Post-Dear Colleague letter, university victories

	A	B	C	D	E
1	Case	Date	Judge	Court	Disposition
2	Z.J. v. Vanderbilt University	20-Dec-18	Waverly Crenshaw	U.S. District Court, Tennessee, Middle Dist.	MTD
3	John Doe v. Harvard University	18-Dec-18	Indira Talwani	U.S. District Court, Massachusetts	TRO (on grounds that university agreed to delay opening investigation until 1-21-19)
4	John Doe v. Arizona Board of Regents	30-Nov-18	--	Maricopa County (AZ) Court of Appeals	affirms expulsion
5	Daniel Caldwell v. Parker University	27-Nov-18	Daniel Horan	U.S. District Court, Texas, Northern Dist.	MTD
6	Christian Ayala v. Butler University, et al.	19-Oct-18	Tanya Walton Pratt	U.S. District Court, Indiana, Southern Dist.	summary judgment (TIX)
7	In the Matter of Benjamin Haug v. State University of New York	18-Oct-18	per curiam	Court of Appeals (NY)	reversed appellate court, reinstated disciplinary judgment against accused student
8	Saifullah Khan v. Yale University	10-Oct-18	James Abrams	New Haven Superior Court	temporary injunction
9	Jason Tolliver v. Prairie View A&M University, et al.	1-Oct-18	Lee Rosenthal	U.S. District Court, Texas, Southern Dist.	MTD (statute of limitations)
10	Matter of Bursch v Purchase Coll. of the State Univ. of N.Y.	20-Sep-18	William Mastro	New York, Appellate Division, Second Dept.	Art. 78 (3-2 vote)
11	Jane Roe v. University of Cincinnati	21-Aug-18	Timothy Black	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	preliminary injunction (complaint was then withdrawn)
12	John Doe v. St. Mary's College	27-July-18	Charles Treat	Contra Costa (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (court set aside two lesser charges)
13	John Doe v. Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois	25-July-18	Colin Bruce	U.S. District Court, Illinois, Central Dist.	summary judgment (Charleston precedent, acc'd student hadn't read handbook before enrolling) (preliminary injunction denied on grounds student not enrolled at time of lawsuit) (MTD previously denied, 15 Nov. 2017, due to lack of x-examination; reasoning unaffected by summ. judgment decision)
14	In the Matter of John Doe v. Cornell University	12-July-18	John Egan	Appellate Division, Third Department (NY)	Article 78 (affirming supreme court decision, 15 Dec. 2017)
15	Tafari Haynes v. Clarion University	27-Jun-18	Billy Roy Wilson	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Western Dist.	summary judgment (appealed to CA3)
16	John Doe v. Regents of the University of California (UCSB)	6-Jun-18	A. Wallace Tashima	U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	MTD (failure to exchaust state remedies)
17	John Doe v. St. Joseph's University, et al.	16-May-18	Paul Diamond	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Eastern Dist.	TRO (no discussion of merits, no irreperable harm by not being able to go on school trip)
18	John Doe v. University of Texas at Austin et al	15-May-18	Robert Pittman	U.S. District Court, Texas, Western Dist.	preliminary injunction/MTD
19	B.B. v. The New School	1-May-18	Analisa Torres	U.S. District Court, New York, Southern Dist.	MTD (TIX claim, remainder of case remanded to NYS court)
20	Benjamin North v. Catholic University	30-Apr-18	Trevor McFadden	U.S. District Court, District of Columbia	MTD (minor claims; TIX & breach of contract claims remain)
21	Doe v. United States Merchant Marine Academy	20-Apr-18	Joseph Bianco	U.S. District Court, New York, Southern Dist.	preliminary injunction (accused student then withdrew lawsuit)
22	John Doe v. Timothy White	17-Apr-18	Mary Stroebel	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	motion for stay of discipline
23	John Doe v. Wallace Loh, et al.	29-Mar-18	Paula Xinis	U.S. District Court, Maryland	MTD (appealed to CA4)
24	Matthew Boermeester v. Ainsley Carry, et al.	21-Mar-18	Amy Hogue	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (appealed to California Appellate Division)
25	John Doe v. Dayton University, et al.	20-Mar-18	Thomas Rose	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD (appealed to CA6)
26	John Doe v. University of Denver, et al.	13-Mar-18	Philip Brimmer	U.S. District Court, Colorado	summary judgment
27	James Haidak v. University of Massachusetts*	9-Mar-18	Michael Ponsor	U.S. District Court, Massachusetts	summary judgment (appealed to CA1) (MTD previously denied)
28	David Romero v. Florida Gulf Coast University	28-Feb-18	Keith Kyle	Florida Circuit Court, Twentieth Judicial Circuit	writ of certiorari denied
29	John Doe v. University of South Carolina, et al.	12-Feb-18	Paige Gossett	U.S. District Court, South Carolina	preliminary injunction (magistrate judge's report, adopted by judge)
30	John Doe v. Florida State University	30-Jan-18	James Schelfer	Leon County (FL) Circuit Court	writ of certiorari denied
31	John Doe v. Occidental College	19-Jan-18	Amy Hogue	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (under appeal, Calif. 2nd District)
32	John Doe v. Carnegie Mellon University	6-Dec-17	Mark Hornak	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Western Dist.	TRO (denied without prejudice, case was eventually settled)
33	John Doe v. Nicholas Dirks, et al.	1-Dec-17	Tom Rogers	Alameda County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
34	Ryan Ruff et al v. Board of Regents of the University of New Mexico et al	30-Nov-17	M. Christina Armijo	U.S. District Court, New Mexico	MTD, TIX claim (other portions of complaint subsequently dismissed)
35	John Doe v. Purdue University	16-Nov-17	Paul Cherry	U.S. District Court, Indiana, Northern Dist.	MTD (currently under appeal, CA7)
36	John Doe v. Colgate University	31-Oct-17	Lawrence Kahn	U.S. District Court, New York, Northern Dist.	summary judgment, exclusion of Aya Gruber report (currently under appeal, CA2)
37	Michigan State Univ. Student #A48212299 v. Michigan State Univ.	30-Oct-17	Christopher Murray	Michigan Court of Claims	summary disposition
38	John Doe v. St. John's University (Minnesota)	26-Oct-17	Paul Magnuson	U.S. District Court, Minnesota	MTD (case ultimately settled)
39	John Doe v. Columbia College-Chicago	25-Oct-17	Amy St. Eve	U.S. District Court, Illinois, Northerm Dist.	MTD (amended complaint also dismissed)
40	John Doe v. Coastal Carolina University	10-Oct-17	https://www.postandcourier.com/news/students-accused-of-sex-assault-are-challenging-disciplinary-process-at/article_f199610e-c998-11e7-92b2-137e981bf6ed.html	Horry County Court
41	Spencer Streno v. Shenandoah University	30-Sep-17	Elizabeth Dillon	U.S. District Court, Virginia, Western Dist.	MTD
42	Tyler Stenzel v. Bemidji State University et al	13-Sep-17	John Tunheim	U.S. District Court, Minnesota	MTD (student cleared by internal appeal as the lawsuit was proceeding)
43	John Doe v. The University of South Alabama et al	08-Sep-17	Callie Granade	U.S. District Court, Alabama, Southern Dist.	TRO
44	John Doe v. Grinnell College	6-Sep-17	Rebecca Goodgame Ebinger	U.S. District Court, Iowa	MTD (partial)
45	John Doe v. DePauw University et al.	30-Aug-17	Richard Young	U.S. District Court, Indiana, Southern Dist.	TRO (complaint then withdrawn)
46	John Doe v. Wright State University et al	24-Aug-17	Walter Rice	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD (reconsideration denied)
47	Diego Venegas et al. v. Wright State University et al.	21-Aug-17	Walter Rice	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD
48	John Doe v. University of Texas at Austin et al	11-Aug-17	Sam Sparks	U.S. District Court, Texas, Southern Dist.	prelim. Injunction (university ultimately settled w/discipine w/drawn)
49	Anthony Brainard v. Western Oregon University	25-July-17	Michael Simon	U.S. District Court, Oregon	MTD
50	John Doe v. California State University San Marcos et al	07-Jul-17	William Hayes	U.S. District Court, California, Southern Dist.	TRO (case then was settled)
51	John Doe v. Ainsley Carey, et al.	05-Jul-17	Howard Halm	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (appealed to CA 2nd District)
52	George Vasquez v. University of Central Florida	26-Jun-17	Renee Roche	Orange County (FL) Superior Court	writ of mandate
53	Natalie Plummer, et al. v. University of Houston, et al.	23-Jun-17	Stephen Higginson	U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	MTD (affirmed district court ruling, 28 May 2015), Judge Jones dissenting
54	Alfonso Pacheco v. St. Mary’s(TX)	20-Jun-17	Royce Lamberth	U.S. District Court, Texas, Western Dist.	MTD
55	Zachary Herrell v. Michael Benson, et al.	12-Jun-17	Karen Caldwell	U.S. District Court, Kentucky	MTD
56	Dominic Artis, et al v. University of Oregon, et al	07-Jun-17	Michael McShane	U.S. District Court, Oregon	MTD (under appeal CA9)
57	Wayne Klocke v. University of Texas at Arlington, et al.*	7-Jun-17	John McBryde	U.S. District Court, Texas, Northern Dist.	summary judgment
58	John Doe v. Occidental College	23-May-17	Mary Stroebel	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (under appeal--CA 2nd District)
59	Michael Weber v. SUNY-Cortland	11-May-17	William McCarthy	Appellate Division, Third Dept. (NY)	Art. 78
60	Bryce Dixon v. Kegan Allee, et al.	25-Apr-17	Howard Halm	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
61	John Doe v. Quinnipiac University, et al.	31-Mar-17	Janet Bond Arterton	U.S. District Court, Connecticut	preliminary injunction
62	John Doe v. Denison University	30-Mar-17	Michael Watson	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD, (appealed to CA6, case was settled after CA6 oral argument)
63	Dyshawn Pierre v. University of Dayton	27-Mar-17	Thomas Rose	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD
64	John Doe v. College of Wooster, et al.	17-Mar-17	Sara Lioi	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Northern Dist.	MTD
65	John Doe v. Ainsley Carry, et al.	14-Mar-17	Howard Halm	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (appealed to CA 2nd District)
66	Jack Montague v. Yale University	08-Mar-17	Alfred Covello	U.S. District Court, Connecticut	preliminary injunction
67	John Doe v. Occidental College	07-Mar-17	Mary Stroebel	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (case subsequently was settled)
68	Olauluwa Faparusi v. Case Western Reserve University*	28-Feb-17	Christopher Boyko	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Northern Dist.	MTD (aff'd by CA6, Supreme Court denied cert.)
69	John Doe v. Occidental College	2-Feb-17	James Chalfant	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (under appeal--CA 2nd District)
70	John Doe v. Ainsley Carry, et al.	24-Jan-17	Howard Halm	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
71	Sam Book v. University of Florida	15-Dec-16	Richard Roundtree	Florida Circuit Court, Eighth Judicial Circuit	writ of certiorari denied
72	John Doe v. Daniel Cummins, et al.	06-Dec-16	Julia Smith Gibbons	U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit	MTD (affirmed district court ruling of 23 March 2016)
73	John Doe v. Regents of the University of California (UCSD)	22-Nov-16	Richard Huffman	Court of Appeal, Fourth District (CA)	writ of mandate
74	Anthony Casolari v. Florida State University	21-Nov-16	Karen Gievers	Leon County (FL) Circuit Court	writ of certiorari denied
75	Jeffrey Koeppel v. District Board of Trustees of Valencia College*	16-Sep-16	Paul Byron	U.S. District Court, Florida, Middle Dist.	MTD (affirmed by CA11, 13 Sept. 2018)
76	Paul Alexander v. Regents of the University of Idaho, et al.	14-Sep-16	Jay Gaskill	Second Judicial Court, Idaho	TRO (case was later settled)
77	Ryan Knoch v. University of Pittsburgh	31-Aug-16	Cynthia Eddy	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Western Dist.	preliminary injunction (case was later settled)
78	Zackery Ramos Taylor v. UC-Santa Cruz	29-Aug-16		Santa Clara (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
79	Jonathan Turner v. Texas A&M, et al.	14-Mar-16	David Hittner	U.S. District Court, Texas, Southern Dist.	preliminary injunction (case was later settled)
80	Alec Jackson v. Macalester College et al	11-Mar-16	Wilhelmina Wright	U.S. District Court, Minnesota	TRO (university ultimately settled)
81	Michael Navarro v. University of Central Florida	9-Feb-16	per curiam	Florida Circuit Court, Ninth Judicial Circuit	writ of certiorari denied
82	Timothy Howe v. Penn State University-Harrisburg, et al.	2-Feb-16	Malachy Mannion	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Middle Dist.	TRO (case subsequently dismised after plaintiff stopped responding to court inquiries)
83	Roberts v. Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia, et al.*	27-Jan-16	Leigh May	U.S. District Court, Georgia, Northern Dist.	MTD
84	John Doe v. Ohio State University	22-Jan-16	James Graham	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	TRO (complaint then withdrawn)
85	Daniel Lambraia v. SUNY-Binghamton	14-Jan-16	Michael Lynch	Appellate Division, Third Dept. (NY)	Art. 78
86	Ahmed Salau v. Brady Denton	07-Jan-16	Stephen Bough	U.S. District Court, Missouri	MTD
87	Daniel Caskey v. University of Central Florida	4-Dec-15	Sally Kest	Florida Circuit Court, Ninth Judicial Circuit	writ of certiorari denied
88	Michael Marshall v. Ohio University	17-Nov-15	George Smith	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD
89	John Doe v. Case Western Reserve University	16-Sep-15	Christopher Boyko	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Northern Dist.	MTD (case eventually settled after state-court lawsuit)
90	Emanuel Uzoechi v. David Wilson (Morgan State University)	03-Sep-15	James Bredar	U.S. District Court, Maryland	MTD (granted summary judgment to Morgan State on 24 May 2018 after CA4 order returning case to district court for further consideration)
91	Stephen Zingarelli v. Kenyon College, et al.	7-Aug-15	Otto Eyster	Kenyon (OH) County Common Court	MTD
92	John Doe v. University of Massachusetts	14-Jul-15	Mark Mastroianni	U.S. District Court, Massachusetts	MTD (appealed to CA1, case was then settled)
93	John Doe v. University of South Florida, et al.	29-May-15	James Moody	U.S. District Court, Florida, Middle Dist.	MTD
94	Kevin Parisi v. Drew University	22-Apr-15	Esther Salas	U.S. District Court, New Jersey	MTD
95	Peter Yu v. Vassar College	31-Mar-15	Ronnie Abrams	U.S. District Court, New York, Southern Dist.	MTD
96	Ethan Peloe v. University of Cincinnati, et al.	19-Feb-15	Susan Dlott	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD
97	Jack Blank v. Knox College	26-Jan-15	Joe McDade	U.S. District Court, Illinois, Northerm Dist.	MTD
98	Matthew Sahm v. Miami University	07-Jan-15	Susan Dlott	U.S. District Court, Ohio, Southern Dist.	MTD (amended complaint on TIX subsequently denied)
99	Reed Dempsey v. Bucknell University	5-Jan-15	Matthew Brann	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Middle Dist.	summary judgment (claims against state actor BUPD affirmed by CA3)
100	Brian Romer v. Washington State University	8-Sep-14	Kevin Korsimo	Washington Court of Appeals, Division Three	injunction