Random Balancing

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L	M	O	Q	V	Z
1	https://settlers-united.com/en/
2	New Random Balancing
3
4
5	Implemented			Not eligible (2.1)				Not Evaluated (yet)
6	egypt l3 at 80 mana			Flood of Fish cost reduced from 10 to 4 and 3 fish per mine				Samurai for all wepaons					Goldsmelter x2 (Asi) x1,5 (Roman)		amaz 1 Stone for small Tower +1 Builder	Amazon - 100 % Hp but 10% less iron bars from laboratoy	roman l3 delayed from 110 to 120 mana
7	Ch'ih-Yu's Shield immune to convert, weaken and freeze							Egypt 1,25-1,33? Mana					asia: 1 or 2 Axe (1 wandering Woodcutter to make space)		amaz soldiers: 8% HP instead of -20 HP (L1 92 HP, L2 110 HP, L3 138 HP)	Egypt +3 shovels, -1 pickaxe	asian woodcutter 7 hits
8	Ch'ih-Yu's Shield cost reduced from 20 to 15							Strengthen: 33% speed increase, Healing					max. 147 Mana for Stone to Iron		5 more Manacost for ban (4 Pyramids needed)	Strengthen Soldiers immune to convert	asian farm bugfix
9	Asian tower -1 wood							shield AoE					12% Damage reduction "Chi'ih-Yu's Shield" (from 33%)		2 Mana for the Spell "Fish to Meat" (was 10 Mana)	Strengthen Soldiers cost reduced from 25 to 20	asian smelter/smith ca. -3 sec
10	special swamp in range of asian starting tower							Tombstone etc. +8					-4 Mana "Chi'ih-Yu's Shield" (2 big Tempel = 1 Shieldspell)		max. 133 Mana for "Fish to Meat"	Cursed arrows imune to convert	asian fisher second attempt
11	Asian mines accelarated and more food efficient							wood/stone stack 11/12					startwamp more accessable		16 Mana for the Spell "Horus' Heat" (was 20 Mana)	4 additional starting wood for Amazons	gold production 1 coal + 2 goldore=2gold
12	more lakes							egypt brewery and sphinx half speed, but double mana for barrel					Samu + movespeed + Armor		8 Mana for the Spell "Forest Fire" (was 20 Mana)	Amazon l3 at 90 mana	amazone tower -1 wood or -1 stone
13	second attempt for egyptian fishermen							egypt brewery randomly 1 or 2 beer for 1 wheat/water, increase sphinx speed by 50%					Soldiers + HP		asia fishers second attempt	8 additional starting wood for Asians	egyptian brewery/sphinx x0.5 but mana x2
14								Snowsmelting + dmg					asia Shield + HP regeneration		ANTAGONIST IDEA (evaluate as one change)	3 additional shovels and 1 axe for asians
15
16
17	Estimated Original Balance
18	game phase	super early	early	early mid	late mid	early late	late	super late
19	minute	0-15	15-30	30-45	45-60	60-75	75-90	90+	total
20	Ägy	10	10	4	5	4	4	6	43
21	Amaz	2	6	7	9	10	10	10	54
22	Asi	5	6	5	8	5	5	6	40
23	Römer	8	7	10	10	8	9	8	60
24
25
26	Estimated Effect Induced by Changes
27	game phase	super early	early	early mid	late mid	early late	late	super late
28	minute	0-15	15-30	30-45	45-60	60-75	75-90	90+	total
29	Ägy	0	0	1	2,5	2,5	1,5	0,5	4,5
30	Amaz	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
31	Asi	2	1	3,5	2	1,5	0,5	0,5	10
32	Römer	0	0	0	0	0	0	0	0
33
34
35	Predicted New Balance
36	game phase	super early	early	early mid	late mid	early late	late	super late
37	minute	0-15	15-30	30-45	45-60	60-75	75-90	90+	total
38	Ägy	10	10	5	7,5	6,5	5,5	6,5	51
39	Amaz	2	6	7	9	10	10	10	54
40	Asi	7	7	8,5	10	6,5	5,5	6,5	51
41	Römer	8	7	10	10	8	9	8	60
42
43
44	Definitions							Evaluation
45		Weight
46	Balance	1	Shift of power dynamic					score<1	not eligible
47								balance<1	not eligible
48	Uniqueness	1	To what extend the given change adds/reduces the uniqueness of the given race					anything -5	not eligible
49								else	eligible
50	Logic	1	Harmony/disharmony with the original game logic (philosophie)
51
52	Transparency	0,5	How noticeable the given change is (-5=for everyone, +5=not even best players)
53
54	Strategic Depth (railroading)	1	Whether the change increases the amount of valid strategic options
55
56	Universality	0,1	Compatibility with other game modes
57
58
59	1. Changes for Egyptians
60
61	egypt l3 at 80 mana (IN DISCUSSION)
62		?	-5	-4	-3	-2	-1	0	1	2	3	4	5	?
63	Balance
64												late mid +1,5; early late +2, late+1
65	Uniqueness
66							late l3 is characteristic
67	Logic
68							Asian is similar, temples should give 8 mana
69	Transparency
70							l3 min 60 is noticable
71	Strategic Depth (railroading)
72
73	Universality
74
75	Score	?
76
77
78	egyptian brewery/sphinx x0.5 but mana x2
79		?	-5	-4	-3	-2	-1	0	1	2	3	4	5	?
80	Balance
81
82	Uniqueness
83
84	Logic
85
86	Transparency
87
88	Strategic Depth (railroading)
89
90	Universality
91
92	Score	?
93
94
95	second attempt for egyptian fishermen (max (1-x)x -> x = 1/2)
96		?	-5	-4	-3	-2	-1	0	1	2	3	4	5	YES
97	Balance
98											+1 early mid; +1 late mid; 0,5 early late; 0,5 late; 0,5 superlate
99	Uniqueness
100