ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACAD
1
Timestamp
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Adamant Mountain]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Biting Zephyr]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Mirror's Glint]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Mist and Shade]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Rapid Current]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Razor's Edge]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Sanguine Knot]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Spirited Steed]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Tempered Iron]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Tooth and Claw]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"The flavor and core idea of the ________ Combat Tradition appeals to me, regardless of how it was executed in the Adventurer's Guide." [Unending Wheel]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Adamant Mountain]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Biting Zephyr]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Mirror's Glint]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Mist and Shade]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Rapid Current]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Razor's Edge]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Sanguine Knot]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Spirited Steed]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Tempered Iron]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Tooth and Claw]
Rate how much you agree with the following statement:

"I am pleased with the design of the existing maneuvers for the ________ Combat Tradition in the Adventurer's Guide, regardless of whether more options should be added." [Unending Wheel]
What would you like to see added/changed about combat maneuvers or traditions, if anything?
2
12/29/2022 14:43:24AgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeDisagreeNeutralAgreeNeutralNeutralAgreeAgreeAgreeAgree
A better variety of options or changes to existing options
3
12/29/2022 16:35:58Strongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly DisagreeNeutralStrongly AgreeNeutralAgreeNeutralNeutralAgreeDisagreeDisagreeStrongly AgreeNeutralDisagree
More ranged options (for traditional fantasy weapons, not just thrown/rare, though those are great, too). Both as stand alone traditions and scattered into existing traditions to provide more depth. Also, more mobility/control maneuvers peppered throughout. And removing/editing maneuvers that fundamentally do nothing or do what one would expect even without a maneuver.
4
12/29/2022 19:28:50Strongly AgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeDisagreeNeutralNeutralAgreeDisagreeStrongly AgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeStrongly DisagreeAgreeDisagreeDisagreeStrongly Disagree
Many more per short rest! For example, it feels aggravating that something as basic as throwing dirt in someone's eyes—yes, which might temporarily blind, admittedly a strong condition—can only be done 2–3 times before my character has to take a breather. *Most* combat maneuvers feel like something a character should just be able to do, with the maneuver training maybe representing greater proficiency.
5
12/30/2022 8:09:32Strongly AgreeAgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeNeutralNeutralStrongly AgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgree
Not a mindblowing critique but another ranged option. One that focuses on verticality would be neat
6
12/30/2022 10:42:29AgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeNeutralAgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeNeutralDisagreeAgreeNeutralNeutralDisagreeNeutralDisagreeNeutralNeutralNeutralNeutralDisagree
Ranged options, of course, and both more traditions and more options within traditions.

More specific criticisms: the flavor of Unending Wheel has never quite clicked for me. I have a hard time imagining what it’s trying to do. Mist and Shade seems to have a lot of mechanics that rely either on Narrator-fiat or player creativity without a lot of guidance on how they can be used. Crit-centric mechanics are always a bit weird because of how unreliable they are, and I prefer more stable options. I feel the same about highly situational maneuvers like those that interrupt spell casting.

Also, I love stances, and would love to see more of them!
7
12/30/2022 11:18:00NeutralStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeNeutralStrongly AgreeAgreeNeutralNeutralNeutralNeutralNeutralNeutralAgreeAgreeNeutralAgreeAgreeNeutralNeutralNeutralNeutralNeutral
I think there ought to be a set of guidelines for anyone wanting to homebrew a new Combat Tradition. Currently the Adventurer's Guide doesn't provide anyone with tips.
8
12/30/2022 12:54:14Strongly AgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeNeutralAgreeNeutralNeutralAgreeStrongly AgreeNeutralAgree
Add Unending Wheel to Rogues, We need a new tradition for tactical maneuvers (ala 4E Warlord), would call "White Lotus"
9
1/23/2023 18:41:56Strongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeStrongly DisagreeStrongly AgreeStrongly AgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeNeutralAgreeAgreeAgreeStrongly DisagreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeAgreeNeutralNeutral
An Arcane Tradition, such as the one from GPG, would make a great addition.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100