ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRS
1
2022 GiveWell cost-effectiveness analysis — version 4Change 1: Incorporated subnational data into our Malaria Consortium CEA for FCT and Oyo, NigeriaChange 2: Updated the leverage and funging adjustment in the AMF CEA for Global Fund-supported states in NigeriaChange 3: Updated the insecticide resistance adjustments for Chad, DRC, and Guinea in the AMF CEAChange 4: Updated the internal validity adjustment and added Nigerian states to the HKI CEAChange 5: Added South Sudan to the AMF CEA2022 GiveWell cost-effectiveness analysis — version 5
2
Cost-effectiveness, including leverage and funging adjustments, including additional adjustmentsCost-effectiveness, including leverage and funging adjustments, including additional adjustmentsDifference in cost-effectiveness estimates between previous two versionsCost-effectiveness, including leverage and funging adjustments, including additional adjustmentsDifference in cost-effectiveness estimates between previous two versionsCost-effectiveness, including leverage and funging adjustments, including additional adjustmentsDifference in cost-effectiveness estimates between previous two versionsCost-effectiveness, including leverage and funging adjustments, including additional adjustmentsDifference in cost-effectiveness estimates between previous two versionsCost-effectiveness, including leverage and funging adjustments, including additional adjustmentsDifference in cost-effectiveness estimates between previous two versionsCost-effectiveness, including leverage and funging adjustments, including additional adjustments
3
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Kq6iHSQFr3eRz1p9KclHuJTQiaJYkpViOyneSd9KCJc/edit?usp=sharing
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ECjEc4XKkviVWNzq7pMS_oZKVq6B6CdTmZBP3Vu5Z0A/edit?usp=sharinghttps://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1F06S8TsKUjm9dv30uRN07gAGT0_zVs7TintgI1JHrZo/edit?usp=sharinghttps://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sdcbIzhPYyJ3yw89LycxS8HmUxIUheOB-WwAadR8HT4/edit?usp=sharinghttps://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1sg3dxTcB1kDqbfvq_fUyGWG7n0eN2G8rM54YGbb2MG8/edit?usp=sharinghttps://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1OdfKIIVwy8S9ZbJym04MJLOLKgihFLvuBEKd9xoqkXQ/edit?usp=sharinghttps://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1tytvmV_32H8XGGRJlUzRDTKTHrdevPIYmb_uc6aLeas/edit?usp=sharing
4
Against Malaria Foundation
5
DRC10.510.50.010.50.09.9-0.69.90.09.90.09.9
6
Guinea15.315.30.015.30.017.32.117.30.017.30.017.3
7
Togo7.87.80.07.80.07.6-0.27.60.07.60.07.6
8
Uganda15.415.40.015.40.015.3-0.115.30.015.30.015.3
9
Nigeria (PMI states)11.811.80.011.80.011.7-0.111.70.011.70.011.7
10
Nigeria (Global Fund states)14.214.20.012.5-1.712.4-0.112.40.012.40.012.4
11
Chad7.17.10.07.10.04.8-2.34.80.04.80.04.8
12
South Sudan---------10.2-10.2
13
Deworm the World
ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1
14
Kenya38.238.20.038.20.038.30.038.30.038.30.038.3
15
Pakistan5.35.30.05.30.05.30.05.30.05.30.05.3
16
Lagos, Nigeria8.78.70.08.70.08.70.08.70.08.70.08.7
17
Oyo, Nigeria16.316.30.016.30.016.30.016.30.016.30.016.3
18
Ogun, Nigeria16.516.50.016.50.016.50.016.50.016.50.016.5
19
Rivers, Nigeria13.213.20.013.20.013.20.013.20.013.20.013.2
20
Cross River, Nigeria12.912.90.012.90.012.90.012.90.012.90.012.9
21
The END Fund
ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1
22
Ethiopia2.52.50.02.50.02.50.02.50.02.50.02.5
23
Angola26.226.20.026.20.026.20.026.20.026.20.026.2
24
DRC10.010.00.010.00.010.00.010.00.010.00.010.0
25
Rwanda7.37.30.07.30.07.30.07.30.07.30.07.3
26
Zimbabwe13.413.40.013.40.013.50.013.50.013.50.013.5
27
SCI Foundation
ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1ChangD 1
28
Overall13.413.40.013.40.013.50.113.50.013.50.013.5
29
Ethiopia6.16.10.06.10.06.20.16.20.06.20.06.2
30
DRC33.333.30.033.30.033.40.133.40.033.40.033.4
31
Madagascar35.635.60.035.60.035.70.135.70.035.70.035.7
32
Tanzania10.010.00.010.00.010.10.110.10.010.10.010.1
33
Cote d'Ivoire15.415.40.015.40.015.40.115.40.015.40.015.4
34
Liberia20.020.00.020.00.020.00.120.00.020.00.020.0
35
Malawi11.011.00.011.00.011.00.111.00.011.00.011.0
36
Mauritania35.635.60.035.60.035.70.135.70.035.70.035.7
37
Uganda-0.6-0.60.0-0.60.0-0.50.1-0.50.0-0.50.0-0.5
38
Burundi21.321.30.021.30.021.40.121.40.021.40.021.4
39
Zanzibar-Pemba0.20.20.00.20.00.20.10.20.00.20.00.2
40
Zanzibar-Unguja-1.0-1.00.0-1.00.0-1.00.1-1.00.0-1.00.0-1.0
41
Sudan8.58.50.08.50.08.50.18.50.08.50.08.5
42
Niger1.71.70.01.70.01.70.11.70.01.70.01.7
43
Sightsavers
44
DRC1.51.50.01.50.01.50.01.50.01.50.01.5
45
Benue State15.415.40.015.40.015.50.015.50.015.50.015.5
46
Kebbi State51.251.20.051.20.051.30.151.30.051.30.051.3
47
Kogi State9.59.50.09.50.09.60.19.60.09.60.09.6
48
Kwara State42.342.30.042.30.042.40.142.40.042.40.042.4
49
Sokoto State42.542.50.042.50.042.60.142.60.042.60.042.6
50
Taraba State6.16.10.06.10.06.20.06.20.06.20.06.2
51
Chad16.216.20.016.20.016.20.016.20.016.20.016.2
52
Senegal3.83.80.03.80.03.80.03.80.03.80.03.8
53
West, Cameroon12.512.50.012.50.012.50.012.50.012.50.012.5
54
Far-North, Cameroon19.619.60.019.60.019.70.019.70.019.70.019.7
55
North, Cameroon25.325.30.025.30.025.40.025.40.025.40.025.4
56
Adamoua, Cameroon12.012.00.012.00.012.10.012.10.012.10.012.1
57
East, Cameroon10.010.00.010.00.010.00.010.00.010.00.010.0
58
Littoral, Cameroon1.61.60.01.60.01.60.01.60.01.60.01.6
59
South, Cameroon13.313.30.013.30.013.40.013.40.013.40.013.4
60
Kaduna State45.045.00.045.00.045.10.145.10.045.10.045.1
61
Kano State18.418.40.018.40.018.50.118.50.018.50.018.5
62
Katsina State10.210.20.010.20.010.30.110.30.010.30.010.3
63
Niger State62.962.90.062.90.062.90.162.90.062.90.062.9
64
Adamawa State32.932.90.032.90.033.00.133.00.033.00.033.0
65
Zamfara State57.457.40.057.40.057.50.157.50.057.50.057.5
66
Guinea-Bissau0.10.10.00.10.00.10.00.10.00.10.00.1
67
Malaria Consortium
68
Burkina Faso13.413.40.013.40.013.2-0.213.20.013.20.013.2
69
Chad5.95.90.05.90.05.7-0.25.70.05.70.05.7
70
Nigeria11.711.70.011.70.011.6-0.111.60.011.60.011.6
71
Togo8.08.00.08.00.07.8-0.27.80.07.80.07.8
72
FCT, Nigeria6.97.20.37.20.07.1-0.17.10.07.10.07.1
73
Oyo, Nigeria14.010.9-3.110.90.010.8-0.110.80.010.80.010.8
74
Mozambique8.48.40.08.40.08.4-0.18.40.08.40.08.4
75
Helen Keller International
76
Burkina Faso19.419.40.019.40.019.40.016.6-2.816.60.016.6
77
Cameroon24.824.80.024.80.024.80.016.7-8.116.70.016.7
78
Côte d'Ivoire10.110.10.010.10.010.10.09.4-0.79.40.09.4
79
DRC15.515.50.015.50.015.50.012.2-3.312.20.012.2
80
Guinea11.411.40.011.40.011.40.010.5-1.010.50.010.5
81
Kenya7.47.40.07.40.07.40.05.5-1.95.50.05.5
82
Mali30.530.50.030.50.030.50.028.4-2.028.40.028.4
83
Niger56.356.30.056.30.056.30.037.9-18.437.90.037.9
84
Nigeria24.824.80.024.80.024.80.0-----
85
Adamawa-------18.8-18.80.018.8
86
Akwa Ibom-------4.6-4.60.04.6
87
Benue-------8.9-8.90.08.9
88
Ekiti-------5.8-5.80.05.8
89
Nasarawa-------11.1-11.10.011.1
90
Taraba-------25.0-25.00.025.0
91
Anambra-------2.7-2.70.02.7
92
Delta-------5.1-5.10.05.1
93
Ebonyi-------12.5-12.50.012.5
94
Edo-------4.0-4.00.04.0
95
Imo-------3.6-3.60.03.6
96
Kogi-------4.5-4.50.04.5
97
Ogun-------5.0-5.00.05.0
98
Osun-------2.8-2.80.02.8
99
Rivers-------7.4-7.40.07.4
100
New Incentives