ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAEAFAGAHAIAJAK
1
2FHBC (2)IRPUC (4)Mr Optimal (1)plaisir (5)TSMHA (3)
2
Instance
best value
sol valuerank
% from best
sol. valuerank
% from best
sol. valuerank
% from best
sol. valuerank
% from best
sol. valuerank
% from best
3
L_abs10n100_2_H50184.7950184.7910.000%50816.0441.258%50189.9820.010%53923.5357.450%50319.4430.268%
4
L_abs10n100_2_L15057.5515332.6631.827%15669.5144.064%15057.5510.000%18806.87524.900%15222.1921.093%
5
L_abs10n100_3_H51077.6551247.5530.333%51279.8940.396%51077.6510.000%54748.6157.187%51080.1820.005%
6
L_abs10n100_3_L15838.9416053.2921.353%16165.0242.059%15838.9410.000%21179.11533.715%16078.8631.515%
7
L_abs10n100_4_H51879.9952005.5130.242%52703.2841.587%51879.9910.000%57567510.962%51968.8220.171%
8
L_abs10n100_4_L16774.4417262.2942.908%17147.1532.222%16774.4410.000%25302.86550.842%16932.4620.942%
9
L_abs10n100_5_H52930.5953688.341.432%53313.8130.724%52930.5910.000%64034.06520.977%53201.5420.512%
10
L_abs10n100_5_L17837.5418192.6441.991%17837.5410.000%17962.6320.701%29385.19564.738%18025.5531.054%
11
L_abs10n200_2_H95425.8495963.2320.563%97159.1541.816%95425.8410.000%105328.73510.378%96561.4731.190%
12
L_abs10n200_2_L22438.2622889.722.012%23990.5446.918%22438.2610.000%30365.54535.329%22970.5232.372%
13
L_abs10n200_3_H96295.1596636.0120.354%97189.2830.929%96295.1510.000%109313.88513.520%97705.541.465%
14
L_abs10n200_3_L23267.2423897.5822.709%24419.9744.954%23267.2410.000%34029.51546.255%24106.633.607%
15
L_abs10n200_4_H97763.3598254.1320.502%99540.5241.818%97763.3510.000%114766.98517.393%99437.3431.712%
16
L_abs10n200_4_L24606.362574324.619%26041.5545.833%24606.3610.000%39581.44560.859%25938.2735.413%
17
L_abs10n200_5_H99346.199872.2220.530%100410.331.071%99346.110.000%118952.32519.735%100904.1841.568%
18
L_abs10n200_5_L26254.7826852.0522.275%27216.6933.664%26254.7810.000%45169.5572.043%27733.6445.633%
19
L_abs10n50_2_H29017.0629073.6840.195%29025.7420.030%29017.0610.000%29582.3951.948%29037.6230.071%
20
L_abs10n50_2_L10499.7210638.6141.323%10515.8920.154%10537.4630.359%10944.3754.235%10499.7210.000%
21
L_abs10n50_3_H30581.6930581.6910.000%30805.3540.731%30596.7120.049%31917.7454.369%30606.1830.080%
22
L_abs10n50_3_L12067.7712135.830.564%12557.7444.060%12067.7710.000%13216.859.521%12081.6420.115%
23
L_abs10n50_4_H32427.2732593.4240.512%32496.9930.215%32427.2710.000%34375.5156.008%32464.0920.114%
24
L_abs10n50_4_L13824.6613927.2920.742%13996.7641.245%13824.6610.000%15569.71512.623%13949.6330.904%
25
L_abs10n50_5_H34183.8534186.0920.007%34183.8510.000%34225.4630.122%37044.3258.368%34341.5140.461%
26
L_abs10n50_5_L15658.115762.5220.667%16000.642.187%15658.110.000%19100.67521.986%15791.6630.853%
27
L_abs1n100_2_H51381.9951479.7630.190%51841.2640.894%51381.9910.000%53685.9654.484%51437.3720.108%
28
L_abs1n100_2_L15509.415656.5530.949%15902.2142.533%15509.410.000%16666.957.463%15636.0220.816%
29
L_abs1n100_3_H52376.6552687.9640.594%52437.5220.116%52440.4530.122%60014.53514.583%52376.6510.000%
30
L_abs1n100_3_L16446.4416517.6430.433%16743.641.807%16446.4410.000%24532.2549.164%16506.220.363%
31
L_abs1n100_4_H53148.6253590.130.831%53434.5720.538%53148.6210.000%62469.05517.537%53646.140.936%
32
L_abs1n100_4_L17290.1217681.1232.261%17699.4142.367%17290.1210.000%24600.12542.278%17594.621.761%
33
L_abs1n100_5_H54537.7954869.9530.609%54922.440.705%54537.7910.000%67149.97523.126%54839.4720.553%
34
L_abs1n100_5_L18651.4719030.3232.031%19035.9642.061%18651.4710.000%28936.96555.146%18969.9721.708%
35
L_abs1n200_2_H97033.2597575.5420.559%98341.8441.349%97033.2510.000%105984.559.225%97644.7830.630%
36
L_abs1n200_2_L23018.0323647.6642.735%23595.7722.510%23018.0310.000%32645.72541.827%23610.1732.573%
37
L_abs1n200_3_H97577.1598099.8620.536%98790.241.243%97577.1510.000%111374.06514.139%98261.530.701%
38
L_abs1n200_3_L23631.124269.8142.703%23944.5121.326%23631.110.000%35824.24551.598%24084.1731.917%
39
L_abs1n200_4_H98378.3898789.5320.418%99002.6230.635%98378.3810.000%114588.77516.478%99015.3240.647%
40
L_abs1n200_4_L24304.224938.8922.611%25241.8143.858%24304.210.000%35707.92546.921%25055.4933.091%
41
L_abs1n200_5_H99160.7299722.4520.566%100617.9341.470%99160.7210.000%114109.33515.075%100096.3930.944%
42
L_abs1n200_5_L25120.8826048.1323.691%26115.8933.961%25120.8810.000%42484.57569.121%26272.8744.586%
43
L_abs1n50_2_H28205.528262.8140.203%28229.2720.084%2825930.190%28613.6351.447%28205.510.000%
44
L_abs1n50_2_L10971.7711000.9230.266%11007.3940.325%10971.7710.000%11336.353.322%10986.8320.137%
45
L_abs1n50_3_H29908.5229908.5210.000%29913.1630.016%30032.940.416%31550.5255.490%29909.620.004%
46
L_abs1n50_3_L12637.1712780.7631.136%12637.1710.000%12702.9820.521%13854.0959.630%12791.8341.224%
47
L_abs1n50_4_H31856.7731997.6630.442%32243.7341.215%31856.7710.000%33371.5554.755%31989.8720.418%
48
L_abs1n50_4_L14596.8814771.0331.193%15099.1143.441%14596.8810.000%16323.6511.829%14691.8220.650%
49
L_abs1n50_5_H34039.3534082.1220.126%34337.2140.875%34149.9630.325%38289.93512.487%34039.3510.000%
50
L_abs1n50_5_L16645.4616749.6330.626%16645.4610.000%16680.8820.213%21744.4530.633%16823.9341.072%
51
L_abs2n100_2_H47690.5147811.6120.254%47908.7340.458%47690.5110.000%48855.9652.444%47900.3830.440%
52
L_abs2n100_2_L14393.6614739.9132.406%14858.3143.228%14393.6610.000%16850.6517.070%14659.421.846%
53
L_abs2n100_3_H48501.6848501.6810.000%48772.3240.558%48517.6520.033%55681.46514.803%48534.3830.067%
54
L_abs2n100_3_L15187.8215485.5231.960%16292.3947.273%15187.8210.000%20418.92534.443%15370.3821.202%
55
L_abs2n100_4_H49390.449526.9520.276%49885.1741.002%49390.410.000%56562.56514.521%49631.2430.488%
56
L_abs2n100_4_L16038.9816474.4442.715%16302.6121.644%16038.9810.000%21631.42534.868%16441.9732.513%
57
L_abs2n100_5_H50461.7750622.520.319%50804.130.678%50461.7710.000%62836.83524.524%50897.2540.863%
58
L_abs2n100_5_L17352.9617589.7131.364%17352.9610.000%17423.2820.405%26855.13554.758%17626.9341.579%
59
L_abs2n200_2_H98369.6999320.5730.967%99494.3841.143%98369.6910.000%105945.6757.702%99093.5220.736%
60
L_abs2n200_2_L23330.2323758.7121.837%23763.0331.855%23330.2310.000%29938.58528.325%23854.3342.246%
61
L_abs2n200_3_H99227.599848.3940.626%99490.2720.265%99227.510.000%113861.06514.747%99843.9330.621%
62
L_abs2n200_3_L23860.5524493.7632.654%24180.6621.342%23860.5510.000%36874.19554.540%24838.9344.100%
63
L_abs2n200_4_H99791.69100449.3720.659%102170.3142.384%99791.6910.000%115572.18515.813%101072.8331.284%
64
L_abs2n200_4_L24639.2525155.222.094%26266.9546.606%24639.2510.000%42214.74571.331%25840.2434.874%
65
L_abs2n200_5_H100846.82101608.7520.756%102805.8841.943%100846.8210.000%121438.61520.419%102642.9931.781%
66
L_abs2n200_5_L25646.6526716.824.173%27888.2548.740%25646.6510.000%45245.42576.418%27522.2937.313%
67
L_abs2n50_2_H27848.9227859.6930.039%27852.1620.012%27848.9210.000%28338.8951.759%27888.740.143%
68
L_abs2n50_2_L11409.0411409.0410.000%11516.0740.938%11477.9430.604%11532.1851.079%11426.1820.150%
69
L_abs2n50_3_H29699.4429788.3740.299%29699.4410.000%29740.7730.139%30782.9253.648%29713.2820.047%
70
L_abs2n50_3_L13298.2213496.0431.488%13546.0441.864%13324.8620.200%14383.2458.159%13298.2210.000%
71
L_abs2n50_4_H31525.1731532.0330.022%31525.1710.000%31528.9720.012%34093.9558.148%31581.7740.180%
72
L_abs2n50_4_L15107.3215493.842.558%15254.2330.972%15107.3210.000%16537.259.465%15154.2720.311%
73
L_abs2n50_5_H33558.1433827.240.802%33747.3720.564%33558.1410.000%36387.858.432%33755.3230.588%
74
L_abs2n50_5_L17136.117185.3720.288%17423.7941.679%17136.110.000%21319.3524.412%17357.7931.294%
75
L_abs3n100_2_H52133.7252385.8620.484%52543.9440.787%52133.7210.000%54012.8653.604%52446.9930.601%
76
L_abs3n100_2_L15503.4515803.6341.936%15759.4331.651%15516.2420.082%17875.33515.299%15503.4510.000%
77
L_abs3n100_3_H53406.853612.3420.385%53720.0340.586%53406.810.000%57574.1357.803%53669.8330.493%
78
L_abs3n100_3_L16695.3116733.2220.227%16841.3530.875%16695.3110.000%20225.32521.144%16842.2640.880%
79
L_abs3n100_4_H55042.5555042.5510.000%55996.5141.733%55056.1420.025%61537.67511.800%55395.1830.641%
80
L_abs3n100_4_L18346.971839220.245%19241.944.878%18346.9710.000%23350.34527.271%18507.3430.874%
81
L_abs3n100_5_H56594.7756890.8220.523%56997.4630.712%56594.7710.000%68940.83521.815%57184.1641.041%
82
L_abs3n100_5_L19882.920444.7342.826%20406.1932.632%19882.910.000%29990.7550.837%20261.5221.904%
83
L_abs3n200_2_H94406.4895050.8220.683%96150.9441.848%94406.4810.000%104729.54510.935%95461.3631.117%
84
L_abs3n200_2_L22844.6223580.2743.220%23569.7633.174%22844.6210.000%30097.15531.747%23417.2922.507%
85
L_abs3n200_3_H95360.6695959.1520.628%96831.7331.543%95360.6610.000%107237.3512.454%97074.1241.797%
86
L_abs3n200_3_L23756.3125194.2546.053%25031.6135.368%23756.3110.000%35407.88549.046%24651.0723.766%
87
L_abs3n200_4_H96814.0397277.0130.478%96832.2220.019%96814.0310.000%113196.29516.921%98505.6541.747%
88
L_abs3n200_4_L25045.0825927.5333.523%25663.7622.470%25045.0810.000%44395.99577.264%26120.7644.295%
89
L_abs3n200_5_H98264.9398782.7630.527%98612.4720.354%98264.9310.000%110871.18512.829%100275.0242.046%
90
L_abs3n200_5_L26702.2427521.1333.067%27077.1721.404%26702.2410.000%48161.12580.364%27867.2144.363%
91
L_abs3n50_2_H27231.4227231.4210.000%27342.120.406%27387.4540.573%27802.6452.098%27371.8230.516%
92
L_abs3n50_2_L10723.1910723.1910.000%10760.5340.348%10754.0530.288%11338.6355.739%10738.5320.143%
93
L_abs3n50_3_H28473.4928535.4940.218%28529.3430.196%28491.5620.063%2915652.397%28473.4910.000%
94
L_abs3n50_3_L11922.9512093.8341.433%11976.5230.449%11922.9510.000%12749.3356.931%11951.6720.241%
95
L_abs3n50_4_H29743.0729862.5540.402%29743.0710.000%29757.8820.050%30931.3853.995%29786.9130.147%
96
L_abs3n50_4_L13228.0313409.7941.374%13308.0520.605%13328.5130.760%14539.0859.911%13228.0310.000%
97
L_abs3n50_5_H31129.3831163.9120.111%31295.840.535%31129.3810.000%33157.8856.516%31270.9230.455%
98
L_abs3n50_5_L14640.4714770.3830.887%15249.744.161%14640.4710.000%18121.99523.780%14687.5620.322%
99
L_abs4n100_2_H46083.7546191.6720.234%46399.9740.686%46083.7510.000%48238.9454.677%46292.7930.454%
100
L_abs4n100_2_L14316.6814788.6833.297%15049.2545.117%14316.6810.000%15754.86510.045%14575.6521.809%