ABCDEFGHIJK
1
Docket Number
Respondent(s)
Permit Number
Date Opened
Date RatifiedDispositionStatutory/Rule Violation(s)Disciplinary ActionIssues IdentifiedCity
School District
2
ARC-A-18-005Michael A. VigilN/A06/13/201804/18/2019Permit DeniedN/AN/ACheyenneN/A
3
A-17-013
Michael T. McDonald
218905/19/201704/26/2018Permit SurrenderedWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-125(a); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4; Appraisal Rules Chapter 4Voluntary Surrender of PermitUnprofessional; Untimely; Deficient AppraisalRivertonN/A
4
A-17-011Georgia E. Williams52601/30/201701/18/2018StipulationUSPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4(b)(iii); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(a)(x); Appraisal Rules Chapter 4 Section 1- Nine (9) months probation;
- Completion of Board approved seven (7) hour online "The Cost Approach" course;
- Completion of Board approved seven (7) hour online "The Sales Comparison Approach course 		Deficient Appraisal; Failure to report prior appraisal services on the subject property within the last three (3) yearsNewcastleN/A
5
A-17-010D. Tyler Dustman107101/19/201705/04/2017StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a)(x)$150.00 fineFailure to complete USPAP update coursePark City, UT
6
A-17-009Ann M. Fear24901/18/201705/04/2017StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a)(x)$150.00 fineFailure to complete USPAP update coursePinedale
7
A-17-003Dustin W. Harris105702/07/201705/04/2017StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a)(x)$150.00 fineFailure to complete USPAP update courseRigby, ID
8
A-16-009Ronald R. Moore66305/18/201611/01/2016StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a)(x)$150.00 fineFailure to complete USPAP update courseSheridan
9
A-16-008Alicia L. BlevinsAP-133003/01/201605/04/2017StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-110(b); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(e)(i), (g), (f); USPAP Standards Rule 1-3(b); USPAP Standards Competency Rule 1, 2, 3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a)(iv)- One (1) month probation;
- Completion of Board approved seven (7) hour "Subdivision Valuations: A Comprehensive Guide to Valuing Improved Subdivisions" course 		Competency; Scope of work; Failure to comply with USPAPCasperN/A
10
A-16-006David P. Brandt113105/18/201611/01/2016StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a)(x)$150.00 fineFailure to complete USPAP update courseColorado Springs, CO
11
A-14-004Matthew S. Koch83306/19/2014StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(vi); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(e), (g); USPAP Standards Rule 1-3(b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(a)(iii), (vii), (viii), (ix), (x), (xi); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 4 Section 1(a)- Completion of Board approved fifteen (15) hour USPAP courseDeficient appraisal; Competency; Conduct; Scope of WorkCasperN/A
12
A-14-001Barry T. Samuels60806/25/201302/19/2014StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(vi); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(x); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1- Completion of Board approved fifteen (15) hour "Residential Market Analysis Highest and Best Use" courseTimeliness; Competency; Deficient appraisalCheyenneN/A
13
A-12-005John B. Wilson96201/12/201201/14/2013StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(vi); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(vii); Appraisal Rules Chapter 4 Section 1(a)- $750.00 fine, in lieu of $500.00 may attend Board approved seven (7) hour "Comparative Analysis" courseDeficient AppraisalCheyenne
14
A-12-001Gregory S. Strable71207/05/201110/21/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(b)- Six (6) month suspension, stayed for 1 year probation;
- Quarterly log presented to the Board with a complete work file;
- Formal request for reinstatement of his permit		Negligent appraisal; Failure to inspect the propertyThermopolisN/A
15
A-11-013Gregory S. Strable71206/20/201110/21/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(b)- Six (6) month suspension, stayed for 1 year probation;
- Quarterly log presented to the Board with a complete work file;
- Formal request for reinstatement of his permit		Negligent appraisalThermopolisN/A
16
A-11-012Cynthia L. Whitlock85906/13/201104/30/2014StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(vii); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 17(a)(iv), (v); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(a)- $1,000.00 fine;
- Completion of Board approved four (4) hour Online Supervising Appraisal Trainee course		Failure to use the correct certificationCasper
17
A-11-011Warren C. Whitlock108906/13/201104/30/2014StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(i), (iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 18(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(a)- Completion of Board approved five (5) hour "Business Practice & Ethics" course;
- Completion of Board approved seven (7) hour "Comparative Analysis" course;
- Review audit every three (3) months for nine (9) months		Violation in procuring a permit; Dishonesty, fraud or misrepresentationCasperN/A
18
A-11-009Gregory S. Strable71202/11/201110/21/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(b)- Six (6) month suspension, stayed for one (1) year probation;
- Quarterly log presented to the Board with a complete work file;
- Formal request for reinstatement of his permit		Negligent appraisalRivertonN/A
19
A-11-006Gregory S. Strable71210/29/201010/21/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(b)- Six (6) month suspension, stayed for one (1) year probation;
- Quarterly log presented to the Board with a complete work file;
- Formal request for reinstatement of his permit		Negligent appraisalRivertonN/A
20
A-11-002Alan C. Brooks34709/20/201001/07/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. 33-39-123(a)(ii)Voluntary Surrender of PermitFelony ConvictionCasperN/A
21
A-11-001Michael A. Vigil82708/23/201004/04/2012StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(viii); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(b), (e); Appraisal Rules Chapter 3 Section 1- Refusal to renew permit
- Conditions on relicensure		Negligent in developing appraisal report; Unprofessional conduct and misleading communication; RecordkeepingCentennial, CON/A
22
A-10-012David H. Kerbs66606/29/201010/27/2010StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-117; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(a)Voluntary Surrender of PermitFalse statement on renewal application; Failure to complete CE for renewal applicationGreeley, CON/A
23
A-10-011Michael A. Vigil82705/19/20104/4/2012StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv), (v), (ix); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(a), (b), (e); Appraisal Rules Chapter 3 Section 1- Refusal to renew permit
- Conditions on relicensure		Negligent in developing appraisal report; Timeliness; ConfidentialityTorrington Cheyenne Laramie CasperN/A
24
A-10-010Michael A. Vigil82705/18/20104/4/2012StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(viii); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(b), (e); Appraisal Rules Chapter 3 Section 1- Refusal to renew permit
- Conditions on relicensure		Negligent in developing appraisal report; Timeliness; RecordkeepingLaramieN/A
25
A-10-009Robert M. Provart40304/19/201003/15/2011StipulationUSPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(e)(iii); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4(b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(viii)Reprimand Professionalism; CompetencyRanchesterN/A
26
A-10-008Neal W. Hilston18503/03/201001/07/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(f); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(x); Appraisal Rules Chapter 3 Section 1- Twelve (12) month probation;
- Completion of either "A-25 Eminent Domain" or "Valuation of Conservation Easement"		Deficient appraisal; Jurisdictional ExceptionHulettN/A
27
A-10-007Gregory S. Strable71202/02/201010/21/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 15(b)- Six (6) month suspension, stayed for (one) 1 year probation;
- Quarterly log presented to the Board with a complete work file;
- Formal request for reinstatement of his permit		Negligent appraisalEdgertonN/A
28
A-10-006Gregory S. Strable71204/06/2009 01/11/201010/27/2010StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3- Twelve (12) month probation;
- Thirty (30) day suspension;
- $5,000.00 fine;
-Completion of Supervisor/Trainee course, fifteen (15) hour USPAP course, seven (7) hour ethics course, seven (7) hour quality assurance/USPAP violation course;
- Provide list of trainees to the Board		Failure to inspect the property; Reported false informationEncampment
29
A-10-004Gregory S. Strable71204/06/2009 12/22/200910/27/2010StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3- Twelve (12) month probation;
- Thirty (30) day suspension;
- $5,000.00 fine;
-Completion of Supervisor/Trainee course, fifteen (15) hour USPAP course, seven (7) hour ethics course, seven (7) hour quality assurance/USPAP violation course;
- Provide list of trainees to the Board		Failure to inspect the property; Reported false informationDubois
30
A-10-003Laurie R. Lipp70609/16/20096/2/2010StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c)$500.00 fineDeficient appraisal; RecordkeepingThermopolis
31
A-10-001Keith F. Kasselder15708/05/200901/07/2011StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); Appraisal Rules Chapter 3 Section 1 $750.00 fineDeficient appraisalLander
32
A-09-006Gregory S. Strable71204/06/200910/27/2010StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 17(a)(i), (v)- Twelve (12) month probation;
- Thirty (30) day suspension;
- $5,000.00 fine;
-Completion of Supervisor/Trainee course, fifteen (15) hour USPAP course, seven (7) hour ethics course, seven (7) hour quality assurance/USPAP violation course;
- Provide list of trainees to the Board		Failure to inspect the property; Reported false information; Failure to maintain an appraisal log; Failure to identify appraisal assistanceRiverton
33
A-09-004James Hastings9412/01/200810/27/2010StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-5(a); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 3 Section 1 - Ninety (90) day suspension;
- Completion of seven (7) hour USPAP course, seven (7) hour quality assurance appraisal course, fifteen (15) hour residential report writing and case studies course with exam		Deficient appraisalCheyenneN/A
34
A-09-003Sarah J. Juschka55207/31/200803/25/2009StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b), and (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(e)(i),(ii)(iii),(iv) and (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4 (a)(b) and (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-6 (a) and (b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1 (a) and (b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2 (b)(iii),(v),(vii),(ix) and (xii) and USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(b),(d)(i) and (ii)- $500.00 fine;
- Eighteen (18) months probation;
- Completion of a supervisor/trainee course;
- Must accompany all appraiser trainees to inspections		Inaccurate response on permit renewal
35
A-09-002Charles P. Morris66207/08/200806/30/2009StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv); USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(c); USPAP Standards Rules 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(e)- $5,000.00 fine;
- Twenty-four (24) month conditional probation;
- Completion of a seven (7) hour USPAP update course		Failure to inspect the property; Two appraisals with two values; Altered appraisal documentsLaramie
36
A-08-011Craig W. Smith71305/21/200811/5/2008StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; USPAP Standards Ethics; USPAP Standards Conduct; USPAP Standards Competency; 2008 Edition USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(e)(i), (f), (g), (h); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4(a); USPAP Standards Rule 1-6(a), (b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a), (b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(iii), (vii), (viii), (x), (xi); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(b) Voluntary Surrender of PermitErroneous and inaccurate appraisalBondurantN/A
37
A-08-009Terence Tener04/30/200806/24/2008 5/14/2008Issued DeniedRenewal DeniedNew York, NYN/A
38
A-08-003Clinton B. Cook85301/22/200711/5/2008StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; 2006 Edition USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(c)(i), (ii), (iii), (iv), (e)(ii); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4(a), (b)(i), (ii), (iii), (c)(i), (ii), (iii), (iv); USPAP Standards Rule 1-5(b); USPAP Standards Rule 1-6(a), (b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a), (b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(iii), (iv), (v), (viii); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; USPAP Standards Rule 3-1(b)(i), (ii), (iii), (iv), (v), (c), (d); USPAP Standards Rule 3-2(d)- $400.00 fine;
- One (1) year probation		USPAP violationsCody
39
A-07-011Susan Hunter07/19/200703/25/2009 5/14/2008Dismissed StipulationUSPAP Standards Rule 1; USPAP Standards Rule 2Permit Not RenewedUSPAP violationsDouglasN/A
40
A-07-001Thomas Kysar08/23/20069/18/2007 06/27/2007DeniedN/AN/AN/A
41
A-06-009Sarah J. Juschka55204/03/20063/25/2009Stipulation OrderWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv), (v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(e)(i), (ii), (iii), (iv), (v); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4(a), (b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-6(a), (b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-1(a), (b); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(iii), (v), (vii), (ix), (xii); USPAP Standards Rule 2-3; USPAP Standards Conduct; USPAP Standards Competency; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(b), (d)(i), (ii); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 16(a)(i), (ii)- $500.00 fine;
- Eighteen (18) months probation;
- Completion of a supervisor/trainee course;
- Must accompany all appraiser trainees to inspections;
- Permit Revoked		Deficient appraisal; Failure to disclose assistance; Failure to view the property; Ehtics Rule of Conduct and CompetencyCheyenne
42
A-06-005Wayne B. Harris24402/27/200706/27/2007StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(i), (iv); Appraiser Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a) 15-day StipulationKnowingly answering a renewal question in a false and dishonest mannerRigby, IDN/A
43
A-04-009Robert L. Scherer II2406/07/200408/02/2006StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(e)Reprimand Failure to produce documents and recordsLaramieN/A
44
A-04-001Neal W. Hilston18507/10/200311/08/2006StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(b), (c); USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(c), (f); USPAP Standards Rule 1-4(a), (c)(iii); USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b)(ii), (v), (ix), (x); USPAP Standards Record Keeping; USPAP Standards Conduct; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(a), (b)- Completion of Highest and Best Use course;
- Twelve (12) months probation;
- Submit semi-annual listing of all appraisal reports during probation period		USPAP Violations; Failure to exercise reasonable diligenceCasperN/A
45
A-02-004Ronald G. Wright31004/03/200209/30/2002Settlement Agreement and Consent OrderWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; USPAP Standards Rule 1-2(h)CensuredFailure to identify a hypothetical condition related to the propertyLovellN/A
46
A-99-014Keith F. Kasselder15706/01/2000 08/23/2000Dismissed StipulationWyo. Stat. §33-39-123(a)(v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107- Reprimanded;
- Completion of 36 or 40 hours of continuing education		Inadequate descriptions of comparables; Failure to adequately research comparables; Confusing dicussions of the analysis and conclusions; Failure to disclose the type of report and the intended use of the reportDuboisN/A
47
A-99-012David K. Baker30606/01/2000Settlement AgreementWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv), (v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(b)Voluntary Surrender of PermitIncomplete appraisalPowellN/A
48
A-99-008Keith F. Kasselder15708/23/2000StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107- Reprimanded;
- Completion of 36 or 40 hours of continuing education		Inadequate descriptions of comparables; Failure to adequately research comparables; Confusing dicussions of the analysis and conclusions; Failure to disclose the type of report and the intended use of the reportDuboisN/A
49
A-99-005Robert Tomb26311/09/2000StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv), (v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b), (c); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(b) - Three (3) months supsenion;
- Six (6) month probationary period subject to random audit;
- Completion of thirty (30) hours of elective continuing education during each three (3) year licensing period;
- Completion of the 15 hour USPAP class annually		Utilization of incorrect comparable sales data; Utilization of inaccuragte and erroneous dataCasperN/A
50
A-98-006Robert Tomb26311/9/2000StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv), (v); Wyo. Stat. § 33-39-107; USPAP Standards Rule 1-1(a), (b), (c); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(b) - Three (3) months supsenion;
- Six (6) month probationary period subject to random audit;
- Completion of thirty (30) hours of elective continuing education during each three (3) year licensing period;
- Completion of 15 hour USPAP class annually		Utilization of incorrect comparable sales data; Utilization of inaccuragte and erroneous dataCasperN/A
51
A-98-004Robert L. Scherer II2402/10/1999Letter of ReprimandWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iii), (iv), (v); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 14(b)N/AFailure to perform an appraisalN/AN/A
52
A-98-002Emory D. Smith92OrderUSPAP ViolationsPermit RevokedUSPAP violationsN/AN/A
53
A-98-002Alva E. Edwards19105/13/1998StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-110(b)Voluntary Surrender of PermitActing beyond the scope of permittees permitN/AN/A
54
A-97-009David K. Webster1410/10/1997Letter of ReprimandWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(iv); Appraisal Rules Chapter 1 Section 5(a); USPAP Standard Rules 1-1(b), (c)N/AFailure to diligently research comparable salesCheyenneN/A
55
A-97-003John R. Pexton22405/13/1998Letter of Reprimand & StipulationWyo. Stat. § 33-39-123(a)(v)Completion of thirty-nine (39) hour course and pass an exam for Basic Income Capitalization, Course Level 3USPAP ViolationsDouglasN/A
56
A-96-001Emory D. Smith9209/05/1996 07/06/1998Stipulation15 hour course on USPAP with 1 hour examN/AN/A
57
A-94-001Douglas MacMartin07/11/1994Stipulation
58
-- End of Sheet --
59
60