Individual Blu-ray Picture Quality Placements (The Tiers List) (Responses)
 Share
The version of the browser you are using is no longer supported. Please upgrade to a supported browser.Dismiss

 
View only
 
 
ABCDEFHIJKLMNOPQRS
1
TimestampWhich Blu-ray are you evaluating?Which Tier do you recommend for this Blu-ray under the Picture Quality Tiers' guidelines?What is your AVSforum username?If you answered Tier 0 (Blu) for the previous question, please enter a more precise judgment for this entry's placement in the top tier.This is an area for any further comments or concerns about this specific Blu-ray placement that may aid in the final verdict:
2
3/16/2013 18:50:56Seeking a Friend for the End of the World*Tier 1.25Phantom StrangerShot with the Arri Alexa
3
3/17/2013 14:56:05Life of Pi*Tier 0 (Blu)JoeBloggzabove The Thin Red Linepossibly the best live-action PQ
4
3/18/2013 0:06:46FlightTier 1.5djoberg
5
3/18/2013 0:07:59Master, TheTier 0 (Blu)vpn75just below "A Serious Man"
6
3/18/2013 0:09:20Master, TheTier 0 (Blu)djobergright above "I, Robot"
7
3/18/2013 0:10:52Rise of the Guardians*Tier 0 (Blu)Gamereviewgodabove "Meet the Robinsons"
8
3/18/2013 0:12:09Twilight Saga, The: Breaking Dawn - Part 2*Tier 2.75Gamereviewgodsub-par black levels
9
3/18/2013 0:13:07Bachelorette*Tier 3.25Gamereviewgod
10
3/18/2013 0:13:37King of Thorn*Tier 1.5Phantom Stranger
11
3/18/2013 0:14:40DreddTier 3.0 (Bronze)audiomagnate
12
3/18/2013 0:16:45Master, TheTier 0 (Blu)audiomagnatesimilar to "The Thin Red Line"
13
3/18/2013 0:20:37Life of Pi*Tier 0 (Blu)Gamereviewgodtop 10 placement
14
3/18/2013 0:22:14Wreck-It RalphTier 0 (Blu)djoberg0.25characters needed more detail
15
3/18/2013 0:23:51Life of Pi*Tier 0 (Blu)djobergright above "The Thin Red Line"three top live action movies would be Life of Pi, The Thin Red Line, and then Avatar
16
3/18/2013 0:25:02Rise of the Guardians*Tier 0 (Blu)djobergright above "Legend of the Guardians"Every single category was amazing
17
3/18/2013 10:44:49Willow*Tier 2.5Gamereviewgod
18
3/18/2013 23:32:03Day, TheTier 4.0 (Copper)Phantom Strangercurrently ranked in Tier 3.0
19
3/19/2013 21:02:55Tell Tale*Tier 2.5audiomagnate
20
3/21/2013 20:01:35Zero Dark Thirty*Tier 1.0 (Gold)djobergThis was SO CLOSE to being a Tier Blu placement!
21
3/21/2013 22:01:03LawlessTier 1.75Phantom Strangercurrently ranked in Tier 1.25
22
3/22/2013 10:13:13Hobbit, The: An Unexpected Journey*Tier 0 (Blu)Gamereviewgod0.5
23
3/22/2013 10:13:27Goro*Tier 4.0 (Copper)Gamereviewgod
24
3/22/2013 22:22:19TekkonkinkreetTier 1.75Phantom Strangercurrent rank is Tier 1.0
25
3/22/2013 22:22:52Wicker Tree, The*Tier 2.0 (Silver)Phantom Strangershot on the Red One
26
3/23/2013 11:18:15Hobbit, The: An Unexpected Journey*Tier 1.5patrick99
27
3/25/2013 0:52:57Hobbit, The: An Unexpected Journey*Tier 0 (Blu)djobergRight above Braveheart
28
3/25/2013 14:21:38VEEP: The Complete First Season*Tier 1.5Phantom Stranger
29
3/26/2013 17:19:14Prep & Landing / Prep & Landing: Naughty & Nice*Tier 1.25Phantom Stranger
30
3/28/2013 9:38:10Zero Dark Thirty*Tier 1.0 (Gold)Gamereviewgod
31
3/30/2013 0:18:48LincolnTier 1.5djoberg
32
3/30/2013 21:34:13Batman: Mystery of the Batwoman*Tier 2.25Phantom Stranger
33
3/31/2013 20:46:01X-Men: First ClassTier 1.0 (Gold)Johnny VertigoThe only weak part are blacks; current rank is Tier 2.5
34
3/31/2013 21:13:51Lady Gaga Presents: The Monster Ball Tour at Madison Square Garden*Tier 1.25Johnny VertigoVideo: AVC, Audio: True HD 5.1, AR: 1,78:1, Universal Music, 1080i
35
4/1/2013 0:37:01Notebook, TheTier 1.5djobergcurrent rank is Tier 3.5; 2010 pressing
36
4/1/2013 22:15:51BattleshipTier 1.25lgans316current rank is Tier 1.5
37
4/1/2013 22:16:40Taken 2Tier 2.0 (Silver)lgans316current rank is Tier 1.75
38
4/1/2013 22:17:46Pulp Fiction*Tier 2.75lgans316
39
4/1/2013 22:19:22Les Misérables (2012)*Tier 2.0 (Silver)lgans316
40
4/1/2013 22:20:21Zero Dark Thirty*Tier 1.75lgans316
41
4/1/2013 22:21:20SkyfallTier 0 (Blu)lgans316above "Avatar"
42
4/1/2013 22:22:23Grey, TheTier 1.75lgans316current rank is Tier 3.25
43
4/1/2013 22:23:24Total Recall (2012)Tier 1.75lgans316current rank is Tier 1.5
44
4/1/2013 22:24:25Amazing Spider-Man, TheTier 1.25lgans316current rank is Tier 1.5
45
4/1/2013 22:25:34Lawless (UK import)*Tier 2.25lgans316a Momentum release
46
4/1/2013 22:32:02Parental Guidance*Tier 3.25Gamereviewgod
47
4/2/2013 9:28:00Hudson Hawk*Tier 2.75Gamereviewgod
48
4/2/2013 22:02:27Deadfall*Tier 3.5djoberg
49
4/3/2013 1:18:50Man With the Iron Fists, The*Tier 1.75djoberg
50
4/3/2013 7:54:43Alex CrossTier 2.0 (Silver)djobergcurrent rank is Tier 1.75
51
4/4/2013 13:16:42Hemingway & Gellhorn*Tier 1.75Phantom Stranger2.0 isn't an unreasonable score.
52
4/6/2013 21:12:27Straitheads (UK)*Tier 4.5Phantom Strangerregion-free UK import; first version as opposed to the reissue; 1080i / 50 Hz in AVC, PCM 2.0; Verve Pictures
53
4/8/2013 20:45:12Life of Pi*Tier 0 (Blu)hungro
Amazing fine details, facial , clothing, wideo shots etc. crisp and well defined textures. Vivid colors that pop out of the screen. , Superb black level and shadow detail. No hint of Edge Enhancement or Noise Reduction , 3D Like Depth.
54
4/9/2013 14:25:09Bible, The: The Epic Miniseries*Tier 1.25Phantom Strangercould be 1.0
55
4/10/2013 10:28:20Dragon Lord*Tier 5 (Coal)Gamereviewgod
56
4/11/2013 13:41:30Ship of Fools*Tier 3.5Gamereviewgodpart of a double feature w/ Lilith
57
4/12/2013 9:46:58Jersey Girl*Tier 3.5Gamereviewgod
58
4/13/2013 15:52:33People Like UsTier 2.0 (Silver)djobergcurrent rank is Tier 2.0
59
4/13/2013 15:59:39Wreck-It RalphTier 1.5audiomagnate
60
4/13/2013 16:00:44SkyfallTier 0 (Blu)audiomagnateSomewhere in the middle.
61
4/13/2013 16:01:29Zero Dark Thirty*Tier 0 (Blu)audiomagnateBelow Skyfall
62
4/13/2013 20:13:51Horror of Dracula (region-locked UK import)*Tier 4.0 (Copper)Phantom Strangerknown as "Dracula" in the UK, locked to Region B.
63
4/15/2013 1:24:24Twilight Saga, The: Breaking Dawn - Part 2*Tier 2.0 (Silver)djobergworse than Part 1
64
4/16/2013 16:48:22Collection, The*Tier 1.75Phantom Stranger
65
4/16/2013 22:28:13Odd Life of Timothy Green, The*Tier 1.25djoberg
66
4/17/2013 10:03:23Django Unchained*Tier 1.0 (Gold)Gamereviewgod
67
4/17/2013 13:03:06Other Guys, TheTier 2.5Comperic2003Current rank is Tier 2.0; Teal and Orange abound, shadow detail and black levels are great and resolution ranges from crisp to soft. Similar in tone and pacing to 21 Jump Street (2012), this was an enjoyable one to watch.
68
4/18/2013 17:54:1121 Jump Street*Tier 2.5comperic2003solid and well-detailed image made to look flat and dull due to an overall dim lighting quality
69
4/20/2013 0:08:06Hitchcock*Tier 1.0 (Gold)djoberg
70
4/20/2013 2:09:46Hitchcock*Tier 1.25Phantom Strangerhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/03/27/hitchcock-review/
71
4/20/2013 15:46:34Greystone Park*Tier 4.5Phantom StrangerXLRator Media
72
4/22/2013 13:42:12Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries Series 1*Tier 2.25Phantom Strangerhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/04/22/miss-fishers-murder-mysteries-series-1-review/
73
4/24/2013 15:14:59Thale*Tier 3.5Phantom Strangerhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/04/24/thale-review/
74
4/24/2013 16:58:36Hello, Dolly!*Tier 0 (Blu)hernanujust above 'Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest"
75
4/24/2013 21:07:44Fresh*Tier 2.5Gamereviewgod
76
4/25/2013 18:44:43Silent Hill: Revelation*Tier 1.75Phantom Stranger
77
4/26/2013 9:51:34Jurassic Park 3D*Tier 2.75Gamereviewgod
78
4/26/2013 14:28:04Haunted House, A*Tier 2.25Phantom Strangerhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/04/25/a-haunted-house-review/
79
4/28/2013 17:10:33Star Driver: Part 1*Tier 1.5Phantom Stranger
80
4/28/2013 17:11:12Star Driver: Part 2*Tier 1.5Phantom Stranger
81
4/29/2013 9:56:14Gangster Squad*Tier 2.0 (Silver)Gamereviewgodhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/04/29/gangster-squad-bluray-review/
82
5/2/2013 10:06:29Broken City*Tier 2.25Gamereviewgodhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/05/02/broken-city-bluray-review/
83
5/3/2013 23:04:55Gangster Squad*Tier 1.5djoberg
84
5/4/2013 21:48:03Guilt Trip, The*Tier 2.25djoberg
85
5/4/2013 22:55:00Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya, The*Tier 1.25Phantom Stranger
86
5/6/2013 14:32:53Man With The Iron Fists, The*Tier 0 (Blu)Phantom Strangerabove "The Lion King"
87
5/8/2013 10:13:28Guilt Trip*Tier 3.0 (Bronze)GamereviewgodSmoothing is an issue here as Streisand is digitally washed over with DNR to hide her age
88
5/8/2013 14:17:27Delhi Safari*Tier 1.25Phantom Strangerhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/05/06/delhi-safari-review/
89
5/8/2013 14:18:29Superman Unbound*Tier 1.0 (Gold)Phantom Strangercould qualify for Tier 0
90
5/9/2013 10:17:11Silver Linings Playbook*Tier 1.75Gamereviewgodhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/05/09/silver-linings-playbook-bluray-review/
91
5/14/2013 13:11:35Puella Magi Madoka Magica: Complete Series Collection (UK Import)*Tier 1.5Phantom StrangerRegion B locked UK import from Manga
92
5/14/2013 14:44:54Ghostbusters* (4K remaster)Tier 2.5Gamereviewgodhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/05/14/ghostbusters-4k-bluray-review/
93
5/14/2013 14:45:11Oranges, The*Tier 2.0 (Silver)Gamereviewgodhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/05/14/the-oranges-bluray-review/
94
5/15/2013 13:58:26Safety Not Guaranteed*Tier 2.75Phantom Stranger
95
5/15/2013 20:54:06Hellsing Ultimate: Collection Volumes I - IV*Tier 2.25Phantom Stranger
96
5/16/2013 9:35:42Shanghai Noon*Tier 2.0 (Silver)Gamereviewgodpart of the Shanghai Noon / Shanghai Knights double feature
97
5/16/2013 9:35:59Shangahi Knights*Tier 2.75Gamereviewgodpart of the Shanghai Noon / Shanghai Knights double feature
98
5/16/2013 20:16:35Brubaker*Tier 3.75Phantom Strangerhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/05/14/brubaker-review/
99
5/17/2013 9:51:23Resident Evil: Retribution*Tier 2.0 (Silver)Gamereviewgodhttp://www.doblu.com/2013/05/17/resident-evil-retribution-3d-review/
100
5/20/2013 14:35:31Jack Reacher*Tier 1.25djoberg
Loading...
 
 
 
Form Responses
Sheet2