ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTU
1
High coverage districtsLow coverage districts
2
unittypeOverallZMZM + mCCTs
3
Simple CEA
4
5
Population
6
Full cohort of those eligible for the programnumberinput1,000
7
Percent of cohort in each group%calc52%48%
8
Cohort in each groupnumbercalc522478
9
Cost
10
Cost per child reached for org$input$2.82$11.16
11
Cost per cohort for org$calc$6,814$1,473$5,340
12
Under-five mortality benefits
13
Total increase in vaccination rates due to SMS reminders, weighted by vaccines' contribution to deaths (percentage points)%input-3.1%3.9%
14
Total increase in vaccination rates due to mCCTs, weighted by vaccines' contribution to deaths (percentage points)%input-9.7%
15
Number of additional children vaccinated as a result of the program%calc821665
16
Probability that an unvaccinated child will die of vaccine-preventable causes before age 5%input1.6%2.4%
17
Effect of vaccination on under-five deaths attributable to vaccine-preventable disease%input67%67%
18
Number of deaths averted before age five#calc1.20.21.0
19
Initial cost-effectiveness estimate
20
Cost per under-five death averted$calc$8,310$5,094
21
Moral value of averting the death of a person under age fiveUoVinput116116116
22
Initial cost-effectiveness in terms of multiples of GiveDirectly's unconditional cash transfer programxcashcalc6.24.26.8
23
Adjustments for other benefits (as a % of under 5 deaths)
24
Adjustment to account for mortalities averted after age 5%input22%22%
25
Adjustment to account for developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input27%27%
26
Adjustment to account for consumption benefits%input0%4%
27
Percentage of program impact coming from different benefits
28
Mortalities averted before age five%input67%65%
29
Mortalities averted after age five%input15%15%
30
Developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input18%17%
31
Consumption benefits%input0%3%
32
Additional adjustments
33
Adjustment for additional program benefits and downsides%input22%22%22%
34
Adjustment for grantee-level factors%input-7%-7%-7%
35
Adjustment for leverage%input-12%-6%
36
Adjustment for funging%input-12%-7%
37
Final cost-effectiveness estimate
38
Final cost-effectiveness in terms of multiples of GiveDirectly's unconditional cash transfer programxcashcalc9.35.410.3
39
Final cost per under 5 life saved$calc$7,837$4,191
40
Difference compared to final estimates from main CEA
41
42
Best Guess for 25th / 75th percentiles for key inputsImplied overall CE from 25/75th
43
25thBest Guess75th25thBest Guess75th25thBest Guess75th25thBest Guess75th
44
High coverage districtsHigh coverage districtsHigh coverage districtsLow coverage districtsLow coverage districtsLow coverage districtsHigh coverage districtsHigh coverage districtsHigh coverage districtsLow coverage districtsLow coverage districtsLow coverage districts
45
unittypeZM onlyZM onlyZM onlyZM + mCCTsZM + mCCTsZM + mCCTsZM onlyZM onlyZM onlyZM + mCCTsZM + mCCTsZM + mCCTs
46
Cost
47
Cost per child reached for org$input$3.80$2.82$1.80$14.00$11.16$8.008.59.310.07.79.311.8
48
Under-five mortality benefits
49
Total increase in vaccination rates due to SMS reminders, weighted by vaccines' contribution to deaths (percentage points)%input1.5%3.1%4.5%2.0%3.9%6.0%8.69.39.78.09.310.4
50
Total increase in vaccination rates due to mCCTs, weighted by vaccines' contribution to deaths (percentage points)%input7.0%9.7%12.0%9.37.69.310.6
51
Probability that an unvaccinated child will die of vaccine-preventable causes before age 5%input0.6%1.6%2.6%1.2%2.4%3.6%8.59.39.95.29.313.2
52
Effect of vaccination on under-five deaths attributable to vaccine-preventable disease%input55%67%79%55%67%79%9.09.39.47.89.310.6