ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
1
PLEASE DOWNLOAD ME AS A GOOGLE SHEET OR XLSX!
2
V3 up to 9547 COMPLETED: Scavenger Hunts (Keiken SH23 x2 - ScarletCelestial SH32 x2) and Days of the Week (Kuroiji Monday x2 - ohpishhposh Wednesday x3)
3
DO NOT DELETE YOUR SIGN-UP OR TURN-IN POSTS
4
And as always, thank you to Jhiday and Myelin_sr for making the project (in this much 'easier' form) possible!
5
6
Hello! As you read this, please keep in mind the following:
7
To check your own invalids, set the "Invalid" column to only show TRUE and ctrl+f your MAL username
8
There may be invalids in adjacent cells, so if there is an invalid in Column E please check Column F etc as well!
9
The order of challenges is the same as in your turn-in chronology on the HoF, found here: https://anime.jhiday.net/hof/user/ScarletCelestial#chrono (change my username to your own)
10
If you need to move entries between SHs/Days of the Week to validate challenges, you can use ones listed as invalid on this sheet - but not valid ones or ones already validated
11
If you think your challenge was mistakenly invalidated please say so - there's over 600 invalid challenges and I didn't have the luxury of the Wayback Machine for some of it!
12
Reply normally in the Invalids thread or discord by pinging me (ScarletCelestial) and list the SH/DotW with what changes were made [example below]
13
I will only re-check your challenges when you've replied to all invalids for the specific challenge (SH/DotW) in order to minimise how much I need to re-check
14
15
Example Invalids reply (with bbcode):
16
[b]SH01[/b]
17
Fixed item …anime rated G - All Ages by changing OLD ANIME to NEW ANIME
18
19
[b]SH20[/b]
20
Fixed item …20 mins per episode by switching OLD ANIME with NEW ANIME
21
Screenshot for 20 in rank/popularity added
22
23
Below are some post-mortems for this project since there were a lot of common mistakes that I would like to comment on…
24
Post-Mortem for SH:
25
There were a lot more errors for the old list of challenges, which required less information to be given consistently (especially when giving characters or episodes/timestamps!)
26
Along with DotW, a large number of people did not use their Post Date as Start Date: many misunderstood the rules thinking both challenges allowed previously started
27
The single letter item in SH26 produced a lot of errors since it was next to a character, not a space (for instance, S: would be invalid)
28
Broadcast items saw a lot of errors as some people did not use TV-types, which is the only MAL type with a Broadcast field listed
29
Even if characters were provided for the 10-year age gap item (SH27) sources were often not provided, leading to invalids
30
SH01 saw many errors for the English Alternative title item, as anime used had a synonym/other language title listed or no English Alternative title listed
31
At least 3 users used discord screenshot links - these break in 3 days causing many invalids from missing information!
32
SH15 created a few invalids as characters used for the single name item had nicknames, invalidating them
33
A few people did not take note of the 10+ ep requirement: hopefully this will now decline as Monthlies now have a similar requirement
34
A couple of people used Child characters that have been barred from the Child Character challenge for a reason (Conan Edogawa etc),
35
please be mindful for items requiring Child/Adult characters that if there's any physical/mental age difference it will be invalidated! (The sentiment will be added to the challenge)
36
(for Adults some people use Wei Wuxian which is a complex case due to being reincarnated into a 17-year old body for instance)
37
38
Post-Mortem for DotW:
39
A consistent major issue is that users do not realise that some anime are valid for multiple days, so appear on multiple HoF checklists, causing a large number of duplicate errors
40
The above is caused by airing start date day and broadcast day to both be valid for TV-types
41
As such, as with SH, if a duplicate appeared between a turned-in challenge and a non turned-in challenge I am making the relevant user aware of the issue
42
Along with SH, a large number of people did not use their Post Date as Start Date: many misunderstood the rules thinking both challenges allowed previously started
43
44
Completed:
45
1365 SH turn-ins and 902 Days of the Week turn-ins
46
397 SH invalid challenges and 263 Days of the Week invalid challenges
47
And in total 2267 turn-ins and 660 invalid challenges
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100