ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
1
Design Challenge Part 2 for EnergyExcursions.com Course:
2
How Much Water Does It Take?
3
4
Here you will design your own power grid for the state of Texas to improve water consumption associated with power generation (from 2021 data).
5
Then using the number of gallons necessary for a single megawatthour of electricty you will consider how many gallons are needed for the total number of megawatthours for each source.
6
Calculations will show you the sum total amount of water needed on average to power our state annually!
7
Can we reduce our water usage for power production? You will take a look at a proposed scenario and decide.
8
9
10
TOTAL ANNUAL MEGAWATTHOURS OF ELECTRICTY GENERATION REQUIRED FOR YOUR DESIGN
11
12
481,844,256Megawatthours (MWh)
13
source: Texas Electricity Profile (EIA) 2021
14
https://www.eia.gov/electricity/state/texas/
15
16
17
DESIGN YOUR OWN MIX
18
Complete Tables G and H by choosing your own mix of energy to satisfy annual electricty generation (481,844,256 MWh)
19
Remember your percentages for each source needs to equal 100%
20
You may need to do some research on each energy source. How reliable are they? Can we power the state solely with wind for example?
21
Fill out the table below (blue cells) with your proposed new Energy Mix for Texas.
22
Table G: PERCENTAGE OF GENERATION BY SOURCE - YOUR MIX
23
Source %Annnual Generation (MWh)
24
Natural Gas ?#VALUE!
25
Wind ?#VALUE!
26
Coal ?#VALUE!
27
Nuclear ?#VALUE!
28
Solar (Photovoltaic) ?#VALUE!
29
Other (approximate, includes other sources, e.g. hydro)1% 4,818,443
30
TOTAL: 1%#VALUE!
31
32
Table H: WATER FOR ELECTRICITY GENERATION - YOUR MIX
33
Source
Gallons of water necessary for 1 MWh
Annnual Generation (MWh)
Total amount of water consumed (gallons)
34
Natural Gas 263#VALUE!#VALUE!
35
Wind 0#VALUE!#VALUE!
36
Coal 382#VALUE!#VALUE!
37
Nuclear 803#VALUE!#VALUE!
38
Solar (Photovoltaic) 26#VALUE!#VALUE!
39
Other (water use considered minimal in comparison)0 4,818,443 -
40
TOTAL: #VALUE!#VALUE!
41
42
source: U.S. Energy Information Administration. 2023. Thermoelectric cooling water data, Final annual data for 2021 (Texas)
43
https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/water/
44
Bridget Scanlon and Bob Reedy. Personal communication. Bureau of Economic Geology, The University of Texas at Austin
45
46
source: Zerrenner, K. 2013. Which energy resources are gulping down our water? GreenBiz
47
https://www.greenbiz.com/article/which-energy-resources-are-gulping-down-our-water
48
49
Is your mix more or less water intensive than what we use currently in Texas? (based on 2021 data)
50
Would you change anything?
51
52
53
54
For comparison purposes, here are the 2021 data from Part 1 of the Design Project.
55
TOTAL ANNUAL MEGAWATTHOURS OF ELECTRICTY GENERATION (2021)
56
57
481,844,256Megawatthours (MWh)
58
source: Texas Electricity Profile (EIA) 2021
59
https://www.eia.gov/electricity/state/texas/
60
61
Table A: PERCENTAGE OF GENERATION BY SOURCE
62
63
Source %Annnual Generation (MWh)
64
Natural Gas 42% 202,374,588
65
Wind 24% 115,642,621
66
Coal 19% 91,550,409
67
Nuclear 10% 48,184,426
68
Solar (Photovoltaic) 4% 19,273,770
69
Other (approximate, includes other sources and rounding of #s)
1% 4,818,443
70
TOTAL: 100% 481,844,256
71
72
Looking at the table, what source provides the most generation in Texas? What source provides the least amount of electricity generation?
73
source: Texas Energy Profile (Texas Comptroller) 2021
74
https://comptroller.texas.gov/economy/fiscal-notes/2022/sep/energy.php
75
76
77
Table B: WATER FOR ELECTRICTY GENERATION
78
79
Take a look at the number of gallons necessary to generate 1 Megawatthour of electricty by source.
80
What energy source is the most water intensive? What energy source is the least water intensive?
81
82
Source
Gallons of water necessary for 1 MWh
Annual Generation (MWh)
Total amount of water consumed (gallons)
83
Natural Gas 263 202,374,588 53,224,516,518
84
Wind 0 115,642,621 -
85
Coal 382 91,550,409 34,972,256,100
86
Nuclear 803 48,184,426 38,692,093,757
87
Solar (Photovoltaic) 26 19,273,770 501,118,026
88
Other (water use considered minimal in comparison)0 4,818,443 -
89
TOTAL: 481,844,256 127,389,984,401
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100