Shai Feedback (Post-Misty July 1, 2022)

	A	B	C
1	Issue	For Change	Against Change
2	Artina Sol is behind on stats compared to Caphras Level 20 V Dandelion and V Blackstar	20	0
3	Artina Sol untaggable from Shai to Shai	18	1
4	Artina Sol untaggable from Shai to non-Shai	19	1
5	Shai lacks a meaningful passive for survivability in player versus player	20	0
6	Healing for Shai is the least protected of all classes	22	1
7	Healing for Shai is reduced to impotent levels in Arena of Solare	17	2
8	Healing for Shai has unreasonably lengthy Cooldowns	26	1
9	Healing for Shai is too low for a support class	26	1
10	Shais Hop III should not cost stamina when used for unprotected mobility, when on cooldown	21	0
11	Artina Sol IV in Arena of Solare means our Song Skills have reduced potency	16	1
12	Shai has the slowest recovery time after getting Crowd-Controled of all classes	22	0
13	No ability to animation cancel available for wakeup-frames on crowd controls to ensure protected recovery from Crowd-Control states.	15	1
14	Forest Echo (bongos) no longer effective at controling zones due to over saturation of Super Armor Skills	19	1
15	Shai unprotected when trying to use Yippee due to lack of Invulnerability-Frame for starting animation	17	2
16	Shai gives up player versus player damage but does not gain powerful support skills	23	1
17	Delusive Light is weak when compared to other classes attack power reduction skills and slows	12	3
18	Donkey is still not a dream donkey	18	1
19	Can't buy or sell Artina Sol on the Central Market	15	8
20	Can't exchange to/from Artina Sol via Weapon Exchange Coupons	23	2
21	Can't Caphras Artina Sol, leading to reduced stats vs Dandelion (most notably +12 Accuracy at C20)	26	0
22	Can't get a guaranteed PEN Artina Sol via Season+	23	1
23	Blackstar and Godr-Ayed Sols do not exist	27	0
24	Artina Sol is missing the All Species Damage of Dandelion (+12 at PEN)	26	0
25	Shai has no Core Skills. Instead, she may only choose a single rank 3 buff.	26	0
26	Party members can i-frame or even physically dodge Shai buffs	30	0
27	Shai buffs are entirely unprotected and interruptible	23	1
28	Shai has the slowest E-buff in the game at 258 frames (~4.3 seconds) with the last 75 frames unprotected. 237 frames are animation-locked.	25	0
29	Shai only has 2 Lute skills, and one now has a 3 minute cooldown. This prevents effective Lute song animation cancelling/chaining.	25	1
30	The Misty Haze cooldown nerf still didn't fix the problem of -%DR being broken at high-end PvE spots. They just require more Shais.	17	1
31	Talent skill damage (especially Sun's Fury and Earth's Tremble) is mostly meaningless in both PvE and PvP, even at 301+ AP.	25	0
32	Sun's Fury and Earth's Tremble have 75 frames of (protected) startup and 75 frames of unprotected putaway animations for a nearly 4 second animation lock.	17	1
33	Shai can't lock the Tuning ability which can scuff other Talent and Florang inputs	11	4
34	Shai does not get either the 30% Awakening AP or the 30% Succession AP bonus from Sol/Florang because she has 'Talent', but Florangs are not stronger than other weapons.	14	8
35	Shai cannot attack or use any skills while on a mount with stirrups	19	2
36	Shai does not have any protected Florang CC in PvP	17	3
37	Shai has no Knockdown at all and only 1 PvE Bound in Tumble-Wumble (required for Pit of the Undying)	22	1
38	Shai has no Down Attacks. Kicking an enemy actually reduces PvP damage since she can't get Back Attacks while an enemy is grounded.	22	1
39	Shai has no Down Smash or Air Smash outside of addons and her Elvia Weapon skill	16	4
40	Shai has no T3 addons	22	2
41	Shai has no addons for Talent Skills	17	8
42	Shai's vacuum skill (Gather Around!) has such low AoE that it can't even be effectively used in most Gathering	25	2
43	Shai has the lowest PvP modifiers in the game (max 62.5% vs Archer and an unreasonable 29.22% vs Striker/Mystic). The lowest modifier of any other matchup is 77.93% (DK vs Striker/Mystic).	17	5
44	Shai has no good way to deal with SAFG (no grab or guard shred)	22	3
45	Shai only has 2 i-frame skills, and 'Play Dead' is a 5 minute cooldown for a 2 second i-frame	26	0
46	Shai's roll (a key mobility/chaining skill) can't be used on cooldown	20	2
47	Enemies (especially players) can glitch through Shai's 'Over Here!' bubble, even landing ranged grabs	24	0
48	Shai's class passives for bonus Gathering/Alchemy XP are bugged and do not work properly	21	5
49	Shai's XP bonus from Gathering/Alchemy is so small that it's meaningless for level 60+	23	3
50	Shai is the only class without a Level 60 (formerly 62) class passive	29	1
51	Florang Surf ('Yippie!') has 30 startup and 30 ending frames, both of which are unprotected, stationary, and animation-locked	5	0
52	Go Away III is a float and not a knockdown.	4	1
53	Being unable to hit the red ap buffs in Arena of Solare due to elevation issues with 1-2-3.	12	0
54	Summer Rain is just a pve skill at this point.	6	0
55	Shais pvp dmg is limited and yet she takes full damage in pvp.	25	0
56	Lower the recovery time for being knocked down, getting knocked down onto the floor is as good as a death sentence	14	1
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100