ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAEAFAGAHAI
1
titledescriptioninstructionsidentifiervalueTemplatevalidValuesdefaultexamplesparentmoduleentityReffieldRefownerlistcollapsingrepeatingrecurringrecursingidentifying
2
GeneralGeneral informationgeneral
3
QURIDQuasi Unique Identifier Record Identifier (QURID).
This is already available in the screening database; a QURID was added to every record. We will use this to automatically import bibliographic information available in that file, such as title, keywords, potentially abstract, etc.
quridstring.identifier"qurid_"
"qurid_6", "qurid_12"
general
4
Authors
This container entity holds the information about the authors.
sourceAuthorsgeneral
5
Authors NameName of author(s).
Look in the article for the full name of every author. Extract last name(s) followed by first name(s). For first names use initials. If no name is present, extract this as "c("nr")".
sourceAuthorNamestring.multic("")
c("Agasisti, T.", "Cannistrà, M.", "Soncin, M.", "Marazzina, D.")
sourceAuthors
6
LanguageThe written language of the article.
Note that articles are not excluded based on language. After the screening we look for students/colleagues who can read a certain language. If not the article will be excluded. Use ISO 639-1 to extract this (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ISO_639-1_codes). If an article is written in a language that is not represented in ISO 639-1, extract using ISO 639-2 instead. e.g. English = en; Dutch = nl.
languagestring"""en", "nl"general
7
Type of reviewReview type according to the authors.
Extract literally which terms the authors use. If the authors use multiple terms to refer to the type of review, use the term they use in the title. If no review type is included in the title, use the term from the abstract. If no review type is included in the abstract, use the term from the keywords. If not reported, "nr". We will later explore these terms inductively (e.g. creating categories).
reviewTypestring""
"Systematic review", "Systematic review and meta analyses"
general
8
Aim
The literal text described as the purpose/ aim/ goal/ reason/ intention of the study.
If the goal is described in several places in the article (e.g., summary, introduction, conclusion), then only the aim described in the introduction is extracted. If the aim is not reported in the introduction by any of these words, enter c("nr") We will later explore these terms inductively (e.g., creating categories).
aimstring.multic("nr")general
9
Research Question
Research question(s) of the study / hypothesis of the study.
If found, check whether the sentences before or the sentences after relate to the research question or hypothesis of this study. If so, copy the literal text. If this is not reported enter c("nr"). We will later explore these terms inductively (e.g., creating categories).
questionstring.multic("nr")general
10
Green spaces definitions
This container entity contains the different concepts around "green spaces" that this review uses. How the authors define "green spaces"-related terms (or whichever synonym for "green spaces" they use, e.g., "street trees, forests, city parks, water bodies")
greenSpaces_definitions
11
Green spaces definition
The definition of green spaces, as the authors descibe it.
If the authors define this term in the introduction, the literal words they use. Extract the term the authors use, if authors cite another paper, a reference to that paper, and if it is defined in the review, the literal definition the authors use. Start with the first sentence where the term is defined; then copy until the last sentence about the concept. If authors continue with parts of the definition later in the article (i.e. if they provide additional information about what the concept does and does not encompass), add that information in additional vector elements (i.e., using "c()"). Example vector: "c("text", "text", "text")". If not reported, "c("nr")".
greenSpaces_definitionstring.multic("")
greenSpaces_definitions
WAARWAAR
12
Green spaces termThe term used for "green spaces"
The exact literal term the authors use for this particular synonym of "green spaces".
greenSpaces_definition_termstring.multic("")
c("green spaces", "forest", "city parks")
greenSpaces_definitions
13
Selection criteria
This container entity contains the reported selection criteria in the article.
selection_criteria
14
Selection criteria articleThe selection criteria in the article.
Extract literally the text the authors use to describe the inclusion and/or exclusion criteria they used in their review. This may include selection criteria such as population (e.g. age, ethnicity), geographic location, urbanization type (e.g., "urban" or "rural"), methods (e.g., "qualitative studies", "quantitative studies" or "mixed methods") of the studies included in the review. If multiple such sentences or fragments are distributed throughout the source, extract them as separate values in a vector using "c()". If no inclusion or exclusion criterion was reported, extract "c("nr")". If it is unclear from the review whether method was an inclusion or exclusion criterion, extract "c("nr")". We will later explore these terms inductively (e.g., creating categories).
selectionCriteria
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")selection_criteria
15
Participant demographics
This container entity contains the reported participant demographics in the article.
participant_demographics
16
Gender and / or sex presence
Whether participants' gender and / or sex is reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.gender.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
17
Gender and / or sex conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concepts of gender and sex.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.gender.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
18
Gender and / or sex reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the gender and/or sex of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to gender and / or sex. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% women) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.gender.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
19
Age presence
Whether participants' age is reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.age.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
20
Age conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concept of age.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.age.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
21
Age reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the age of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to age. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% > 80 years) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.age.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
22
Socioeconomic status presence
Whether participants' socioeconomic status is reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.SES.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
23
Socioeconomic status conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concept of socialeconomic status.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.SES.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
24
Socioeconomic status reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the socioeconomic status of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to socioeconomic status. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% with a low level of education) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.SES.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
25
Care responsibilities presence
Whether participants' care responsibilities are reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.care.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
26
Care responsibilities conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concept of care responsibilities.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.care.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
27
Care responsibilities reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the care responsibilities of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to care responsibilities. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% caring for a minor) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.care.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
28
Sexual identity presence
Whether participants' sexual identity is reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.SO.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
29
Sexual identity conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concept of sexual identity.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.SO.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
30
Sexual identity reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the sexual identity of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to care responsibilities. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% were gay) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.SO.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
31
Ethnicity-racial identity presence
Whether participants' ethnicity and / or race are reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.ER.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
32
Ethnicity-racial identity conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concepts of ethnicity and / or race.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.ER.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
33
Ethnicity-racial idenity reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the ethnicity and / or race of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to ethnicity and / or race. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% Black) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.ER.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
34
Religion and worldviews presence
Whether participants' religion and / or worldviews are reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.RW.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
35
Religion and worldviews conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concepts of religion and / or worldviews.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.RW.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
36
Religion and worldviews reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the religion and / or worldviews of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to religion and / or worldviews. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% Jewish) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.RW.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
37
Mental health presence
Whether participants' mental health is reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.MentalHealth.presence
categorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
38
Mental health conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concept of mental health.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.MentalHealth.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
39
Mental health reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the mental health of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to mental health. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% showed depressive symptoms) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.MentalHealth.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
40
Physical health and disability presence
Whether participants' physical health and / or disabilities are reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.PhD.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
41
Physical health and disability conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concepts of physical health and / or disabilities.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.PhD.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
42
Physical health and disability reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the physical health and / or disabilities of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to physical health and / or disabilities. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% were hard of hearing) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.PhD.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
43
Perceived discrimination presence
Whether participants' perceived discrimination experiences are reported in the article.
Extract this as "no" if they do not provide information on this demographic variable and "yes" if they do.
participant.PD.presencecategorical"yes" || "no""no""yes", "no"
participant_demographics
module 2
44
Perceived discrimination conceptualization
How the authors conceptualized the concepts of perceived discrimination experiences.
Copy and paste the conceptualization described in the article exactly as it appears. Typically, this information is found in the method section of the article. Use c("nr") if no conceptualization is given.
participant.PD.conceptualization
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
participant_demographics
module 2
45
Perceived discrimination reporting
Which metrics (e.g., percentages) are utilized to document and report the perceived discrimination experiences of the participants.
Copy and paste the specific metrics employed for characterizing the sample(s) with respect to perceived discrimination experiences. Typically, you can find this information in the results section, look for information provided for each study seperate (for example in table) but also reported as overall results. Please refrain from copying and pasting the actual numerical values (e.g., 20% reported to be discriminated because of their old age) and focus solely on the types of metrics used (e.g., percentage). Use c("nr") if no metric is used. If numbers are reported at both the study level and the review level, indicate this clearly (e.g., “number of studies” or “number of individuals.”).
participant.PD.reporting
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")
c("percentage", "number of studies”)
participant_demographics
module 2
46
Method
This container entity contains the reported methods in the article.
methods
47
Search period: start yearThe start of the search period.
Extract the start year of the search period in the format "YYYY". If this is not clear, not reported or not restricted, extract keep empty.
reviewPeriodStartinteger2000, 2010methods
48
Search period: end yearThe end of the search period.
Extract the end year of the search period in the format "YYYY". In case of an updated search was performed, use latest year. If this is not clear, not reported or not restricted, extract keep empty.
reviewPeriodEndinteger2000, 2010methods
49
Number of included articlesNumber of articles included in the review.
Look for the final number of included articles (not studies). If this is not clear or not reported, extract keep empty.
nrOfArticlesinteger40, 70methods
50
Results
This entity container contains the entities that are most likely extracted from the results section of the included review.
results
51
Health effects of green spaces
The effects of green spaces as the review authors describe them.
Copy all pieces of text from results that describe the effects of green spaces on health, including subgroup differences.
greenSpacesEffects_verbatim
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")results
52
Discussion
This entity container contains the entities that are most likely extracted from the discussion section of the included review.
discussion
53
Limitations and strengths
The limitations and strenghts of the review that the authors describe.
In the 'discussion' section, identify the description of the review's limitations and strengths by using a search for the word "limitation" and "strength". If it occurs, copy-paste all limitations and strengths that are reported. If the word "limitation" or "strength" does not occur, or if it occurs but does not refer to the review's limitations or strengths, start reading the discussion more carefully and identify whether there are statements that describe weak or strong points or problems or assets. Then extract these literally. If multiple such sentences or fragments are distributed throughout the source, extract them as separate values in a vector using "c()". If the authors list no limitations, weak points, or strengths, extract "c("nr")".
limitations_verbatim
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")discussion
54
Future research
The authors' recommendations for future research.
In the 'discussion' section, identify the description of the authors' suggestions for future research. Copy-paste all such suggestions literally. If multiple such sentences or fragments are distributed throughout the source, extract them as separate values in a vector using "c()". If the authors make no suggestions for future research, extract "c("nr")".
futureResearch_verbatim
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")discussion
55
ConclusionsThe conclusions the authors draw.
In the 'discussion' section, identify the description of the authors' conclusions. Copy-paste all such conclusions literally. If multiple such sentences or fragments are distributed throughout the source, extract them as separate values in a vector using "c()". If the authors draw no conclusions, extract "c("nr")".
conclusions_verbatim
string.multi.mandatory
c("nr")discussion
56
AMSTAR
This entity container contains the AMSTAR entities of the included review.
AMSTAR
57
Item 1 - AMSTAR 2 - a
Component "population" is included in the research questions and inclusion criteria of the review
Additional information: Component "population" asks the question: How is the population defined? Did the research questions and inclusion criteria for the review include the component "population"? Extract this as "yes" if the components is included. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item1_acategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
58
Item 1 - AMSTAR 2 - b
Component "exposure" is included in the research questions and inclusion criteria of the review
Additional information: Component "exposure" asks the question: What has the population been deliberately or inadvertently exposed to? Did the research questions and inclusion criteria for the review include the components "exposure"? Extract this as "yes" if the components is included. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item1_bcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
59
Item 1 - AMSTAR 2 - c
Component "comparator group" is included in the research questions and inclusion criteria of the review
Additional information: Component "comparator group" asks the question: What has this been compared with, e.g., a different level of exposure? Did the research questions and inclusion criteria for the review include the component "comparator group"? Extract this as "yes" if the component is included. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item1_ccategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
60
Item 1 - AMSTAR 2 - d
Component "outcome" is included in the research questions and inclusion criteria of the review.
Additional information: Component "outcome" asks the question: Which result(s) is the focus on or measured What are they hoping to improve? Did the research questions and inclusion criteria for the review include the component "outcome"? Extract this as "yes" if the components is included. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item1_dcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
61
item 1 - AMSTAR 2 - optional
Component "timeframe for follow-up" is included in the research questions and inclusion criteria of the review
Additional information: Did the research questions and inclusion criteria for the review include the component "timeframe for follow-up"? Extract this as "yes" if the components is included. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item1_optionalcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
62
Item 2 - AMSTAR 2 - a
The authors state that they had a written protocol or guide that include review question(s).
Additional information: Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the authors had a written protocol or guide that include review question(s) prior to the conduct of the review Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item2_acategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
63
Item 2 - AMSTAR 2 - b
The authors state that they had a written protocol or guide that include a search strategy.
Additional information: Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the authors had a written protocol or guide that include a search strategy prior to the conduct of the review? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item2_bcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
64
Item 2 - AMSTAR 2 - c
The authors state that they had a written protocol or guide that include inclusion/exclusion criteria.
Additional information: Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the authors had a written protocol or guide that include inclusion or exclusion criteria prior to the conduct of the review? Extract this as "yes" if at least one of them is included. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item2_ccategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
65
Item 2 - AMSTAR 2 - d
The authors state that they had a written protocol or guide that include a risk of bias assessment.
Additional information: Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the authors had a written protocol or guide that include a risk of bias assessment prior to the conduct of the review? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item2_dcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
66
Item 2 - AMSTAR 2 - e
The authors state that they had the protocol registered and specified a meta-analysis/synthesis plan, if appropriate.
Additional information: Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the protocol was registered and specified a meta-analysis or synthesis plan. Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item2_ecategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
67
Item 2 - AMSTAR 2 - f
The authors state that they had the protocol registered and specified a plan for investigating causes of heterogeneity.
Additional information: Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the protocol was registered and specified a plan for investigating causes of heterogeneity. Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item2_fcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
68
Item 2 - AMSTAR 2 - g
The authors state that they had the protocol registered and specified justification for any deviations from the protocoll.
Additional information: Did the report of the review contain an explicit statement that the protocol was registered and specified a justification for any deviations from the protocol. Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item2_gcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
69
Item 3 - AMSTAR 2 - aExplanation for including only RCTs in the review.
Additional information: Did the review authors give an explanation for including only RCTs in the review? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item3_acategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
70
Item 3 - AMSTAR 2 - bExplanation for including only NRSI.
Additional information: Did the review authors give an explanation for including only NRSI in the review? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item3_bcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
71
Item 3 - AMSTAR 2 - cExplanation for including both RCTs and NRSI.
Additional information: Did the review authors give an explanation for including both RCTs and NRSI. in the review? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item3_ccategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
72
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - aAuthors searched at least 2 databases
Additional information: Did the review authors searched at least 2 databases (relevant to research question)? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_acategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
73
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - b
Authors provided key word and/or search strategy.
Additional information: Did the review authors provided key word and/or equivalent? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_bcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
74
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - cAuthors justified publication restrictions.
Additional information: Did the review authors justified publication restrictions (e.g., language)? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_ccategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
75
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - d
Author searched the reference lists / bibliographies of included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors searched the reference lists / bibliographies of included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_dcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
76
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - eAuthors searched trial/study registries.
Additional information: Did the review authors searched trial/study registries? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_ecategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
77
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - f
Authors included/consulted content experts in the field.
Additional information: Did the review authors included/consulted content experts in the field? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_fcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
78
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - g
Authors where relevant, searched for grey literature.
Additional information: Did the review authors where relevant, searched for grey literature)? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_gcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
79
Item 4 - AMSTAR 2 - h
Authors conducted search within 24 months of completion of the review.
Additional information: Did the review authors conducted search within 24 months of completion of the review? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item4_hcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
80
Item 5 - AMSTAR 2 - a
At least two reviewers independently agreed on selection of eligible studies and achieved consensus on which studies to include.
Additional information: Did at least two reviewers independently agreed on selection of eligible studies and achieved consensus on which studies to include? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not. If not reported, extract "nr".
AMSTAR2_item5_acategorical"yes" || "no" || "nr"""
"yes", "no", "nr"
AMSTAR
81
Item 5 - AMSTAR 2 - b
Two reviewers selected a sample of eligible studies and achieved good agreement (at least 80 percent), with the remainder selected by one reviewer.
Additional information: Did two reviewers selected a sample of eligible studies and achieved good agreement(at least 80 percent, e.g. Kappa score), with the remainder selected by one reviewer? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not. If not reported, extract "nr".
AMSTAR2_item5_bcategorical"yes" || "no" || "nr"""
"yes", "no", "nr"
AMSTAR
82
Item 6 - AMSTAR 2 - a
At least two reviewers achieved consensus on which data to extract from included studies.
Additional information: Did at least two reviewers achieved consensus on which data to extract from included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item6_acategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
83
Item 6 - AMSTAR 2 - b
Two reviewers extracted data from a sample of eligible studies and achieved good agreement (at least 80 percent), with the remainder extracted by one reviewer.
Additional information: Did two reviewers extracted data from a sample of eligible studies and achieved good agreement (at least 80 percent), with the remainder extracted by one reviewer? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item6_bcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
84
Item 7 - AMSTAR 2 - a
Authors provided a list of all potentially relevant studies that were read in full-text form but excluded from the review.
Additional information: Did the review authors provided a list of all potentially relevant studies that were read in full-text form but excluded from the review? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item7_acategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
85
Item 7 - AMSTAR 2 - b
Authors justified the exclusion from the review of each potentially relevant study
Additional information: Did the review authors justified the exclusion from the review of each potentially relevant study? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item7_bcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
86
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - a
Authors described populations of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the populations of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_acategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
87
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - b
Authors described exposure of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the exposure of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_bcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
88
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - c
Authors described comparators of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the comparators of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_ccategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
89
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - d
Authors described outcomes of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the outcomes of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_dcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
90
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - e
Authors described research designs of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the research designs of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_ecategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
91
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - f
Authors described populations in detal of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the populations in detal of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_fcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
92
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - g
Authors described interventions in detal of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the described intervention in detail (including doses where relevant) of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_gcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
93
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - h
Authors described comparators in detail of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the described comparator in detail (including doses where relevant) of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_hcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
94
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - i
Authors described described study’s setting of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the described study’s setting of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_icategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
95
Item 8 - AMSTAR 2 - j
Authors described timeframe for follow-up of the included studies.
Additional information: Did the review authors describe the timeframe for follow-up of the included studies? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not.
AMSTAR2_item8_jcategorical"yes" || "no""""yes", "no"AMSTAR
96
Item 9 - AMSTAR 2 - a
Authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from unconcealed allocation.
Additional information: Did the review authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from unconcealed allocation? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not. Extract "na" if no RCTs are included in the review.
AMSTAR2_item9_acategorical"yes" || "no" || "na"""
"yes", "no", "na"
AMSTAR
97
Item 9 - AMSTAR 2 - b
Authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from lack of blinding of patients and assessors when assessing outcomes (unnecessary for objective outcomes such as all-cause mortality).
Additional information: Did the review authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from lack of blinding of patients and assessors when assessing outcomes (unnecessary for objective outcomes such as allcause mortality)? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not. Extract "na" if no RCTs are included in the review.
AMSTAR2_item9_bcategorical"yes" || "no" || "na"""
"yes", "no", "na"
AMSTAR
98
Item 9 - AMSTAR 2 - c
Authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from allocation sequence that was not truly random.
Additional information: Did the review authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from allocation sequence that was not truly random? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not. Extract "na" if no RCTs are included in the review.
AMSTAR2_item9_ccategorical"yes" || "no" || "na"""
"yes", "no", "na"
AMSTAR
99
Item 9 - AMSTAR 2 - d
Authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from selection of the reported result from among multiple measurements or analyses of a specified outcome.
Additional information: Did the review authors assess RCTs for the risk of bias from selection of the reported result from among multiple measurements or analyses of a specified outcome? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not. Extract "na" if no RCTs are included in the review.
AMSTAR2_item9_dcategorical"yes" || "no" || "na"""
"yes", "no", "na"
AMSTAR
100
Item 9 - AMSTAR 2 - e
Authors assess NRSI for the risk of bias (RoB) from confounding.
Additional information: Did the review authors assess NRSI for the risk of bias (RoB) from confounding? Extract this as "yes" if the answer is yes to this question. Extract "no" if not. Extract "na" if no NRSI's are included in the review.
AMSTAR2_item9_ecategorical"yes" || "no" || "na"""
"yes", "no", "na"
AMSTAR