GSU fair use analyses - Dist Ct findings Chart

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	M	N	O	Q	R	S	T	U	V	W	X	Y	Z	AA	AB	AC	AE	AF	AG	AH	AI	AJ	AK	AM	AN	AO	AP	AQ	AR	AT	AU	AV	AW	AX	AY
1												SUMMARY			2012 District Court [Cambridge I]													2016 District Court [Cambridge III]							Changes - 2012 decision to 2016 decision						2020 Dist. Ct. [Cambridge V (2020/03/02)]
2		USE - professor	USE - class	USE - term	# of students	pubr of work	Work	about the book	revenue	USE Required or Optional?	USE - specific content	2012	2016	2020	Pages (Slip. op)	Infringing?	Prima Facie Ownership / Originality	De Minimis Use?	Fair Use?	Amount used	License avail?	Lost Pub. Lic. Fee	Who won 1st factor?	Who won 2d factor?	Who won 3rd factor?	Who won 4th factor?	Note	Pages (slip op.)	Fair use?	Won First Factor	Won Second Factor?	Won Third Factor?	Won Fourth Factor?	Notes	Change in Second Factor?	Change in Third Factor?	Change in Fourth Factor?	If changed, second factor now favors	If changed, third factor now favors	If changed, fourth factor now favors	discussion item #	discussed on page stamp #s	Fair use?	NOTES / substantive and if changed, why?	fun quotes

3			RED: infringing all 3 times	purple: mixed
4
5	ct	FAIR USE ANALYSIS (48 claims)						notes from 2020	notes from 2020	notes from 2020	notes from 2020											2012 : 48 titles .... 43 fair use, 5 NOT fair use								2016 : 48 titles .... 44 fair use, 4 NOT fair use													2016 : 48 titles .... 37 fair use, 11 NOT fair use
6	5	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education I	May 2009		Sage	Hanbook of Critical and Indigenous Methodologies / Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln, eds. (2008)	619 pp., 30 ch., edited volume ... retail $146	$161,205	REQUIRED	2 chapters (5.98%): pp. 85-99 ("Critical Race Theory & Indigenous Methodologies" by Christopher Dunbar Jr.) , pp. 135-156 ("Indigenous Knowledges in Education: Complexities, Dangers, & Profound Benefits" by Joe L. Kintheloe & Shirtley R. Steinberg) ... 5	fair use	fair use	NOT fair	127-131	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	5.98% (2 chap)	Yes	$57.24	GSU	GSU	Pub	Pub	Low demand for excerpts and low income in that area allowed the court to revise its forth factor analysis	38-42	fair use	GSU	Pub	Pub	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Pub	No change	GSU	5	36-41	NOT fair	"Students would not pay $146.00 for the entire book when only 37 of 619 pages were required reading. Neither would a professor require students to purchase the entire book in such an instance. Therefore, the Court rejects any argument that the use of the exerpt ... had a negative effect on the market for sale of the book itself." (p.40)	"The chapter first provides an overview and critique of critical race theory, which seeks to analyze both the racially insensitive segments of the American psyche as well as enhance and expand upon race consciousness in people of color." (p.38)
7	2	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education I	May 2009		Sage	Handbook of Feminist Research: Theory and Praxis / Sharlene Nagy Hesse-Biber ed. (2006)	767 p., 43 chapter - edited volume ... retail $146	$94,086	REQUIRED	chapter 26 "Feminist Research Ethics" by Judith Preissle ... 20 p. long, 2.61% of 767 total pages	fair use	fair use	fair use	112-115	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	2.61% (1 chap)	Yes	$31.30	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		24-29	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	2	18-23	fair use		"These pages make up 2.61% of the total book, which is a very small (not merely small) amount" (p.20)
8	6	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education I	May 2009		Sage	Handbook of Narrative Inquiry: Mapping and Methodology / D. Jean Clandinin ed. (2006)	710 p., 24 ch., edited volume ... retail $146	$131,516	REQUIRED	1 chapter, pp. 3-34, 4.51% of total work. Chapter one: "Locating Narrative Inquiry Historically: Thematics in the Turn to Narrative" / Stefinee Pinnegar & J. Gary Daynes	fair use	fair use	fair use	133-136	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	4.51% (1 chap)	Yes	$33.32	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		42-47	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	6	41-47	fair use		""Locating Narrative Inquiry Historically" is simultaneously objectively and subjectively descriptive, as the chapter aims to acquaint readers with narrative inquiry through summaries and explanations of previous work in the field." (p.44)
9	3	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education I	May 2009		Sage	Handbook of Social Theory / George Ritzer & Barry Smart, eds. (2001)	564 p, 39 chapter, edited volume ... retail $150 hc, $69.95 pb	$62,454	REQUIRED	217-228 (one chapter) - chapter 17 "Symbolic Interactionism at the End of the Century" by Kent Sandstrom, Daniel Martin & Gary Alan Fine	fair use	fair use	fair use	115-119	No	Yes	No	fair use	2.12% (1 chap)	Yes	$18.72	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		29-34	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	3	23-29	fair use		"The amount taken is tiny, even without the leavening effect of the nonprofit educational purpose and character of the use." (p.27)
10	1	Kaufmann, Jodie	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education I	May 2009		Oxford	The Craft of Inquiry: Theories, Methods, Evidence / Robert R. Alford (1998)	176 p. / 8 chap. ... $32.95	$86,325	REQUIRED	pp. 21-31 (11pgs) - entirety of chapter 2, 6.25% of book	fair use	fair use	fair use	109-112	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	6.75%	Yes	$14.89	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		20-24	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	1	pp. 12-18 of 241	fair use		"The writer's style in this chapter is modestly conversational but still rather formal. ... Chapter Two has no humorous or fanciful aspects." (p.15)
11	4	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education I	May 2009		Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (Third Edition) / Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln, eds. (2005)	1229 p., 44 ch., edited volume ... retail $156	$1,327,804	REQUIRED	4 chapters (8.38%): EXCERPT 1: 1-32 (Introduction), EXCERPT 2: 357-375 (chapter 14: Critical Humanism & Queer Theory--Living with the Tensions), EXCERPT 3: (chapter 17, pp. 443-465, "Qualitative Case Studies"), EXCERPT 4: chapter 25, pp. 651-679, "Narrative Inquiry -- Multiple Lenses, Approaches, Voices")	NOT fair	NOT fair	NOT fair	119-124	Yes	Uncontested	No	NOT fair	8.38% (4 chap)	Yes	$159.34	GSU	GSU	Pub	Pub	Court weighs heavily the fact that there is "substantial demand for exerpts" in publishers favor	34-38	NOT fair	GSU	Pub	Pub	Pub	On remand, defendants conceded plaintiff's showing that use could cause substnatial harm.	Yes	No	No	Pub	No change	No change	4	29-36	NOT fair	NOTE: 4 chapters was "very large", even though it was 44 chapters total -- apparently, an objectively large quantity regardless of %
12	15	Esposito	EPSF 8280	Summer 2009			Handbook of Feminist Research: Theory and Praxis / Sharlene Nagy Hesse-Biber ed. (2006)	767 pg book		REQUIRED	1 chapter, 18 pp., 2.35% ... chapter 8: "Toward Understandings of Feminist Ethnography"	fair use	fair use	fair use	170-172	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	2.53% (1 chap)	Yes	$47.52	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		69-73	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	14	73-76	fair use		"Moreover, the excerpt was narrowly tailored to fit Professor Esposito's pedagogical purpose." (p.74) ("narrowly tailored" used 3 or 4 times in opinion)
13	44	Orr	MUS 8860 "Romantic Music"	Summer 2009		Cambridge	Liszt: Sonata in B Minor [Cambridge Music Handbooks] / Kenneth Hamilton (1996)	5 chapters, 101 pp. $80 hb, $28.99 pb	19,322 pounds	REQUIRED	one excerpt - chapter 3, pp. 28-48 -- 21 pages, 20.79%: "Paris from 1830 to 1848"	fair use	fair use	fair use	190-194	No	Yes*	No	fair use	20.79%	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	Pub	GSU	Court revised down the percentage used to 18.525, based on public domain material contained in the excerpt. Still not "decidedly small."	95-98	fair use	GSU	Pub	Pub	GSU		Yes	No	No	Pub	No change	No change	20	100-104	fair use	* "Chapter three also constitutes the heart of the work...."	"The objective music of the Sonata guides the entire chapter, with the author complementing the music with observations and descriptions clearly derived from his own experience playing the piece." (p.102)
14	45	Orr	MUS 8860 "Romantic Music"	Summer 2009		Cambrdg UP	The Cambridge Companion to Mendelssohn / Peter Mercer-Taylor ed. (2004)	331 p. / edited volume ... $90 hc, $32.99 pb		REQUIRED	one excerpt - pp. 96-111, 16 pages (4.83% of book) ... excerpt of chapter 6, "Sympohny and Overture" / Douglass Seaton /... NOT the complete chapter	fair use	fair use	fair use	194-197	No	Yes	No	fair use	4.83% (< 1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		98-101	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	21	104-107	fair use
15	46	Orr	MUS 8860 "Romantic Music"	Summer 2009		Cambrdg UP	The Cambridge Companion to Schumann / Beate Perrey, ed. (2007)	324 pp., 13 chapters -- $94.99 hc, $31.99 pb	27,866 pounds		one excerpt (pp. 105-119) - 15 page (4.63% of book) excerpt from chapter "Why Sing? Lieder and Song Cycles"	fair use	fair use	fair use	197-200	No	Yes	No	fair use	4.63% (< 1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		101-103	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	22	107-110	fair use
16	47	Orr	MUS 8860 "Romantic Music"	Summer 2009		Oxford	The Music of Berlioz / Julian Rushton (2001)	10 chapter, 379 pp. book -- retail $65.95	$9,580		one excerpt taken from chapter 9 "A Fantastic Symphony" ... 18 pages, 4.75% of book ... less than a whole chapter	fair use	fair use	fair use	203-206	No	Yes	No	fair use	4.75% (< 1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		103-106	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	23	110-114	fair use		"The excerpt is written in a formal tone, with any fanciful language strictly used to describe the nature of the music." (p.112) ..
17	16	Esposito	EPSF 8280	Summer 2009		Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (First Edition) / Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln (1994)	653 p., 36 chapter, edited volume ... OUT OF PRINT but REPRINTS available			1 chapter, 13 pages, 1.99% ... Chapter 4, pp. 70-82, "Working the Hyphens" / Michelle Fine	fair use	fair use	fair use	176-179	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	1.99% (1 chap)	Yes	$34.03	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		78-83	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	16	81-86	fair use
18	29	Kaufmann	EPRS 8510 Qualitative Research in Education II - Data Collection	Summer 2009		Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (Second Edition)	1142 p., 36 ch., edited volume ... retail $175 ... OUT OF PRINT	$1,300,054	REQUIRED	2 chapters, 37 pages, 3.24% ... ch. 27, pp. 717-732 "Reimagining Visual Methods: Galileo to Neuromancer" / Douglas Harper ... ch. 36, pp. 923-943, "Writing: A Method of Inquiry" / Laurel Richardson	NOT fair	NOT fair	NOT fair	136-140	Yes	Uncontested	No	NOT fair	3.01% (2 chap)	Yes	$34.04	GSU	GSU	Pub	Pub	Court weighs heavily the fact that there is substantial and inreasing income from licensed excerpts in publishers favor	47-52	NOT fair	GSU	Pub	Pub	Pub	Factor 3 is small, but full chapters were used and "chapters have greater value than parts of chapters"; defendants conceded and do not argue lack of "substantial harm"	Yes	No	No	Pub	No change	No change	7	47-54	NOT fair
19	17	Esposito	EPSF 8280 Qualitative Research in Education II - Data Collection	Summer 2009		Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (Second Edition) / Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln eds. (2000)	1142 p., 36 ch., edited volume ... retail $175 ... OUT OF PRINT	$1,300,055		1 chapter, pp. 455-486, 2.80% of total ... "Ethnography and Ethnographic Representation" / Barbara Tedlock	fair use	fair use	NOT fair	172-176	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	2.80% (1 chap)	Yes	$83.78	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		73-78	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	Pub		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	15	77-81	NOT fair	"There is conflicting evidence of whether [it] is currently out of print" (p.77) ... technically out of print but "reprint" available at extra charge. The Court "treats this as in print."
20	7	Angorro	EPY 8690 Seminar in Educational Psychology	Fall 2009	9	Cambridge	Language Acquisition & Conceptual Development / Melissa Bowerman & Stephen C. Levinson eds. (2001)	614 pages, 19 chapter, edited volume ... $140 hb, $53 pb			one excerpt -- chapter 19 "Covariation between spatial language and cognition..." / Stephen C. Levinson ... pp. 566-588 (3.75% of book)	fair use	fair use	fair use	272-276	No	Yes*	No	fair use	3.75% (1 chap)	Yes	$26.39	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		149-154	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	35	164-171	fair use		"[Chapter 19] contains occasional parenthetical asides and footnotes that lighten the tone; but the chapter is not humorous or fanciful." (p.168)
21	8	Davis	HIST 7010 Issues & Interpretations in American History	Fall 2009	17	Oxford	Region, Race & Reconstruction / J. Morgan Kousser & James McPHerson eds. (1982) ... $29.95	500 pages, 15 chapter, edited volume		REQUIRED	one excerpt ... pp. 143-177, chapter, "Ideology and Race in American History" / Barbara J. Fields ... 35 pp. 7% total	fair use	fair use	fair use	284-287	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	7.00% (1 chap)	Yes	$60.69	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		154-158	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	36	171-177	fair use	* discussed Professor Davis' conversations about fair use, reading guidelines, etc! ... ""As for the substantiality (value) of the excerpt, the essay itself was no more or less important to the overall work than any other ssay in the colection." (p.175
22	9	Davis	HIST 7010 Issues & Interpretations in American History	Fall 2009	17	Oxford	The Unpredictable Past / Lawrence W. Levine (1993)	394 pages	$79,368		one excerpt ... chapter 3 "Slave Songs and Slave Consciousness: An Exploratoin in Neglected Sources" ... pp. 35-58 (24 pages), 6.09% of work	fair use	fair use	fair use	287-290	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	6.09% (1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		158-161	fair use	GSU	Pub	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Pub	No change	No change	37	177-180	fair use
23	10	Dixon	AAS 3000 African American Family	Fall 2009		Sage	African American Single Mothers / Bette Dickerson ed. (1995)	232 page, 10 chapter -- edited volume -- $67.95 pb	$53,008	NOT required -- used by 2-3 students for class presntn	pp. 117-145 (29 page, 12.5% of book ) excerpt of chapter 7, "African American Children in Single-Mother Families" / Suzanne M. Randolph .... 2-3 students assigned; hit count of 15 on ERES system.	fair use	fair use	fair use	214-217	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	12.50% (1 chap)	Yes	$203.61	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		114-119	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	26	124-130	fair use
24	11	Dixon	AAS 3000 African American Family	Fall 2009		Sage	Black Children (Second Edition) / Harriette Pipes McAdoo, ed. (2001)	256 page, 12 chapter, edited volume. $114 retail hb, $58.95 pb.	$104,829	NOT required -- used by 2-3 students for class presntn	chapter 6 (pp. 73-96) "Racial Identity Development in African American Children" / Carolyn Bennett Murray & elani Mandara ... 24 pages, 9.38% of work .... used by 2-3 students for presentation ... hit count 13 on ERES system	fair use	fair use	fair use	217-220	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	9.38% (1 chap)	Yes	$168.50	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		119-124	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	27	130-136	fair use	"...the Court finds that the percentage of the copyrighted work (9.38%) used by Professor Dixon borders on the excessive. It is at the top end of a 'reasonable' range." (p.135
25	12	Dixon	AAS 3000 African American Family	Fall 2009		Sage	Black Families (Third Edition) / Hariette Pipes McAdoo (1996)	416 page, 21 chapter, edited volume -- $114 hb, $58.95 pb	$144,388	NOT required -- used by 2-3 students for class presntn	chapter "Out There Stranded?" / Beverly Tatum, pp. 214-233 -- 20 pages, 4.8% of total .... used by 2-3 students for presentation ...hit count 9 ... Professor owned several copies of book	fair use	fair use	fair use	221-224	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	4.80% (1 chap)	Yes	$140.42	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		124-129	fair use	GSU	Pub	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Pub	No change	GSU	28	137-143	fair use
26	13	Dixon	AAS 3000 African American Family	Fall 2009		Oxford	The Slave Community / John W. Blassingame (1979)	430 p., 8 chapter / edited volume. -- $42.95	$1,602,935		one excerpt, chapter 7, pp. 249-283 (35 pages, 8.14% of the work)	fair use	fair use	NOT fair	210-214	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	8.14%	Yes	$210.63	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		110-114	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	25	118-124	NOT fair	* Prof. Dixon owned several copies of the book herself ... and uploaded some assignments for a small number of students. .... "The percentage of the copyrighted work used by Professor Dixon (8.14%) together with the number of pages in the excerpt (35) borders on being excessive." (p.122)
27	14	Esposito	EPRS 8520: Qualitative Research Education III	Fall 2009		Sage	Theoretical Frameworks in Qualitative Research / Vincent A. Anfara & Norman T. Mertz eds. (2006)	237 p., 10 chapter, edited volume ... retail $51.95	$75,321		2 excerpts, total 16 pages, 6.75% of total ... pp. xxiii-xxxii and pp. 189-196	fair use	fair use	NOT fair	179-182	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	6.75% (1 chap equiv)	Yes	$26.88	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		83-88	fair use	GSU	Pub	Pub	GSU		Yes	Yes	Yes	Pub	Pub	GSU	17	86-91	NOT fair
28	18	Freeman, Carrie Packman	JOUR 4800 Media Ethics & Society	Fall 2009		Oxford	Living Ethics: Across Media Platforms / Michael Bugeja (2007)	365 pages		REQUIRED	two excerpts : 13 pages, 3.56% of total ... 116-121 (from chapter 3 "Truth") and 299-305 (chapter 10 "Value Systems") ...	fair use	fair use	fair use	290-293	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	3.65% (< 1 chap equiv)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		161-164	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	38	180-184	fair use
29	19	Hankla, Charles	POLS 3450 US Foreign Policy	Fall 2009	48	Sage	Contemporary Cases in U.S. Foreign Policy (2d Edition) / Ralph G. Carter, ed. (2005)	499 pages / 15 chapter edited volume ... TEXTBOOK ... $38.95	$365,751	background reading	chapter / pp. 89-121 (33 pages, 6.61% of the book) - "The Return of the Imperial Presidency" / Jeffrey Lantis & Eric Moskowitz	fair use	fair use	fair use	304-307	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	6.61% (1 chap)	Yes	$190.08	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		178-182	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	42	201-206	fair use	* he had his own personal fair use rubric or more accurately, his own rules about what he would & wouldn't assign
30	20	Hankla, Charles	POLS 3450 US Foreign Policy	Fall 2009	48	Sage / CQ Press	U.S. Foreign Policy: The Paradox of World Power / Steven W. Hook (2005)	519 page, 12 chapter ... TEXTBOOK ... $84.95	$738,329		pp. 153-188 "The Foreign-Policy Bureaucracy" (36 page chapter, 6.94% of total)	fair use	fair use	fair use	307-310	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	6.94% (1 chap)	Yes	$207.36	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		183-187	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	43	206-211	fair use
31	21	Hartwig, Melinda	AH 4900 : Materiality of Ancient Egyptian Painting	Fall 2009	13	Cambrdg UP	Ancient Egyptian Materials & Technology / Paul T. Nicholson & Ian Shaw eds. (2000)				two excerpts -- EXCERPT 1, portion of chapter 2 "Stone" / Barbara Aston, James Herrel, & Ian S. Shaw (pp. 44-54) ... EXCERPT 2 "Painting Materials" / Lorna Lee & Stephen Quirke (pp. 104-120) ... TOTAL 28 pages, 3.87% of work	fair use	fair use	fair use	225-228	No	Yes*	No	fair use	3.87% (1.5 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	Pub	GSU		130-132	fair use	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		No	Yes	No	No change	GSU	No change	29	143-147	fair use		"The chapter discusses various stones used in ancient Egypt. ... Specific stones covered by this page range include marble, obsidian, and quartz. The first excerpt is wholly objective, restating facts and details about the stones in question. It is written in a formal tone, and is devoid of any fanciful language. At no point does the excerpt move from the dry facts about the stones to a subjective discussion...." (p.145)
32	22	Harvey	SOCI 8030 Social Theory I	Fall 2009	16	Oxford	The Power Elite (New Edition) / C. Wright Mills (2000)	* first published 1956 ... 448 pages, 15 chapters ... originally for general audiences, used frequently in college sociology ... $19.95 pb	$232,467		two excerpts -- two full chapters, pp. 269-297 and 298-324, total 12.5% of work ... chapter 12 "The Power Elite" ... chapter 13 "The Mass Society"	NOT fair	fair use	NOT fair	323-329	Yes	Yes*	No	NOT fair	12.50% (2 chap)	Yes	$91.39	GSU	GSU	Pub	Pub	Chapter used was covered by an earlier copyright registration (dated 1956). Defendant's did not contest, and so the court was able to find that ownership existed. On reevaluation of the factors, the court found that factor three weighed heavily against GSU (as it was the heart of the work), and so the claim succeeded.	196-201	fair use	GSU	Pub	Pub	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Pub	No change	GSU	46	222-228	NOT fair	... chapters 12 & 13 were the "heart of the work" .... * PLAINTIFFS (?) conceded this outcome in remand brief	"The tone of these two chapters, when considered together, is critical, and at times provocative, but still intellectual." (p.226)
33	23	Kaufmann		Fall 2009		Oxford	Approaches to Qualitative Research: A Reader on Theory and Practice / Sharlene Nagy Hesse-Biber & Patricia Leavy, eds. (2004)	564 p., 25 ch., edited volume ... $92 hc, $49.95 pb	no info on record	REQUIRED	1 chapter, chapter 21, pp. 447-472, 26 pp., 4.61% -- "The Art and Politics of Interpretation" / Norman K. Denzin	fair use	fair use	fair use	145-148	No	Yes	No	fair use	4.61% (1 chap)	Yes	$55.69	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		52-55	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	9	54-58	fair use		"Weighing all of the factors (as adjusted) together, placing the burden of proof on Defendants, and giving factor two insubstantial weight and factor four additional weight as directed, Defendants' use of Approaches to Qualitative Research is protected by fair use." (p.58)
34	26	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education II	Fall 2009		Sage	Handbook of Feminist Research: Theory and Praxis / Sharlene Nagy Hesse-Biber ed. (2006)			REQUIRED	2 chapters, 38 pages, 4.95% ... EXCERPT 1: Chapter 26 (pp.515-534) "Feminist Research Ethics" / Judith Preissle ... chapter 8 (pp. 155-172) "Toward Understandings of Feminist Ethnography" / Wanda S. Pillow & Cris Mayo	fair use	fair use	fair use	148-152	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	4.95% (2 chap)	Yes	unstated	GSU	GSU	Pub	Pub	originally claimed infringement for three chapters; publishers could not prove ownership of the third chapter; the court revisited the fourth factor and found that it was overstaded because permission income was historically small and unlikely in the future	56-60	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	Yes	Yes	Neutral	GSU	GSU	10	58-62 (see also #2)	fair use
35	24	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education II	Fall 2009			Handbook of Narrative Inquiry: Mapping a Methodology			REQUIRED	1 chapter, 41 pp., 5.77% ... Chapter 2: "Mapping a Landscape" / D. Jean Clandinin & Jerry Rosiek	fair use	fair use	fair use	152-156	No	Yes	No	fair use	5.63% (1 chap)	Yes	$102.46	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		60-64	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	11	63-66	fair use		"The number of pages copied was quite large but not too large ...." (p.64)
36	25	Kaufmann		Fall 2009			Handbook of Social Theory			REQUIRED	Chapter 17 -- see analysis in #3 above	fair use	fair use	fair use	164-167	No	Yes	No	fair use	2.12% (< 1 chap)	Yes	$30.24	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		69	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU	See 29-30 above	Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	13	72-73	fair use	see #3 analysis
37	27	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education II	Fall 2009		Oxford	The Craft of Inquiry: Theories, Methods, Evidence / Alford (1998)				COURT SAYS SEE ANALYSIS FOR #1	fair use	fair use	fair use	143-145	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	6.25%	Yes	$23.56	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		52-52	fair use	GSU	Pub	GSU	GSU	See above	Yes	No	Yes	Pub	No change	GSU	8	p.50 (see #1)	fair use
38	28	Kaufmann	EPRS 8500 Qualitative / Interpretive Research in Education II	Fall 2009		Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (Third Edition) / Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln, eds. (2005)			REQUIRED	7 chapters, 153 pp., 12.45% ... pp.1-32, 109-138, 357-375, 443-465, 547-557, 915-932, 959-978 ... SEE NUMBER FOUR for intro, ch. 14, ch. 17 ... EXCERPT 4: chapter 5 "Freeing Ourselves from Neocolonial Domination in Research" / Russell Bishop ... EXCERPT 5, ch. 22, pp. 547-557, "Testimonio, Subalternity, and Narrative Authority" / John Beverly ... EXCERPT 6, ch. 36, pp. 915-931, "Relativism, Criteria, & Politics" / John K. Smith & Phil Hodkinson ... EXCERPT 7, ch. 38, pp. 959-978, "Writing: A Method of Inquiry" / Laurel Richardson & Elizabeth Adams St. Pierre	NOT fair	NOT fair	NOT fair	156-161	Yes	Uncontested	No	NOT fair	12.29% (7 chap)	Yes	$467.31	GSU	GSU	Pub	Pub	Concluded in favor of publishers where use under third factor "dramatically exceeds" permissible limits and where substantial historical licensing enhances harm under fourth factor	64-69	NOT fair	GSU	Pub	Pub	Pub		Yes	No	No	Pub	No change	No change	12	66-72	NOT fair	* listed twice in 2020 (p.235) ... see #4 ... "Professor Kaufmann captured a very large amount of the book's value by copying and distributing seven complete chapters. ... Professor Kaufmann used much too much of the work--both with respect to its quantity and quality...." (p.70-71)
39	30	Kim, YouJin	AL 8550 Second Language Evaluation & Assessment	Fall 2009		Cambrdg UP	Asessing Speaking / Sari Luoma (2004)	228 pages, 8 chapters		REQUIRED	two excerpts -- two full chapters ... EXCERPT 1 Chapter 4 "Speaking Scales" (pp. 59-95, 37 pages) ... Chapter 7 "Developing Speaking Tasks" (pp. 139-169, 31 pages) ... total 68 pages, 29.82%	fair use	fair use	fair use	249-253	No	Yes*	No	fair use	29.82%	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	Pub	GSU		136-140	fair use	GSU	Neutral	Pub	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	31	151-154	fair use	"The unpaid use of full chapters comprising 29.2% of the work leans very strongly against fair use. ... the portion uploaded is much too large to support a finding of fair use." ... BUT "While the excerpt was large, it was not so large as to substitute for the book and did not affect the potential market for the book. Because digital permissions were unavailable ..." FAIR USE
40	31	Kim, YouJin	AL 8550 Second Language Evaluation & Assessment	Fall 2009		Oxford	Fundamental Considerations in Language Testing / Lyle Bachman (1990)	420 p.		OPTIONAL	one excerpt -- chapter 4 "Communicative Language Ability" (pp. 81-110, 30 pages -- 7.14% of total)	fair use	fair use	fair use	237-241	No	Yes*	No	fair use	7.14%	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		132-136	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	30	147-151	fair use		"The author occasionally uses illustrative examples that are light and even humorous...." (p.149)
41	32	Kim, YouJin	AL 8550 Second Language Evaluation & Assessment	Fall 2009		Cambridge	Learning Vocabulary in Another Language / I.S.P. Nation (2001)	491 pages, 11 chapters	151,583 pounds	required / partly	one excerpt: chapter 10 "Testing Vocabulary Knowledge and Use", pp. 344-379 (36 pages, 7.33% of total)	fair use	fair use	fair use	250-258	No	Yes*	No	fair use	8.4-2.2% (1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		140-143	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	32	154-157	fair use
42	33	Kruger, Anne Cale	EPY 7090: Psychology of Learning & the Learner	Summer & Fall 2009 (one course, 2 semesters)		Oxford	Awakening Children's Minds: How Parents and Teachers Can Make a Difference / Laura E. Berk	320 pg, 7 chapter book ... retail $28	$130,482	REQUIRED	one excerpt: one chapter, 39 pages, 12.19% ...	fair use	fair use	fair use	182-186	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	12.19%	No?	$67.63	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU	Even though Judge Evans cites CCC potential revenue figures,she concludes that the fourth factor does not favor Pubs because there is no ready market for digital licenses.	88-91	fair use	GSU	Neutral	Pub	GSU		Yes	Yes	No	Neutral	Pub	No change	18	92-95	fair use		"The book is highly readable and probably sells well to general audiences such as parents of young children and not just to the academic community."	"
43	34	Kruger, Anne Cale	EPY 8220, "Advanced Developmental Psychology: Personality and Socialization"	Fall 2009		Cambridge	Understanding Trauma: Integrating Biological, Clinical and Cultural Perspectives / Laurence J. Kirmayer, Robert Lemelson, & Mark Barad, eds. (2007)	547 p., 21 ch, edited volume ... retail $110 hb, $35.99 pb	33,629 pounds		one excerpt, one chapter, 18 pages, 3.29% ... chapter 11: "The Developmental Impact of Childhood Trauma" / Bessel A. van der Kolk, pp. 224-241	fair use	fair use	fair use	186-190	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	3.29% (1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		91-95	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	19	95-99	fair use		"The author frequently cites the work of others, but he also cites a great deal of his own research." (p.98)
44	35	Lasner	PERS 2001 Comparative Culture	Fall 2009	114	Oxford	Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanization of the United States / Kenneth T. Jackson (1985)	405 pages, 16 chapters ... $19.95	$740,414		one excerpt: one chapter, "The Drive-In Contemporary America", pp. 246-271 (26 pages, 6.42% total)	fair use	fair use	fair use	298-300	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	6.42% (1 chap)	Yes	$302.33	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		169-174	fair use	GSU	Pub	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Pub	No change	GSU	40	191-197	fair use
45	36	Lasner	PERS 2001 Comparative Culture	Fall 2009	114	Oxford	The Politics of Public Housing / Rhonda Y. Williams (2004)		$45,114		chapter 1, pp. 21-53 (33 pages, 10.78%) "Creating 'A Little Heaven for Poor People': Decent Housing & Respectable Communities"	fair use	fair use	fair use	300-303	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	10.78%	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	Pub	GSU		174-178	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	Yes	No	Neutral	GSU	No change	41	197-201	fair use
46	37	McCombie, Susan	ANTH 4440/6440 "Epidemiology and Anthropology"	Fall 2009		Oxford	Evolution of Infectious Disease / Paul W. Ewald (1994)	305 pages, 11 chapters	222,038.50 pounds	"assigned"	one excerpt, chapter 2: "Symptomatic Treatment (Or How to Bind The Origin of Species to The Physician's Desk REference)" ... pp. 15-34 (20 pages) ... 6.56% of total work	fair use	fair use	fair use	267-269	No	Yes	No	fair use	6.56% (1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		146-149	fair use	GSU	Pub	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Pub	No change	No change	34	161-164	fair use		"The author specifically purports to break with the traditional view that parasites theoretically should evolve towards benign coexistence with their hosts. This view, according to the author, contradicts both the evidence and natural selection." (p.162)
47	38	McCombie, Susan	ANTH 4440/6440 "Epidemiology and Anthropology"	Fall 2009		Cambridge	International Health Organisations and Movements 1918-1939 / Paul Weindling ed. (1995)	355 pages, 15 chapters		"assigned"	one excerpt, chapter 11 (pages 222-243, 22 pages total, 6.2% of total): "The Cycles of Eradication: The Rockefeller Foundation & Latin American Public Health 1918-1940" / Marcos Cueto	fair use	fair use	fair use	263-267	No	Yes*	No	fair use	5.91% (1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		143-146	fair use	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change	33	158-161	fair use	"'The cycles of eradication' certainly embodies the work's underlying theme; however, it provides only one of the many perspectives included in the work. Therefore, it is not the heart of the work." (p.160)
48	39	McCoy, Jennifer	POS 8250 Latin American Politics	Fall 2009		Oxford	Regimes & Democracy in Latin America / Gerardo L. Munck ed. (2007)	299 pages	$12,689	REQUIRED	"Introduction: Research Agendas & Strategies in the Study of Latin American Politics" and chapter 1 "The Study of Politics and Democracy" / Gerardo L. Munck ... pp. 1-38 total (38 pages, 12.71%)	fair use	fair use	fair use	311-314	No	Yes/No * see NOTES to the right	No	fair use	12.71%	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	Pub	GSU	Plaintiffs could only produce evidence for contracts with authors of one chapter,so plaintiffs for half the alleged infringement. Total percentage used was 16.72%	187-191	fair use	GSU	Neutral	Pub	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	44	211-216	fair use
49	40	Moloney, Margaret	NURS 8035 Theoretical & Philosophical Foundations of Nursing	Fall 2009	14	Sage	Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social & Behavioral Research / Abbas Tashakkori & Charles Teddlie eds. (2002)	784 pages, 26 chapters, edited volumes ... $151	$391,077		chapter 20 "Status of Mixed Methods Research in Nursing" / Sheila Twinn ... full chapter, pp. 541-556, 2.04% of book	fair use	fair use	fair use	294-297	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	2.04% (1 chap)	Yes	$26.66	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		164-169	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	39	184-191	fair use		"Chapter 20 is neither humorous nor fanciful." (p.187-188
50	41	Ohmer, Mary	SW 8200 Evaluation & Technology	Fall 2009	42	Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (Second Edition) / Norman K. Denzin & Yvonna S. Lincoln eds. (2000)	1142 pages, 36 chapter, edited volume. $156 or $175 retail ... out of print? maybe			one chapter, 18 pages, pp. 803-820 -- 1.58% of total work: "Software and Qualitative Research" / Eben A. Weitzman	fair use	fair use	NOT fair	329-333	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	1.58% (1 chap)	Yes	$89.96	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		201-205	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	Pub		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	47	228-233	NOT fair		"Most notably, the author explains that while software can provide tools to assist researchers in analyzing data it cannot actually conduct the analyses." (p.231)
51	42	Ohmer, Mary	SW 8200 Evaluation & Technology	Fall 2009	42	Sage	Utilization-Focused Evaluation (Third Edition) / Michael Quinn Patton (1996)	447 pages, 15 chapters. $115 hc, $77.95 pb. Out of print in 1999.	$812,595	REQUIRED	two full chapters, 37 total pages, 8.28% of total work; pages 2-38. Chapter 1 "Evaluative Use: Both Challenge and Mandate" ... chapter 2 "What Is Utilization-Focused Evaluation? How Do You Get Started?"	NOT fair	NOT fair	NOT fair	333-337	Yes	Uncontested	No	NOT fair	8.28% (2 chap)	Yes	$189.92	GSU	GSU	Pub	Pub	Upon revisiting the factors, the court concluded that an adjustment in Pub favor was needed because licensing revenue formed a very important part of the value of this work	205-211	NOT fair	GSU	Neutral	Pub	Pub		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	48	234-238	NOT fair
52	43	Orr	Baroque Music	Fall 2009		Oxford	The Organ as a Mirror of Its Time / Kerala J. Snyder, ed. (2002)	25 chapter, 392 p., edited volume -- $65	$55,831	REQUIRED	one excerpt, "The Organ in Seventeenth Century Cosmology" / Hans Davidson -- 14 pages, 3.57% of book	fair use	fair use	fair use	206-209	No	Uncontested	No	fair use	3.57% (1 chap)	No	N/A	GSU	GSU	GSU	GSU		106-109	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	No	Neutral	No change	No change	24	114-118	fair use
53	48	Whitten, Kathleen	PSYC 4030 Introduction to Cross-Cultural Psychology	Fall 2009	13	Cambridge	A World of Babies / Judy DeLoache & Alma Gottlieb (2000)	293 pages, 8 chapters ... general readership ... $55.99 hb, $30.99 pb	99,831 pounds		page 27 (from chapter 1 -- explains how the book is organized), and pages 91-112 (excerpt of chapter 4, "Gift from the Gods: A Balinese Guide to Early Child Rearing" / Marissa Diener) ... total 7.85%	fair use	fair use	fair use	318-323	No	Yes*	No	fair use	7.85%	Yes	$36.47	GSU	GSU	GSU	Pub		191-195	fair use	GSU	Neutral	GSU	GSU		Yes	No	Yes	Neutral	No change	GSU	45	216-222	fair use	"The Court notes that the percentage of the work which was used (7.85%) is at the upper range of what is a reasonable amount." (p.221)
54
55
56		NOTES
57		Ownership Notes:		* no registration within 5 years
58				~not all material in work was original; could not prove what was original and what was copied
59		Fair Use Amt Used:		If a chapter amount is indicated (e.g., "1 chap") the book contains 10 or more total chapters.
60				If no chapter amount is indicated, the book contained less than 10 chapters.
61
62											NOT FAIR	5	4	10
63											FAIR USE	43	44	38
64											% infringing	10.4%	8.3%	20.8%
65											% fair use	89.6%	91.7%	79.2%
66
67
68
69	ct	COPYRIGHT - OWNERSHIP, REGISTRATION, ORIGINALITY (16 claims)																				2012 : 16 titles
70	1	Orr		Fall 2009			North German Church Music					no (c)			209-210	No	Unregistered	No	N/A	7.26%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	Pub contended that work was foreign and needed no registration; court said no evidence indicated that, and the front cover of the book says "published in the united states by Oxford… New York"	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
71	2	Gable-Hover		Fall 2009			A History of Feminist Literary Criticism					no (c)			270-271	No	No	No	N/A	3.85% (1 chap)	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	Foreign work, not registered; failed to prove author agreements	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
72	3	Baker		Fall 2009			Film Language					no (c)			276-279	No	No	No	N/A	14.54% (1 chap)	Yes	$92.01	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	Translation. Registration Cert. in Oxford's name, but could not produce evidence of transfer aggreement b/w translator and Oxford	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
73	4	Duffield		Fall 2009			Behavior, Society, & Nuclear War, Volume 1					no (c)			315-317	No	No	No	N/A	9.20%	Yes	$54.26	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	No contributing author agreements proven	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
74	5	Kaufmann		May 2009		Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (Second Edition)					no (c)			124-127	No	No	N/A	N/A	3.06% (1 chap)	Yes	$53.14	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
75	6	Kaufmann		Summer 2009			Inside Interviewing: New Lenses, New Concerns					no (c)			140-142	No	No	N/A	N/A	2.30% (1 chap)	Yes	$15.12	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
76	7	Kaufmann		Fall 2009		Sage	The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (Second Edition)					no (c)			161-163	No	No	N/A	N/A	3.06% (1 chap)	Yes	$87.41	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
77	8	Esposito		Summer 2009			Handbook of Ethnography					no (c)			167-170	No	No	N/A	N/A	3.05% (1 chap)	Yes	$41.89	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
78	9	Kim		Fall 2009			Language Testing in Practice					no (c)			242-244	No	No*~	No	N/A	14.10% (3 chap)	Yes	$88.13	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
79	10	Kim		Fall 2009			Assessing Listening					no (c)			244-247	No	No*~	No	N/A	13.24%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
80	11	Kim		Fall 2009			Asessing Vocabulary					no (c)			258-260	No	No*~	No	N/A	12.63%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
81	12	Kim		Fall 2009			Assessing Writing					no (c)			260-262	No	No*~	No	N/A	22.34%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
82	13	Murphy		May 2009			More Grammar Games: Cognitive, Affective and Movement Activities for ESL Students					no (c)			096-99	No	No*~	N/A	N/A	13.54%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
83	14	Kim		Fall 2009			Criterion Referenced Language Testing					no (c)			230-232	No	No*~	N/A	N/A	13.98%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
84	15	Kim		Fall 2009			Assessing Languages for Specific Purporses					no (c)			247-249	No	No~	No	N/A	4.85%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
85	16	Kim		Fall 2009			Assessing Reading					no (c)			235-237	No	No~	N/A	N/A	16.46%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
86
87
88	ct	DE MINIMIS (10 claims)																				2012 : 10 titles
89	1	Murphy		May 2009			Pronunciation Games					de minimis			091-94	No	Yes	de minimis	N/A	16.98%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
90	2	Murphy		May 2009			Keep Talking: Communicative Fluency Activities for Language Teaching					de minimis			094-96	No	Yes	de minimis	N/A	26.11%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
91	3	Murphy		May 2009			Grammar Practice Activities					de minimis			099-101	No	Yes	de minimis	N/A	6.08-12.5%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
92	4	Murphy		May 2009			Newspapers					de minimis			104-106	No	Yes	de minimis	N/A	18.75%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
93	5	Murphy		May 2009			Role Play: Resource Books for Teachers					de minimis			106-108	No	Yes	de minimis	N/A	15.70%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
94	6	Kaufmann		May 2009			Qualitative Research Practice					de minimis			131-133	No	Yes	de minimis	N/A	2.34% (1 chap)	Yes	unstated			N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		Yes	No	No	N/A	No change	No change
95	7	Murphy		May 2009			Five-Minute Activities					de minimis			101-104	No	Yes*	de minimis	N/A	19.65%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
96	8	Orr		Summer 2009		Cambrdg UP	The Cambridge Companion to Beethoven					de minimis			200-203	No	Yes*	de minimis	N/A	5.17% (1 chap)	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
97	9	Kim		Fall 2009			Assessing Grammar					de minimis			232-235	No	Yes*	de minimis	N/A	25.24%	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	Unclear whehter the work was assigned; other de minimis uses were not assigned; hit count was 1	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
98	10	Gainty		Fall 2009		Cambrdg UP	The Cambridge History of China, Volume 8, Part 2					de minimis			280-283	No	Yes*	de minimis	N/A	2.63% (1 chap)	No	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A	N/A		No	No	No	No change	No change	No change
99
100