Vocabulary Map for Evidence-Related Resources.xlsx

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L	M	N	O
1	Resource	Element	Binding Strength	Binding	Value Set Display URL	Short Name Description	Work Group	Suggested change to Short Name Description	Rationale/Discussion for change to Short Name Description	Suggested change to Binding Strength	Rationale/discussion for change to Binding Strength	Link to code set in progress (code/display/definition)	External Code Sets	SMEs to Recruit (Type)	SMEs to Recruit (Groups)

2	Evidence	variableDefinition.variableRole	Extensible	EvidenceVariableRole	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-variable-role.html	population \| subpopulation \| exposure \| referenceExposure \| measuredVariable \| confounder	Statistical Content	The role of the evidence variable in this instance of an Evidence Resource (eg, population \| subpopulation \| exposure \| referenceExposure \| measuredVariable \| confounder)	description and code choices are both desired for rapid viewing			EvidenceVariableRole
3	Evidence	variableDefinition.directnessMatch	Extensible	EvidenceDirectness	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-directness.html	low \| moderate \| high \| exact	Quality/Certainty Rating	The degree of matching between the observed evidence variable and the intended evidence variable (eg, low \| moderate \| high \| exact)	description and code choices are both desired for rapid viewing			EvidenceDirectness
4	Evidence	synthesisType	Extensible	SynthesisType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-synthesis-type.html	The particular type of synthesis if this is a synthesis summary	Classifying Content	The method of combining data from multiple studies, such as 'individual patient data meta-analysis	better description	Preferred	Change to Preferred until and unless we can define the use cases where extensible binding strength would be needed	SynthesisType		People designing code systems for evidence synthesis types for use in reporting research results and systematic review findings	COVID-END (Cochrane, MAGIC, Epistemonikos, McMaster), ask in COKA daily update
5	Evidence	studyType	Extensible	StudyType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-study-type.html	The type of study that produced this summary	Classifying Content	The research design for the study or studies from which the evidence is derived	better description	Preferred	Change to Preferred until and unless we can define the use cases where extensible binding strength would be needed	StudyType		People designing code systems for study types for use in reporting research results and systematic review findings	COVID-END (Cochrane, MAGIC, Epistemonikos, McMaster), ask in COKA daily update
6	Evidence	certainty.rating	Preferred	QualityOfEvidenceRating	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-evidence-quality.html	Quality or certainty of the Evidence	Quality/Certainty Rating	Rating of quality or certainty (eg, high \| moderate \| low \| very-low)	description and code choices are both desired for rapid viewing			QualityOfEvidenceRating
7	Evidence	certainty.certaintySubcomponent.type	Extensible	CertaintySubcomponentType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-certainty-subcomponent-type.html	Aspect of quality or certainty being rated	Quality/Certainty Rating					CertaintySubcomponentType
8	Evidence	certainty.certaintySubcomponent.rating	Extensible	CertaintySubcomponentRating	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-certainty-subcomponent-rating.html	Quality or certainty of the Evidence	Quality/Certainty Rating					CertaintySubcomponentRating
9
10	Statistic	statisticType	Extensible	StatisticStatisticType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-statistic-type.html	Type of statistic, eg relative risk	Statistical Content					StatisticStatisticType
11	Statistic	attributeEstimate.type	Extensible	StatisticAttributeEstimateType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-attribute-estimate-type.html	The type of attribute estimate, eg confidence interval or p value	Statistical Content					StatisticAttributeEstimateType
12	Statistic	modelCharacteristic.code	Extensible	StatisticModelCode	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-statistic-model-code.html	Model specification	Statistical Content				Extensible confirmed to support interoperability but we can change to Preferred if we learn that someone else is using another code set (we are not aware of anyone using codes for this concept)	StatisticModelCode	STATO but only has half the codes we need
13	Statistic	modelCharacteristic.value[x]	Extensible	StatisticModelMethod	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-statistic-model-method.html	Model specification details	Statistical Content					StatisticModelMethod
14	Statistic	modelCharacteristic.variable.handling	Required	EvidenceVariableHandling	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-variable-handling.html	continuous \| ordinal \| dichotomous \| polycategorical	Statistical Content	continuous \| ordinal \| dichotomous \| polycategorical (longer description can state: How the variable is classified for use in analysis)	Element to be added	Required	There does not appear to be additional codes that would be relevant. The 4 codes describe the universe of options.	EvidenceVariableHandling	STATO
15
16	EvidenceVariable	handling	Required	EvidenceVariableHandling	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-variable-handling.html	dichotomous \| continuous \| descriptive	Statistical Content	continuous \| ordinal \| dichotomous \| polycategorical (longer description can state: How the variable is classified for use in analysis)	description and code choices are both desired for rapid viewing; code set changed for complete use options	Required	There does not appear to be additional codes that would be relevant. The 4 codes describe the universe of options.	EvidenceVariableHandling	STATO
17	EvidenceVariable	characteristicCombination	Required	CharacteristicCombination	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-characteristic-combination.html	intersection \| union	Classifying Content					CharacteristicCombination
18	EvidenceVariable	characteristic.method	Example	CharacteristicMethod	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-characteristic-method.html	Method used for describing characteristic	Classifying Content	Method used to measure or determine the characteristic	better description			CharacteristicMethod
19	EvidenceVariable	characteristic.groupMeasure	Required	GroupMeasure	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-group-measure.html	mean \| median \| mean-of-mean \| mean-of-median \| median-of-mean \| median-of-median	Statistical Content					GroupMeasure
20
21	Citation	summary.style	Extensible	CitationSummaryStyle	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-citation-summary-style.html	Format for display of the citation	Citation and Classification Tools					CitationSummaryStyle
22	Citation	variantCitation.type	Extensible	CitationVariantType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-citation-variant-type.html	Used to describe the reason for the variant citation, such as version or subpart specification	Citation and Classification Tools					CitationVariantType
23	Citation	publishingModel and alternativeForm.publishingModel	Extensible	PublishingModelType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-publishing-model-type.html	Identify the medium/media in which the cited article is published, eg print, electronic or print-electronic	Citation and Classification Tools					PublishingModelType
24	Citation	journal.journalIssue.citedMedium and alternativeForm.journalIssue.citedMedium	Extensible	JournalIssueMedium	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-journal-issue-medium.html	NLM codes Internet or Print (Internet-Without-Issue added for article publication separate from issue)	Citation and Classification Tools					JournalIssueMedium
25	Citation	publicationInfo.publishedIn.type and alternativeForm.publicationInfo.publishedIn.type	Extensible	PublishedInType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-published-in-type.html	Database or book (Dataset was added to the code set)	Citation and Classification Tools					PublishedInType
26	Citation	alternativeTitle.type and alternativeAbstract.type	Extensible	AlternativeTitleType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-alternative-title-type.html	Used to express the reason and specific aspect for the variant [title/abstract], such as language	Citation and Classification Tools					AlternativeTitleType
27	Citation	articleUrl.type	Extensible	ArticleUrlType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-article-url-type.html	Code the reason for different URLs, eg abstract and full-text	Citation and Classification Tools					ArticleUrlType
28	Citation	contributorship.entry.contribution	Extensible	CitationContribution	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-citation-contribution.html	The specific contribution	Citation and Classification Tools					CitationCountribution
29	Citation	contributorship.summary.type	Extensible	ContributorSummaryType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-contributor-summary-type.html	Either authorList or contributorshipStatement	Citation and Classification Tools					ContributorSummaryType
30	Citation	contributorship.summary.style	Extensible	ContributorSummaryStyle	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-contributor-summary-style.html	The format for the display string	Citation and Classification Tools					ContributorSummaryStyle
31	Citation	contributorship.summary.source	Extensible	ContributorSummarySource	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-contributor-summary-source.html	Used to code the producer or rule for creating the display string	Citation and Classification Tools					ContributorSummarySource
32	Citation	classifier	Extensible	CitationClassifier	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-citation-classifier.html	Used for many classifiers including PublicationType, CitationSubset, MeshHeading, Chemical	Citation and Classification Tools					CitationClassifier
33	Citation	medlinePubMed.medlineState	Extensible	MedlinePubMedStatus	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-medline-pubmed-status.html	Completed \| In-Process \| PubMed-not-MEDLINE \| In-Data-Review \| Publisher \| MEDLINE \| OLDMEDLINE	Citation and Classification Tools					MedlinePubMedStatus
34	Citation	medlinePubMed.owner	Extensible	MedlinePubMedOwner	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-medline-pubmed-owner.html	NLM \| NASA \| PIP \| KIE \| HSR \| HMD \| SIS \| NOTNLM	Citation and Classification Tools					MedlinePubMedOwner
35	Citation	medlinePubMed.pubMedPubDate.publicationState and medlinePubMed.publicationState	Extensible	PubMedPubStatus	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-pubmed-pubstatus.html	PubMed Publication Status	Citation and Classification Tools					PubMedPubStatus
36
37	EvidenceReport	type	Extensible	EvidenceReportType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-evidence-report-type.html	Kind of report	Summarization			Preferred	Because we do not yet know the precise uses we do not want to require specific codes for conformance, but we do want to encourage common use of codes for interoperability.	EvidenceReportType	None identified	Defer until actual use
38	EvidenceReport	subject.characteristic.code	Extensible	FocusCharacteristicCode	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-focus-characteristic-code.html	Characteristic code	Summarization				Because we do not yet know the precise uses we do not want to require specific codes for conformance, but we do want to encourage common use of codes for interoperability.	FocusCharacteristicCode	None identified	People designing search portals using PICO concepts	COVID-END (Cochrane, MAGIC, Epistemonikos, McMaster), PICO Portal, ask in COKA daily update
39	EvidenceReport	relatesTo.code	Required	ReportRelationshipType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-report-relation-type.html	replaces \| amends \| appends \| transforms	Summarization				Because we do not yet know the precise uses we do not want to require specific codes for conformance, but we do want to encourage common use of codes for interoperability.	ReportRelationshipType	None identified	Defer until actual use
40	EvidenceReport	section.focus	Extensible	ReportSectionType	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-evidence-report-section.html	Classification of section (recommended)	Summarization			Preferred	Because we do not yet know the precise uses we do not want to require specific codes for conformance, but we do want to encourage common use of codes for interoperability.	ReportSectionType	None identified	Defer until actual use
41	EvidenceReport	section.entryClassifier	Extensible	EvidenceClassifier	http://build.fhir.org/valueset-evidence-classifier-code.html	Extensible classifiers	Classifying Content					EvidenceClassifier
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100