ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAAB
1
Results
2
Data we currently use to estimate New Incentive's cost effectiveness
3
SourceOriginal linkArchive link
4
Number of enrollments
5
Number of BCG vaccine disbursements, per year
85,457Calculation
6
10
Repeat enrollments - BCG scars on returning infants
11
Infant has only 1 BCG scar, % of infants surveyed from June 1 to October 8, 202097.37%Calculation
12
Infant has no BCG scar, % of infants surveyed from June 1 to October 8, 20202.60%
New Incentives, Inquiries dashboard, BCG Scar verification
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/IpGWBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Inquiries_dashboard_BCG_Scar_verification.pdf
13
Infant has two or more BCG scars, % of infants surveyed from June 1 to October 8, 20200.04%
New Incentives, Inquiries dashboard, BCG Scar verification
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/IpGWBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Inquiries_dashboard_BCG_Scar_verification.pdf
14
15
Data we plan to use as a benchmark to estimate New Incentive's cost effectiveness in the future
16
17
Enrollments per immunization day and retention
18
Retention rate, 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020
19
PENTA192.97%
New Incentives, Progress Dashboard, Second Visit & Immunisation Rate
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1fFDdzOXYGtTCqpwgm5y7E5g1xAQgXgYU/page/IQWshttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Progress_Dashboard_Second_Visit_and_Immunisation_Rate.pdf
20
PENTA289.61%
New Incentives, Progress Dashboard, Second Visit & Immunisation Rate
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1fFDdzOXYGtTCqpwgm5y7E5g1xAQgXgYU/page/IQWshttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Progress_Dashboard_Second_Visit_and_Immunisation_Rate.pdf
21
PENTA388.59%
New Incentives, Progress Dashboard, Second Visit & Immunisation Rate
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1fFDdzOXYGtTCqpwgm5y7E5g1xAQgXgYU/page/IQWshttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Progress_Dashboard_Second_Visit_and_Immunisation_Rate.pdf
22
MEASLES91.31%
New Incentives, Progress Dashboard, Second Visit & Immunisation Rate
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1fFDdzOXYGtTCqpwgm5y7E5g1xAQgXgYU/page/IQWshttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Progress_Dashboard_Second_Visit_and_Immunisation_Rate.pdf
23
24
Supply-side issues
25
Stockouts per 100 disbursement days
5Calculation
26
Runouts per 100 disbursement days
1Calculation
27
Infants not served per 100 disbursement days
20Calculation
28
29
Fraud at the expense of beneficiaries
30
% of vaccine disbursements for which FOs have taken a picture of the infant, and the caregiver holding cash transfer 100%Calculation
31
% of vaccine disbursements for which caregivers reported "dashing" someone0.11%
New Incentives, Disbursement Volume & Program Reach, Beneficiary Transport Cost
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1A2r_YZ3CB8RFEb7DV87LnwOoscl-K9eA/page/0lYJBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Disbursement_Volume_and_Program_Reach_Beneficiary_Transport_Cost.csv
32
% of audits in which suspected clinic staff or FOs fraud was reported
5%Calculation
33
34
Calculations/further details
35
36
Yearly BCG disbursements
37
BCG disbursements, 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020
199,399
New Incentives, Vaccinations Dashboard, Comparison Between Periods, RCT period
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1jnl9i3cuix9rOj7tvtAPJvFUvUaiFDl6/page/RORrhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Vaccinations_Dashboard_Comparison_Between_Periods_RCT_period.pdf
38
Yearly BCG disbursements, based on 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020 data
85,457Calculation
39
40
Suspected fraud (by beneficiaries, clinic staff or FOs) reported in audits
41
Disbursement days as of 3rd June 2020
26,896
New Incentives, Progress Dashboard, Clinic Supply Outages and disbursement days, misc periods
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1fFDdzOXYGtTCqpwgm5y7E5g1xAQgXgYU/page/rbWshttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Progress_Dashboard_Clinic_Supply_Outages_and_disbursement_days_misc_periods.pdf
42
Audit data reports as of 3rd June 2020
1374
New Incentives, Master Activities Dashboard
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1WP47g0vvssE1NGFJ6bATCmJta5hHd9gV/page/2fFJBUnpublished
43
Audit data reports reporting suspected beneficiary fraud as of 3rd June 2020
178
New Incentives, Inquiries Dashboard
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/hjPJBUnpublished
44
Audit data reports reporting suspected clinic staff fraud as of 3rd June 2020
53
New Incentives, Inquiries Dashboard
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/hjPJBUnpublished
45
Audit data reports reporting suspected NI-ABAE staff fraud as of 3rd June 2020
13
New Incentives, Inquiries Dashboard
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/hjPJBUnpublished
46
Percentage of disbursement days for which an audit was conducted5.11%Calculation
47
48
BCG scars on returning infants
49
Infant has only 1 BCG scar, and the scar is on the left arm, % of infants surveyed from 1st June to 8th October 202096.96%
New Incentives, Inquiries dashboard, BCG Scar verification
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/IpGWBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Inquiries_dashboard_BCG_Scar_verification.pdf
50
Infant has only 1 BCG scar, and the scar is on the right arm, % of infants surveyed from 1st June to 8th October 20200.41%
New Incentives, Inquiries dashboard, BCG Scar verification
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/IpGWBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Inquiries_dashboard_BCG_Scar_verification.pdf
51
Infant has no BCG scar, % of infants surveyed from 1st June to 8th October 20202.60%
New Incentives, Inquiries dashboard, BCG Scar verification
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/IpGWBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Inquiries_dashboard_BCG_Scar_verification.pdf
52
Infant has two or more BCG scars, % of infants surveyed from 1st June to 8th October 20200.04%
New Incentives, Inquiries dashboard, BCG Scar verification
https://datastudio.google.com/u/0/reporting/1KIqrIqiBWDJQ3BiK1RMzmSPDe4BVMagl/page/IpGWBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Inquiries_dashboard_BCG_Scar_verification.pdf
53
54
55
Enrollments per immunization day and retention
56
Disbursement days, 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020
24,024
New Incentives, Progress Dashboard, Clinic Supply Outages and disbursement days, RCT period
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1fFDdzOXYGtTCqpwgm5y7E5g1xAQgXgYU/page/rbWshttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Progress_Dashboard_Clinic_Supply_Outages_and_disbursement_days_RCT_period.pdf
57
BCG disbursements per disbursement day, based on 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020 data8Calculation
58
59
Supply-side issues
60
Total stockouts, 1 Dec 2017- 29 Feb 2020
1,170Calculation
61
Total runouts, 1 Dec 2017- 29 Feb 2020
221Calculation
62
Total infants not served, 1 Dec 2017- 29 Feb 2020
4,712Calculation
63
Disbursement days, 1 Dec 2017- 29 Feb 2020
23,930
New Incentives, Progress Dashboard, Clinic Supply Outages and disbursement days, misc periods
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1fFDdzOXYGtTCqpwgm5y7E5g1xAQgXgYU/page/rbWshttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Progress_Dashboard_Clinic_Supply_Outages_and_disbursement_days_misc_periods.pdf
64
Stockouts per 100 disbursement days
5Calculation
65
Runouts per 100 disbursement days
1Calculation
66
Infants not served per 100 disbursement days
20Calculation
67
68
Disbursement with a picture of caregiver holding cash
69
Disbursements, 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020759,821
New Incentives, Vaccinations Dashboard, Comparison Between Periods, RCT period
 https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1jnl9i3cuix9rOj7tvtAPJvFUvUaiFDl6/page/RORrhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Vaccinations_Dashboard_Comparison_Between_Periods_RCT_period.pdf
70
Photo of infants and caregiver holding cash transfer missing, 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020413
New Incentives, Cash Management Errors, Error Breakdowns
 https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1LseK3AsgVYg5JAkG_o7_Fi7JThwifJB5/page/QacIBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Cash_Management_Errors_Error_Breakdowns.pdf
71
% of disbursements for which photo of infants and caregiver holding cash transfer was submitted, 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020100%Calculation
72
73
Vaccine disbursements for which caregivers reported "dashing" FO and clinic staff
74
Responses collected on "dashes", 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020
759,821
New Incentives, Disbursement Volume & Program Reach, Beneficiary Transport Costs and tips
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1A2r_YZ3CB8RFEb7DV87LnwOoscl-K9eA/page/0lYJBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Disbursement_Volume_and_Program_Reach_Beneficiary_Transport_Costs_and_tips.pdf
75
% of disbursements for which information on dashes was submitted, 1 Nov 2017 to 29 Feb 2020100%Calculation
76
77
Data on "dashes"
78
% of caregivers reporting "dashing" someone, between 1 Nov 2017 - 29 Feb 2020
0.1%
New Incentives, Disbursement Volume & Program Reach, Beneficiary Transport Costs and tips
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1A2r_YZ3CB8RFEb7DV87LnwOoscl-K9eA/page/0lYJBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Disbursement_Volume_and_Program_Reach_Beneficiary_Transport_Costs_and_tips.pdf
79
% of caregivers reporting "dashing" clinic staff, among those reporting "dashing", between 1 Nov 2017 - 29 feb 20206.60%
New Incentives, Disbursement Volume & Program Reach, Beneficiary Transport Costs and tips
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1A2r_YZ3CB8RFEb7DV87LnwOoscl-K9eA/page/0lYJBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Disbursement_Volume_and_Program_Reach_Beneficiary_Transport_Costs_and_tips.pdf
80
% of caregivers reporting "dashing" ABAE staff, among those reporting "dashing", between 1 Nov 2017 - 29 feb 20200.60%
New Incentives, Disbursement Volume & Program Reach, Beneficiary Transport Costs and tips
https://datastudio.google.com/reporting/1A2r_YZ3CB8RFEb7DV87LnwOoscl-K9eA/page/0lYJBhttp://files.givewell.org/files/DWDA%202009/NewIncentives/New_Incentives_Disbursement_Volume_and_Program_Reach_Beneficiary_Transport_Costs_and_tips.pdf
81
82
Suspected fraud by clinic staff or FOs reported in audits
83
Percentage of audits reporting suspected fraud by clinic staff or NI staff
4.80%Calculation
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103