EPDP-IDNs Phase 2 Initial Report Public Comment Review Tool

	A	B	C	D	F	G	H	I	J
1	££	Comments Received?	Significant Concerns or Objections Raised?	Further Discussion Required	Public Comment Statistics

2	Section 4.1 C1-2: "Same Entity" at the Second-level				No. Submission	8
3	Rec 1	Yes	No	Pending updates	No. Commenters	8
4	IG 2	Yes	Yes	Pending updates	Commenters	Michael Bauland	Note: Providing input as an individual		26 April 2024
5	Rec 3	Yes	No	Pending updates		ICANN org	Michael Karakash	Significant changes required for: IG2, PR14	20 May 2024
6	Rec 4	Yes	No	Pending updates		NCSG	Mesumbe Tomslin Samme-Nlar	Significant changes required for: PR14 (and IG15)	21 May 2024
7	Section 4.1 C4-5: IDN Table Harmonization					RrSG	Sarah Wyld		21 May 2024
8	Rec 5	No	No	No		BC	Business Constituency		21 May 2024
9	Rec 6	Yes	No	Pending updates		RySG	Registries Stakeholder Group	Significant changes required for: PR9, PR10, PR11, IG12 Do NOT support: IG15, PR20	21 May 2024
10	IG 7	Yes	No	Pending updates		ALAC	At-Large Advisory Committee		21 May 2024
11	Section 4.1 D4, D6, D6a, D7a, F2, D8: Procedures related to the Domain Name Lifecycle					GAC	Australian GAC Representative	Note: Late Submission	8 June 2024
12	Rec 8	Yes	No	Pending updates	No. Outputs that received comments	17 out of 20	PR1, IG2, PR3, PR4, PR6, IG7, PR8, PR9, PR10, PR11, IG12, PR13, PR14, IG15, IG17, PR18, PR20	Note: Some commenters did not explicitly indicate the level of support or non-support; staff placed such comments under relevant recommendations and categories for the EPDP Team to discuss.
13	Rec 9	Yes	Yes	Pending updates	No. Outputs that received significant concerns or objections	9 out of 20	IG2, PR8, PR9, PR10, PR11, IG12, PR14, IG15, PR20	Note: Some commenters did not explicitly indicate the level of support or non-support; staff placed such comments under relevant recommendations and categories for the EPDP Team to discuss.
14	Rec 10	Yes	Yes	Pending updates	Charter qu's with NO Outputs that raised questions	4 out of 8	C3, C3a, C6, D5
15	Rec 11	Yes	Yes	Pending updates
16	IG 12	Yes	Yes	Pending updates
17	Rec 13	Yes	No	No
18	Rec 14	Yes	Yes	Pending updates
19	IG 15	Yes	Yes	Pending updates
20	Rec 16	No	No	No
21	IG 17	Yes	No	Pending updates
22	Section 4.1 G1: IDN Implementation Guidelines
23	Rec 18	Yes	No	Pending updates
24	IG 19	No	No	No
25	Rec 20	Yes	Yes	Pending updates
26	Other Comments
27	Other	Yes	Yes	Yes
28
29
30		Recommendations NOT supported
31		Recommendations with significant change required
32		Not sifnificant, maybe non-substantive, but requires discussion/confirmation
33		Team has reviewed, discussed, but requires further updates and review, thus further action required
34		Concluded
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100