The Funnel of Gov -- On the Depth of Major Rule Regulatory Cost Review, 2001-Present


1	Tip of the Costberg project on the cost of federal regulation: Wayne Crews -- www.tenthousandcommandments.com
2	The Funnel of Gov
3	Rules With and Without Cost-Benefit Analysis, 2001-Present
4			Major Executive Agency Rules Reviewed by OMB						Total OMB	*Federal	Costed Rules	Costed Rules as
5			Both costs	Rules w/	Grand Total,	Costs	Total	“Budget”	Major Rule	Register	as % of Major	as % of Finalized*
6			& benefits	Costs Only	rules w/ costs	Absent	Rules	Rules	Reviews	Final Rules	Rule Flow	Rule Flow
7	FY 2001 (OMB 2002, Table 7, p. 38)		14	13	27	7	34	53	87	4,136	31.03%	0.65%
8	FY 2002 (OMB 2003, Table 1, p. 6)		3	0	3	3	6	25	31	4,173	9.68%	0.07%
9	FY 2003 (OMB 2004, Table 1, p. 7)		6	4	10	4	14	25	39	4,285	25.64%	0.23%
10	FY 2004 (OMB 2005, Table 1-3, p. 12)		11	7	18	8	26	19	45	4,176	40.00%	0.43%
11	FY 2005 (OMB 2006, Table 1-3, p. 7)		13	2	15	6	21	24	45	3,978	33.33%	0.38%
12	FY 2006 (OMB 2007, Table 1-3, p. 8)		7	1	8	2	10	18	28	3,730	28.57%	0.21%
13	FY 2007 (OMB 2008, Table 1-3, p. 10)		12	4	16	2	18	22	40	3,590	40.00%	0.45%
14	FY 2008 (OMB 2009, Table 1-3, p. 14)		13	6	19	2	21	21	42	3,820	45.24%	0.50%
15	FY 2009 (OMB 2010, Table 1-3, p. 20)		16	12	28	5	33	33	66	3,468	42.42%	0.81%
16	FY 2010 (OMB 2011, Table 1-4, p. 23)		18	8	26	8	34	32	66	3,564	39.39%	0.73%
17	FY 2011 (OMB 2012, Table 1-5,6)		13	6	19	5	24	30	54	3806	35.19%	0.50%
18	FY 2012 (OMB 2013, Table 1-5,6)		14	9	23	2	25	22	47	3708	48.94%	0.62%
19	FY 2013 (OMB 2014)		7	11	18	6	24	30	54	3658	33.33%	0.49%
20	FY 2014 (OMB 2015)		13	3	16	3	19	35	54	3543	29.63%	0.45%
21	FY 2015 (OMB 2016 Draft)		21	6	27	3	30	29	59	3408	45.76%	0.79%
22	FY 2016 (OMB 2017)		16	32	48	6	54	31	85	3,853	56.47%	1.25%
23	FY 2017 (OMB 2018)		20	10	30	4	34	26	60	3,280	50.00%	0.91%
24	FY 2018 (OMB 2019)		5	4	9	5	14	18	32	3,368	28.13%	0.27%
25	FY 2019 (OMB 2020)		5	14	19	8	27	28	55	2,964	34.55%	0.64%
26	FY 2020	(prelim)	9	27	36	39	75	35	110	3,353	32.73%	1.07%
27	FY 2021	(prelim)	8	20	28	30	58	39	97	3,257	28.87%	0.86%
28	FY 2022	(prelim)	14	9	23	10	33	30	63	3,168	36.51%	0.73%
29	TOTALS		258	208	466	168	634	625	1259	80,286	37.01%	0.58%
30	Benefits Percentages
31	Source: Compiled by W. Crews from OMB, various fiscal years' editions of Report to Congress on Benefits and Costs of Regulation, https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/information-regulatory-affairs/reports/ Notes: *Federal Register final rules are presented by calendar year; other data by fiscal year. Budget rules are "regulations implement[ing] or adjusting Federal budgetary programs, which primarily caused income transfers, usually from taxpayers to program beneficiaries.
32


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1


1