ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAEAFAGAHAIAJAKALAMANAOAPAQARASATAUAVAWAXAYAZBABBBCBDBEBFBGBHBIBJBKBLBMBNBOBPBQBRBSBTBUBVBWBXBYBZ
1
study_IDlong_citeshort_citepeer_reviewedcoderexpt_numexpt_conditionsame_infantresponse_modeexposure_phasemethoddependent_measureparticipant_designnative_langinfant_typegroup_name_1group_name_2n_1n_2mean_age_1mean_age_2x_1x_2x_difSD_1SD_2tFdd_varrcorrspecial_cases_measuresage_range_1age_range_2n_excluded_1n_excluded_2gender_1gender_2dependent_measure_2dependent_measure_2_x_diffdependent_measure_2_SD_1dependent_measure_2_SD_2n_excluded_fussersn_excluded_non_criterionexclusion_criteriatest_langcontrast_pseudoIPAcontrast_sampasampa_commentscounterbalancedbacknessheightnasalityroundnesstensenesslengthstimuli_notesF1_1F2_1F1_2F2_2duration_word_1duration_word_2duration_vowel_1duration_vowel_2frequency_1frequency_2frequency_sourceobject_typeobject_noobject_motion_word_coordinationobject_motionmethod_notesresults_extraMSDapproxgeneral_notessame_infant_dich
2
Clarkson1983
Clarkson, M.G., & Berg, W.K. (1983). Cardiac Orienting and Vowel Discrimination in Newborns: Crucial Stimulus Parameters. Child Development, 54(1), 162-171.
Clarkson, & Berg (1983)yesSho TsujiE2NA148physiologytest_onlySAheart_ratewithin_twoEnglishtypicalNANA16NA1.5NANANANANANANANANANANANA1NA33NANANANA250
fussiness, eq errror, exp error
nativea-i_a-i_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: F taken from Peterson and Barney (1952); F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: 136; average.f0: 136; max.f0: 136; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: constant; other: temporal pattern was also varied: continuous (ISI 0s) vs pulsed (ISI 500 ms) presentation; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 500 or 0; SOA: Na; ambient.noise: 30; snr: 40; differ.in:
NANANANA5005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
3
Cheour1998
Cheour, M., Alho, K., Ceponiene, R., Reinikainen, K., Sainio, K., Pohjavuori, M., Aaltonen, O., & Naatanen, R. (1998). Maturation of mismatch negativity in infants. International Journal of Psychophysiology 29, 217-226.
Cheour, Alho, Ceponiene, Reinikainen, Sainio, Pohjavuori, Aaltonen, & Naatanen (1998)
yesSho TsujionlyNA171EEGtest_onlyoddball
peak_amplitude
within_oneFinnishtypicalNANA12NA3NA1.70NA2.41351342NA2.44NANANANANA4NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativey-i_y:-i:_
not_looked_up
1000100
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: 200/1700/2800; F1/F2/F3.2: 200/2400/2800; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
20017002002400100100100100NANANA0
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
no
4
Weir2009
Weir, C. G., & Lamb, J. (1990). Differential sensitivity of newborns to synthetic vowel stimuli. British Journal of Audiology, 24(6), 419–430.
Weir & Lamb (1990)yesSho TsujiE1NA153behaviortest_onlySA
body_movement
within_twoEnglishtypicalNANA40NA3.4NANANANANANANANANANANANA7NANANANANANANANANAnativeae-i{-iAEnglish0020000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: ae: 600/1600/2800; F1/F2/F3.2: i:300/2400/3000; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: NA; IDS: NA; naturalness: NA; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
60016003002400NANANANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
5
Weir2009
Weir, C. G., & Lamb, J. (1990). Differential sensitivity of newborns to synthetic vowel stimuli. British Journal of Audiology, 24(6), 419–430.
Weir & Lamb (1990)yesSho TsujiE2NA154behaviortest_onlySA
body_movement
within_twoEnglishtypicalNANA46NA3.6NANANANANANANANANANANANA7NANANANANANANANANAnativei-aei-{AEnglish0020000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: i:300/2400/3000; F1/F2/F3.2: ae: 600/1600/2800; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: NA; IDS: NA; naturalness: NA; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
30024006002800NANANANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
6
Trehub1973
Trehub, S. E. (1973). Infants Sensitivity to Vowel and Tonal Contrasts. Developmental Psychology, 9(1), 91-96.
Trehub (1973)yesSho TsujiIVNA4behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control10104949NANANANANANA10.46NANANANA7070NANANANANANANANANANA
parental interference, fussiness, failure to reach a priori sucking criterion
nativei-u_i-M_AEnglish1200100
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f3: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: male voice, stimuli matched in noncritical features visually "mingographic" [never seen this word before!!] then resynthesizedײ呜ײ楠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ榀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ懀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ勠3¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ斠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ昀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ漠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ泀Џ字と小文字を区別する(&C)セル内容が完全に同一であるものを検索する(&O)半角と全角を区別する(&B)制御文字を区別する(&T)オプション(&T) >>すべて置換(&A)置換(&R)すべて検索(&I)
34323233809925005005005000.093461068430.08650814733
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:33;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
individual data was sucks converted to percentage of baseline;figures could be used to estimate means
no
7
Swoboda1976
Swoboda, P.J., Morse, P.A., & Leavitt, L.A. (1976). Continuous Vowel Discrimination in Normal and At Risk Infants. Child Development 47(2), 459-465.
Swoboda, Morse, & Leavitt (1976)yesSho TsujionlyNA5behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishmixed
experimental
control202056.956.96.88-2.8NANANANANANANANA
20;5.83;;3;4.49
141445.1545.15NANANANANANA26.1876.321
fussiness, sleeping, criterion, eq error, exp error
nativei-I_i-I_
not_looked_up
1000010
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: 298/2226/2902 i3; F1/F2/F3.2: 336/2144/2776 i5; min.f0: 125; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 80; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: synthesized (Pisoni), 240 ms long, 3 formants with terminal F0 that fell linearly from 125-80H. Four stim varied in equal log steps from I to I. First two were cat. As I by adults, second two as I. Presented with 65db against 45 dB noise; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 45; snr: 20; differ.in:
298222633621442402402402400.093461068430.1302692755
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:20;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
data was sucks per minute;using formula 5 for d (F between 3 cond) some of the infants were at risk for developmental problems, but no significant effects of that found
no
8
Swoboda1976
Swoboda, P.J., Morse, P.A., & Leavitt, L.A. (1976). Continuous Vowel Discrimination in Normal and At Risk Infants. Child Development 47(2), 459-465.
Swoboda, Morse, & Leavitt (1976)yesSho TsujionlyNA6behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishmixed
experimental
control202056.956.95.83-2.8NANANANANANANANANA141445.1545.15NANANANANANA26.1876.321
fussiness, sleeping, criterion, eq error, exp error
artificiali-I'_i-I'_
not_looked_up
1000010
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: 270/2300/3019 i1 or I7 374/2070/2666; F1/F2/F3.2: 298/2226/2902 i1 or I5 336/2144/2776; min.f0: 125; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 80; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: synthesized (Pisoni), 240 ms long, 3 formants with terminal F0 that fell linearly from 125-80H. Four stim varied in equal log steps from I to I. First two were cat. As I by adults, second two as I. Presented with 65db against 45 dB noise; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 45; snr: 20; differ.in:
270230029822262402402402400.093461068430.1302692755
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:20;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
data was sucks per minute;note this control group is the same as in the previous line
no
9
Swoboda1978
Swoboda, P.J., Morse, P.A., & Leavitt, L.A. (1976). Continuous Vowel Discrimination in Normal and At Risk Infants. Child Development 47(2), 459-465.
Swoboda, Morse, & Leavitt (1976)yesSho TsujionlyNA7behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishmixed
experimental
control30NA59.959.9NANANANANANANANANANANA141445.545.5NANANANANANA17.53.5
fussiness, sleeping, criterion, eq error, exp error
nativei-I_i-I_
not_looked_up
1000010
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: 298/2226/2902 i3; F1/F2/F3.2: 336/2144/2776 i5; min.f0: 125; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 80; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: synthesized (Pisoni), 240 ms long, 3 formants with terminal F0 that fell linearly from 125-80H. Four stim varied in equal log steps from I to I. First two were cat. As I by adults, second two as I. Presented with 65db against 45 dB noise; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 45; snr: 20; differ.in:
29822263362144606060600.093461068430.1302692755
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:20;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
Some statistics reported, but only on pre-post changes, as there is no control group. Not included in Tsuji&Cristia(2013), Developmental Psychobiology, bc difficult to compare to other HAS studies
no
10
Swoboda1978
Swoboda, P.J., Morse, P.A., & Leavitt, L.A. (1976). Continuous Vowel Discrimination in Normal and At Risk Infants. Child Development 47(2), 459-465.
Swoboda, Morse, & Leavitt (1976)yesSho TsujionlyNA8behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishmixed
experimental
control30NA59.959.9NANANANANANANANANANANA141445.545.5NANANANANANA17.53.5
fussiness, sleeping, criterion, eq error, exp error
artificiali-I'_i-I'_
not_looked_up
1000010
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: 270/2300/3019 i1 or I7 374/2070/2666; F1/F2/F3.2: 298/2226/2902 i1 or I5 336/2144/2776; min.f0: 125; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 80; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: synthesized (Pisoni), 240 ms long, 3 formants with terminal F0 that fell linearly from 125-80H. Four stim varied in equal log steps from I to I. First two were cat. As I by adults, second two as I. Presented with 65db against 45 dB noise; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 45; snr: 20; differ.in:
27023002982226606060600.093461068430.1302692755
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:20;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
Some statistics reported, but only on pre-post changes, as there is no control group. Not included in Tsuji&Cristia(2013), Developmental Psychobiology, bc difficult to compare to other HAS studies
no
11
Cowan1982
Cowan, N., Suomi, K. & Morse, P. A. (1982). Echoic storage in infant perception. Child Development, 53(4), 984-990.
Cowan, Suomi, & Morse (1982)yesAlex Cristiaexp2NA15behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control1818606014.42-2.64NANANA3.08NANANANANA7714.514.5NANANANANANANANA
fussiness, sleeping
native
[a-a] to [a-ε] OR [ε-ε] to [ε-a] versus control: [a-a] to [ε-a] OR [ε-ε] to [a-ε]
[a-a] to [a-E] OR [E-E] to [E-a] versus control: [a-a] to [E-a] OR [E-E] to [a-E]
rather /a/ F1 750 F2 1150
0NANANANANANA
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: a 750/1150/2400 E 245/2250/3000; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: 200; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 40; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: Notice that they presented pairs of vowels; synthetic, 50 ms long, 0ms within pair, 900ms between pair, amplitude ramped 10ms onset and offset, f0 fell linearly from 200 to 40 hz across 50 ms; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 900; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 45; snr: 22; differ.in:
7501150NANA50505050NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
sucks per 30s;not coding ES because too different from others - REVISIT.
no
12
Cowan1982
Cowan, N., Suomi, K. & Morse, P. A. (1982). Echoic storage in infant perception. Child Development, 53(4), 984-990.
Cowan, Suomi, & Morse (1982)yesAlex Cristiaexp3NA16behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control10106060NA-2.64NANANA2.27NANANANANA775.3333333355.333333335NANANANANANANANA
fussiness, sleeping
native
[a-a] to [a-ε] OR [ε-ε] to [ε-a] versus control: [a-a] to [ε-a] OR [ε-ε] to [a-ε]
[a-a] to [a-E] OR [E-E] to [E-a] versus control: [a-a] to [E-a] OR [E-E] to [a-E]
rather /a/ F1 750 F2 1150
0NANANANANANA
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: a 750/1150/2400 E 245/2250/3000; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: 200; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 40; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: Notice that they presented pairs of vowels; synthetic, 50 ms long, 250ms within pair, 900ms between pair, amplitude ramped 10ms onset and offset, f0 fell linearly from 200 to 40 hz across 50 ms; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 700; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 45; snr: 22; differ.in: diphthonguization
7501150NANA50505050NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
sucks per 30s;not coding ES because too different from others - REVISIT.
no
13
Jusczyk1987
Jusczyk, P. W., & Derrah, C. (1987). Representation of Speech Sounds by Young Infants. Developmental Psychology, 23(5), 648-654.
Jusczyk & Derrah (1987)yesAlex Cristiaonlybu_group12behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control161660.260.25.78-12.03NA10.7412.08NANANANANANA44.144.118.62518.625NANANANANANA22.7225186.25
fussiness, sleeping, eq err, criterion [note: counting here half of the kids excluded for the control group]
native
[bi, bo, ber, ba] to [bi, bo, ber, ba, bu, bu, bu, bu] (randomized)
[bi, bo, b@r, bA] to [bi, bo, b@r, bA, bu, bu, bu, bu] (randomized)
not_looked_up
0NANANANANANA
comments_F: allowed to vary over time; here taking values for the 'stable' portion, at 180 ms; F1/F2/F3.1: well-described in paper (table 1 on p. 650), but not writing the F's for the 'first stimulus set' here because there's a lot of variability; F1/F2/F3.2: 317/966/2240; min.f0: 125; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 100; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: synthetic modeled on male talker, 300 ms, f0 begins 121 rises to 125 at 50 ms and falls linearly to 100 hz at offset; ISI 750 ms; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 750; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 57; snr: 15; differ.in:
NANA317966300300300300NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:25;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
sucks per minute;noting here the 2 minute results, but 4 minute results also reported
no
14
Jusczyk1987
Jusczyk, P. W., & Derrah, C. (1987). Representation of Speech Sounds by Young Infants. Developmental Psychology, 23(5), 648-654.
Jusczyk & Derrah (1987)yesAlex Cristiaonlydu_group13behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control161660.260.210.55-12.03NA11.6812.08NANANANANANA44.144.118.62518.625NANANANANANA22.7225186.25
fussiness, sleeping, eq err, criterion [note: counting here half of the kids excluded for the control group]
native
[bi, bo, ber, ba] to [bi, bo, ber, ba, du, du, du, du] (randomized)
[bi, bo, b@r, bA] to [bi, bo, b@r, bA, bu, bu, bu, bu] (randomized)
not_looked_up
0NANANANANANA
comments_F: allowed to vary over time; here taking values for the 'stable' portion, at 180 ms; F1/F2/F3.1: well-described in paper (table 1 on p. 650), but not writing the F's for the 'first stimulus set' here because there's a lot of variability; F1/F2/F3.2: 317/1100/2240; min.f0: 125; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 100; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: falling; other: synthetic modeled on male talker, 300 ms, f0 begins 121 rises to 125 at 50 ms and falls linearly to 100 hz at offset; ISI 750 ms; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 750; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 57; snr: 15; differ.in:
NANA3171100300300300300NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:25;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
sucks per minute;noting here the 2 minute results, but 4 minute results also reported
no
15
Marean1992
Marean, G., Werner, L., & Kuhl, P. (1992). Vowel categorization by very young infants. Developmental Psychology, 28(3), 396-405.
Marean, Werner, & Kuhl (1992)yesAlex Cristiaonly2mo84behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA10NA60.84NA8050NA41.42583735NANANANANANANANANA11NANANANANANANA45
criterion, fussiness, hearing
nativea-iA-i
not_looked_up
0020000
comments_F: [copied from Kuhl 1979] F1-F3. Steady-state.; F1/F2/F3.1: 775/1064/2614; F1/F2/F3.2: 263/2378/3099; min.f0: 132; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 92; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: With pitch variation ( monotonous and falling mixed both pre and post). Synthesized on terminal analog serial synthesizer. Steady-state, male talker characteristics. F1-F3+ constant (for a and i) upper formants (f4=F10). 500 ms duration.; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 200; SOA: 0; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
775106426323785005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:7000;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:human.distraction;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:7000;CHT.criterion:9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
trials to criterion from the conditioning phase, not the shaping phase; trials to criterion from the categorization phase also reported; d' is shown in graphs but calculated for the group, not individually; percent correct is for the first occurrence in t
no
16
Trehub1973
Trehub, S. E. (1973). Infants Sensitivity to Vowel and Tonal Contrasts. Developmental Psychology, 9(1), 91-96.
Trehub (1973)yesSho TsujiIINA2behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control10106363NANANANANANA6.38NANANANA7777NANANANANANANANANANA
parental interference, fussiness, failure to reach a priori sucking criterion
nativeta-ti_tA-ti_AEnglish1020000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f1: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: male voice, stimuli matched in noncritical features visually "mingographic" [never seen this word before!!] then resynthesizedײ呜ײ楠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ榀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ懀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ勠3¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ斠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ昀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ漠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ泀Џ字と小文字を区別する(&C)セル内容が完全に同一であるものを検索する(&O)半角と全角を区別する(&B)制御文字を区別する(&T)オプション(&T) >>すべて置換(&A)置換(&R)すべて検索(&I)
756130934323235005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:33;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
individual data was sucks converted to percentage of baseline;figures could be used to estimate means
no
17
Trehub1973
Trehub, S. E. (1973). Infants Sensitivity to Vowel and Tonal Contrasts. Developmental Psychology, 9(1), 91-96.
Trehub (1973)yesSho TsujiIIINA3behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control10107070NANANANANANA5.9NANANANA7777NANANANANANANANANANA
parental interference, fussiness, failure to reach a priori sucking criterion
nativea-i_A-i_AEnglish1020000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f2: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: male voice, stimuli matched in noncritical features visually "mingographic" [never seen this word before!!] then resynthesizedײ呜ײ楠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ榀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ懀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ勠3¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ斠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ昀Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ漠Џ¸_x0008_က耀呜ײ呜ײ泀Џ字と小文字を区別する(&C)セル内容が完全に同一であるものを検索する(&O)半角と全角を区別する(&B)制御文字を区別する(&T)オプション(&T) >>すべて置換(&A)置換(&R)すべて検索(&I)
756130934323235005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:33;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
individual data was sucks converted to percentage of baseline;figures could be used to estimate means
no
18
Trehub1973
Trehub, S. E. (1973). Infants Sensitivity to Vowel and Tonal Contrasts. Developmental Psychology, 9(1), 91-96.
Trehub (1973)yesSho TsujiINA1behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control101073.573.5NANANANANANA17.43NANANANA5656NANANANANANANANANANA
parental interference, fussiness, failure to reach a priori sucking criterion
nativepa-pi_pA-pi_AEnglish1020000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: male voice, stimuli matched in noncritical features visually "mingographic" [never seen this word before!!] then resynthesized .5s sound+ .5 s silence; 18dB above room noise level; exp 5-7 skipped because on non-speech; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 38; snr: 18; differ.in:
756130934323235005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:33;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
individual data was sucks converted to percentage of baseline;figures could be used to estimate means
no
19
Trehub1976
Trehub, S. E. (1976).The Discrimination of Foreign Speech Contrasts by Infants and Adults. Child Development 47(2), 466-472.
Trehub (1976)yesSho TsujiINA9behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control101073.573.5NANANANANANA5.25NANANANA77778.258.25NANANANANANA47.5
fussiness, sleeping, criterion, eq error
nonnativepa-pã_pa-pa~_French1001000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: male; .5s sound+.5s silence; matched visually on intensity contour and duration; 6 french native speakers okayed the stimuli; played at 62 dB (noise at infant's head was 38dB); voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 38; snr: 24; differ.in:
6781200692987500500500500NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:33;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
individual data was sucks converted to percentage of baseline;figures could be used to estimate means
no
20
Kuhl1982
Kuhl, P.K., & Miller, J.D. (1982). Discrimination of auditory target dimensions in the presence or absence of variation in a second dimension by infants. Perception & Psychophysics 31(3), 279-292.
Kuhl & Miller (1982)yesSho Tsujionlyno_variation10behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control81678.478.40.2-0.07NANANANANANANANA
8;0.21;;3;10.34
77772.152.15NANANANANANA04.3criterionnativea-i_A-i_
their vowel doesn't correspond to any of the formants given in P&B52, contra their statement… but the closest might indeed be A
1020000
comments_F: F1-F3. Steady-state. ; F1/F2/F3.1: 775/1064/2614; F1/F2/F3.2: 263/2378/3099; min.f0: 132; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 92; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: No pitch variation (either monotonous or falling). Synthesized on terminal analog serial synthesizer. Steady-state, male talker characteristics. F1-F3+ constant (for a and i) upper formants (f4=F10). 500 ms duration.; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 12; snr: 56; differ.in:
775106426323785005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:20;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:colorful bear;size.in:15.8823801742686;dist.from.child.in:30;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
individual data was sucks converted to percentage of baseline; they do an ANOVA including both vowel change in the absence of pitch variation and its control and pitch change in the absence of vowel variation and its control. So pooled SD is calculated in the R script from the information available.
no
21
Kuhl1982
Kuhl, P.K., & Miller, J.D. (1982). Discrimination of auditory target dimensions in the presence or absence of variation in a second dimension by infants. Perception & Psychophysics 31(3), 279-292.
Kuhl & Miller (1982)yesSho Tsujionly
with_variation
11behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control8878.478.40.15-0.08NANANA2.88NANANANANA77772.152.15NANANANANANA04.3criterionnativea-i_A-i_
their vowel doesn't correspond to any of the formants given in P&B52, contra their statement… but the closest might indeed be A
1020000
comments_F: F1-F3. Steady-state. ; F1/F2/F3.1: 775/1064/2614; F1/F2/F3.2: 263/2378/3099; min.f0: 132; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 92; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: the familiarization stimuli varied in pitch. Synthesized on terminal analog serial synthesizer. Steady-state, male talker characteristics. F1-F3+ constant (for a and i) upper formants (f4=F10). 500 ms duration.; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 12; snr: 56; differ.in:
775106426323785005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:20;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:colorful bear;size.in:15.8823801742686;dist.from.child.in:30;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
individual data was sucks converted to percentage of baseline; they do an ANOVA for one part, and t-tests for the other. So ES for the first cond (without pitch variation) based on F of Anova where also a cond with only pitch var was in, and ES for the second cond (with pitch variation) is based on t-test for only that condition.
no
22
Miller1979
Miller, J. L., & Eimas, P. D. (1979). Organization in infant speech perception. Canadian journal of psychology, 33(4), 353-367.
Miller & Eimas (1979)yesAlex Cristiaexp1NA14behaviorhabituationHAS
sucking_time
betweenEnglishtypical
experimental
control123690906.10NANANA1.676NANANANANA606019.519.5NANANANANANA36.661.56
fussiness, sleeping, criterion, eq error, exp error (note: counting here the excluded kids for all of the control groups -- there were 3)
native
[ba-da]-[bae-dae]_
[ba-da]-[b{-d{]_
Aenglish. the authors say nothing but /a/ everywhere, and based on the Fs I guess that it is indeed a: male voice F1 770 (so ok for both) but F2 1220 -- too forward for A, so it could fit a
1000010
comments_F: formants varied somewhat over vowel, here noting the 'steady state'; notice that order was counterbalanced, so I'm noting both vowels in the second stim column; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: a 771/1233/2520, ae 771/1796/2780; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: synthetic, 300 ms; ISI 700 ms; background level of noise 63 dB, stimuli at 75 db; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 700; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: 63; snr: 12; differ.in:
77112337711796300300300300NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:20;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:colorful bear;size.in:15.8823801742686;dist.from.child.in:30;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
sucks per minute;noting here the 2 minute results minus the mean for 2 mins before shift, although other results also reported this is the only one for which stats were reported; IMPORTANT t estimated from approx p - see notes txt file
no
23
Marean1992
Marean, G., Werner, L., & Kuhl, P. (1992). Vowel categorization by very young infants. Developmental Psychology, 28(3), 396-405.
Marean, Werner, & Kuhl (1992)yesAlex Cristiaonly3mo85behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA10NA91.26NA9050NA31.6227766NANANANANANANANANA14NANANANANANANA21
criterion, fussiness, hearing
nativea-iA-i
not_looked_up
0020000
comments_F: [copied from Kuhl 1979] F1-F3. Steady-state.; F1/F2/F3.1: 775/1064/2614; F1/F2/F3.2: 263/2378/3099; min.f0: 132; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 92; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: With pitch variation ( monotonous and falling mixed both pre and post). Synthesized on terminal analog serial synthesizer. Steady-state, male talker characteristics. F1-F3+ constant (for a and i) upper formants (f4=F10). 500 ms duration.; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 200; SOA: 0; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
775106426323785005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:7000;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:human.distraction;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:7000;CHT.criterion:9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
trials to criterion from the conditioning phase, not the shaping phase; trials to criterion from the categorization phase also reported; d' is shown in graphs but calculated for the group, not individually; percent correct is for the first occurrence in t
no
24
Cheour1998
Cheour, M., Alho, K., Ceponiene, R., Reinikainen, K., Sainio, K., Pohjavuori, M., Aaltonen, O., & Naatanen, R. (1998). Maturation of mismatch negativity in infants. International Journal of Psychophysiology 29, 217-226.
Cheour, Alho, Ceponiene, Reinikainen, Sainio, Pohjavuori, Aaltonen, & Naatanen (1998)
yesSho TsujionlyNA172EEGtest_onlyoddball
peak_amplitude
within_oneFinnishtypicalNANA6NA96.5NA3.10NA2.489645312NA3.05NANANANANA15NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativey-i_y:-i:_
not_looked_up
1000100
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: 200/1700/2800; F1/F2/F3.2: 200/2400/2800; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
20017002002400100100100100NANANA0
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
no
25
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp3NA96behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA12NA97.26NA61.850NA9.8NANANANANANANA46.42NA5NANANAd-prime2.829016319NANA04
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nativedet-døtdet-d2t
Danish_2OR9?
0000100
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 355/1879/2576; F1/F2/F3.2: 412/1838/2550; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.333333333333; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
35518794121838NANA100.333333394NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
26
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp3NA97behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA12NA97.26NA54.450NA6.9NANANANANANANA46.42NA5NANANAd-prime1.991858429NANA04
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nativedøt-detd2t-det
Danish_2OR9?
0000100
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 349/1620/2284; F1/F2/F3.2: 412/1838/2550; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.333333333333; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
34916204121838NANA94100.3333333NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
27
Sato2003
Sato, Y., Mori, K., Furuya, I., Hayashi, R., Minagawa-Kawai, Y., & Koizumi, T. (2003). Developmental changes in cerebral lateralization to spoken language in infants: measured by near-infrared spectroscopy. Jpn J Logoped Phoniatr, 44,165–171.
Sato, Mori, Furuya, Hayashi, Minagawa-Kawai, & Koizumi (2003)
NASho TsujiphonemeNA165NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanese typicalNANA7NA100.65NA-0.028375714290NA0.1298108691NANANANANANANA13.42NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativeitta-itte_itta-itte_JapaneseNA110000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
info retrieved by personal communication. Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
no
28
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp2NA92behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA15NA103.76NA51.150NA11.8NANANANANANANA83.26NA7.5NANANAd-prime3.046746899NANA05.5
criterion, scheduling
nativedet-dɛtdet-dEtAEnglish0000010
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 355/1879/2576; F1/F2/F3.2: 412/1838/2550; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 115.666666666667; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
35518794121838NANA100.3333333107.6666667NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
29
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp2NA93behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA15NA103.76NA60.150NA8.6NANANANANANANA83.26NA7.5NANANAd-prime2.220510452NANA05.5
criterion, scheduling
nativedɛt-detdEt-detAEnglish0000010
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 412/1838/2550; F1/F2/F3.2: 355/1879/2576; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 115.666666666667; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
41218383551879NANA107.6666667100.3333333NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
30
Minagawa-Kawai2007a
Minagawa-Kawai, Y., Mori, K., Naoi, N., & Koijima, S. (2007). Neural Attunement Processes in Infants during the Acquisition of a Language-Specific Phonemic Contrast. The Journal of Neuroscience, 27(2), 315–321.
Minagawa-Kawai, Mori,Naoi,& Koijima (2007)
yesSho TsujionlyNA161NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanesetypicalNANA15NA106.47NA0.073517839320NA0.2459022822NA7.18NANANANANA30.42NA8NANANA
activation_difference
0.20364285710.1122890749NANANA
fussiness, motion artifacts, probe placement, parental interference, exp error
native
mama -mama:
mama -mama:
JapaneseNA000001
comments_F: F was always the same, but not reported. Length always differed in 33 ms steps. In this condition, length differences reflect different native categories (session DC) F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: across category length contrast; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANA184217NANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
ts were reported separately for left and right hemisphere, we code average over both (which results in the same as claculating average ES afterwards)
yes
31
Minagawa-Kawai2007a
Minagawa-Kawai, Y., Mori, K., Naoi, N., & Koijima, S. (2007). Neural Attunement Processes in Infants during the Acquisition of a Language-Specific Phonemic Contrast. The Journal of Neuroscience, 27(2), 315–321.
Minagawa-Kawai, Mori,Naoi,& Koijima (2007)
yesSho TsujionlyNA161NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanesetypicalNANA15NA106.47NA-0.001338681130NA0.2874147764NA5.275NANANANANA30.42NA8NANANA
activation_difference
0.21307142860.1559947507NANANA
fussiness, motion artifacts, probe placement, parental interference, exp error
nonnative
mama -mama:
mama -mama:
JapaneseNA000001
comments_F: F was always the same, but not reported. Length always differed in 33 ms steps. In this condition, length differences reflect same native category. could either be session AB (151-184) or CD (217-250). I coded first possibility here F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: across category length contrast; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANA151184NANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
ts were reported separately for left and right hemisphere, we code average over both (which results in the same as claculating average ES afterwards)
yes
32
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA88behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA17NA107.26NA55.750NA8.7NANANANANANANA66.84NA17.25NANANAd-prime2.110059938NANA014.25
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nonnativedɒt-dʌtdAt-dVtAEnglish0010000
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 653/898/2482; F1/F2/F3.2: 672/1454/2425; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 4 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
6538986721454NANA171.25152NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:4;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
;using change score/SD change score (Within-subject version of formula 1) for d
no
33
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA89behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA17NA107.26NA63.450NA9.7NANANANANANANA66.84NA17.25NANANAd-prime2.352595563NANA014.25
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nonnativedʌt-dɒtdVt-dAtAEnglish0010000
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 672/1454/2425; F1/F2/F3.2: 653/898/2482; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 4 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
6721454653898NANA152171.25NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:4;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
34
Minagawa-Kawai2007b
Minagawa-Kawai, Y., Naoi, N., Nishijima, N., Kojima, S., & Dupoux, E. (2007). Developmental Changes in Cerebral Responses to Native and Non-Native Vowels: A NIRS Study]. Proceedings of the International Conference of Phonetic Sciences XVI.
Minagawa-Kawai, Naoi, Nishijima, Kojima, & Dupoux (2007)
NASho TsujionlyNA170NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanese typicalNANA12NA119NA0.12431791650NA0.1929170465NANANANANANANANANA20NANANA
activation_difference
0.25395833330.1815995671NANANA
motion artifacts, scheduling
nativei-ɯ_i-M_JapaneseNA100000
comments_F: 220 Hz F2 difference between S1 and S2, no absolute values reported; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: 1250 ms ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
info retrieved by personal communication. Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
yes
35
Minagawa-Kawai2007b
Minagawa-Kawai, Y., Naoi, N., Nishijima, N., Kojima, S., & Dupoux, E. (2007). Developmental Changes in Cerebral Responses to Native and Non-Native Vowels: A NIRS Study]. Proceedings of the International Conference of Phonetic Sciences XVI.
Minagawa-Kawai, Naoi, Nishijima, Kojima, & Dupoux (2007)
NASho TsujionlyNA170NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanese typicalNANA12NA119NA0.026767414160NA0.2691283225NANANANANANANANANA20NANANA
activation_difference
0.2246250.1844674693NANANA
motion artifacts, scheduling
nonnativeɯ-u_M-u_JapaneseNA100100
comments_F: 220 Hz F2 difference between S1 and S2, no absolute values reported; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: 1250 ms ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
info retrieved by personal communication. Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
yes
36
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp1NA43
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoCatalantypicalNANA12NA120NANANA2.31.7666918242.182384018NANANANA0.303NA34NA2.5NANANANANANANA1.51
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebel-bilbel-bil
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 652/2423/3167; F1/F2/F3.2: 367/2645/3206; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
652242336726450.850.86NANA0.050.14manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
37
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp1NA45
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoCatalantypicalNANA12NA120NANANA-0.031.8706148722.043819953NANANANA0.521NA34NA2.5NANANANANANANA1.51
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebil-belbil-bel
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 367/2645/3206; F1/F2/F3.2: 652/2423/3167; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
367264565224230.860.85NANA0.140.05manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
38
Sebastian2009
Sebastián-Gallés, N., & Bosch, L. (2009). Developmental shift in the discrimination of vowel contrasts in bilingual infants: is the distributional account all there is to it? Developmental science, 12(6), 874–887.
Sebastián-Gallés & Bosch (2009)yesAlex Cristiaexp3
monolingual_4m
71
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_two
Catalan, Spanish
typicalNANA12NA121.68NANANA5.7536.2353829074.6649901754.03NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnativededi-dudi_dedi-dudi_
not_looked_up
1210100
comments_F: e taken from bosch & seb-gal 03; averages over all tokens; first stim = fam, second stim = test; Formant frequency mean values in Hz of the first two formants were obtained from a 150–200 ms central section of the target vowel; F1/F2/F3.1: e 452/2729, u 377/995; F1/F2/F3.2: e 443/2685, u 363/1049; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 6 different female talkers for u, 5 different female talkers for e (this seems odd, perhaps there's an error and it wasn't the same stimuli as in bosh & seb-gal 2003?); voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 65; differ.in:
45227293701022NANANANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:12;visual.stim:simple, colorful animated images;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:35;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:2 same, 2 switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
NB!!!! AGE WAS NOT PROVIDED OTHER THAN '8MO';author provided SDs (except for E2a & 2b, where they are given in the article)
no
39
Sebastian2009
Sebastián-Gallés, N., & Bosch, L. (2009). Developmental shift in the discrimination of vowel contrasts in bilingual infants: is the distributional account all there is to it? Developmental science, 12(6), 874–887.
Sebastián-Gallés & Bosch (2009)yesAlex Cristiaexp3bilingual_4m73
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_two
Catalan, Spanish
bilingualNANA12NA121.68NANANA4.9325.1961524235.3809045092.768NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnativededi-dudi_dedi-dudi_
not_looked_up
1210100
comments_F: e taken from bosch & seb-gal 03; averages over all tokens; first stim = fam, second stim = test; Formant frequency mean values in Hz of the first two formants were obtained from a 150–200 ms central section of the target vowel; F1/F2/F3.1: e 452/2729, u 377/995; F1/F2/F3.2: e 443/2685, u 363/1049; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 6 different female talkers for u, 5 different female talkers for e (this seems odd, perhaps there's an error and it wasn't the same stimuli as in bosh & seb-gal 2003?); voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 65; differ.in:
45227293701022NANANANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:12;visual.stim:simple, colorful animated images;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:35;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:2 same, 2 switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
NB!!!! AGE WAS NOT PROVIDED OTHER THAN '8MO';author provided SDs (except for E2a & 2b, where they are given in the article)
no
40
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp3NA98behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA12NA123.47NA55.850NA12.1NANANANANANANA108.68NA5NANANAd-prime3.492969129NANA04
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nativedet-døtdet-d2t
Danish_2OR9?
0000100
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 412/1838/2550; F1/F2/F3.2: 349/1620/2284; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.333333333333; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
41218383491620NANA100.333333394NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
41
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp3NA99behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA12NA123.47NA63.350NA13.2NANANANANANANA108.68NA5NANANAd-prime3.781644263NANA04
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nativedøt-detd2t-det
Danish_2OR9?
0000100
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 349/1620/2284; F1/F2/F3.2: 412/1838/2550; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.333333333333; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
34916204121838NANA94100.3333333NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
42
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp1NA42
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoSpanishtypicalNANA12NA124NANANA1.652.251666052.25166605NANANANA0.61NA31NA5NANANANANANANA3.51
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebel-bilbel-bil
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 652/2423/3167; F1/F2/F3.2: 365/2615/3199; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
652242336526150.850.86NANA0.28666666670.1666666667manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
43
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp1NA44
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoSpanishtypicalNANA12NA124NANANA-0.42.0091789372.286307066NANANANA0.622NA31NA5NANANANANANANA3.51
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebil-belbil-bel
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 367/2645/3206; F1/F2/F3.2: 652/2423/3167; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
367264565224230.860.85NANA0.16666666670.2866666667manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
44
Sundara2011
Sundara, M., & Scutellaro, A. (2011). Rhythmic distance between languages affects the development of speech perception in bilingual infants. Journal of Phonetics 39(4), 505-513
Sundara & Scutellaro (2011)yes
Megha Sundara
exp1NA183
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_two
English, Spanish
bilingualNANA20NA126NANANA1.363.654.42NANANANA0.364NA33NA9NANANANANANANA27
fussiness, failure to habituate, failure to dishabituate to the post test trial, experimenter error
nativehed–hεdhed-hEd_AEnglish1010011NA54124577201996NANA3142711.94%2.92%
Percentage within all vowels and consonants in English; Denes, 1963; Tobias, 1959; cf. article
0NANANANAno
45
Sato2003
Sato, Y., Mori, K., Furuya, I., Hayashi, R., Minagawa-Kawai, Y., & Koizumi, T. (2003). Developmental changes in cerebral lateralization to spoken language in infants: measured by near-infrared spectroscopy. Jpn J Logoped Phoniatr, 44,165–171.
Sato, Mori, Furuya, Hayashi, Minagawa-Kawai, & Koizumi (2003)
NASho TsujiphonemeNA166NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanese typicalNANA6NA127.49NA0.057511613710NA0.1373006576NANANANANANANA13.42NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativeitta-itte_itta-itte_JapaneseNA110000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
info retrieved by personal communication. Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
no
46
Sundara2011
Sundara, M., & Scutellaro, A. (2011). Rhythmic distance between languages affects the development of speech perception in bilingual infants. Journal of Phonetics 39(4), 505-513
Sundara & Scutellaro (2011)yes
Megha Sundara
exp1NA182
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoEnglishtypicalNANA20NA128NANANA1.923.815.04NANANANA0.452NA30NA9NANANANANANANA27
fussiness, failure to habituate, failure to dishabituate to the post test trial, experimenter error
nativehed–hεdhed-hEd_AEnglish1010011NA54124577201996NANA3142711.94%2.92%
Percentage within all vowels and consonants in English; Denes, 1963; Tobias, 1959; cf. article
0NANANANAno
47
Sato2010
Sato, Y., Sogabe, Y., & Mazuka, R. (2010). Discrimination of phonemic vowel length by Japanese infants. Developmental psychology, 46(1), 106-119.
Sato, Sogabe, & Mazuka (2010)yesAlex Cristiaexp1NA33
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA15NA131NANANA0.8582.7713.0311.056NANANA0.4136643196NA27.378NA4.5NANANANANANANA40
fussiness, exp err
native
mana-ma:na
mana-ma:na
not_looked_up
0000001
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 215.046; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: bell; other: there were 18 tokens of ma:na, which were then artificially shortened to make the mana tokens by removing on average 106 ms of vowel; NOTICE that duration is for the 'ma' syllable, not just the vowel; pitch averages across the averages given for both syll; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural_processed; ISI: 1103.954; SOA: 1500; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 60; differ.in:
NANANANA343.006449.086133.12239.2NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:29;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:1 same 1 oddball, with order counterbalanced across kids;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: 0.296
no
;CI of the difference reported; all same stats provided for pre vs posttest
no
48
Sato2010
Sato, Y., Sogabe, Y., & Mazuka, R. (2010). Discrimination of phonemic vowel length by Japanese infants. Developmental psychology, 46(1), 106-119.
Sato, Sogabe, & Mazuka (2010)yesAlex Cristiaexp1NA34
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA17NA131NANANA-0.3463.1023.380.53NANANA0.6575968788NA27.378NA4.5NANANANANANANA40
fussiness, exp err
native
ma:na-mana
ma:na-mana
not_looked_up
0000001
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 215.046; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: bell; other: there were 18 tokens of ma:na, which were then artificially shortened to make the mana tokens by removing on average 106 ms of vowel; NOTICE that duration is for the 'ma' syllable, not just the vowel; pitch averages across the averages given for both syll; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural_processed; ISI: 1103.954; SOA: 1500; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 60; differ.in:
NANANANA449.086343.006239.2133.12NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:29;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:1 same 1 oddball, with order counterbalanced across kids;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: 0.107
no
;CI of the difference reported; all same stats provided for pre vs posttest
no
49
Figueras2010
Figueras Montiu, M., & Bosch Galceran, L. (2010). Capacidades de discriminación fonética de un contraste vocálico nativo en el prematuro. Psicothema 22(4), 669-676. Retrieved from http://www.unioviedo.es/reunido/index.php/PST/article/view/8935
Figueras Montiu & Bosch Galceran (2010)
NAAlex Cristiaexp1NA60
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_two
Catalan, Spanish
premature
NANA14NA134NANANA-0.356.786.17NANANANANANA49NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativedodi-dudi_dodi-dudi_
not_looked_up
1010000
comments_F: averages over all tokens; first stim = o, second u (averaging over fam and test tokens); dur: o 856 u 916.67; o 843.17 u 873.67; F1/F2/F3.1: o 549/1211, u 377/995; F1/F2/F3.2: o 526/1131 u 363/1049; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 6 different female talkers; ACOUSTIC ANALYSES FROM SEB-GAL & BOSCH 2009; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
537.511713701022849.585896.635278.21173.915NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:12;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:2 same, 2 switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: 0.571428571428571; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
CORRECTED age;also report means, SD and t between first and last familiarization trial
no
50
Polka 1994
Polka, L., & Werker, J. F. (1994). Developmental changes in perception of nonnative vowel contrasts. Journal of experimental psychology: Human perception and performance, 20(2), 421-435.
Polka & Werker (1994) yesSho Tsujiexp2NA54
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoEnglishtypicalNANA12NA135.68NANANANANANANANANANANANA34.42NA8.333333333NANANANANANANANANA
observer agreement, criterion, fussiness, eq error
nativedit-dat_dit-dAt_
no info given, they say "American /a/" so I'm guessing they actually mean A
1020000
comments_F: rangeover 6 tokens, for F2 only; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 69; differ.in:
34323237561309NANANANA0.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:50;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:black-white static checkerboard;size.in:13;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:last.hab&change;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:4: two switch, two same in that order;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
graph with means for CHT + VH part CF.recovery, but no error bars
no
51
Polka 1994
Polka, L., & Werker, J. F. (1994). Developmental changes in perception of nonnative vowel contrasts. Journal of experimental psychology: Human perception and performance, 20(2), 421-435.
Polka & Werker (1994) yesSho Tsujiexp2NA55
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoEnglishtypicalNANA12NA135.68NANANANANANANANANANANANA34.42NA8.333333333NANANANANANANANANA
observer agreement, criterion, fussiness, eq error
nonnativedut-dyt_du:t-dy:t_German1200000
comments_F: rangeover 6 tokens, for F2 only; F1/F2/F3.1: F2 742-1170; F1/F2/F3.2: F2 1658-1739; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 69; differ.in:
NA956NA1698.5NANA187.7187.7NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:50;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:black-white static checkerboard;size.in:13;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:last.hab&change;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:4: two switch, two same in that order;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
graph with means for CHT + VH part CF.recovery, but no error bars
no
52
Polka 1994
Polka, L., & Werker, J. F. (1994). Developmental changes in perception of nonnative vowel contrasts. Journal of experimental psychology: Human perception and performance, 20(2), 421-435.
Polka & Werker (1994) yesSho Tsujiexp2NA56
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoEnglishtypicalNANA12NA135.68NANANANANANANANANANANA34.42NA8.333333333NANANANANANANANANA
observer agreement, criterion, fussiness, eq error
nonnativedʊt-dʏt_dUt-dYt_German1200000
comments_F: rangeover 6 tokens, for F2 only; F1/F2/F3.1: F2 1099-1353; F1/F2/F3.2: F2 1566-1658; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 69; differ.in:
NA1226NA1612NANA90.7590.75NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:50;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:black-white static checkerboard;size.in:13;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:last.hab&change;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:4: two switch, two same in that order;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
graph with means for CHT + VH part CF.recovery, but no error bars
no
53
Bosch2003
Bosch, L., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2003). Simultaneous Bilingualism and the Perception of a Language-Specific Vowel Contrast in the First Year of Life. Language and Speech 46(2-3), 217-243.
Bosch & Sebastian-Galles (2003)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA77
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_two
Catalan, Spanish
bilingualNANA12NA138NANANA4.1635.5185.1352.93NANANA0.575NA23NA2NANANANANANANA20
crying, fussiness, failure to reach familiarization criterion, parental interference
nativedεði -deði_dEDi -deDi_AEnglish1000010
comments_F: F1 & F2 taken from 150-200 ms central section of vowel; F1/F2/F3.1: 675/2526; F1/F2/F3.2: 442/2716; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: first syllable stressed. 18 tokens from 5 female talkers. ; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 65; differ.in:
67525264422716761.9792.8NANANANANA0
fam.length:120;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:image on screen;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:35;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:4,same-switch-same-switch, order counterbalanced;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: 0.75; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
54
Bosch2003
Bosch, L., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2003). Simultaneous Bilingualism and the Perception of a Language-Specific Vowel Contrast in the First Year of Life. Language and Speech 46(2-3), 217-243.
Bosch & Sebastian-Galles (2003)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA75
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_twoCatalantypicalNANA12NA139NANANA2.7465.2295.4163.295NANANA0.855NA25NA3NANANANANANANA20
crying, fussiness, failure to reach familiarization criterion, parental interference
nativedεði -deði_dEDi -deDi_AEnglish1000010
comments_F: F1 & F2 taken from 150-200 ms central section of vowel; F1/F2/F3.1: 675/2524; F1/F2/F3.2: 442/2714; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: first syllable stressed. 18 tokens from 5 female talkers. ; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 65; differ.in:
67525244422714761.9792.8NANANANANA0
fam.length:120;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:image on screen;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:35;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:4,same-switch-same-switch, order counterbalanced;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: 0.833333333333333; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
55
Mazuka2013
Mazuka, R., Hasegawa, M., & Tsuji, S. (2013). Development of non-native vowel discrimination: Improvement without exposure. Developmental Psychobiology, 56(2), 192-209.
Mazuka, Hasegawa, & Tsuji (2013)yesSho TsujiE3NA159
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA28NA139.3236NANANA1.432.142.6NANANANA0.35NA30.42NA18NANANANA14NA
fussiness, eq error, exp error, parental interference, infant behavior
nonnativebu:k-by:kbu:k-by:kGerman0200000
comments_F: mean over 10 tokens; F1/F2/F3.1: F1 390/F2 720; F1/F2/F3.2: F1 350/F2 1870; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 244.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: flat; other: NA; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
3907203501870660656NANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:28;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:counterbalanced for order of same-switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
56
Mazuka2013
Mazuka, R., Hasegawa, M., & Tsuji, S. (2013). Development of non-native vowel discrimination: Improvement without exposure. Developmental Psychobiology, 56(2), 192-209.
Mazuka, Hasegawa, & Tsuji (2013)yesSho TsujiE3NA159
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA28NA139.3236NANANA0.741.932.98NANANANA0.55NA30.42NA18NANANANA14NA
fussiness, eq error, exp error, parental interference, infant behavior
nonnativeby:k-bu:kby:k-bu:kGerman0200000
comments_F: mean over 10 tokens; F1/F2/F3.1: F1 390/F2 720; F1/F2/F3.2: F1 350/F2 1870; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 244.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: flat; other: NA; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
3907203501870660656NANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:28;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:counterbalanced for order of same-switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
57
Sato2010
Sato, Y., Sogabe, Y., & Mazuka, R. (2010). Discrimination of phonemic vowel length by Japanese infants. Developmental psychology, 46(1), 106-119.
Sato, Sogabe, & Mazuka (2010)yesAlex Cristiaexp5NA41
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA24NA140NANANA0.9592.972.5742.255NANANA0.7262613131NA27.378NA11NANANANANANANA9.50
fussiness, exp err
nativemana-mina_mana-mina_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 277.7315; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: bell; other: an additional 10 mina tokens were recorded and judging from the averages it looks like mana was also re-recorded; NOTICE that duration is for the 'ma' syllable, not just the vowel and pitch is averaged across the values given for each syllable; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural_processed; ISI: 1195.3035; SOA: 1500; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 60; differ.in:
63112672972320310.213299.18117.783108.83NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:29;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:1 same 1 oddball, with order counterbalanced across kids;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: 0.346
no
;CI of the difference reported; all same stats provided for pre vs posttest
no
58
Figueras2010
Figueras Montiu, M., & Bosch Galceran, L. (2010). Capacidades de discriminación fonética de un contraste vocálico nativo en el prematuro. Psicothema 22(4), 669-676. Retrieved from http://www.unioviedo.es/reunido/index.php/PST/article/view/8935
Figueras Montiu & Bosch Galceran (2010)
NAAlex Cristiaexp1NA61
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_two
Catalan, Spanish
typicalNANA14NA140NANANA3.56.445.69NANANANANANA31NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativedodi-dudi_dodi-dudi_
not_looked_up
1010000
comments_F: averages over all tokens; first stim = fam, second stim = test; F1/F2/F3.1: o 549/1211, u 377/995; F1/F2/F3.2: o 526/1131 u 363/1049; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 6 different female talkers; ACOUSTIC ANALYSES FROM SEB-GAL & BOSCH 2009; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
537.511713701022849.585896.635278.21173.915NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:12;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:2 same, 2 switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: 0.928571428571429; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
;also report means, SD and t between first and last familiarization trial
no
59
Bosch2003
Bosch, L., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2003). Simultaneous Bilingualism and the Perception of a Language-Specific Vowel Contrast in the First Year of Life. Language and Speech 46(2-3), 217-243.
Bosch & Sebastian-Galles (2003)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA76
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_twoSpanishtypicalNANA12NA140NANANA3.0434.6796.3762.616NANANA0.776NA38NA3NANANANANANANA20
crying, fussiness, failure to reach familiarization criterion, parental interference
nonnativedεði -deði_dEDi -deDi_AEnglish1000010
comments_F: F1 & F2 taken from 150-200 ms central section of vowel; F1/F2/F3.1: 675/2525; F1/F2/F3.2: 442/2715; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: first syllable stressed. 18 tokens from 5 female talkers. ; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 65; differ.in:
67525254422715761.9792.8NANANANANA0
fam.length:120;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:image on screen;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:35;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:4,same-switch-same-switch, order counterbalanced;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: 0.833333333333333; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
60
Mazuka2013
Mazuka, R., Hasegawa, M., & Tsuji, S. (2013). Development of non-native vowel discrimination: Improvement without exposure. Developmental Psychobiology, 56(2), 192-209.
Mazuka, Hasegawa, & Tsuji (2013)yesSho TsujiE1NA155
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA27NA141.1488NANANA0.42.782.9NANANANA0.57NA28.5948NA14NANANANA11NA
fussiness, eq error, exp error, parental interference, infant behavior
nonnativebi:k-be:kbi:k-be:kGerman0010000
comments_F: mean over 10 tokens; F1/F2/F3.1: F1 270/F2 2620; F1/F2/F3.2: F1 360/F2 2550; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 224.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: flat; other: NA; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
27026203602550655625NANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:28;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:counterbalanced for order of same-switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
61
Mazuka2013
Mazuka, R., Hasegawa, M., & Tsuji, S. (2013). Development of non-native vowel discrimination: Improvement without exposure. Developmental Psychobiology, 56(2), 192-209.
Mazuka, Hasegawa, & Tsuji (2013)yesSho TsujiE1NA155
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA27NA141.1488NANANA0.222.923.09NANANANA0.46NA28.5948NA14NANANANA11NA
fussiness, eq error, exp error, parental interference, infant behavior
nonnativebe:k-bi:kbe:k-bi:kGerman0010000
comments_F: mean over 10 tokens; F1/F2/F3.1: F1 270/F2 2620; F1/F2/F3.2: F1 360/F2 2550; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 224.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: flat; other: NA; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
27026203602550655625NANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:28;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:counterbalanced for order of same-switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
62
Sebastian2009
Sebastián-Gallés, N., & Bosch, L. (2009). Developmental shift in the discrimination of vowel contrasts in bilingual infants: is the distributional account all there is to it? Developmental science, 12(6), 874–887.
Sebastián-Gallés & Bosch (2009)yesAlex Cristiaexp1abilingual_4m66
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_two
Catalan, Spanish
bilingualNANA12NA141.17NANANA2.755459.57081435.311622477NANANANANANA17NA2NANANANANANANA1.750
fussiness, parental
nativedodi-dudi_dodi-dudi_
not_looked_up
1010000
comments_F: averages over all tokens; first stim = fam, second stim = test; Formant frequency mean values in Hz of the first two formants were obtained from a 150–200 ms central section of the target vowel; F1/F2/F3.1: o 549/1211, u 377/995; F1/F2/F3.2: o 526/1131 u 363/1049; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 6 different female talkers; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 65; differ.in:
537.511713701022849.585896.635278.21173.915NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:12;visual.stim:simple, colorful animated images;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:35;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:2 same, 2 switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
author_provided
no
63
Sebastian2009
Sebastián-Gallés, N., & Bosch, L. (2009). Developmental shift in the discrimination of vowel contrasts in bilingual infants: is the distributional account all there is to it? Developmental science, 12(6), 874–887.
Sebastián-Gallés & Bosch (2009)yesAlex Cristiaexp1a
monolingual_4m
64
eye-tracking
familiarization
HPP
looking_time
within_two
Catalan, Spanish
typicalNANA12NA142NANANA3.216.905109226.30466494NA15.285NANANANA22NA2NANANANANANANA1.750
fussiness, parental
nativedodi-dudi_dodi-dudi_
not_looked_up
1010000
comments_F: averages over all tokens; first stim = fam, second stim = test; Formant frequency mean values in Hz of the first two formants were obtained from a 150–200 ms central section of the target vowel; F1/F2/F3.1: o 549/1211, u 377/995; F1/F2/F3.2: o 526/1131 u 363/1049; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 6 different female talkers; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: NA; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 65; differ.in:
537.511713701022849.585896.635278.21173.915NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:25000;nb.tokens.trial:12;visual.stim:simple, colorful animated images;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:35;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:4;CF.testDetails:2 same, 2 switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
author_provided
no
64
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA90behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA18NA143.18NA56.750NA12.2NANANANANANANA86.26NA17.25NANANAd-prime2.875567577NANA014.25
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nonnativedɒt-dʌtdAt-dVtAEnglish0010000
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 653/898/2482; F1/F2/F3.2: 672/1454/2425; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 4 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
6538986721454NANA171.25152NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:4;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
65
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA91behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA18NA143.18NA65.150NA9.8NANANANANANANA86.26NA17.25NANANAd-prime2.309882152NANA014.25
criterion, scheduling, eq error, exp error
nonnativedʌt-dɒtdVt-dAtAEnglish0010000
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 672/1454/2425; F1/F2/F3.2: 653/898/2482; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 120.5; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 4 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
6721454653898NANA152171.25NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:4;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
66
Mazuka2013
Mazuka, R., Hasegawa, M., & Tsuji, S. (2013). Development of non-native vowel discrimination: Improvement without exposure. Developmental Psychobiology, 56(2), 192-209.
Mazuka, Hasegawa, & Tsuji (2013)yesSho TsujiE2NA157
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA28NA143.2782NANANA0.181.41.92NANANANA0.34NA28.5948NA22NANANANA16NA
fussiness, eq error, exp error, parental interference, infant behavior
nonnativebu:k-bo:kbu:k-bo:kGerman0010000
comments_F: mean over 10 tokens; F1/F2/F3.1: F1 390/F2 720; F1/F2/F3.2: F1 470/F2 750; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 245; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: flat; other: NA; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
390720470750660630NANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:28;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:counterbalanced for order of same-switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
67
Mazuka2013
Mazuka, R., Hasegawa, M., & Tsuji, S. (2013). Development of non-native vowel discrimination: Improvement without exposure. Developmental Psychobiology, 56(2), 192-209.
Mazuka, Hasegawa, & Tsuji (2013)yesSho TsujiE2NA157
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoJapanesetypicalNANA28NA143.2782NANANA1.332.282.68NANANANA0.59NA28.5948NA22NANANANA16NA
fussiness, eq error, exp error, parental interference, infant behavior
nonnativebo:k-bu:kbo:k-bu:kGerman0010000
comments_F: mean over 10 tokens; F1/F2/F3.1: F1 390/F2 720; F1/F2/F3.2: F1 470/F2 750; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 245; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: flat; other: NA; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
390720470750660630NANANANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:35;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:15000;nb.tokens.trial:10;visual.stim:red & black checkerboard;size.in:19;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:first;CF.window.size:4;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:28;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:counterbalanced for order of same-switch;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
68
Sato2003
Sato, Y., Mori, K., Furuya, I., Hayashi, R., Minagawa-Kawai, Y., & Koizumi, T. (2003). Developmental changes in cerebral lateralization to spoken language in infants: measured by near-infrared spectroscopy. Jpn J Logoped Phoniatr, 44,165–171.
Sato, Mori, Furuya, Hayashi, Minagawa-Kawai, & Koizumi (2003)
NASho TsujiphonemeNA167NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanese typicalNANA7NA154.33NA0.13089428570NA0.1193365195NANANANANANANA13.42NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativeitta-itte_itta-itte_JapaneseNA110000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
info retrieved by personal communication. Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
no
69
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp2NA94behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA15NA166.6NA57.950NA7.8NANANANANANANA44.42NA7.5NANANAd-prime2.01395134NANA05.5
criterion, scheduling
nativedet-dɛtdet-dEtAEnglish0000010
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 355/1879/2576; F1/F2/F3.2: 412/1838/2550; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 115.666666666667; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
35518794121838NANA100.3333333107.6666667NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
70
Polka2011
Polka, Linda, & Bohn, O.-S. (2011). Natural Referent Vowel (NRV) framework: An emerging view of early phonetic development. Journal of Phonetics, 39(4), 467–478.
Polka & Bohn (2011)yesSho Tsujiexp2NA95behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneDanishtypicalNANA15NA166.6NA60.950NA12.1NANANANANANANA44.42NA7.5NANANAd-prime3.124206566NANA05.5
criterion, scheduling
nativedɛt-detdEt-detAEnglish0000010
comments_F: mean (range, length, pitch also available); F1/F2/F3.1: 412/1838/2550; F1/F2/F3.2: 355/1879/2576; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 115.666666666667; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: 3 tokens per vowel; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1500; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
41218383551879NANA107.6666667100.3333333NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.333333333333333;max.trial.duration:4800;nb.tokens.trial:3;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:4800;CHT.criterion:7 out of 8;CHT.criterionByChance:0.0625;CHT.maximum.trials:25;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;no
71
Liu2015
Liu, L. & Kager, R. (2015). Perception of a native vowel contrast by Dutch monolingual and bilingual infants: A bilingual perceptual lead. International Journal of Bilingualism. Advance online publication
Liu & Kager (2015) yesSho TsujionlyNA178
eye-tracking
test_onlyCF
looking_time
within_two
Dutch, one other
bilingualNANA30NA173.7NANANA-0.041853.6184919575.489815215NANANANA0.6309368123NANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnativei-Ii-I
not_looked_up
0000010
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f1: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
72
Liu2015
Liu, L. & Kager, R. (2015). Perception of a native vowel contrast by Dutch monolingual and bilingual infants: A bilingual perceptual lead. International Journal of Bilingualism. Advance online publication
Liu & Kager (2015) yesSho TsujionlyNA174
eye-tracking
test_onlyCF
looking_time
within_twoDutchtypicalNANA50NA176.7NANANA-0.506483.2805297343.563228081NANANANA0.389002466NANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnativei-Ii-I
not_looked_up
0000010
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f1: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
73
Tsao2004
Tsao, F.-M., Liu, H.-M., & Kuhl, P. K. (2004). Speech perception in infancy predicts language development in the second year of life: A longitudinal study. Child Development, 75(4), 1067–1084. Retrieved from http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=16017499
Tsao Liu, & Kuhl (2004)yesAlex CristiaonlyNA82behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA28NA180.0864NA73.6150NA10.98NANANANANANANA18.252NA6NANANANANANANA06criterionnonnativeu-yu:-y:
not_looked_up
0200000
comments_F: single tokens, synthesized; probably more info in Kuhl et al. 1992; F1/F2/F3.1: 289/630; F1/F2/F3.2: 255/1947; min.f0: 120; average.f0: 120; max.f0: 120; range.f0: 0; pitch.contour: flat; other: pitch etc. found in Cardillo 2009; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1729; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
2896302551947271271271271NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:5000;nb.tokens.trial:1;visual.stim:human.distraction;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:5000;CHT.criterion:3 consecutive;CHT.criterionByChance:0.125;CHT.maximum.trials:30;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
;range also given
no
74
Sato2003
Sato, Y., Mori, K., Furuya, I., Hayashi, R., Minagawa-Kawai, Y., & Koizumi, T. (2003). Developmental changes in cerebral lateralization to spoken language in infants: measured by near-infrared spectroscopy. Jpn J Logoped Phoniatr, 44,165–171.
Sato, Mori, Furuya, Hayashi, Minagawa-Kawai, & Koizumi (2003)
NASho TsujiphonemeNA168NIRStest_onlySA
laterality_index
within_oneJapanese typicalNANA6NA181.17NA0.20860NA0.1749468491NANANANANANANA13.42NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativeitta-itte_itta-itte_JapaneseNA110000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
info retrieved by personal communication. Assumed control group with 0 change for ES calculation
no
75
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp2NA47
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoCatalantypicalNANA12NA182NANANA1.541.7666918242.459512147NANANANA0.707NA33NA2.5NANANANANANANA20.5
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebel-bilbel-bil
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 652/2423/3167; F1/F2/F3.2: 367/2645/3206; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
652242336726450.850.86NANA0.050.14manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
76
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp2NA49
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoCatalantypicalNANA12NA182NANANA0.382.3555890982.009178937NANANANA0.654NA33NA2.5NANANANANANANA20.5
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebil-belbil-bel
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 367/2645/3206; F1/F2/F3.2: 652/2423/3167; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
367264565224230.860.85NANA0.140.05manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
77
Marean1992
Marean, G., Werner, L., & Kuhl, P. (1992). Vowel categorization by very young infants. Developmental Psychology, 28(3), 396-405.
Marean, Werner, & Kuhl (1992)yesAlex Cristiaonly
6mo_measure
86behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA10NA182.52NA10050NA17.89265914NANANANANANANANANA18NANANANANANANA24
criterion, fussiness, hearing
nativea-iA-i
not_looked_up
0020000
comments_F: [copied from Kuhl 1979] F1-F3. Steady-state.; F1/F2/F3.1: 775/1064/2614; F1/F2/F3.2: 263/2378/3099; min.f0: 132; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 92; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: With pitch variation ( monotonous and falling mixed both pre and post). Synthesized on terminal analog serial synthesizer. Steady-state, male talker characteristics. F1-F3+ constant (for a and i) upper formants (f4=F10). 500 ms duration.; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 200; SOA: 0; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
775106426323785005005005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:7000;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:human.distraction;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:7000;CHT.criterion:9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:2;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
SD of PC is 0; but as such difficult to calculate valid ES. Therefore, mean of al CHT efect sizes chosen as SD
no
78
Kuhl1983
Kuhl, P. K. (1983). Perception of auditory equivalence classes for speech in early infancy. Infant Behavior and Development, 6(2-3), 263–285.
Kuhl (1983)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA129behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-ɔ_A-O_AEnglish1100100
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male,female; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810;1030/1370/3170; F1/F2/F3.2: 570/840/2410;590/920/2710;680/1060/3180; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 132; range.f0: 40; pitch.contour: falling; other: NA; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010905708405005005005000.059267595770.03818982759
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:10 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
79
Kuhl1983
Kuhl, P. K. (1983). Perception of auditory equivalence classes for speech in early infancy. Infant Behavior and Development, 6(2-3), 263–285.
Kuhl (1983)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA129behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-ɔ_A-O_AEnglish1100100
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male,female; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810;1030/1370/3170; F1/F2/F3.2: 570/840/2410;590/920/2710;680/1060/3180; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 223; range.f0: 131; pitch.contour: falling and rising; other: NA; voice: mixed; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010905708405005005005000.059267595770.03818982759
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:11 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
80
Kuhl1983
Kuhl, P. K. (1983). Perception of auditory equivalence classes for speech in early infancy. Infant Behavior and Development, 6(2-3), 263–285.
Kuhl (1983)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA129behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-ɔ_A-O_AEnglish1100100
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from center.; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1729; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
73010905708405005005005000.059267595770.03818982759
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:12 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
81
Kuhl1983
Kuhl, P. K. (1983). Perception of auditory equivalence classes for speech in early infancy. Infant Behavior and Development, 6(2-3), 263–285.
Kuhl (1983)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA129behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-ɔ_A-O_AEnglish1100100
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male,female; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810;1030/1370/3170; F1/F2/F3.2: 570/840/2410;590/920/2710;680/1060/3180; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 132; range.f0: 40; pitch.contour: falling and rising; other: NA; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010905708405005005005000.059267595770.03818982759
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:13 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
82
Kuhl1983
Kuhl, P. K. (1983). Perception of auditory equivalence classes for speech in early infancy. Infant Behavior and Development, 6(2-3), 263–285.
Kuhl (1983)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA129behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-ɔ_A-O_AEnglish1100100
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from center.; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1729; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
73010905708405005005005000.059267595770.03818982759
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:14 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
83
Kuhl1983
Kuhl, P. K. (1983). Perception of auditory equivalence classes for speech in early infancy. Infant Behavior and Development, 6(2-3), 263–285.
Kuhl (1983)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA129behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA8NA182.52NA67.350NANANANANANANANANA30.42NA5NANANANANANANA15criterionnativea-ɔ_A-O_AEnglish1100100
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male,female; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810;1030/1370/3170; F1/F2/F3.2: 570/840/2410;590/920/2710;680/1060/3180; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 223; range.f0: 131; pitch.contour: falling; other: NA; voice: mixed; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010905708405005005005000.059267595770.03818982759
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:15 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;yes
84
Kuhl1992
Kuhl, P. K.,Williams, K. A., Lacerda, F., Stevens, K. N., & Lindblom, B. (1992). Linguistic Experience Alters Phonetic Perception in Infants by 6 Months of Age. Science, 255(5044), 606-608. doi: 10.1126/science.1736364
Kuhl, Williams, Lacerda,Stevens, & Lindblom (1992)
yesSho TsujionlyNA130behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneSwedishtypicalNANA16NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnonnativei-yi:-y:Swedish0000000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from center.; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1729; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
NANANANA271271271271NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:16 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
85
Kuhl1992
Kuhl, P. K.,Williams, K. A., Lacerda, F., Stevens, K. N., & Lindblom, B. (1992). Linguistic Experience Alters Phonetic Perception in Infants by 6 Months of Age. Science, 255(5044), 606-608. doi: 10.1126/science.1736364
Kuhl, Williams, Lacerda,Stevens, & Lindblom (1992)
yesSho TsujionlyNA131behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA16NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnonnativey-iy:-i:Swedish0000000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from center.; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1729; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
NANANANA271271271271NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:17 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
86
Kuhl1992
Kuhl, P. K.,Williams, K. A., Lacerda, F., Stevens, K. N., & Lindblom, B. (1992). Linguistic Experience Alters Phonetic Perception in Infants by 6 Months of Age. Science, 255(5044), 606-608. doi: 10.1126/science.1736364
Kuhl, Williams, Lacerda,Stevens, & Lindblom (1992)
yesSho TsujionlyNA132behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA16NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnonnativei-yi:-y:Swedish0000000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from center.; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1729; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
NANANANA271271271271NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:18 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
87
Kuhl1992
Kuhl, P. K.,Williams, K. A., Lacerda, F., Stevens, K. N., & Lindblom, B. (1992). Linguistic Experience Alters Phonetic Perception in Infants by 6 Months of Age. Science, 255(5044), 606-608. doi: 10.1126/science.1736364
Kuhl, Williams, Lacerda,Stevens, & Lindblom (1992)
yesSho TsujionlyNA133behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneSwedishtypicalNANA16NA182.52NANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANANAnonnativey-iy:-i:Swedish0000000
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from center.; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1729; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: NA; differ.in:
NANANANA271271271271NANANA0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:NA;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:19 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAno
88
Jansson-Verkalo2010
Jansson-Verkalo, E., Ruusuvirta, T., Huotilainen, M., Alku, P., Kushnerenko, E., Suominen, K., Rytky, S., Luotonen, M., Kaukola, T., Tolonen, U., Hallman, M., (2010). Atypical perceptual narrowing in prematurely born infants is associated with compromised language acquisition at 2 years of age. BMC Neuroscience, 11-88.
Jansson-Verkalo, Ruusuvirta, Huotilainen, Alku, Kushnerenko, Suominen, Rytky, Luotonen, Kaukola, Tolonen, Hallman, (2010)
yesSho TsujionlyNA173EEGtest_onlyoddball
peak_amplitude
within_oneFinnishtypicalNANA13NA182.52NA0.5710NA1.24NANANANANANANA84NANANANANANANANANANANANAnativee-ö_e-2_X-Sampal1000100
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
89
Jansson-Verkalo2010
Jansson-Verkalo, E., Ruusuvirta, T., Huotilainen, M., Alku, P., Kushnerenko, E., Suominen, K., Rytky, S., Luotonen, M., Kaukola, T., Tolonen, U., Hallman, M., (2010). Atypical perceptual narrowing in prematurely born infants is associated with compromised language acquisition at 2 years of age. BMC Neuroscience, 11-88.
Jansson-Verkalo, Ruusuvirta, Huotilainen, Alku, Kushnerenko, Suominen, Rytky, Luotonen, Kaukola, Tolonen, Hallman, (2010)
yesSho TsujionlyNA173EEGtest_onlyoddball
peak_amplitude
within_oneFinnishtypicalNANA13NA182.52NA0.8190NA2.79NANANANANANANA84NANANANANANANANANANANANAnonnativee- _e-7X-Sampal1100100
comments_F: NA; F1/F2/F3.1: NA; F1/F2/F3.2: NA; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: NA; other: NA; voice: ; IDS: ; naturalness: ; ISI: ; SOA: ; ambient.noise: ; snr: ; differ.in:
NANANANANANANANANANANA0NA
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
90
Kuhl1979
Kuhl, P K. (1979). Speech perception in early infancy: perceptual constancy for spectrally dissimilar vowel categories. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 66(6), 1668–1679.
Kuhl (1979)yesSho Tsujiexp1
initialtraining
117behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA183NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-i_A-i_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 132; range.f0: 40; pitch.contour: falling; other: NA; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010902702290NANA5005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:6000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:3 consecutive correct and 9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:6;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
exp1 only reports trials to criterion & gradually adds variation s-somewhat difficult to interpret what infants are picking up on; SD calculated from the raw data, available on the paper
yes
91
Kuhl1979
Kuhl, P K. (1979). Speech perception in early infancy: perceptual constancy for spectrally dissimilar vowel categories. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 66(6), 1668–1679.
Kuhl (1979)yesSho Tsujiexp1
pitchvariation
117behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA183NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-i_A-i_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 132; range.f0: 40; pitch.contour: falling and rising; other: NA; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010902702290NANA5005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:6000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:3 consecutive correct and 9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:6;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
exp1 only reports trials to criterion & gradually adds variation s-somewhat difficult to interpret what infants are picking up on; SD calculated from the raw data, available on the paper
yes
92
Kuhl1979
Kuhl, P K. (1979). Speech perception in early infancy: perceptual constancy for spectrally dissimilar vowel categories. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 66(6), 1668–1679.
Kuhl (1979)yesSho Tsujiexp1
talkervariation
117behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA183NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-i_A-i_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male,female; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010;310/2790/3310; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 223; range.f0: 131; pitch.contour: falling; other: NA; voice: mixed; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010902702290NANA5005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:6000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:3 consecutive correct and 9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:6;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
exp1 only reports trials to criterion & gradually adds variation s-somewhat difficult to interpret what infants are picking up on; SD calculated from the raw data, available on the paper
yes
93
Kuhl1979
Kuhl, P K. (1979). Speech perception in early infancy: perceptual constancy for spectrally dissimilar vowel categories. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 66(6), 1668–1679.
Kuhl (1979)yesSho Tsujiexp1
talkerxpitchvariation
117behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA183NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-i_A-i_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male,female; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010;310/2790/3310; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 223; range.f0: 131; pitch.contour: falling and rising; other: NA; voice: mixed; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010902702290NANA5005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:6000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:3 consecutive correct and 9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:6;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
exp1 only reports trials to criterion & gradually adds variation s-somewhat difficult to interpret what infants are picking up on; SD calculated from the raw data, available on the paper
yes
94
Kuhl1979
Kuhl, P K. (1979). Speech perception in early infancy: perceptual constancy for spectrally dissimilar vowel categories. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 66(6), 1668–1679.
Kuhl (1979)yesSho Tsujiexp1
entireensemble
117behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA4NA183NANANANANANANANANANANANA30.42NA1NANANANANANANA10fussinessnativea-i_A-i_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male, female, child in that order; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810;1030/1370/3170; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010;310/2790/3310;370/3200/3730; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 264; range.f0: 131; pitch.contour: falling and rising; other: NA; voice: mixed; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010902702290NANA5005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:6000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:3 consecutive correct and 9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:6;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
exp1 only reports trials to criterion & gradually adds variation s-somewhat difficult to interpret what infants are picking up on; SD calculated from the raw data, available on the paper
yes
95
Kuhl1979
Kuhl, P K. (1979). Speech perception in early infancy: perceptual constancy for spectrally dissimilar vowel categories. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 66(6), 1668–1679.
Kuhl (1979)yesSho Tsujiexp2NA190behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA8NA183NA79.250NA11.3NA7.2NANANANANA30.42NA2NANANANANANANA02criterionnativea-i_A-i_
not_looked_up
1020000
comments_F: F1/F2/F3 for male, female, child in that order; F1/F2/F3.1: 730/1090/2440;850/1220/2810;1030/1370/3170; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010;310/2790/3310;370/3200/3730; min.f0: 92; average.f0: NA; max.f0: 264; range.f0: 131; pitch.contour: fallind and rising; other: NA; voice: mixed; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 68; differ.in:
73010902702290NANA5005000.059267595770.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:6000;nb.tokens.trial:6;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:3 consecutive correct and 9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:6;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
noNAyes
96
Grieser1989
Grieser, D., & Kuhl, P. K. (1989). Categorization of Speech by Infants: Support for Speech-Sound Prototypes. Developmental Psychology, 25(4), 577–588.
Grieser & Kuhl (1989)yesSho Tsujiexp2prototype127behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA16NA184.9536NA64.850NANANANANANANANA
16;77.5;;;9.4
30.42NA7NANANANANANANA34.5
fussiness, criterion
artificiali-i'i-i'
not_looked_up
0000000
comments_F: F1-F3 for center vowels taken from Peterson and Barney (1952); 32 variant stimuli created. F3 constant & reported in paper. F1.1 & F2.1 looked up in Peterson & Barney. F1.2 and F2.2 computed the following way: The center of i' (poor i example) was -90 mel horizontal (F1) and 90 mel vertical (F2) from center of good exemplar. Thus, ; F1/F2/F3.1: 270/2290/3010; F1/F2/F3.2: 212/2348/3010; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: rise-fall; other: Good i vs. variants. Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from 'good' i. F1 & F2 varied, F3 constant; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 60; differ.in:
270229021223485005005005000.093461068430.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;P groupno
97
Grieser1989
Grieser, D., & Kuhl, P. K. (1989). Categorization of Speech by Infants: Support for Speech-Sound Prototypes. Developmental Psychology, 25(4), 577–588.
Grieser & Kuhl (1989)yesSho Tsujiexp2
nonprototype
128behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA16NA184.9536NA77.550NANANANANANANANANA30.42NA8NANANANANANANA34.5
fussiness, criterion
artificiali'-ii'-i
not_looked_up
0000000
comments_F: F1-F3 for center vowels taken from Peterson and Barney (1952); 32 variant stimuli created. F3 constant & reported in paper. F1.1 & F2.1 looked up in Peterson & Barney. F1.2 and F2.2 computed the following way: The center of i' (poor i example) was -90 mel horizontal (F1) and 90 mel vertical (F2) from center of good exemplar. Thus, ; F1/F2/F3.1: 212/2348/3010; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: rise-fall; other: Bad i vs. variants. Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from 'poor' i. F1 & F2 varied, F3 constant; voice: male; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 60; differ.in:
212234827022905005005005000.093461068430.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no;NP groupno
98
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp2NA46
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoSpanishtypicalNANA12NA185NANANA0.911.5242047111.835973856NANANANA0.543NA36NA4NANANANANANANA2.50.5
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebel-bilbel-bil
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 652/2423/3167; F1/F2/F3.2: 367/2645/3206; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
652242336726450.850.86NANA0.28666666670.1666666667manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
99
Pons2012
Pons, F., Albareda-Castellot, B., & Sebastian-Galles, N. (2012). The Interplay Between Input and Initial Biases: Asymmetries in Vowel Perception During the First Year of Life. Child Development 83(3), 965-976.
Pons, Albareda-Castellot, & Sebastian-Galles (2012)
yesSho Tsujiexp2NA48
eye-tracking
habituationCF
looking_time
within_twoSpanishtypicalNANA12NA185NANANA0.21.4202816621.766691824NANANANA0.29NA36NA4NANANANANANANA2.50.5
crying, fussiness, exp error, eq error,criterion
nativebil-belbil-bel
not_looked_up
0010000
comments_F: average (of 10 hab & test stimuli); range available; F1/F2/F3.1: 367/2645/3206; F1/F2/F3.2: 652/2423/3167; min.f0: NA; average.f0: 263; max.f0: NA; range.f0: 190.5; pitch.contour: NA; other: 10 tokens per vowel; voice: female; IDS: yes; naturalness: natural; ISI: 1000; SOA: NA; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 70; differ.in:
367264565224230.860.85NANA0.16666666670.2866666667manuscript0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:40;proportion.same.change:0.5;max.trial.duration:14000;nb.tokens.trial:5;visual.stim:static bw checkerboard;size.in:18.4390889145858;dist.from.child.in:29.5;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:longest;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:24;CF.contrast:same-switch;CF.ntest:2;CF.testDetails:2, same-switch, counterbalances;CHT.responsetimeout:NA;CHT.criterion:NA;CHT.criterionByChance:NA;CHT.maximum.trials:NA;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
yes
; the stimuli differed in frequency for spanish and catalan learning infants: I more frequent for c, e for spanish
no
100
Grieser1989
Grieser, D., & Kuhl, P. K. (1989). Categorization of Speech by Infants: Support for Speech-Sound Prototypes. Developmental Psychology, 25(4), 577–588.
Grieser & Kuhl (1989)yesSho Tsujiexp1NA126behaviorconditioningCHT
pc_head_turns
within_oneEnglishtypicalNANA16NA185.562NA83.650NANANANANANANANANA30.42NA7NANANANANANANA25
fussiness, criterion
nativeε-i_ε-i_
not_looked_up
1010010
comments_F: F1-F3 for center vowels taken from Peterson and Barney (1952); 32 variant stimuli created. F3 constant & reported in paper. F1.1 & F2.1 looked up in Peterson & Barney. For this experiment on between-category contrasts, the center frequencies were taken for average distance measure. ; F1/F2/F3.1: 530/1840/3010; F1/F2/F3.2: 270/2290/3010; min.f0: NA; average.f0: NA; max.f0: NA; range.f0: NA; pitch.contour: rise-fall; other: Values for variants at 30,60,90,120 vertical, horizontal and diagonal axes from center. F1 & F2 varied, F3 constant; voice: NA; IDS: no; naturalness: synthetic; ISI: 1500; SOA: 2000; ambient.noise: NA; snr: 60; differ.in:
530184053022905005005005000.070700305720.09346106843
R.Daland corpus, overall vowel counts
0
fam.length:NA;habituation.criterion:NA;proportion.same.change:NA;max.trial.duration:4500;nb.tokens.trial:NA;visual.stim:NA;size.in:NA;dist.from.child.in:NA;side.degrees:NA;CF.longest.first:NA;CF.window.size:NA;CF.min.hab:NA;CF.max.hab:NA;CF.contrast:NA;CF.ntest:NA;CF.testDetails:NA;CHT.responsetimeout:6000;CHT.criterion:9 out of 10;CHT.criterionByChance:0.03125;CHT.maximum.trials:40;CHT.Max.nb.visits:NA;
proportion.infants.passed: NA; partial.eta.squared: NA; d: NA
no
pc calculated from 81.7% response to cat 2 and 14.5% to cat 1 (thus 85.5% correct rejections);but the actual comparison is about discrimination from baseline category and vice versa.
no