How easy is it to learn Commander's color identity rules in Magic the Gathering? (Responses)

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L	M	N	O	P	Q	R	S	T	U	V	W	X	Y	Z	AA	AB	AC
1	Timestamp	Score	Where did you find this poll? Be specific please but don't dox yourself.	Which of these describes you best?	Multicolor	Within Rules Text	Mentions Another Color	Basic Lands	Reminder Text	Tokens	Fetchlands	Split Cards	Modal Double-Faced cards	Hybrid Mana	Twobrid Mana	Phyrexian Mana	Color Indicators	Pips in Rules Text as Commander	Mentions Another Color as Commander	Reminder text as commander	Tokens as Commander	Modal Double-faced Cards as Commander	Color Indicators as Commander	Hybrid Mana as Commander	Twobrid Mana as Commander	Phyrexian Mana as Commander	Would you change any of these noncommander card rules?	Would you change any of these commander rules?	Do you have any other thoughts on anything?

2	12/6/2025 9:40:54	12 / 22	Discord / blood on the clocktower	I'm just starting	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	White cards only	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Green cards only	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.
3	12/6/2025 9:41:27	18 / 22	Archipelago	I'm just starting	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)
4	12/6/2025 9:43:14	22 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.
5	12/6/2025 9:43:24	19 / 22	Reddit Thread	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)
6	12/6/2025 9:46:36	22 / 22	Hellscube	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)
7	12/6/2025 9:46:41	21 / 22	MSE	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	I would abolish color identity altogether., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.
8	12/6/2025 9:48:19	22 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
9	12/6/2025 9:49:52	22 / 22	Prefer not to answer	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
10	12/6/2025 9:51:13	22 / 22	Archipelago Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Lands should be judged by the color of their borders.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	You shouldn't be able to run off color lands in your deck
11	12/6/2025 9:54:12	22 / 22	Posted by UID 442747240142864384 on MSE discord, soliciting responses.	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	I would abolish color identity altogether., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Back faces like Archangel Avacyn should not restrict CI		Commander is like D&D 5th.
12	12/6/2025 9:54:23	22 / 22	custom magic discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	hybrid mana <- my favorite joke
13	12/6/2025 9:55:19	21 / 22	Hellscube	I'm an established player	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
14	12/6/2025 9:55:29	22 / 22	Overwatch Discord	I have never played a trading card game	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	I've never heard of color identity before, but holy cow this is like the easiest concept ever. Do y'all Magic players really struggle with "is this red?"
15	12/6/2025 9:59:35	22 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
16	12/6/2025 10:00:28	17 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.
17	12/6/2025 10:01:24	15 / 22	fw	I have never played a trading card game	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	White cards only	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Green cards only	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)
18	12/6/2025 10:01:58	12 / 22	my boyfriend is having me do this, he found it on reddit	I'm just starting	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Green cards only	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	I would abolish color identity altogether., Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Lands should be judged by the color of their borders., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	The rules as is make no sense
19	12/6/2025 10:03:23	15 / 22	Archipelago discord	I'm an established player	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White cards only	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Green cards only	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Lands should be judged by the color of their borders., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.
20	12/6/2025 10:12:43	22 / 22	Hellscube	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	The Split and Modal cards changing color identity is something I would want to see, but probably won't happen due to being confusing to new players. That I think is the leading factor to why WoTC is even considering changing hybrid rules, to make it more intuitive. For something interesting about how changing color identity can be useful, see Hellscube 6, the commander cube, where we introduced the based hybrid rule (the one WoTC wants to add) and also allowed phyrexian mana to go in any color. This made drafts much smoother than normal commander cube, with lots of glue cards, and could be useful for real commander draft sets.
21	12/6/2025 10:13:33	13 / 22	Archipelago	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	If a card mentions a color by name, it should have that identity also., Off-color tokens should count for identity., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.	My commander mentioning a color by name should allow me to run that color., If my commander's costs consist of hybrid mana, I should have to choose a color to go into my deck.	Yugioh player takes a Magic quiz, probably fails miserably.
22	12/6/2025 10:14:27	16 / 22	Someone shared it on Discord	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Green cards only	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)		The back face of my commander should not let me run cards of that color.
23	12/6/2025 10:16:33	19 / 22	Hellscube	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Lands should be free., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
24	12/6/2025 10:16:36	22 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.
25	12/6/2025 10:17:32	17 / 22	Dnd 5e tool discord	I've stopped playing	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.
26	12/6/2025 10:19:43	14 / 22	Archipelago Discord	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color., The Phyrexian pips on my commander should not let me run cards of that color.	Two people walk into a bar. One person walks out. People are just milling around.
27	12/6/2025 10:22:02	22 / 22	reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.
28	12/6/2025 10:22:41	14 / 22	BOTC	I have never played a trading card game	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Multicolor cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Lands should be free., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color., I should be able to run cards that are the color(s) of tokens created by my commander., If my commander's costs consist of hybrid mana, I should have to choose a color to go into my deck.
29	12/6/2025 10:25:36	22 / 22	hellscube discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	I would abolish color identity altogether., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
30	12/6/2025 10:27:58	16 / 22	Sent it by a member of the hellscube server	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Either green or white cards; not both	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Lands should be judged by the color of their borders., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.	??? bruh
31	12/6/2025 10:28:19	22 / 22	Reddit Post	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
32	12/6/2025 10:29:20	20 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Lands should be free., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
33	12/6/2025 10:30:17	21 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
34	12/6/2025 10:35:30	16 / 22	discord	I know that the game exists, I don't know anything about it	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White cards only	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Green cards only	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Colorless cards only	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	Multicolor cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Lands should be judged by the color of their borders.	Colored pips inside of the text box of my commander should not let me run cards of that color., The back face of my commander should not let me run cards of that color.	generally i don't think something is a real boardgame unless more time is spent arguing about the rules rather than playing, so that's a point in favor of MtG
35	12/6/2025 10:36:37	19 / 22	mse	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
36	12/6/2025 10:39:40	22 / 22	discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
37	12/6/2025 10:40:39	21 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
38	12/6/2025 10:48:21	20 / 22	hellscube offtopic	in a middle ground between just started and established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Lands should be free., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.
39	12/6/2025 10:48:58	20 / 22	hellscube discord	I'm an established player	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	I would abolish color identity altogether., Multicolor cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Lands should be free., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.		colour identity is fucking stupid
40	12/6/2025 10:53:08	19 / 22	Twixy's Palace Discord	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity., Lands should be judged by the color of their borders., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color., I should be able to run cards that are the color(s) of tokens created by my commander.
41	12/6/2025 10:57:34	15 / 22	sent	I've stopped playing	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	White cards only	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only
42	12/6/2025 10:58:01	22 / 22	5eTools Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.
43	12/6/2025 10:58:06	12 / 22	My roommate	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	No	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White and blue cards	Green cards only	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	I would abolish color identity altogether., Multicolor cards should be able to go into decks of either color., If a card mentions a color by name, it should have that identity also., Off-color tokens should count for identity., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.	My commander mentioning a color by name should allow me to run that color., I should be able to run cards that are the color(s) of tokens created by my commander.
44	12/6/2025 10:58:08	17 / 22	Discord	I've stopped playing	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Green cards only	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color., I should be able to run cards that are the color(s) of tokens created by my commander.
45	12/6/2025 10:59:54	22 / 22	Someone shared it on a Discord channel I'm part of	I've stopped playing	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Lands should be judged by the color of their borders., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	The back face of my commander should not let me run cards of that color.	How many MTG players does it take to screw in a lightbulb? Three. One to do it, two to stand and watch, telling them after the fact how they could have done it three turns faster.
46	12/6/2025 11:14:38	18 / 22	discord	I've stopped playing	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	I was under the impress that alternate casting costs like flashback didn't have to have that colour in the commander as you just couldn't use the flashback casting cost.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	When I played EDH, i used to run a mono blue clone/steal your deck with Braid's Dominaria Summoner as my commander. Was a lot of fun copying and stealing everyone else's decks.
47	12/6/2025 11:21:01	21 / 22	Discord	I've stopped playing	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.	Keywords are a short hand for the rules contained within their reminder text. The rules of Firebending for example have RR in their rules text, and the word "Firebending" is just a way to save space on the card. If the reminder text is just the print out of the rules from a short hand form like keywords, then the colored pips in those rules should be included in color identity.
48	12/6/2025 11:45:01	21 / 22	mse discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	I would abolish color identity altogether., Lands should be free., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.	I would abolish color identity altogether.
49	12/6/2025 11:47:15	22 / 22	MSE discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1tQYve2K4l4VcDTgiJpFQhu2eU_JEudm2fScyX4bPM00/edit?usp=sharing I made a presentation about why the hybrid mana change would be slightly more complicated than most imagine, but I still support it.
50	12/6/2025 11:58:38	11 / 22	Was sent it by a friend on discord	I know that the game exists, I don't know anything about it	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Either green or white cards; not both	Colorless cards only	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	I am so confused...	Ahhhhh something needs ro be changed but Idk enough to know what	AHHHHHH WHAT IS THIS
51	12/6/2025 12:07:16	15 / 22	Blood on the Clocktower friend group	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color., A color indicator on my commander should not let me run cards of that color.	I played commander once and it was with a commander with all 5 colors. I see that saved me a lot of headache lol.
52	12/6/2025 12:08:51	22 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
53	12/6/2025 12:09:08	13 / 22	I am part of a group that plays board games. Many people in this group play Magic, but I do not play trading card games and have never closely watched people play Magic	I have never played a trading card game	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.	I should be able to run cards that are the color(s) of tokens created by my commander.	i literally do not play trading card games so do not take my responses seriously lol
54	12/6/2025 12:12:32	22 / 22	MSE discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	fetch lands that search for named off color basic lands types shouldn't be legal	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
55	12/6/2025 12:27:27	22 / 22	Magic discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	I think the rules the format has established make sense now and are well understood after learning the rules. They may not be intuitive but Magic is confusing so making intuitive restrictions like color identity is very difficult without introducing imbalance.
56	12/6/2025 12:38:19	22 / 22	mse discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
57	12/6/2025 12:48:45	19 / 22	Discord	I'm just starting	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White and blue cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
58	12/6/2025 12:50:16	22 / 22	Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity., Phyrexian mana would be valid, if it wasn't a clear design mistake. I'm not opposed to it changing.	A color indicator on my commander should not let me run cards of that color., A commander with extort or firebending should allow me to run white/black or red cards, respectively	I am established, but I do remember thinking the way that hybrid was made was kinda weird. Especially since it was before the abolishment of the rule that said that colored mana outside your color identity would become colorless. Also, in case anyone brings it up... If the only thing holding you back from being creative is the restrictions of color identity, that says more about your ability to be creative than the necessity of the color identity rules. Additionally, as far as making changes to this being confusing... In a world where most people are starting deckbuilding with either a precon or edhrec, I don't think this is as much of a problem as people are saying. In the first case, WotC can just include hybrid cards in the precon. Rules are now clear. In the second case, if there are decent off-color hybrid cards to use, they will use them. So, they will show up and it will become clear pretty quickly to the new players.
59	12/6/2025 12:51:23	20 / 22	Found in a discord server	I'm just starting	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Multicolor cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color.
60	12/6/2025 13:06:52	22 / 22	A friend posted it to a MTG discord channel	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	I feel like the rules are good as they are. To me color identity is integral to the integrity of the game. I'm an established commander player, but I've also played in limited formats like sealed and draft. Commander to me operates differently than other formats as far as color identity goes and I think for good reason. I look at it from this perspective, your commander is an extension of you as a player but your commander is what ultimately gives your deck its identity because it literally commands the deck. Having hybrid cards or twobrid cards included in a deck where a color isn't shared by the commander ultimately changes the identity of the deck and therefore in a way feels out of place. I have an Atraxa deck because I love Phyrexians. Imagine me running something like manamorphose in the deck which is hybrid R/G. There's a reason Atraxa isn't red and that is based on magic lore. The red faction of phyrexia kind of separated itself from the others because the leader didn't agree with the others. Adding red, even if hybrid, just wouldn't be true to Atraxa's identity.
61	12/6/2025 13:17:07	22 / 22	Official Magic TCG Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.
62	12/6/2025 13:24:57	22 / 22	On a shared Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	I think that changing the rules of color identity would be incredibly disruptive to the format. The color identity rule is fairly simple. I think that using this quiz to highlight the edge cases where it's not is biased and not a fair or accurate quiz.
63	12/6/2025 13:41:56	20 / 22	hellscube discord	I've stopped playing	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.	A color indicator on my commander should not let me run cards of that color.
64	12/6/2025 13:50:39	22 / 22	UTD MTG Discord Server	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Lands should be free., Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Modal double faced cards should be able to into decks of either color.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.
65	12/6/2025 14:04:00	22 / 22	Friend sent it to me	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	The whole point of a hybrid or split mana cost to me is a unique way to identify that character's dedication or confusion on where to go. While it might be cool, the concept of going into one or the other but not requiring both feels like you making a lore choice where you shouldn't have that option.
66	12/6/2025 14:19:18	22 / 22	R/edh	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
67	12/6/2025 14:19:56	20 / 22	discord	I'm just starting	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.
68	12/6/2025 14:23:47	22 / 22	Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
69	12/6/2025 14:37:17	14 / 22	Friend sent it to me!	I know that the game exists, I don't know anything about it	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Colorless cards only	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	Multicolor cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Reminder text should count for color identity.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color.	I tried my best to give well thought out answers, although this stuff is so so confusing to me! I hope you guys find the results you're looking for- good luck with the project!!! :)
70	12/6/2025 14:38:38	22 / 22	Archipelago	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Split cards should be able to go into decks of either color.
71	12/6/2025 15:21:08	22 / 22	My wife sent it to me	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
72	12/6/2025 15:38:26	21 / 22	Sent by a friend	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)
73	12/6/2025 15:49:16	18 / 22	discord	I know that the game exists, I don't know anything about it	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Either green or white cards; not both	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	Just wondering if it would be possible to merge pips and color indicators to just be pips where the location of the pip on the card determines whether it is mana(top right) or just a color indicator(idk elsewhere)? I feel like this would help determine which cards we can have in our deck given a commander like Archangel Avacyn. Never played and don't know the differences so forgive me, I'm stupid. Also, reminder text could prob exchange the pip/token symbols for the highlighted words or abbreviations to more easily differentiate it from the normal text imo.
74	12/6/2025 16:28:39	22 / 22	Shared via Discord	I've played a little bit of MTG, but don't currently play. I have about 6 games under my belt.	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Off-color tokens should count for identity., I didn't check the box because this is a little more complex. I feel that having a color in card text should count for color identity in some contexts but not others. "protection from X color" and "Target X color" obviously shouldn't give color identity but "target creature becomes X color should" or stuff like that.	I should be able to run cards that are the color(s) of tokens created by my commander., See earlier comment RE: color names in text
75	12/6/2025 19:55:36	17 / 22	Discord	I've stopped playing	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Colorless cards only	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	If a card mentions a color by name, it should have that identity also., Reminder text should count for color identity.	The Phyrexian pips on my commander should not let me run cards of that color.	Just passing by
76	12/6/2025 20:13:39	12 / 22	Roommate	I know that the game exists, I don't know anything about it	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	White cards only	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Either green or white cards; not both	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Lands should be judged by the color of their borders.	Colored pips inside of the text box of my commander should not let me run cards of that color., My commander mentioning a color by name should allow me to run that color.
77	12/6/2025 20:35:15	20 / 22	From a friend	I'm just starting	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)
78	12/6/2025 20:37:42	18 / 22	Discord friend sent it to me	I'm just starting	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Red, green, white, and blue cards only	Multicolor cards should be able to go into decks of either color., Color identity should ignore the pips in the rules text., Lands should be judged by the color of their borders.	Colored pips inside of the text box of my commander should not let me run cards of that color., The Phyrexian pips on my commander should not let me run cards of that color.
79	12/6/2025 23:01:30	22 / 22	From the moxfield link posted in the Official Magic Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Phyrexian mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.
80	12/7/2025 3:38:48	17 / 22	discord	I know that the game exists, I don't know anything about it	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)
81	12/7/2025 6:46:46	22 / 22	The official MTG Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	For a small piece of constructive criticism….There’s more variety to perspectives of not wanting a rule change than “ color identity is perfect as is.”
82	12/7/2025 6:47:37	22 / 22	discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.	The color identity rules are in a comfortable place and it took a long time to get here. I say keep them as they are.
83	12/7/2025 8:03:51	21 / 22	Reddit	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
84	12/7/2025 9:31:28	18 / 22	Texted to me by a player	I know the basics of Magic the Gathering but don't play	No	No	Yes	No	No	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue, black, and red cards	White cards only	Green cards only	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Nothing. Color identity is perfect how it is.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
85	12/7/2025 11:22:05	22 / 22	r/mtg	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.
86	12/7/2025 12:03:52	20 / 22	Black Dragon Discord	I've stopped playing	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White cards only	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	It's fine how it is, though commander is a complex format.	It's fine how it is, though commander is a complex format.	MTG's rules are a complex mess, which is part of the fun.
87	12/7/2025 12:18:42	22 / 22	Discord	I'm an established player	No	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	No	No	No	No	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Reminder text should count for color identity., Off-color tokens should count for identity., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck.	Colored pips inside of the reminder text of my commander should let me run cards of that color., I should be able to run cards that are the color(s) of tokens created by my commander.	I find it vaguely amusing just how invested people are in this whole thing. It’s such a minor question in the grand scheme of things!
88	12/7/2025 12:22:18	18 / 22	told about it	I'm just starting	No	No	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes	No	Yes	White and green cards	Green, blue, and red cards only	Blue and black cards only	White cards only	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	White and red cards	Both green and white cards	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Every color of card (White, blue, black, red, and green)	Lands should be free., Hybrid mana should be able to go into decks of either color., Twobrid mana should be able to go into any deck., Color indicators should be ignored in terms of color identity.	Nothing. Commander color identity is perfect how it is.
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100