COVID-19 evidence summary and guidance resources - IN PROGRESS

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L	M	N	O	P	Q	R	S	T	U	V	W	X	Y
1	Description of wanted capabilities	Find Evidence - >	A user gets information when there are new studies in your focus area... Collaboration.. blah blah ... use FHIR Citation standard, enable federated search.... Use a standardized common terminology for Population and intervention name and description,										Create Living systematic reviews -- >						Create Living guidance -->
2	Name	Find Evidence - >	Cochrane Central/COVID-19 Study Register	McMaster PLUS	L·OVE Platform by Epistemonikos Foundation	ACTS COVID-19 Guidance to Action Collaborative - Guidance Summaries	Epistemonikos search database incl. matrix	NIPH - Live map of COVID-19 evidence	GIN guideline library	SRDR - repository	MAGICapp - published guidelines repository	GDTs database of evidence profiles	Create Living systematic reviews -- >	Eppi-reviewer 4	RevMan 5 (.rm5) and RevMan Web	Covidence	Rayyan	DistillerSR	Create Living guidance -->	GDT	MAGICapp - authoring and publication platform - as a tool

3	Short explanation (status, what evidence products)->				The L·OVE Platform gathers and organises health evidence to facilitate access to it. It holds the largest COVID19 evidence collection so far and allows users to conduct basic and advanced searches on evidence of interventions, tests and diagnostics, prevention, among other topics. It considers not only all systematic reviews available, but also primary studies and other kinds of articles, included and not included on the strategies of the different PICO Questions already built in the platform.
4	Target users ->
5	Read only or can export data										Read + extract through API			Both
6	Link to site		http://covid-19.cochrane.org		app.iloveevidence.com/covid19	https://covid-acts.ahrq.gov/display/COV/Guidance+Summaries+and+About+This+Project	http://www.epistemonikos.org/	https://www.fhi.no/en/qk/systematic-reviews-hta/map/	http://www.g-i-n.net/library/international-guidelines-library	http://srdr.ahrq.gov/	http://www.magicapp.org	http://dbep.gradepro.org/		http://eppi.ioe.ac.uk/cms/	http://tech.cochrane.org/revman	www.covidence.org	http://rayyan.qcri.org	https://www.evidencepartners.com/		http://www.guidelinedevelopment.org	https://app.magicapp.org
7	Owners active in COVID-END													Yes		Yes?		?
8	Ownership				Epistemonikos Foundation	AHRQ	Epistemonikos	NIPH	G-I-N	AHRQ	Magic EE Foundation	McMaster U, Evidence prime		EPPI-Centre, UCL	Cochrane collaboration		Qatar Computing Research Institute	Privately held		Evidence Prime and McMaster University	Magic EE Foundation
9	open access				Yes									No, 1 month free trial				Free for students doing course work		Up to a certain number of profiles	Personal use
10	Subscription plan/ licensing				The COVID19 L·OVE (collection of evidence) is completely free to access and browse. To obtain/download evidence, free registration is needed.	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A			Monthly per user; different options available	Yes, for for-profits			Yes. Monthly per/user subscription. Unlimited reviews		Yes, for for-profits	Only needed for publishing Orgs
11	Population and intervention elements coded with standard terminology										Both PICO level and recommendation level			User-defined							Both PICO level and recommendation level
12	API in place						JSON https://api.epistemonikos.org/			Programming underway	JSON. http://www.magicapp.org/docs			Yes, but not publicly documented yet	RevMan online		Partial API, undocumented, available soon	?			JSON. http://www.magicapp.org/docs
13	Use COKA FHIR CItation standard
14	Use COKA FHIR Evidence standard
15	Use COKA FHIR EvidenceVariable standard									Can send Outcome definitions
16	Support "Improve my RIS"					N/A
17	Use or contribute to Risk Of Bias Code System (FHIR, COKA)
18	Use or contribute to Study Design Code System (FHIR, COKA)
19	Use or contribute to Statistic Type Code System (FHIR, COKA)
20	Use or contribute to Statistic Model Code System (FHIR, COKA)
21	Languages available					N/A	2: en, es		1: en	1: en	14: en, de, no, se, dk, nl, ar, fr, es, fi, pt, ko, zh, ja	4: en, de, sp, it		1: en	1: en	1: en	1: en	1: en		4: en, de, sp, it	14: en, de, no, se, dk, nl, ar, fr, es, fi, pt, ko, zh, ja
22	Export files with results data (xml, JSON)					N/A					All date in JSON through API			Yes, xml, html, doc, xls, json etc	Yes, xml			Yes, CSV and RIS with mapped fields. Will ship support for JSON Q1, 2017		Evidence profiles.	Evidence profiles from app. All other data through API
23	Export files with metadata (xml, JSON)					N/A					Through the API			json			Yes: RIS, BibTeX, EndNote & CSV	Yes, CSV and RIS with mapped fields. Will ship support for JSON Q1, 2018			Through the API
24	Export text files					N/A					PDF, Word			Yes? RIS etc??				Yes. Exports to Word			Yes, PDF and for print
25	Perform meta-analysis					N/A
26	Perform screening of studies					N/A	No, but plans.											Yes, and full data extraction
27	Perform deduplication of studies					N/A
28	Detailed (too detailed)	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V	V
29	Non-profit ownership														Yes, as a part of cochrane?
30	Web - Online
31	Online: Which browsers can be used					all	All		All	All	All, IE down to 6 (but limited design on 6, authoring only 9+)	FF, Safari, Chrome, IE 10+		V4 requires silverlight (IE / Firefox); Web requires 'modren' browser		All	All (IE9+)	Tested on all major browsers		FF, Safari, Chrome, IE 10+	All, IE down to 6 (but limited design on 6, authoring only 9+)
32	Web - Offline										Yes, view only	No?								Yes	View only
33	Downloadable									Data exports only
34	Mobile (responsive design or app)													Web UI resizes, though data extraction tricky on a phone (fine on ipad)
35	Many can access at same time, state if limits																			Yes, no limit	Yes, no limit
36	Many can author at same time, state if limits		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A			No, system of checking in, checking out
37	Which roles exist, if multiple persons can access									Leader, Consolidator, Contributor, Auditor	Admin, Author, Reviewer, Viewer			Admin / author / read only / multiple Cochrane roles			Private reviews: Owner, Collaborator, Viewer & Translator. Public reviews: Viewer	Detailed permissions matrix for all users to manage roles independantly on each project			Admin, Author, Reviewer, Viewer
38	GL/ SR -specific chatroom, forum or comments					N/A	No				Yes, comment- sections on all PICOs and recommendations						http://support.rayyan.qcri.org	Yes. Also, live chat-based support			Yes, comment- sections on all PICOs and recommendations
39	Perform GRADE assessment		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A		Yes in older, Silverlight version	No, but use evidence profiles made elsewhere
40	Perform Risk of Bias assessment		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A						Includes a number of customizable RoB templates		Yes, included in GRADE assessment	Yes, included in GRADE assessment
41	Structured PICO questions						Yes, in matrix of evidence											Yes, through customizable forms
42	Structured Recommendations						No
43	Structured references						Yes
44	Document sharing						No										Yes: realtime collaboration
45	Text mining capabilities (link to site with info)						No, but plans.							http://eppi.ioe.ac.uk/cms/Default.aspx?tabid=3772		?	Yes: main business	In develoment. Currently supports keyword highlighting
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62