOR RUDIN (DR.) | fawazi.kl@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Design and optimization of a soft gripper using machine learning | N/A | Needs better understanding on optimization objective | ok | keywords are attacked, objective clear. good if more detail step by step on ML application | Marked Report Link | The abstract and chapter 1 reeks of AI generated paragraphs. This makes the reporting too general and not supported by evidence (references). Background should be supported by some statistics, and problem statement should be specific. While Literature review is comprehensive, no gap of knowledge is presented. some formatting in LR has to be corrected. Please make sure formatting is standard in ALL chapters! text must be justified, references formatting must be correct | Marked Report Link | |
14 | 11 | FAKHRUL NUQMAN HAZIM BIN ZULKULNAIN | A20MJ0022 | fakhrulnuqmanhazim@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NURSHAFINAZ BINTI MOHD MARUAI (DR.) | nurshafinaz@utm.my | WIND | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | The influence of flow-induced vibration on electromagnetic induction over bluff bodies. | The research problem (espacially fluid frequency) is unclear. | Good presentation but must improve in justification | Good performance | Good progress and more critical discussion are expected for FYP 2 following the findings. | Marked Report Link | Background too little and not supported by any references. Problem statement is cut short, not clear focus on frequency or magnetic induction. Objectives are clear and fully explained. No gap of knowledge included in the LR summary. Methodology should be about YOUR work and plan. For example, you will be using ANSYS, what ANSYS modules will be used? what are the settings, what is the meshing info etc. The result sections should be in Methodology and some in LR... should have put expected result, or some pictures of your simulation setup There were 52 listed references, however, in LR chapter, references 36-44 are missing! | Marked Report Link | |
15 | 12 | JACOB LEE NING ZHI | A20MJ0025 | ning00@graduate.utm.my | MPE | JUN ISHIMATSU (DR.) | junishimatsu@utm.my | TriPrem | KANAO FUKUDA (PROF. DR.) | fukuda.kl@utm.my | Ultrasonically excited fliud for small NC machine tools | overall, very good presentation. | Clear and good presentations | 1. Elaborate the main target in the objective- be specific. 2. Add mechanism how the ultrasonics works in improving cutting performance | so far okey | Marked Report Link | good | Marked Report Link | |
16 | 13 | LEE JIANXI | A20MJ0180 | leejianxi@graduate.utm.my | MPE | WIRA JAZAIR BIN YAHYA (ASSOC. PROF. DR) | wira@utm.my | Advance Vehicle System (AVS) | FAUZAN BIN AHMAD (DR.) | fauzan.kl@utm.my | Performance of gasoline passenger car equipped with intake manifold water injection system | I wanted to know why you decided to supply water and fuel separately instead of mixing them. | Excellent visual aid. Good presentation but not very confident in q&a.. must improve in justification | GOOD | Good performance | Marked Report Link | good | Marked Report Link | |
17 | 14 | LIANG ZUO HOW | A20MJ0032 | lianghow@graduate.utm.my | MPE | TAN LIT KEN (DR.) | tlken@utm.my | Takasago | YUTAKA ASAKO (PROF.DR) | y.asako@utm.my | Artificial Mangrove: A Novel Approach for Enhancing Mangrove Protection and Debris Entrapment | Artificial roots capture debris, so it would be better to take that into account in CFD simulations. | Good presentation but must imrpove in justification | Explanation on the novelty of the project should be emphasized. | Good. Refer to report. Literature review need to write more. | Marked Report Link | good | Marked Report Link | |
18 | 15 | MAISARAH BINTI SHAFFE | A20MJ0038 | maisarah.s@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NURSHAFINAZ BINTI MOHD MARUAI (DR.) | nurshafinaz@utm.my | WIND | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | The influence of flow-induced vibration on strain rate over bluff bodies. | Objectives needs to be more specific. Also need justifications on the selected methodology. | In the methodology, the description on the connection between CFD simulation in OpenFOAM and MATLAB computation can be further clarified. Student can have a kickstart on CFD modelling in OpenFOAM sooner to get over the learning curve of using the software by the time she starts her FYP2. | The student must continue exploring the research area and related methodology. | Good and can be improved. Further comments are in the marked report. | Marked Report Link | Preliminary results and conclusion are absent from the report. Gantt chart is missing UTM thesis format is not properly followed. Refer to annotated report for other comments | Marked Report Link | |
19 | 16 | MOHAMAD IRFAN BIN MOHAMAD ZAIN | A20MJ3011 | mohamad00@graduate.utm.my | MPE | FARAH LIANA BINTI MOHD REDZUAN (DR.) | farahliana@utm.my | WIND | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | Thermal Analysis on The Cold Side of Thermoelectric Radiant Panel (TERP) System for Small Rooms in Malaysia. | Good | Need to details the problem and translates to methodology | The overall research is acceptable and easy to understand. | This student showed good effort in doing his FYP. For the report, minor mistakes were detected as he is also guided by a PhD student for this work. Expecting significant findings in the upcoming FYP2 | Marked Report Link | good | Marked Report Link | |
20 | 17 | MOHAMED HUSAM MOHAMED SALAHELDIN ELSHANAWANY | A20MJ0151 | husam.mohamed@graduate.utm.my | MPE | USWAH BINTI KHAIRUDDIN (DR.) | uswah.kl@utm.my | CAIRO | ZOOL HILMI BIN ISMAIL (IR. DR.) | zool@utm.my | Cloud Prediction model for optimized solar power generation | Good | Later i will comment | Must complete the report | please improve for FYP2 | Marked Report Link | good | Marked Report Link | |
21 | 18 | MOHAMED MUNZIR MOHAMED AJIWATH | A20MJ5001 | mohamed20@graduate.utm.my | MPE | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | WIND | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | Numerical Optimization of Cross-Ventilation Prediction in Idealized Model with Shear Stress Transport Model | Good | The research is too broad and not specific as in the presentation | Good student - needs to explore the research subject more elaborately | Improvement: Detailed explanation of method & critical analysis of results | Marked Report Link | Generally OK for FYP 1. Detailed comments in marked report. | Marked Report Link | |
22 | 19 | MOHAMMAD IKHWAN BIN CHE AZAMI | A20MJ3012 | mohammadikhwan@graduate.utm.my | MPE | ZAINUDIN BIN A. RASID (DR.) | arzainudin.kl@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Bending stress of palf fibre reinforced composite wind turbine blade using FEM | Please clarify research gap. | The integration of palf fibre with the study of the turbine blade is not clearly presented. Unclear presentation of the flowchart, in particular the decision box where comparison is made: 1) What variable is being compared? 2) No action is specified if the comparison is unsatisfactory. | Good effort. | In overall, the report is very good. | Marked Report Link | What is meaning of comparison between manual calculation and simulation? not on physical wing? | Marked Report Link | |
23 | 20 | MOHAMMAD IRFAN BIN SAMSULHADI | A20MJ0123 | irfan2001@graduate.utm.my | MPE | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | WIND | AHMAD FAIZ BIN MOHAMMAD (DR.) | ahmadfaiz@utm.my | Aerodynamic Performance Analysis of H-Rotor Darrieus Turbine with Dimple-Enhanced Blades using Shear Stress Transport Model | Already gave him verbally | Ensure that the data for validation from 3D-based published study is compatible with the 2D simplified geometry of the present study; apple to apple comparison | Good student - needs to explore the research subject more elaborately | Improvement: Detailed explanation of method & critical analysis of results | Marked Report Link | What is your contribution? Problem is not clear | Marked Report Link | |
24 | 21 | MUHAMAD AMIN BIN SABAR | A20MJ0131 | muhamadamin@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SAMSOL FAIZAL BIN ANIS (TS. DR.) | samsol.kl@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Design of automatic portable shooting target plates for military. | Totally is not research however no requirement shown as development project, all assessments are subjective. Should discuss with SV about engineering approach. | Poor methodology is the main concern here for this FYP1 project. The presented methodology on the evaluation of the design seems to be based on personal judgement rather than being backed up by any engineering approach (e.g. theory, formula, DOE, etc). The scoring system is also questionable. The importance of solving the problem is unclear. Literature presented in a very inadequate fashion. Research gap not identified. | In overall, the student is good. | Overall, the report is good. Need to add more references. | Marked Report Link | Many too general information is included in the report. | Marked Report Link | |
25 | 22 | MUHAMMAD AIMAN BIN SAHAR | A20MJ0050 | muhammad.aiman.sahar@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NORHASNIDAWANI BINTI JOHARI (TS. DR.) | norhasnidawani@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | Enhancing Thermal and Mechanical Performance of Nanocoating in Marine Pipelines | Problem statement should be more clear | Suggest to condense/rewrite the 4 objectives into 2 for FYP level. Since corrosion is a long-term process (it takes years), presentation of the FYP study (it takes just months) to combat corrosion in pipelines may be toned down; for example when describing problem statement etc. Source of literature is not presented | EXCELLENT | Please revise based on the comment given | Marked Report Link | Check fprmatting | Marked Report Link | |
26 | 23 | MUHAMMAD AMIN BIN MAZLAN | A20MJ0124 | muhammad.amin.mazlan@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SHAHIRA LIZA BINTI KAMIS (DR.) | shahiraliza@utm.my | TriPrem | KANAO FUKUDA (PROF. DR.) | fukuda.kl@utm.my | [Industry] Effects of Lubricant Additives on the Friction of Rolling Bearings | The methodology flowchart needs to be revised by considering the decision cycle. | May clarify on what variable is actually investigated, and clarify the parameter you compare your results with | Good | few comments are included in the thesis. Overall good just need to improve chapter 2 | Marked Report Link | Significant topic, good writing. Would be better if not limit to only one type of additive. | Marked Report Link | |
27 | 24 | MUHAMMAD AMIRUL ISLAH BIN LOKMAN NOOR | A20MJ0048 | maislah2@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NOOR FAWAZI BIN MD NOOR RUDIN (DR.) | fawazi.kl@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Development and evaluation of a soft gripper with metamaterial segment for flexible grasping | The limitation of soft robotics can be considered for further discussed. | The scope can be clarified: Limitations of the gripper designed in the study should be clarified in with respect to the weight of the load, type of shapes of the load. Referring to flowchart, the "Testing and Evaluation" should be clarified. What parameter is being evaluated? | ok | few pages with different font. wording and explanation is suggested direct to the direction of this title,any plan for metamaterial segment modeling, anaysis, evaluation? | Marked Report Link | Aims, objectives and scope should be properly written. Methodology is not clear. Evaluation method and parameters used to be analysed should be clearly stated. | Marked Report Link | |
28 | 25 | MUHAMMAD DANISH DANIEL BIN NAJEE MUDDIN | A20MJ0053 | muhammaddanishdaniel@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NORHASNIDAWANI BINTI JOHARI (TS. DR.) | norhasnidawani@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | Environmental Impact of Nanocoatings for Sustainable Corrosion Mitigation in Marine Pipelines | Suggestion to take saltwater for immersion test. | Presentation on the literature can be improved by citing the sources where the relevance/ recentness of the area of study can be assessed. | EXCELLENT | Please revise the report based on the comment | Marked Report Link | Overall OK with minor improvements Need to revise number of objectives Research gap should be included Include Gantt chart | Marked Report Link | |
29 | 26 | MUHAMMAD EIZUAN BIN DAUD | A20MJ0067 | muhammadeizuan@graduate.utm.my | MPE | JUN ISHIMATSU (DR.) | junishimatsu@utm.my | TriPrem | KANAO FUKUDA (PROF. DR.) | fukuda.kl@utm.my | Effects of different ultrasonic frequencies on grinding fluid performance | Suggestion to do illustrations of mechanism for grinding process. | Suggest to produce clearer presentation of the grinding process with sonication apparatus, to assist examiners for better understanding of the problem at hand | Good | so far so good | Marked Report Link | Overall OK Suggestion for minor improvements can be found in annotated document | Marked Report Link | |
30 | 27 | MUHAMMAD FARIS AMZAR BIN AHMAD RAMLI | A20MJ0057 | muhammadfarisamzar@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SHAHIR YASIN BIN MOHD YUSUF (DR.) | shahiryasin@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | 4D Printing of Shape Memory Polymer via Material Extrusion Process | Student understand well about the research | Research objectives are too broad and should be limited to 2 or 3 objectives Can clarify on the variable being studied | To significantly improve understanding on the knowledge of the topic, approach on supervisor and writing skills. | Poorly written. Poor academic writing skills, not up to research at undergraduate level. Student does not seem to understand what he needs to do for his project. Possible use of ChatGPT also detected. Please improve focus, attitude, and commitment in FYP2. | Marked Report Link | Need some correction of the report. | Marked Report Link | |
31 | 28 | MUHAMMAD HAKIM BIN MOHD ARSHAD | A20MJ5010 | hakim-01@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NURULAKMAR BINTI ABU HUSAIN (ASSOC. PROF. IR. DR.) | nurulakmar@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Damage Identification of a Simple Engineering Assembly | student understand the process of the experiment and research | Research objectives could be compressed to 2 instead of 4 | Student shows great experiment work. However, there is a need for improvement in understanding underlying principles, refining experimental approaches, and enhancing problem-solving skills. | 1) Check citation formatting 2) Report writing format | Marked Report Link | All comments are in the marked report. | Marked Report Link | |
32 | 29 | MUHAMMAD HARITH BIN HASPIRUDIN | A20MJ0061 | harith01@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NOOR FAWAZI BIN MD NOOR RUDIN (DR.) | fawazi.kl@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Development and optimization of a soft gripper with bellows actuator for flexible grasping | OK. Able to answer questions | Suggest to justify, based on the literature, as to why 4 fingers was chosen for the gripper design rather than the other configurations (3 fingers, 2 fingers etc) | ok | target variable for optimization? | Marked Report Link | Overall ok. refer to the comments in the thesis. | Marked Report Link | |
33 | 30 | MUHAMMAD HAZIQ BIN MUHAMMAD NIZAR | A20MJ0063 | muhammad-96@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SHAHIR YASIN BIN MOHD YUSUF (DR.) | shahiryasin@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | 3D Printing of AlSI10Mg Specimens via Vat Photopolymerisation Process | OK able to answer question | Presentation of the methodology is inadequate without the DOE/case matrix; For example, what are the variations of composition for metal powder + polymer resin? | Overall performance is good. | Student shows adequate level of research at undergraduate level with good understanding of the requirements and execution for the project. Academic writing skills generally OK for undergraduate level, but of course can be improved. Keep up the good work in FYP 2. | Marked Report Link | Similarity more than 20 %. refer to the comments in the thesis. | Marked Report Link | |
34 | 31 | MUHAMMAD NUR AFIQ BIN ZAKARIA | A20MJ0064 | muhammadnurafiq.z@graduate.utm.my | MPE | AHMAD MUHSIN BIN ITHNIN (DR.) | ahmadmuhsin@utm.my | Advance Vehicle System (AVS) | FAUZAN BIN AHMAD (DR.) | fauzan.kl@utm.my | EMULSIFIER-FREE WATER-IN-BIODIESEL EMULSION FUEL WITH HYDOXYL ENRICHMENT IN A SINGLE-CYLIDER ENGINE APPLICATION | Need to be more specific on the problem statement, and understand what your expected outcome is. | Need to ensure problem statement, aim and objectives, and methodology align with each other. | Need to be proactive to ask senior to understand more on the research study, more literature review on the study | Overall good report. The need to use RTES is not mentioned in the chapter 1. The expected result should not mentioned explicitly which type of fuel is produced better result since the test is not conducted yet | Marked Report Link | ok. comments referred to the thesis. | Marked Report Link | |
35 | 32 | NOR NADIA SYAHIRA BINTI RASLI | A20MJ0078 | nornadiasyahira@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NOOR FAWAZI BIN MD NOOR RUDIN (DR.) | fawazi.kl@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Development and evaluation of a soft gripper for food packaging | Ok | Need to re-check research direction with SV as the present research is similar to previous FYP student (Susavien). | ok | plan for food used gripper. prelim desingn is ok but how to claim it is for food picking | Marked Report Link | The philosophy and novelty of the technical background are weak. | Marked Report Link | |
36 | 33 | NUR AQILAH BINTI DZUL FIKRI | A20MJ5011 | nur-99@graduate.utm.my | MPE | HAFIZAL BIN YAHAYA (DR.) | hafizal.kl@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | RAINWATER ELECTRIC GENERATOR USING 3 DIMENSIONAL PRINTER | Ok | Problem statement and objectives need to be specific and measurable. Please discuss with your SV. | Student delivered a good progress for this semester and has high potential to complete the research as planned. | very good | Marked Report Link | There is a big gap between the problems and the objectives. Key technical idea between them is not clear. | Marked Report Link | |
37 | 34 | NUR AZIRA HANUM BINTI PANGURUSAN @ MASDIN | A20MJ0086 | nurazirahanum@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | Characteristics of Magnetorheological Elastomer under Saltwater Ageing | Good presentation but lacks latest review of related studies. | Need to improve critical analysis skills. | Diligent, compliant, eager to learn, and quick to comprehend assigned tasks. | The thesis is meeting the FYP standard | Marked Report Link | The overall report is poorly constructed despite clear motivation, problem statement, and objectives. | Marked Report Link | |
38 | 35 | NURUL AIN NATASHA BINTI AZMI | A20MJ0091 | nurulainnatasha@graduate.utm.my | MPE | WIRA JAZAIR BIN YAHYA (ASSOC. PROF. DR) | wira@utm.my | Advance Vehicle System (AVS) | FAUZAN BIN AHMAD (DR.) | fauzan.kl@utm.my | Performance of Diesel engine fuelled with crude palm oil diesel blended emulsion fuel | The presentation lacks latest review of related studies. | Need to justify decisions made for every activity in the research. | Student showed minimal amount of commitment. Sometimes went missing during rinkou. | Good reporting. Need active participation in the group activities and rinkoh. | Marked Report Link | Good. Refer comments at report. | Marked Report Link | |
39 | 36 | OOI XIN YIN | A20MJ0098 | ooiyin@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SHAHIRA LIZA BINTI KAMIS (DR.) | shahiraliza@utm.my | TriPrem | KANAO FUKUDA (PROF. DR.) | fukuda.kl@utm.my | (Industry) Understanding of basic characteristics of surface textures technology for next-generation power transmission | Good presentation and the student can answer very well during the Qn A | Overall too fast | Excellent | Good report. but need to improvise chapter 1 related to research objectives | Marked Report Link | Malay abstract need to revise. Minor formating issue | Marked Report Link | |
40 | 37 | RAJA HARITH DANIAL BIN RAJA KHALID | A20MJ0100 | rajaharithdanial@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | Mechanical Properties of Magnetorheological Elastomer under Seawater Ageing | Interesting topic. The student present very well | Slide filled with words and skipped by student frequently | Good, very passionate and hardworking in doing his research. | As stated in the report | Marked Report Link | Good thesis. All important elements are well reported | Marked Report Link | |
41 | 38 | RAJVINDERJEET SINGH A/L AMARJEET SINGH | A20MJ5007 | rajvinderjeetsingh@graduate.utm.my | MPE | KANAO FUKUDA (PROF. DR.) | fukuda.kl@utm.my | TriPrem | KANAO FUKUDA (PROF. DR.) | fukuda.kl@utm.my | Influence of Relative Humidity on the Tribological Properties of Hard Coatings | Good Presentation. The student manage to answer all the questions | 1. include appropriate application of coating in dry condition where humidity will plays it role in reducing friction 2. what is the COF value for literature used 3. provide roughness value after lapping | (1) no background on type of coating: CrC and VC. (2) term "chemisorption" is wrong (3) add why lapping is need in methodology | Good achievements in the preliminary tests. In general, the reports has been improved accordingly to the suggestions given during supervision. | Marked Report Link | Revise abstract and Chapter 2- should focusing more on relation humidity with tribology and Hard coating | Marked Report Link | |
42 | 39 | SITI ZULAIKHA BINTI MOHAMED ANIBFAH | A20MJ0105 | siti-01@graduate.utm.my | MPE | USWAH BINTI KHAIRUDDIN (DR.) | uswah.kl@utm.my | CAIRO | ZOOL HILMI BIN ISMAIL (IR. DR.) | zool@utm.my | CCTV reporting dashboard | Fair presentation. Please avoid to use capital letters for all the wording in the slide | 1. Significant of study is not clear 2. How to detect the listening and sleeping behavior ? not clear | Finish the report and methodology is not written | good reporting | Marked Report Link | overall this report is good and clear with that the students planning to do | Marked Report Link | |
43 | 40 | TSI SHI QI | A20MJ0112 | tsiqi@graduate.utm.my | MPE | WIRA JAZAIR BIN YAHYA (ASSOC. PROF. DR) | wira@utm.my | Advance Vehicle System (AVS) | FAUZAN BIN AHMAD (DR.) | fauzan.kl@utm.my | Design and fabrication of a hand operated manual transmission clutch for disable driver | The presentation exceeded the set time limit but was clear in the Q & A session | N/A | GOOD | Overall good and committed. Require fast action to fabricate the model. | Marked Report Link | Need to rewrite, the scope, & significance. Improve the way of writing this is not describing like writing a thesis proposal but like a report. Many pictures are provided but there is no explanation or stating in the proposal | Marked Report Link | |
44 | 41 | UMAR ABDULAZIZ BIN MOHAMMAD AMIN | A20MJ5013 | umarabdulaziz@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NURULAKMAR BINTI ABU HUSAIN (ASSOC. PROF. IR. DR.) | nurulakmar@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | FE modelling and updating of damaged structures | Students understand the FYP topics they are doing. It is also necessary to be careful in thinking about the problem of critical thinking | N/A | Student shows great progress in numerical analysis, reflecting commendable dedication. However, there is a need for improvement in understanding fundamental concepts, articulating outcomes technically, navigating simulation environments effectively, and critically solving problems. | 1) The writing is toooo general. Almost ChatGPT style of writing. It is wordy but not relevant to the content. 2) Incorrect citation format 3) All figures & tables MUST be explained in the main text | Marked Report Link | The way of writing should be improved. The thesis proposal looks like a normal report and not like a thesis proposal and many make small mistakes such as not having numbers for equations, not stating figures in the text, etc. | Marked Report Link | |
45 | 42 | VITIYASHINI A/P SILVATAMILAN | A20MJ0144 | vitiyashini@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SHAHIR YASIN BIN MOHD YUSUF (DR.) | shahiryasin@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | Multi-alloy 3D Printing via Material Extrusion Process | ok | N/A | Significantly improve understanding on the knowledge and skills, approach supervisor, and writing skills. | Poor academic writing skills, many important information not included. Unfortunately, the overall quality is not adequate for research at undergraduate level. Please focus, improve attitude, and show proper commitment for FYP 2. | Marked Report Link | The way of writing needs to be improved. Writing a report and a thesis are two different things. | Marked Report Link | |
46 | 43 | WAN NAJMI AINAN BIN ISMAIL | A20MJ5030 | wannajmiainan@graduate.utm.my | MPE | YUTAKA ASAKO (PROF.DR) | y.asako@utm.my | Takasago | YUTAKA ASAKO (PROF.DR) | y.asako@utm.my | Estimation of outlet water temperature of a cooling tower based on weather data in KL | ok | N/A | Good topic of FYP and good presentation delivered by student. Student has wide knowledge in his FYP topic and can answer most of the questions from the evaluator. | good | Marked Report Link | Referencing/citation and bibliography format are wrong. Unclear problem statement, some objectives are too general and may be unrealistic. Unclear research gap. Methodology too general. No discussion presented in Chapter 4. | Marked Report Link | |
47 | 44 | WAYNE WOO YAO WEN | A20MJ0115 | wayne@graduate.utm.my | MPE | TAN LIT KEN (DR.) | tlken@utm.my | Takasago | YUTAKA ASAKO (PROF.DR) | y.asako@utm.my | Designing an Adaptive Structure for River Monitoring System (RMS) Camera | ok | N/A | This student fully understands his project. | Overall, good writing and progress. | Marked Report Link | Average report quality, acceptable for FYP level, but needs to be improved, especially in writing abstract, identifying problem statement, identifying research gap, design of methodology, and results display and discussion. Detailed comments in marked report. | Marked Report Link | |
48 | 45 | WEE LIANG JUN | A20MJ0191 | weeliangjun@graduate.utm.my | MPE | TAN LIT KEN (DR.) | tlken@utm.my | Takasago | YUTAKA ASAKO (PROF.DR) | y.asako@utm.my | Gaussian-Weighted Histogram of Oriented Gradient / Local Binary Pattern for Object Recognition | good | very good presentation. | Scope of project can be further clarified, Literature review can be made more concise, model training can be further clarified in the methodology | Very good | Marked Report Link | would suggest to include step by step flow computatinal algorthm with the respective eq2. show Simple example first can be an adavantge | Marked Report Link | |
49 | 46 | YASMIN ATIQAH BINTI ROSZAIDI | A20MJ0117 | yasminatiqah@graduate.utm.my | MPE | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | IDS | AMINUDIN BIN ABU (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | aminudin.kl@utm.my | Vibration absorbers with an auxiliary mass-spring system. | good | can explain specific on model and explain on limitation parameter | Good effort. | ok, but need to improve more on the manuscript by adding research questions and the literature review | Marked Report Link | if u have specific focus on certain analytical model, focus on it and highlight the research trend. include recent refs. check format for refs | Marked Report Link | |
50 | 47 | YUVARAJAN A/L NAGARATHINAM | A20MJ0192 | yuvarajan.n@graduate.utm.my | MPE | SHAHIR YASIN BIN MOHD YUSUF (DR.) | shahiryasin@utm.my | eMAST | SAIFUL AMRI BIN MAZLAN (PROF. IR. TS. DR.) | amri.kl@utm.my | 3D Printing of AlSI10Mg Specimens via Material Extrusion Process | good | justify the usage of 2%, PVA | the student need to establish a more consistent work schedule. | Student exhibits effort to write the report/thesis. But the understanding and execution required of the project need to be improved. Please improve in FYP 2. | Marked Report Link | expected result = prelim result (need to be highlighted with discussion) | Marked Report Link | |
51 | 48 | MUHAMMAD FADHIL SYUKRAN BIN ANUAR | A20MJ0055 | fadhil01@graduate.utm.my | MPE | AHMAD MUHSIN BIN ITHNIN (DR.) | ahmadmuhsin@utm.my | Advance Vehicle System (AVS) | FAUZAN BIN AHMAD (DR.) | fauzan.kl@utm.my | Biodiesel - Hydrogen Dual Fuel for Single Cylinder Diesel Engine Application | good | the flow of explanation is not quite smooth. | Need more reading to understand the research study, lack of self driven to ask for knowledge | Poor reporting. Many incomplete information. Expected result not being properly discussed. Not follow thesis format. Referencing not follow the format and some cited from wikipedia | Marked Report Link | Ok, but need to add data to support that adding hydrogen can lower the Nox emission. | Marked Report Link | |
52 | 49 | MOHAMMAD FAHIM IDLAN BIN ABDUL RAHIM | A20MJ0045 | mohammadfahimidlan@graduate.utm.my | MPE | NOR’AZIZI BIN OTHMAN (ASSOC. PROF. TS. DR.) | norazizio.kl@utm.my | MEMO-Bio | MUHAMAD ALI BIN MOHD YUZIR (PROF. DR.) | muhdaliyuzir@utm.my | Noise reduction of blender machines | good | selection of blender need to explain more | k | good | Marked Report Link | mechanism how noise propagate and hamful to our health? you already choose the blender. so no need to do selection of the blender | Marked Report Link | |
53 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
54 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
55 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
56 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
57 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
58 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
59 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
60 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
61 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
62 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
63 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
64 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
65 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
66 | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | #N/A | Marked Report Link | #N/A | Marked Report Link | ||||||||||||
67 | |||||||||||||||||||
68 | |||||||||||||||||||
69 | |||||||||||||||||||
70 | |||||||||||||||||||
71 | |||||||||||||||||||
72 | |||||||||||||||||||
73 | |||||||||||||||||||
74 | |||||||||||||||||||
75 | |||||||||||||||||||
76 | |||||||||||||||||||
77 | |||||||||||||||||||
78 | |||||||||||||||||||
79 | |||||||||||||||||||
80 | |||||||||||||||||||
81 | |||||||||||||||||||
82 | |||||||||||||||||||
83 | |||||||||||||||||||
84 | |||||||||||||||||||
85 | |||||||||||||||||||
86 | |||||||||||||||||||
87 | |||||||||||||||||||
88 | |||||||||||||||||||
89 | |||||||||||||||||||
90 | |||||||||||||||||||
91 | |||||||||||||||||||
92 | |||||||||||||||||||
93 | |||||||||||||||||||
94 | |||||||||||||||||||
95 | |||||||||||||||||||
96 | |||||||||||||||||||
97 | |||||||||||||||||||
98 | |||||||||||||||||||
99 | |||||||||||||||||||
100 | |||||||||||||||||||