ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABAC
1
Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Valuation of Ethereum by Ryan Allis
2
Model last updated: September 7, 2022, make a copy to edit inputs
Share via this linkbit.ly/ethereumdcfJoin our newsletter:Coinstack.substack.comJoin our Telegram: t.me/thecoinstack
3
4
Model InputsSource/NotesConclusions:
5
Last 6 Month Ethereum Revenue (Mar-Aug '22)$1,839,953,077Glassnode
Ethereum should be worth around 2x-3x more than it is currently worth, and may increase in value as people realize this post-Merge, especially as we close in on 2024 BTC halving
6
Last 6 Month Ethereum Revenue x2$3,679,906,154
Accumulate heavily up until $5k price point
7
Annual PoS Staking Rewards (Based on current price)$825,000,000
8
Annualized Total Revenue (Txs + Staking)$4,504,906,154
9
Profit Margin (No Costs in Distributed Network)100%
10
Current Value Per ETHDCF Value Per ETHDCF Value Per Staked ETHExpected Increase
11
Ether Supply120,425,353Etherscan$1,650$2,965$3,630119.98%
12
13
PE Ratio Comparative ValuationsPE MultipleImplied ValuationCurrent Market CapImplied Value Per ETHExpected Increase
14
Actual Ethereum PE Ratio54$198,701,832,764$198,701,832,764$1,650--%
*Using the last month of revenues *12
15
Average Company in S&P 50020$90,098,123,080$198,701,832,764$783-54.66%
16
Fast Growing Company50$225,245,307,700$198,701,832,764$1,95913.36%
17
Extremely Fast Growing Company100$450,490,615,400$198,701,832,764$3,917126.72%
18
*In the above chart, it's fair to compare Ethereum to a fast or extremely fast growing tech company, thus using a 100 PE ratio to approximate fair value based on current earnings. Compare to Tesla at PE of 100.
19
46
47
ETHEREUM DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW VALUATION - STAKED ETH
48
ASSET NAME Valuation Based on Cash Flows DATE COMPLETED INITIAL INVESTMENT DISCOUNT RATE
49
Ethereum$437,110,271,2909/7/202212%
50
51
YEARYEAR DATE INCOME PROJECTED ANNUAL REVENUE NET CASH DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW PRESENT VALUE
52
REVENUES GROWTH RATE EXPENSES INFLOW LESS OUTFLOW PRESENT VALUE CUMULATIVE PRESENT VALUE
53
12022 $ 4,504,906,154 40%$0 $ 4,504,906,154 $ 4,022,237,638 $ 4,022,237,638 $ 4,022,237,638
54
22023 $ 6,306,868,616 40%$0 $ 6,306,868,616 $ 5,027,797,047 $ 9,050,034,684 $ 9,050,034,684
55
32024 $ 8,829,616,062 40%$0 $ 8,829,616,062 $ 6,284,746,309 $ 15,334,780,993 $ 15,334,780,993
56
42025 $ 12,361,462,487 35%$0 $ 12,361,462,487 $ 7,855,932,886 $ 23,190,713,879 $ 23,190,713,879
57
52026 $ 16,687,974,357 35%$0 $ 16,687,974,357 $ 9,469,204,818 $ 32,659,918,696 $ 32,659,918,696
58
62027 $ 22,528,765,382 30%$0 $ 22,528,765,382 $ 11,413,773,664 $ 44,073,692,360 $ 44,073,692,360
59
72028 $ 29,287,394,996 30%$0 $ 29,287,394,996 $ 13,248,130,146 $ 57,321,822,506 $ 57,321,822,506
60
82029 $ 38,073,613,495 30%$0 $ 38,073,613,495 $ 15,377,293,919 $ 72,699,116,426 $ 72,699,116,426
61
92030 $ 49,495,697,544 30%$0 $ 49,495,697,544 $ 17,848,644,728 $ 90,547,761,153 $ 90,547,761,153
62
102031 $ 64,344,406,807 25%$0 $ 64,344,406,807 $ 20,717,176,916 $ 111,264,938,069 $ 111,264,938,069
63
112032 $ 80,430,508,509 25%$0 $ 80,430,508,509 $ 23,121,849,237 $ 134,386,787,306 $ 134,386,787,306
64
122033 $ 100,538,135,636 25%$0 $ 100,538,135,636 $ 25,805,635,309 $ 160,192,422,615 $ 160,192,422,615
65
132034 $ 125,672,669,545 25%$0 $ 125,672,669,545 $ 28,800,932,264 $ 188,993,354,879 $ 188,993,354,879
66
142035 $ 157,090,836,931 20%$0 $ 157,090,836,931 $ 32,143,897,616 $ 221,137,252,496 $ 221,137,252,496
67
152036 $ 188,509,004,317 15%$0 $ 188,509,004,317 $ 34,439,890,303 $ 255,577,142,799 $ 255,577,142,799
68
162037 $ 216,785,354,965 15%$0 $ 216,785,354,965 $ 35,362,387,365 $ 290,939,530,164 $ 290,939,530,164
69
172038 $ 249,303,158,209 15%$0 $ 249,303,158,209 $ 36,309,594,169 $ 327,249,124,334 $ 327,249,124,334
70
182039 $ 286,698,631,941 10%$0 $ 286,698,631,941 $ 37,282,172,585 $ 364,531,296,919 $ 364,531,296,919
71
192040 $ 315,368,495,135 10%$0 $ 315,368,495,135 $ 36,616,419,503 $ 401,147,716,422 $ 401,147,716,422
72
202041 $ 346,905,344,648 10%$0 $ 346,905,344,648 $ 35,962,554,869 $ 437,110,271,290 $ 437,110,271,290
73
74
75
76
Author's Notes:
77
A DCF gives what the valuation of an asset should be based strictly on the cash flow paid back to holders of an asset (stock, bond, or token). This is separate from any other utility the asset may have such as for using blockchain applications or as a monetary instrument.
78
This Ethereum valuation model that assumes PoS goes live in July 2022. Currently Ethereum uses its revenues to reduce supply (like a stock buyback). By Summer 2022 it will also use revenues to pay staking rewards to holders (like a dividend)
79
You could assume a "Utility Premium" or "Monetary Premium" of 2x to get to the long-term fair value per ETH
80
I assume lower Ethereum growth rates than I actually expect in order to make this DCF model conservative
81
Ethereum is a decentralized blockchain network with no costs. All costs are paid for by a decentralized network of validators. Thus all revenues are profits for the sake of a DCF model.
82
100% of Ethereum revenues will soon flow to long term holders (directly through staking rewards or indirectly through token burns), thus all revenues can be considered earnings.
83
Starting August 2021 with EIP-1559 70% of all ETH transaction are burned, reducing the token supply (like a stock buyback).
84
Starting in July 2022 with the launch of Ethereum PoS all miner fees will be paid out to the stakers of the token (essentially the long term holders), like a stock dividend.
85
Since profits will be used for stock buybacks (token burning) and dividends (staking rewards) going forward, one can use a DCF to approximate today's fair value of Ethereum from a traditional financial perspective
86
Bitcoin doesn't provide any cash flows to holders, nor does it use transaction fees to burn supply, thus you can't do a DCF on holding Bitcoin.
87
Note this DCF does NOT use a terminal value to be conservative. A more traditional way to do this would be to take a terminal value at year 21 onward and take the present value of that to add to today's price. I didn't add that on to be more conservative.
88
Send any questions to me on Twitter @ryanallis
89
90
See Justin Drake's model for valuing Ethereum here
91
See Justin Drake's staking reward model here
92
Learn more about Ethereum and Bitcoin here
93
94
Estimating 2022 Annualized Ethereum Staking Rewards (Post-Merge)
95
Annual Reward in ETHPrice Per EthAdditional Annual Cash Flows to Stakers in Today's Value
96
500,000$1,650$825,000,000
97
98
The annual cash flow to stakers is a conservative estimate as it is based on today's price not the future price AND does NOT include MEV which will also flow to stakers and has recently been around $10-$20M per day in additonal rewards
99
100
What could make this model overly bullish?
101
Transaction revenue may go down as scaling allows for lower cost per transactions, via L2 networks or sidechains like Polygon, Arbitrum, Optimism, ZkRollups, ZkPorter
102
If lower cost per transaction isn't made up for in demand, total revenue could peak at current levels
103
If total revenue stays at current levels for next 20 years and never grows further, ETH would be worth ~$1000 per ETH based on the DCF model
104
You can validate this by making a copy of this model and then changing all growth rates in column F to 0%
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126