XF Meeting Discussion And Planning

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J
1
2				WARNING - please do not modify this without contacting gwatts@uw.edu!
3
4	If you agree to the meeting, please add your frontier name in this column. If not, please do not add anything			Colors: White: Not yet reviewed Yellow: Not signed off on yet Green: Signed off	WARNING: If Status says "done", and you modify it here, you have to make sure to explicitly tell gwatts@uw.edu or it won't make it back into the master schedule!
5	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
6	CF	NF	XNF1	Neutrino mass scale with beta decay kinematics, double beta decay, and cosmology	NF, CF	4			CF Comment: Should also discuss cosmological measurements of neutrino masses	Done
7	EF	NF	XNF2	Cross-cutting issues	NF, EF	2			Comment from EF -- 4 hours is way too much for these discussions. we do not see many whitepapers on such issues. Reply from NF: agree, I am not sure how 4 hours was determined to be the default, will reduce to 2	Done
8		NF	XNF3	Success stories from NF	NF, CEF	2			Convert to NF ONLY Session (see email)	Done
9	CF, IF	NF	XNF4	Dark matter detector	NF, CF, IF	4	focus on common detector/instrumentation issues between neutrinos (both accelerator nu and 0nbb) and dark matter detection: liquid noble detectors, low background detector components, possibilities for dark matter detection using detectors designed for neutrino experiments (eg: DUNE module of opportunity).	XIF4		Done
10	TF	NF	XNF5	Neutrino theory network	NF, TF	2		XTF1	TF: Ok to include TF here? NF: Yes, good, CEF removed as doesn't want to be part of it	Done
11	RF	NF	XNF6	Netrinoless double beta decay	NF, RF	4		XUF2	UF: Suggestion below to add UF 0nuBB facility topics to this session. OK. Is 4 hours enough for all three Frontiers? (But 4 hours is also long). This is a duplicate after sign off from NF	Done
12	CF, TF	NF	XNF7	high energy and ultrahigh energy astrophysical neutrino	NF, CF, TF	4		XTF1		Done
13	AF	NF	XNF8	Accelerator neutrino sources/cross-cutting issues	NF, AF	4			AF: AF02 topical group needs to be involved in planning	Done
14
15	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
16	UF, CompF, IF	CF	XCF1	Future Facilities	CF, IF, CompF, UF	2	Future facilities for each frontier; synergies between them	XIF4	UF: XUF3 was just with CF and XUF4 just with IF, but these can readily combine into this one (XCF1), assuming IF signs-on.	Done
17	EF, RF, TF	CF	XCF2	CF1 CF2 CF3 CF7 DM Complementarity	CF, EF, RF, TF	4	Intro to DM; Dark matter searches at each frontier; complementarity of the searches (Maybe expand to 4 hous?)	XUF3?, XRF5?, XEF15	Increased length to 4 hours	Done
18
19	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
20	CompF	IF	XIF1	readout and AI/ML	IF, CompF	2				Done
21	UF	IF	XIF2	facilities (and training?)	IF, UF	1.5		XAF8, XAF9	UF: Happy to particpate. Was not in our plans. Recomment 1.5 hours.	Done
22	NF	IF	XIF3	Instrumentation for Neutrino experiments	IF, NF	4		XNF10	NF: XNF4 is just DM complementarity, NF-IF have other crosscuts as well that would go in this session	Done
23	NF, CompF, UF	IF	XIF4	Instrumentation for Cosmic frontier	IF, CF, NF	4	Photon Detectors, Quantum Sensors, DM detectors	XCF1, XNF4		Done
24	EF, AF	IF	XIF5	detectors and MDI	IF, EF, AF	4		XEF2, XEF9	AF: among other topics - MDI in Muon Colliders; detector backgrouns in linear colliders incl plasma based; please involve AF1,3,4 and 6 in planning	Done
25	RF, EF	IF	XIF6	focus on timing and more generally tracking detectors.	IF, RF, EF	2			EF comment --- it would be helpful to understand what will be dicussed here - which witepapers. 4 hours is a bit too much. RF comment: agree with EF. IF: that's fine.	Done
26
27	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
28	TF, RF, EF, AF, UF, NF, IF, CompF	CEF	XCEF1	Feedback of other frontiers for other frontiers	CEF, EF, NF, RF, CF, TF, AF, IF, CompF, UF	4	Any CEF issues or topics from other frontiers, summary of major topics, to be presented to the community, see if aspects not captures, or needs updating, etc.	XEF1	NF: Possibly covers same as line 8 requested by NF? CEF: Reports presented earlier, NF: not sure I understand this response? Or maybe this is a separate comment? We thought it might be interesting to have a session to focus on details of successful CEF programs within NF which may be too detailed for this larger all-frontier meeting - Should this become a large afternoon session?	Done
29	AF	CEF, AF	XCEF3	Accelerator Technology spin-offs - colloquium			Was added here by AF	XAF9	(added by AF to match AF request - see AF) - Colloquia, will likely be afternoon - move to colloquia document!	Done
30
31	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
32		RF	XRF1	RF4 EF9 on exotics at colliders	RF1, EF09	2		XEF13?	EF Comments - can this be discussed during one of the EF09 teport review sessions, as by CSS, the report will be out for comment and a seperate discussion would be uncessary. This then should be discussed as an integra; part of the EF9 report	Done
33	TF, EF, RF	RF	XRF2	RF1	RF, EF, TF	2	Flavor anomalies, exotics at colliders	XTF1, XEF13?	EF Comments - which whitepapers will be discussed here? RF: the ones submitted to RF1 and of interest to EF (flavor anomalies, for example)?	Done
34	IF	RF	XRF3	RF1	RF, IF	2	Discuss picosecond detectors (fast timing in tracking and calorimetry)			Done
35	TF, EF	RF	XRF4	RF7-EF6-EF7	RF, EF, TF	2	hadrons as production probes; production mechanisms probing the internal structure of exotic hadrons	XEF16	EF Comment - can this be discussed during one of the EF6/7 teport review sessions, as by CSS, the report will be out for comment and a seperate discussion would be uncessary. This then should be discussed as an integra; part of the EF6/7 report RF: I don't understand your point. You don't want a meeting to discuss physics, you want RF to confirm EF6/7 report?Duplicate of others	Done
36	NF, TF, CF	RF	XRF5	DM Complementarity	RF, CF, EF, NF, TF	3	Topics are duplicates of other group's	XCF2?, XTF1	EF-comment - merge with line 17 (CF agrees-- maybe expand line 17 to four hours?) RF: yes, that was the idea NF: Should we do two sessions (line 9 from NF and line 17 from CF or are these similar enough that we should merge them all? TF: Adding TF here to align with XCF2. Then this would cover the XTF1 request.	Done
37	NF	RF	XRF6	RF5 to discuss CLFV and neutrinos	RF, NF	2	Relation between intensity frontier muon facilities (mu2e, etc) and nutrino facilities			Done
38	CF	RF	XRF7	RF1	RF, CF	2	large-volume data analysis and simulation and usage of HPC in data analysis			Done
39	AF, EF	RF	XRF8	RF5	RF, EF, AF	2	to discuss CLFV and heavy states	XAF6	EF Comment - which EF topical group would this belong to? AF comment :don't you want to have AF folks, too? RF: yes, we do want AF as well, please add. AF :agree, AF5 should take part in organization	Done
40	UF, NF	RF	XRF9	RF4-NF5 double beta decay	RF, NF, UF	2	Double Beta Decay	XUF2	There are duplicate entries. NF: duplicates XNF6	Done
41
42	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
43	NF	UF	XUF1	Long Baseline	UF, NF	1.5	Discussion with DUNE community about what future underground needs are (planned or desired).		UF: Do not see equivalent XNF session	Done
44	NF	UF	XUF2	0nuBB	UF, NF, RF	1	Discussion with 0nuBB neutrino community about what future underground needs are (planned or desired).	XNF6, XRF9	UF: Reworked row based on suggestion to add UF to XNF6. It probably means more time is needed and XNF6 only covers 0nuBB. Thus, create XUF2.5 in the next row.
45	NF	UF	XUF6	Nu from Natural Sources (non-0nuBB)	UF, NF, RF	1	Discussion with (non-DUNE, non-0nuBB) neutrino community about what future underground needs are (planned or desired).		UF: New X session. It appears there may not be X-interest in this topic. Let's discuss.
46	CF	UF	XUF3	Direct Detection Dark Matter	UF, CF	2		XCF2?	See XCF2 - waiting for confirmation there	Done
47	IF	UF	XUF4	Cross-cutting and Facilities	UF, IF	2		XCF1	See XCF1	Done
48	IF	UF	XUF5	QIS	UF, IF	1.5	Discussion on the potential need, use, and requirements to support future quantum information science (QIS) platforms underground. This is especially relevant to superconducting qubits for quantum computing applications.		UF: Do not see equivalent XIF session. Propose UF organize/host the "Underground QIS" disccussion. Key invited group is IF, but it might be a "general audience interest" discussion session. Email sent to IF suggesting UF would "just do this".	Done
49
50	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
51	TF, EF	AF	XAF1	ITF report and discussion	AF, EF, TF	4			suggest to make it plenary, mb Day 2? part can be done in AF only. TF: happy to be involved if AF would find it useful.	Done
52	TF, EF	AF	XAF2	Muon collider Forum report and discussion	AF, EF, TF	4		XEF4	same as in the EF request. TF: was also TF request that didn't make it into this spreadsheet.	Done
53	TF, EF	AF	XAF3	e+e- collider Forum report and discussion	AF, EF, TF	4		XEF7	same as in the EF request	Done
54	AF	EF	XAF4	Unstructured	EF, AF	2		XEF11	(AF comment - just copied from EF - topic tbd)	Done
55	NF	NF, AF	XAF5	NF-AF Accelerator neutrino sources/cross-cutting issues	NF, AF	2 or 4	NF: same as line 14	XNF8	(AF comment - copied from NF list - for completeness)	Done
56	RF	AF	XAF6	RPF-AF Cross-cutting issues	AF, RF	4		XRF8?		Done
57		AF	XAF7	CompF-AF Cross-cutting issues	AF, CompF	2 or 4
58		AF	XAF8	"Accelerator Education and Training" colloq	AF, Young, CEF	2 or 4		XIF2?	tbd with Young Duplicate (moved to colloquia sheet)	Done
59		AF	XAF9	Accelerator Technology spin-offs colloquium	AF, CEF	2 or	(initial title "Success Stories from AF")	XCEF3, XIF2?	duplicate (Moved to colloquia sheet)	Done
60		AF	XAF10	"Limits of Colliders" colloquium	AF, EF	2 or 4	Other possibility "Accelerator R&D in the US and Overseas" (tbd with EF)		duplicate (on colloquia sheet)	Done
61
62	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
63	NF	TF	XTF1		TF, NF, RF	4		XNF5, XNF7, XRF2, XRF5	TF: Need met by combination of XNF5, XNF7, XRF2, XRF5, propose to drop this session request in favor of XNF5, XNF7, XRF2, XRF5.	Done
64	EF	TF	XTF2	Energy Frontier Theory	TF, EF	4		XEF10	Propose 4h instead of 2h	Done
65	CF	TF	XTF3	Cosmic Frontier Theory	TF, CF	4	CF Suggests: interplay of models, new ideas for analyses/experiments, and calculations with CF activities.		TF response: sounds good, would also propose to emphasize non-DM aspects of CF/TF interface here (e.g. inflation etc.) since DM complementarity has its own cross-frontier activity.	Done
66	CompF	TF	XTF4	Quantum Information Science	TF, CompF	2			Was originally proposed by TF as a panel	Done (on colloquia sheet)
67
68	Frontier Signon	Requesting Frontier	Session Name	Inter Frontier Theme	Toipcal Groups	Meeting Duration (hr)	Discussion Topics	Is Same As Session	Comments	Status In Master Schedule
69		EF	XEF1	EF Centric Discussions	EF, CEF	2	Not needed - merge with line 28	XCEF1	same as CEF request on line 28, so can be merged with it	Done
70		EF	XEF2	EF Centric Discussions	EF, IF	2	merge with line 24	XIF5	same as IF request on line 24 by IF - so can be merged with them	Done
71	CompF	EF	XEF3	EF Centric Discussions	EF, CompF	2	provide feedback on EF centered topics in CompF report	XEF8		Done
72	AF, TF	EF	XEF4	Muon Forum Report	EF, AF, TF	4		XAF2, XTF2	TF: same as XAF2, but 2h vs 4h	Done
73	IF	EF	XEF5	Finalizing Plots & Tables, Detector Resolutions, etc.	EF, IF	2	Really need to sync reports and plots			Done
74	AF	EF	XEF6	Finalizing Plots and Tables	EF, AF	2	ITF Folks from AF		AF: what kind of people needed?	Done
75	AF, TF, IF	EF	XEF7	e+e- Forum	EF, IF, AF, TF	2	e+e- Forum	XAF3	TF: same as XAF3, but 2h vs 4h	Done
76		EF	XEF8		EF, CompF	1	same as line 70 - not needed	XEF3		Done
77		EF	XEF9	Discussions	EF, IF	2		XIF5	Already 4 hours with IF	Done
78		EF	XEF10	Discussions	EF, TF	2	Generic EF focused TF discussion	XTF2		Done
79	AF	EF	XEF11	Unstructured	EF, AF	2	combined EF/AF report discussion, ef/af combined report? Lots of connections, so this is "in case"	XAF4		Done
80	TF	EF	XEF12	EF Centric Discussions	EF, TF	2		XTF2	TF: propose 4h vs 2h	Done
81		EF	XEF13	EF Centric Discussions	EF, RF	2		XRF1?, XRF2?, XRF4?		Done
82	NF	EF	XEF14	EF Centric Discussions	EF, NF	2	NF: Same as line 7	XNF2		Done
83		EF	XEF15	EF Centric Discussions	EF, CF	2	same as line 17 -- merge	XCF2		Done
84		EF	XEF16	Discussions	Ef, TF	2	meeting between EF05-07 and TF would be helpful to communicate about the physics prospects and theoretical computations in precision SM studies.	XRF4	XTF2??? is that enough?	Done
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100