ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAE
1
TimestampHow do you feel about changing the Nix logo?
^^ Hexagon outline, alternating colours
^^ Hexagon outline, feature lambda
^^ Circle outline, alternating colours
^^ Circle outline, feature lambda
Other feedback
2
9/16/2015 20:11:58I want to keep the existing logo!About as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
3
9/16/2015 20:12:54I have no strong opinions either way.About as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
4
9/16/2015 20:18:58I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.
5
9/16/2015 20:28:10Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.
6
9/16/2015 20:28:44Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.
7
9/16/2015 20:33:53Let's do it!Better than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
8
9/16/2015 20:39:22Let's do it!Better than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
9
9/16/2015 20:41:41Let's do it!My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
10
9/16/2015 20:42:03I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.My favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.the fonts all look bad IMO but I really like the thicker flat lines of the hex logo. Scales down much more nicely
11
9/16/2015 20:55:14Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
12
9/16/2015 21:12:56I want to keep the existing logo!Worse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careAll the new propositions look too "fat".
IMHO, The current logo is more representative of a "light and elegant" OS.
13
9/16/2015 21:15:33Let's do it!My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.qknight
14
9/16/2015 21:35:26Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
15
9/16/2015 21:35:51I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
16
9/16/2015 21:50:47Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
17
9/16/2015 21:59:20Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
18
9/16/2015 22:01:02Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
19
9/16/2015 22:01:30I have no strong opinions either way.Better than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
20
9/16/2015 22:05:57Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
21
9/16/2015 22:12:00Let's do it!Better than the current logoWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
22
9/16/2015 22:15:02Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
23
9/16/2015 22:15:35Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.As mentioned on the list, I'm not a fan of the typeface. The S in particular looks super narrow (almost half the width) next to that giant O and looks unbalanced as a result. I don't have much of an opinion on a replacemenet typeface, but I'd like one where the S is closer in width to the O.
24
9/16/2015 22:33:53I have no strong opinions either way.Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
25
9/16/2015 23:45:04I have no strong opinions either way.About as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
26
9/16/2015 23:45:17I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.Worse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
27
9/16/2015 23:45:52I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
28
9/16/2015 23:47:35Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careI like the new proposals, was never a big fan of the current logo.
29
9/16/2015 23:47:36Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
30
9/16/2015 23:48:17Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
31
9/16/2015 23:49:29Let's do it!About as good as the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoBetter than the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
32
9/16/2015 23:51:14I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
33
9/16/2015 23:56:30I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
34
9/16/2015 23:58:51I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
35
9/17/2015 0:01:52Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
36
9/17/2015 0:02:03I want to keep the existing logo!Worse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
37
9/17/2015 0:02:39Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
38
9/17/2015 0:06:44Let's do it!Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteYes, let's have both.
39
9/17/2015 0:23:19Let's do it!My favouriteWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.
40
9/17/2015 0:27:08I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.you should do the poll again and present all the version so you can see them all at once on the same page - it is too hard to scroll back and forth trying to make comparisons
41
9/17/2015 0:27:25I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.
42
9/17/2015 0:30:22I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
43
9/17/2015 0:30:29Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
44
9/17/2015 0:36:21I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.Better than the current logoWorse than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
45
9/17/2015 0:41:41Let's do it!About as good as the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoBetter than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careI love the idea of the lambda.
46
9/17/2015 0:45:08I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteWorse than the current logoBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
47
9/17/2015 0:46:58I have no strong opinions either way.Better than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careto me it's mostly about the color and the line thickness
48
9/17/2015 0:49:12Let's do it!Better than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.Thanks!
49
9/17/2015 0:50:42Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
50
9/17/2015 0:54:13Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.I think we still need some more time to figure things out and maybe see other proposals. This kind of things can’t be done in less than a year or so…
51
9/17/2015 0:58:05Let's do it!About as good as the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteYes, let's have both.
52
9/17/2015 1:05:00Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.Keep it up!
53
9/17/2015 1:10:17Let's do it!Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteNo - the flat version looks better.
54
9/17/2015 1:13:35I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careThese are more of a redrawing of the current logo than a redesigning of it. I'd love to see concepts that went a bit further than these.
55
9/17/2015 1:14:41I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careThis is a poll done right. Congratulations.
56
9/17/2015 1:48:24Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.
57
9/17/2015 1:50:04I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
58
9/17/2015 2:06:44Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
59
9/17/2015 2:16:20Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
60
9/17/2015 2:47:17Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
61
9/17/2015 3:48:05I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
62
9/17/2015 3:53:56Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
63
9/17/2015 4:26:08I have no strong opinions either way.Better than the current logoMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.
64
9/17/2015 4:36:29Let's do it!My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careI wouldn't say the logo I selected above is a *great* improvement, but I think it is an improvement.
65
9/17/2015 4:37:38I have no strong opinions either way.About as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
66
9/17/2015 4:39:22I want to keep the existing logo!Worse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
67
9/17/2015 4:41:31Let's do it!My favouriteWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.I would change the police of "NixOS" to something that gives an identity to Nix.
68
9/17/2015 4:49:41Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
69
9/17/2015 6:26:31Let's do it!Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
70
9/17/2015 6:26:53I have no strong opinions either way.About as good as the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteI can't tell the difference / don't care
71
9/17/2015 8:51:30Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.
72
9/17/2015 9:09:25Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't carePlease do also change text font, current text is way too generic and does not fit next to logo.

If you need designer to choose right font text I have a spare one, I can ask. You can contact me on jakahudoklin@gmail.com
73
9/17/2015 10:55:47I have no strong opinions either way.Worse than the current logoWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoYes, let's have both.
74
9/17/2015 12:58:34Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.
75
9/17/2015 16:47:28I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
76
9/17/2015 18:03:37Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.
77
9/17/2015 20:19:57I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.My favouriteMy favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
78
9/17/2015 22:39:48Let's do it!Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteNo - the flat version looks better.
79
9/17/2015 22:41:05I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
80
9/17/2015 22:55:25Let's do it!Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.Much better than the tiny twig-like logo!
81
9/17/2015 23:33:54Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
82
9/17/2015 23:36:20I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
83
9/17/2015 23:44:45I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.Better than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
84
9/17/2015 23:57:35I have no strong opinions either way.Better than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
85
9/18/2015 0:16:25Let's do it!Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
86
9/18/2015 0:25:46I want to keep the existing logo!Worse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
I like the 'snowflake' look better than superimposing a hexagon or circle. A snowflake is a good metaphor for a nixos system, unique but regularly patterned and made out of lambdas. Imposing a hexagon or circle on this shape deemphasizes the snowflake-ness and makes it more of a generic space filling pattern.

For similar reasons I prefer thinner lines than in the new logos. I prefer the alternating colors to the single dark lambda.
87
9/18/2015 1:15:39I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
88
9/18/2015 1:52:31I want to keep the existing logo!Worse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careI'm not adverse to changing the current logo, but the proposals seem a little heavy-handed.

Things I like about current logo:
- has a lightness about it because of the thinner straight lines
- I prefer the colors, although there could be more of a difference in the shades

Thing I like about the proposals:
- the feature lambda (I admit I never "saw" the lambdas in the current logo)

I can't decide about the breaks between lambdas. I think they may make the logo look too busy. As a general statement, I prefer the hexagon outline.
89
9/18/2015 1:57:07Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteWorse than the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
90
9/18/2015 2:48:05Let's do it!My favouriteAbout as good as the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
91
9/18/2015 2:51:56Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoNo - the rich version looks good, but we should stick to one logo.
92
9/18/2015 3:30:47Let's do it!My favouriteMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.Honestly, it's hard to choose between the first two (hexagon shaped logos). They're both very good (and much better than the round ones). I could see them both working well when combined with other visual elements of their own.

IMO the symmetry of the first one speaks of 'unity' and 'collaboration' more than the second which speaks of 'process' or 'distinction'.. in one sense I would choose the first on the principles of open-source, but if I was in the business of marketing NixOS to consumers I might actually go with the second..

It really is a tough call, but since the first matches the original more I would likely vote for that in order to maintain more of the original author's spirit.
93
9/18/2015 3:48:10I think we should change the logo, but I don't like these proposals.About as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoWorse than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't careboth hexagon and circle shapes cut lambdas in unnatural ways, that's the only problem
94
9/18/2015 3:48:26Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteAbout as good as the current logoAbout as good as the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care
95
9/18/2015 4:23:15I have no strong opinions either way.Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteNo - the flat version looks better.
96
9/18/2015 4:53:04Let's do it!My favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoAbout as good as the current logoYes, let's have both.
97
9/18/2015 4:58:25Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoYes, let's have both.
98
9/18/2015 5:01:15I have no strong opinions either way.My favouriteWorse than the current logoBetter than the current logoWorse than the current logoNo - the flat version looks better.
99
9/18/2015 6:03:28I have no strong opinions either way.Better than the current logoBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoMy favouriteI can't tell the difference / don't care
100
9/18/2015 6:16:09Let's do it!Better than the current logoMy favouriteBetter than the current logoBetter than the current logoI can't tell the difference / don't care