Child Murder Master Database (2008-2017)
 Share
The version of the browser you are using is no longer supported. Please upgrade to a supported browser.Dismiss

 
View only
 
 
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAEAFAGAHAIAJAKALAMANAOAPAQARASATAUAVAWAXAYAZBABBBCBDBEBFBGBHBIBJBKBLBMBNBOBPBQBRBSBTBUBVBWBXBYBZCACBCCCDCECFCGCHCICJCKCLCMCNCOCPCQCRCSCTCUCV
1



2
A Sampling of Children Killed in the U.S. by a Parent when Divorce, Separation, Custody, Visitation, Child Support were Mentioned in News Coverage (2008-2017)
3
*Work In Progress* - Last updated 12/07/2017
4
5
TOTAL DEATHS = 618
6
TOTAL CASES = 427
7
8
KEY/CATEGORIES:
9
BrownCases w/ mother as (alleged) killer
10
BLACKCases w/ father as (alleged) killer
11
YellowCases where a family court knowingly placed children into unsupervised contact or custody with a dangerous parent, when there was a safer parent fighting for their child’s safety.
12
Grey Murder-suicide or familicide (during visitation, stemming from divorce/separation, custody issues or to punish the other parent)
13
Blue • Cases with a clear custody/court/family service angle that require more research or cases that require more research because news reports lacked specific details about parents’ custody status and prior court involvement.
• Cases in which parents killed child(ren) with mention of child support, visitation or stemming from separation, divorce, custody issues or to punish the other parent.
14
PINKStepmom or girlfriend charged with murder and father’s role in death varies.
15
yearNew case that has not been added to death/case totals yet
16
17
Child Murder Cases w/ Family Court Failure
18
Filicide in U.S. Family Courts: A Snapshot (2008-2017)
19
TOTAL DEATHS: 77
20
TOTAL CASES: 59
21
22
YearStateCounty(Alleged) KillerChild Victim(s) / Age(s)Date (if known)Kid VicsCircumstancesTagsSource Article Links
23
2017: 10 DEATHS / 8 CASES
24
2017CaliforniaLos AngelesARAMAZD ANDRESSIAN SR."Piqui" Aramazd Andressian Jr. (5)17-Apr-171Father murdered his 5-year-old son, Aramazd Andressian Jr., in failed murder-suicide. Dad survived & charged with murder. Officials have evidence to believe that the Pasadena father planned to kill his son amid a custody battle and tumultuous divorce from his wife Ana Estevez. According to court papers, Estevez and Andressian were both seeking sole custody of the boy during their contentious divorce. Ana Estevez, who called her son Piqui, reported him missing on April 22 when Andressian Sr. failed to turn over the child to his mother for a scheduled custody exchange. They found signs that Andressian Sr. had been plotting the attack for months, and he created a new will just days before. According to LA District Attorney, the circumstantial evidence surrounding Andressian was enough to arrest him on murder charges even before investigators found his son's body. Andressian Sr. eventually confessed, admitting to smothering his son in the back seat of the car with his child's own jacket. • FAMILY COURT
• Divorce
• Custody Battle
• Custody exchange
• Custody evaluator
• Child Welfare Agency
•http://abc7.com/lasd-detectives-discuss-cracking-case-in-south-pasadena-boys-murder/2381474/http%3A%2F%2Fabc7.com%2F2381474%2F
•http://mynewsla.com/crime/2017/08/23/horrified-mom-of-murdered-5-year-old-son-blames-social-workers-courts-killer-dad-gets-25-to-life/
•http://www.cbsnews.com/news/body-of-missing-5-year-old-boy-aramazd-andressian-jr-found-in-california/
•http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/06/26/sheriffs-detective-says-father-of-missing-south-pasadena-boy-spent-last-47-days-in-las-vegas-planned-to-kill-son-amid-divorce-2/
•http://www.cnn.com/2017/06/26/us/california-father-murder-charge/index.html
25
2017CaliforniaSan BernardinoSHAKIR OMARI NUNNDominic Nunn (8) 5-Jan-171Shakir Omari Nunn was charged with murder the death of his son Dominic Nunn (8). A search through county court records revealed that the children’s mother, Alisha Johnson, had filed a restraining order against Shakir Nunn —then two weeks later Nunn filed a restraining order against Johnson, prompting a custody dispute. Nunn was removed from the home after Johnson filed the restraining order, but the order was thrown out because her criminal case was still pending. The restraining orders appeared to stem from a domestic violence incident in early July in which Johnson was arrested on suspicion of battery on a spouse or cohabitant. Court records also show Nunn had primary custody of the children following the incident. Johnson’s criminal case was eventually dismissed, according to court records, but the couple’s custody dispute continued. Johnson was allowed weekly phone calls and visitation with her children every weekend — orders which were ignored by Nunn. The children's aunt (Ramsey) said there were several witnesses to Nunn’s abuse of Johnson— including their children, who lived in fear of their father. “All the kids were very scared of him. They thought if they didn’t do what he said, they would get beat or get in trouble,” Ramsey said. Despite the witness statements and reports made against Nunn, Ramsey said authorities didn’t appear to take the matter seriously until Dominic’s death.• FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody Dispute
• Visitation
• Restraining Order
• Court/Authorities ignored concerns for child's safety
•http://www.vvdailypress.com/news/20170110/update-apple-valley-man-pleads-not-guilty-to-8-year-old-sons-murder-bail-set-at-1-million
•http://www.vvdailypress.com/news/20170106/update-apple-valley-man-arrested-on-suspicion-of-murder-after-death-of-8-year-old-son
26
2017CaliforniaSonomaALVARA CAMARAJuliana (6), Julian Camara (19mos)18-Jun-172Father in bitter custody battle, killed his two children, Juliana (6) and Julian Camara (18mos), in a murder-suicide during a custodial visit over Father's Day weekend. Mother had warned authorities that children were in danger with their father. The weekend was the children's first visit with their father under a shared-custody order approved in Sonoma County family court only three days before. An arrangement their mother, Connie Camara, had clear misgivings about. Santa Rosa police say they have records of calls beginning in April from both the husband and wife, all centered around custody disputes. The children's mother, Connie Camara, wrote, "I sought help on numerous occasions and said many many many times my children were in danger in their father's care." Lt. Lazzarini acknowledged Connie Camara called authorities five times over two and a half days, worried about her kids while they visited Alvaro. But police say they didn't "have any information he was a danger to himself or the children." Father hung himself - The children's cause of death is still being determined. • FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Mom's warnings re child safety w/ dad ignored
• Court approved shared-custody order
• Authorities involved prior to killings
•http://www.ktvu.com/news/ktvu-local-news/262737668-story
•http://abc7news.com/news/santa-rosa-mother-of-murdered-children-breaks-silence/2124348/
•http://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/Killings-of-2-children-by-suicidal-father-baffles-11234574.php
•http://www.pressdemocrat.com/news/7123662-181/autopsies-underway-on-slain-santa?artslide=0
27
2017HawaiiHonoluluGERALD AIKAUReef Aikau (7)Jun-17.1Father going through divorce killed his son, Reef Aikau, in murder-suicide. The 7-year-old boy who Hawaii authorities believe was killed by his father in a murder-suicide was supposed to be on vacation with his mother when the incident happened, but he was unable to secure a passport earlier in the summer. Court documents show while applying for the passport Katherine Aikau wrote she had "immediate safety concerns" for Reef. Court documents give a glimpse into the relationship between Gerald Aikau and his estranged wife, Katherine. The couple was in the middle of divorce proceedings, and Katherine Aikau had filed restraining orders against him, citing physical abuse. She also claimed that her husband was mentally ill and using illegal drugs. Court documents reveal he had recently undergone a drug treatment program. Katherine Aikau wrote that she had planned a trip to Europe and wanted to take her son during his summer vacation, but Gerald Aikau refused to help secure his passport.` The documents also show that Gerald Aikau had a history of family abuse, and that he and his wife, Katherine, were in the middle of a bitter divorce and custody battle for their son.
• FAMILY COURT
• Divorce proceedings
• Child custody battle
• Restraining order, alleged abuse
• Mental illness, substance abuse
• Mom's concerns ignored by court, passport request denied
•http://khon2.com/2017/06/13/police-investigation-underway-in-pauoa/
•http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/35668641/after-a-boys-death-at-the-hands-of-his-father-questions-but-few-answers
•https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/hawaii/articles/2017-06-15/passport-refusal-kept-slain-son-from-vacationing-with-mother
28
2017KansasSedgwickMiranda Miller, STEPHEN "Bo" BodineEvan Brewer (3)2-Sept-171Months before police found 3-year-old Evan Brewer’s body encased in concrete, a woman told a judge that a man living with the boy said he had nearly beat him to death. Four times the boy’s father and others contacted the state agency charged with protecting children, expressing concern about the boy’s safety, said Shayla Johnston, an attorney for Evan’s father. “Evan’s death was predicted and happened, and we begged the court system to save him before he was murdered,” Johnston said Thursday."
--http://www.kansas.com/news/local/crime/article171910312.html
29
2017MissouriWebsterROBERT KINNEYWilliam (5), Robbie Kinney (7)30-Jul-172Just one week after his divorce was finalized, father shot dead his two children, William (5) and Robbie (7), and set his home on fire before turning the gun on himself. In the months leading up to the deaths the children's mother, Liegh Ann Malone, had tried to protect them. Malone said she had primary custody, but the plan was that the boys would spend every other weekend, and one day each week, with their father. Law enforcement records indicate that Missouri Children's Division staff filed seven reports in connection with the Kinney family- twice filed a "danger statement" indicating the agency thought Kinney could harm Robbie and William. But no further action was taken. Malone said she "tried to do no contact" with Kinney for a while after separating. She said she filed for and received an ex parte order, and really wanted a protective order that would keep Robbie and William from their father. But she said she received advice from an attorney that "because he had not physically harmed the children, that there was not a judge that would give a protective order." Additionally, Malone said she doesn't believe the guardian ad litem appointed to her case took her seriously. Malone said that taking the children away from Kinney likely complicated protecting them from him. She said she had evidence of Kinney's abuse of her older children, but "the little boys, I got them out before anything really happened to them." Robert Kinney was the one who actually filed for divorce and it was granted about a week before the three deaths.• FAMILY COURT
• Divorce finalized 1 week prior
• Child Custody
• Protective mom's concerns ignored
• Alleged abuse
• Child welfare agency involvement
•http://www.news-leader.com/story/news/crime/2017/08/27/am-very-private-person-living-through-nightmare/579689001/
•http://www.ktts.com/news/local-news/court-records-shine-light-on-murder-suicide
30
2017New JerseyMercerCHRISTOPHER KUHNQadan Kuhn (2)Oct-17.1Father killed son Qadan Kuhn (2). Homicide by vehicle. Mackenzy Trievel said her son’s father, Christopher Kuhn, was a violent man who abused her for years. Trievel said on Facebook she’d repeatedly petitioned the court to get sole custody of Qadan, but failed. “The system is so messed up [I’ve] told everyone I could what a terrible person [Kuhn] was and how he didn’t deserve to have my son because he was using drugs,” the post read. She wrote the courts never mandated that Kuhn “get help” and gave him custody of the child three days a week.• FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody
• Court ignored moms concerns
- Dad- history of DV, crim record
•http://nypost.com/2017/10/05/mom-of-boy-killed-in-walmart-heist-slams-her-disgusting-ex/
•http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4948624/Cops-Shoplifting-suspect-crashes-leaves-2-year-old-die.html
31
2017PennsylvaniaYorkFRANKIE WILLIAMSKelly June Williams (3) 23-Apr-171Father in custody battle, who warned he'd kill family, shot dead his daughter, Kelly June Williams (3), and his mother Tammy Williams (50) in a murder-suicide pact. Father was granted shared custody despite having threatened to kill child's mother and family if she filed for custody. According to a court order filed April 5, the three-year-old was supposed to be in the custody of her mother, Makayla Lane, as part of a court-ordered shared custody program between Lane and Kelly's father, Frankie. Court documents allege that Williams had threatened to kill the girl's mother and her entire family if she filed for custody, a claim he denied. Lane filed for custody anyway, Lane’s lawyer wrote in a March 13 filing, “Mother has concerns for her safety, but these concerns are outweighed by the concerns for the safety of the child.” Despite fathers threat to kill family- About a month after the custody suit began, a York County judge court ordered the two share custody -- each taking alternative two-week blocks. Police say that "information on the scene indicates this was a planned act or pact between Tammy June Williams and her son Frankie Thomas Williams. The mother of Kelly June Williams had recently filed for full custody." The next custody hearing was scheduled for May.• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Court-ordered shared custody plan
• Dad- granted shared custody depsite threats against mom/kids
• Mom recently filed for full custody
•Father warned he'd kill family, documents say: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2017/04/24/father-warned-hed-kill-family-documents-say/100841480/
•http://www.pennlive.com/news/2017/04/three-year-old_slain_in_york_c.html
•http://local21news.com/news/local/police-three-year-old-killed-after-mother-son-plan-murder-suicide-in-manchester-township
•http://www.ldnews.com/story/news/crime/2017/05/12/murder-suicide-manchester-township/100901834/
•http://nypost.com/2017/04/24/man-kills-mom-daughter-and-himself-in-murder-suicide-pact-cops/
32
2016: 14 DEATHS / 9 CASES
33
2016ArizonaMaricopaJERAD ARISMENDEZ Audrey (5), Ariah Arismendez (4) Oct-162Father killed his two daughters, Audrey Arismendez (5 years), Ariah Arismendez (4 years) in murder-suicide. The blueprint was penned in August by the girls’ mother, Carmen Castillo. While she expressed reservations about “unrestricted” contact between her ex-husband and daughters, there was little in court records that could have predicted the tragedy that unfolded. Court records show Carmen filed and received an order of protection against Jerad in June, amid divorce proceedings that finalized in August. The two had been married for 16 years. The order-of-protection filing offers a chilling glimpse of the family in retrospect, alleging “violent tendencies” and obsessive behavior on the part of Jerad. But Carmen never alleged her ex would harm the children intentionally. When drafting her custody agreement, she proposed “reasonable restrictions” with the girls. In order of protection: “He threatened harm if I tried to leave because ‘he can’t live without us,’ Carmen’s filings indicate she feared for her safety, but she never wrote that Jerad directly threatened the children. In the parenting plan filing, Carmen focused on Jerad’s way of life and how it could affect the girls. “Unrestricted parenting time by Jerad Arismendez would seriously endanger the children’s physical, mental, moral or emotional health,” she wrote. Carmen did not request supervised visits between Jerad and the girls, and asked only that “reasonable restrictions” be ordered. Among them: Jerad was not to drink during visits, and must run background checks and drug screenings on people living in his home. Jerad did not respond to the petition in court, meaning the order would have defaulted to Carmen’s request. Avondale Police said Jerad has been in trouble through the years for family fights, assault, and domestic violence.• FAMILY COURT
• Divorce finalized
• Child Custody
• Mother's concerns re visitation ignored
• Order of protection
• Dad- history of DV, assaults
•http://www.azcentral.com/story/news/local/phoenix-breaking/2016/10/18/police-identify-father-children-west-phoenix-murder-suicide/92337104/
•http://www.azfamily.com/story/33417193/pd-identifies-2-young-girls-man-in-tolleson-murder-suicide
•http://www.ibtimes.com/domestic-violence-2016-phoenix-father-murders-daughters-commits-suicide-2434779
34
2016GeorgiaSeminoleHENRY RAMONE BROWNAleah (1), Henry IV (4)22-Jul-162Father with record of DV shot and killed his two children children in murder-suicide. A judge granted Chericia Brown a domestic-violence injunction against her husband. She asked for a divorce and he pushed for full custody. He had threatened to kill her if she took the couple's children away from him. She filed for the injunction on Dec. 21 — three days after reporting the violence to Altamonte Springs police. Records show she asked a judge to let her keep their children, but that Henry Brown could have unsupervised visits. The injunction did not cover the kids*. Hours after police responded to a domestic violence call at the home, the estranged husband shot his wife and her two children, as well as her father. Chericia Brown told investigators that her husband would not allow her to have custody of their children. A judge granted a permanent injunction in February to keep Henry Brown away from the couple’s apartment and from Chericia Brown’s workplace, but the state attorney declined to prosecute the Dec. domestic battery case, writing: “There is insufficient evidence to prosecute this case.” Court records show that while Henry Brown was initially barred from being on property, Chericia Brown decided to move out and left her two children in the custody of Henry Brown. *Judge should not have granted father with record of DV access to kids.• FAMILY COURT
• Divorce
• Child Custody
• DV Injunction, court failed to prosecute case
•http://wfla.com/2016/04/19/man-who-killed-wife-children-had-history-of-domestic-violence-records-show/
•http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/breaking-news/os-seminole-murder-wife-kids-suicide-20160418-story.html
35
2016IowaPolkStephenie EricksonMason Wyckoff (2) 22-Jul-161Mother killed her son, Mason Wyckoff (2). The child's father, Dillon Wyckoff, was not married to Erickson but lived with her until nine months ago. He said the potential that Erickson would harm Mason was what his family feared most during a heated custody battle with Erickson. Wyckoff said he went to police, the courts and the Iowa Department of Human Services for help with Mason's mother, Stephenie Erickson, who he said was dealing with serious mental health issues. Erickson, who was found unresponsive with Mason in the Grimes home they shared, died at a hospital several days later. “I kept telling (officials) that she was going to harm him,” Cunningham said. “We were more or less treated as if we were overreacting.• Custody Battle
• Father's concerns ignored
• Iowa DHS, Police, Courts
• Parents not married
• Mental Health Issues
•http://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/2016/07/31/his-boy-dead-all-dad-wanted-someone-listen/87676388/
•http://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/politics/2016/08/19/father-dead-toddler-pleads-legislators-update-iowa-custody-laws/89012116/
36
2016MassachusettsSuffolkMaria Buie, DAVE WHYTE JR.Kenai Whyte (3)2-Feb-161Father with history of DV granted sole custody of son. Kenai Whyte was found unresponsive at his father’s house, Stepmother — Marie Buie — was indicted on murder charges (father was in court supporting Buie during trial). Prosecutor said that Buie was supposed to be caring for Kenai while his father was away from the home. The DCF had an open case with the boy before he died, according to court documents and DCF officials - a care provider told state child welfare officials that Kenai was well just days before he died. Whyte had history of DV arrests and restraining orders, although charges against him were repeatedly dismissed. Ashley Young fled her marriage to Kenai’s father, Dave Whyte Jr., when their son was just 3mos old, according to Young and court documents, which allege that Whyte abused her. According to court and family records, Kenai Whyte’s mother, father, and stepmother had a long history of relationship problems, which sometimes involved their children. Ashley Young once repeatedly told the Suffolk County Probate Court that Whyte had abused her, and that she feared for her son’s safety in his care. “I feel as if my child is in danger with his father,” wrote Ashley Young in a February 2013 probate filing. “If he can beat on me and abuse me, I feel he can do the same to my son.” Despite the abuse allegation, Whyte and Young shared legal and physical custody of Kenai until November 2015, records show. Whyte was later granted sole legal custody of Kenai after Young did not appear for a custody trial. Young said she missed the court appearance because she had just given birth to her daughter, who was born prematurely days before the hearing. Young said she called the clerk’s office to say she could not attend the hearing. * Court records also reveal a tumultuous relationship between Whyte Jr. and Buie. Buie was once accused of attacking Whyte with a glass liquor bottle and biting him repeatedly after the two argued over Kenai’s care, records show. Buie was charged with assault and battery and assault and battery with a dangerous weapon; both charges were later dismissed. -- Morris-Covington (Kenai's grandmother) said she had complained to DCF multiple times over the years that Kenai wasn't being properly cared for but nothing was done. She said her grandson was "scared to death" of Buie. • FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody
• Dad-Legal Custody, Shared Phys-Custody
• Dad-Criminal Record, abuse
• DV/Restraining Orders
• Mom feared for her son's safety
• DCF
• Protective mom & grandmother
• **Mom lost custody-missed court bc she was giving birth
• http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2016/02/05/governor-baker-dcf-working-with-district-attorney-death-year-old/wLvc9mktekovymwv2XsuOK/story.html
•https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2016/03/30/kenai-whyte-was-child-left-danger/ApI0rd9rADTrExHytGR5eP/amp.html
• http://www.necn.com/news/new-england/Stepmother-Indicted-in-Boston-3-Year-Olds-Murder-377623591.html
•http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2016/02/02/year-old-roxbury-boy-dies-from-injuries-investigation-continues/QlUeicrzDxQPk9axIu3iKL/story.html?p1=Article_Related_Box_Article_More
• http://boston.homicidewatch.org/2016/05/10/stepmother-charged-in-murder-of-roxbury-toddler-kenai-whyte/
37
2016MissouriJasperTONY KERNELWesley (9), Timber Kernel (7) Jan-162Father shot his son Wesley (9) and his daughter Timber (7) to death in murder-suicide. Murder-suicide appears to have taken place four days before a hearing on a amended parenting plan in a custody case between Kernel and Brandy Corum (before Judge Carlton in Jasper County) Josh Beck, the children's uncle, said there were custody problems between his sister and Kernel and that his family had called CPS in the past to report Kernel for abusing the children. Nov 2015: an individual (listed as having same address as Kernel) filed a petition against him seeking an order of child custody and an order of child support. Records also show that Judge Carlton issued a full order of protection against Kernel for an individual in March 2014, which was ultimately dismissed. • FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody Case
• Upcoming hearing re parenting plan
• Child Support
• Order of protection
• Prior reports to CPS re abuse
•http://www.carthagepress.com/news/20160116/update-sheriff-says-father-shot-his-two-children-then-shot-himself
•http://www.joplinglobe.com/news/local_news/jasper-county-authorities-investigate-apparent-murder-suicide/article_cb1f48bc-34cc-577b-9401-b17ea9a1dfb9.html
38
2016MontanaMusselshellSara AtkinsonKenny Kreuscher (5)6-Mar-161Atkinson shot her son in his sleep. Incident took place while he was visiting her in Montana. Ken Kreuscher divorced Atkinson a few years ago and fought to gain full custody of Kenny. The couple had been embroiled in a years’ long heated custody battle in Denver County and there were multiple incidents involving Denver police and Denver County child welfare workers. The parents had 50-50 custody of Kenny. The father, Ken Kreuscher, had sought a restraining order against the boy's mother and had court documentation of the mother's erratic actions. Numerous police reports indicate authorities were told about potential abuse and issues surrounding the child's mother. Father blames child welfare officials for not taking his concerns seriously enough. Kreuscher says DHS knew about the problems since 2012 and never did anything about it. • FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Shared custody
• Restraining order
• Authorities warned about mom's potential abuse
• Denver DHS involved since 2012
•http://billingsgazette.com/news/state-and-regional/montana/father-of-boy-killed-in-roundup-says-mom-had-threatened/article_fdfbd8c2-a0cd-5b82-8353-cd9effab94f9.html
•http://www.9news.com/news/crime/father-points-to-warnings-before-boys-death/78369500
•http://www.denverpost.com/2016/03/11/father-of-5-year-old-denver-boy-shot-by-his-mother-feared-son-was-not-safe/
39
2016NevadaClarkJASON DEJ-OUDOMAnhurak Jason(9), Xonajuk J.J.(14), & Dalavanh Ariel Dej-Oudom (15) & their motherJun-163Father fatally shot his wife and their three children. Wife, Phoukeo Dej-Oudom, filed for divorce and custody of the children on May 25. She represented herself in the divorce case, and in court paperwork she checked boxes that indicated the case involved domestic violence and CPS. Clark County Family Court records show that an application for a temporary protection order filed by wife was denied without a hearing just weeks before the murders. In the application, she indicated that her husband had threatened the family with weapons in the past, she wrote that “Throughout the marriage, the childrens’ lives as well as mine have been threatened. Guns have been pulled out and pointed to our heads multiple times,” and that her husband was arrested for DV in Ohio in 2005. Husband had also showed up at her workplace and threatened to take the children back to Ohio. She indicated that he had just returned from taking the kids there without her permission. Note: A Clark County spokesman could not confirm whether CPS had involvement with the family.• FAMILY COURT
• Divorce
• Custody Battle
• Clark Family Court
• Domestic Violence
• CPS
• http://www.reviewjournal.com/crime/homicides/vegas-woman-denied-protection-order-weeks-husband-fatally-shot-her-3-children
• http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/las-vegas/woman-killed-quadruple-homicide-filed-divorce-last-month
• Courts response: http://www.ktnv.com/news/contact-13/court-explains-why-protection-order-denied
40
2016North CarolinaBuncombe SETH PICKERINGLila Pickering (6)9-Sep-161Father killed his daughter Lila Pickering (6 years) because he did not want to lose custody of her. Pickering said: “Now they will never be able to take her away from me. She’s happier now. … It’s what she wanted.” System involvement prior to death. Pickering had been in a custody fight over his daughter, who weeks earlier was temporarily placed under the care of a custodian for the Buncombe County Department of Health Services, but Pickering was allowed supervised visits. Pickering’s estranged wife Ashley Pickering said that Lila was placed under protective care because her husband struck another woman. Ashley Pickering said she and her husband separated because he was abusive; they’d been locked in a custody battle for more than a year. Hours before her daughter’s death, Ashley Pickering said, a CPS case worker from the county told her that her Lila “was happy and healthy and in a great home.” “They were going to work on getting her back down here,” said Ashley Pickering, who now lives in Florida.• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Supervised Visits
• Domestic Violence
• Buncombe County DHS
• CPS
•https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/true-crime/wp/2016/09/14/its-what-she-wanted-dad-in-custody-battle-kills-daughter-in-front-of-park-rangers-police-say/
•http://www.inquisitr.com/3498904/6-year-old-girl-killed-by-father-after-losing-bitter-custody-battle/
•http://people.com/crime/father-indicted-for-allegedly-stabbing-daughter-to-death-his-grasp-of-right-and-wrong-just-fell-apart/
41
2016VirginiaFairfaxROY RUMSEYKyra Franchetti (2)Jul-161Father shot daughter in murder-suicide. "Kyra was on visitation with her father." *Family court angle not yet reported on, but CJE has alternate sources.• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Custody Evaluator
• Visitation
•http://www.wusa9.com/news/local/police-toddler-man-in-va-house-fire-died-from-murder-suicide/299828459
42
2015: 9 DEATHS / 8 CASES
43
2015ConnecticutMiddlesexTONY MORENOAaden Moreno (7 mos)Jul-151Father was in custody fight with mother, mother refused restraining order despite death threats, abuse. Baby killed in botched murder-suicide attempt in which father survived. • Father allegedly threatened to make his son Aaden Moreno "disappear any time of the day" during a bitter custody battle that ended when a skeptical Superior Court judge lifted a temporary restraining order, apparently made good on the threat. The father and the child's mother, Adrianne Oyola, had agreed to split Aaden's custody after a judge lifted a temporary restraining order and denied Oyola's request for a permanent one on June 29th. Mother feared for child’s safety (Courant).• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Lifted Temporary Restraining Order
• Denied Permanent Restraining Order
•http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/infant-body-found-ct-river-dad-tosses-bridge-article-1.2284983
•http://www.courant.com/breaking-news/hc-middletown-baby-search-0707-20150706-story.html
44
2015FloridaPinellas JOHN JONCHUCKPhoebe Jonchuck (5)8-Jan-151Custodial father killed his 5-year-old daughter. He threw her off a bridge (possibly while she was still alive). Experts say a history of stalking, battery and domestic-violence arrests involving John Jonchuck should have disqualified him as Phoebe’s custodial parent. Jonchuck was arrested shortly after he threw his daughter and was in jail facing a first-degree murder charge, police said. An attorney who had represented Jonchuck in the past reported him to police and child welfare workers on Wednesday, though it wasn't immediately clear why. The attorney, Torres told the 911 dispatcher that she had asked Jonchuck if he wanted her to file paperwork in his custody case. "It's not going to matter anymore," she recalled him saying. Phoebe's mother, Michelle Kerr, was with Jonchuck for six tumultuous years, and police were called numerous times. Since 2008, Jonchuck has been charged with domestic battery six times, but in every case, the charges were dropped or never pursued. Both parents had arrest records, Kerr had an arrest record consisting of child neglect, petty theft and contributing to the delinquency of a minor, among other charges. DCF Secretary Mike Carroll said a team is reviewing the agency's involvement with the family, which included at least three prior investigations into the family. Authorities said Jonchuck filed a domestic violence report against the child's mother last month, but it wasn't granted. He had custody of the child, and they lived with his father in Tampa.• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Custodial Father w/ Criminal Record
• History of Stalking, Battery & DV Arrests
• Both parents had arrest records
• DCF
•http://spacecoastdaily.com/2015/02/domestic-violence-could-have-raised-red-flag-in-death/
•http://www.tbo.com/news/experts-there-was-cause-for-jonchuck-to-lose-custody-of-phoebe-20150210/
•http://www.miamiherald.com/news/state/florida/article5668248.html
•http://www.miamiherald.com/news/state/florida/article5613888.html
•http://www.miamiherald.com/news/state/florida/article9637706.html
•http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/dad-tosses-daughter-5-death-florida-bridge-cops-article-1.2070064
45
2015MarylandCharlesRomechia SimmsJi'Aire Donnell Lee (3)May-15.1Just days after father filed for sole custody, his son Ji'Aire Donnell Lee’s (3) body was discovered on a park swing that his mother had been pushing back and forth for two days. A medical examiner ruled the boy died of dehydration and low body temperature. His death was ruled a homicide. James Lee said he went to court before his son Ji-Aire was found dead while being pushed in a swing by his mother. Lee was concerned the mother, Romechia Simms, was suffering from mental illness. He said he did not want to keep Ji-Aire’s mother out of his life forever; he just wanted her to get help. He believed he was the better parent at the time. A judge disagreed. Simms was hospitalized after the death of her son. In 2016 a judge found Romechia Simms not criminally responsible due to mental health. Court records in Charles County also show a history of domestic disputes between Simms and her mother, Vontasha Sim (wbaltv.com)• FAMILY COURT
• Court ignored dad's concerns re mom's mental health
• Mom found not criminally responsible due to mental health
• Hisory of domestic dipsutes b/t mom & her mother
•http://wtop.com/charles-county/2015/05/father-of-toddler-found-dead-in-swing-with-mother-speaks-out
•http://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/Father-of-3-Year-Old-Found-Dead-in-Park-Swing-Wanted-Sole-Custody-304955411.html
•http://www.wbaltv.com/article/watch-doing-your-own-taxes-is-smarter-heres-why/9081620
•http://people.com/crime/mom-found-pushing-dead-son-in-swing-charged-with-manslaughter/
46
2015MarylandMontgomeryNarges ShafeiradDaniel Dana (5)16-Jun-151Mom was due in court for the final hearing in a bitter divorce and custody case just 12 hours after she killed her son Daniel (5 years). **The husband described his spouse as physically and mentally abusive, and claimed that her behavior caused both him and Daniel to fear for their safety. Court records — "the marriage was troubled. In June 2013, the couple separated. A month later, Shafeirad and Azimi-Dana filed requests for restraining orders against each other — with each alleging in court filings that the other had physically abused them in front of their son." Shafeirad and Azimi-Dana agreed to stay away from each other without admitting to the alleged abuse. Father was worried about problems his son was having around her. A joint custody arrangement was worked out for Daniel according to court documents. Shafeirad pleaded guilty to killing Daniel by forcing him to swallow a lethal amount of cold medicine before setting her car on fire and staging a crash to mask her brutality. (read article for full details re divorce & restraining orders, etc.): • FAMILY COURT
• Joint custody arrangemetn
• Mom-Mental/Physical abusive
•https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/maryland-mother-pleads-guilty-to-poisoning-her-son-setting-his-body-on-fire/2016/07/28/478ce05a-54be-11e6-88eb-7dda4e2f2aec_story.html
•http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3181741/Mother-forced-son-5-overdose-medicine-set-car-fire-staged-wreck-killing-boy-day-court-final-divorce-hearing.html#ixzz4a0URXdae
•https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/prosecutors-jealous-rage-motivated-mother-who-poisoned-son-lit-his-body-afire/2017/02/27/a35615ec-fd0a-11e6-8f41-ea6ed597e4ca_story.html?utm_term=.86756adbb479&wpisrc=nl_p1most-partner-1&wpmm=1
47
2015MichiganAllegan COREY LaVALLEY Emma McComber (12), Corey LaValley Jr.(10) & their mom 1-Mar-152Protective father sought custody of his daughter - Custody battle referenced abuse before triple murder. Prosecutors say Corey LaValley shot Debra Sheppard, their son Corey LaValley Jr. (10) and her daughter Emma McComber (12) and then torched their trailer. The girl's father, William McComber is Sheppard's ex-husband. He says he fought with CPS for years, unsuccessfully trying to regain custody of Emma, because he feared for her safety. He had petitioned the courts multiple times over the past seven years for physical custody of his daughter. McComber says he had not had contact with his daughter since Nov. One day after William McComber’s daughter was found dead, the devastated dad told reporters he had warned authorities that 12-year-old Emma was in danger. Court records examined back up that claim. *Note: Emma had protective father with family court involvement, whereas her half brother Corey did not, as his parents were still together. CPS FAILURE: The Office of Children’s Ombudsman found the Allegan County CPS did not comply with policies and state law in the handling of a child safety case of two children who were later shot and killed by their mother’s boyfriend, who was father to one of the victims. did not comply with rules and laws regarding contact to verify the well-being of the children, Emma, Corey, and a third child The Sentinel will not identify.• Custody Battle
• Father's concerns ignored by CPS & Family Court
• Protective Father fought with CPS for years trying to regain custody of his daughter
• Abuse allegations prior to death
• Allegan County CPS (did not comply w/rules & laws)
• http://www.wilx.com/home/headlines/Man-Charged-With-Three-Counts-of-Murder-in-Allegan-County-296153101.html
• http://woodtv.com/2015/03/13/custody-battle-referenced-abuse-before-triple-murder/
• http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2015/03/father_of_girl_killed_in_alleg.html
• http://www.hollandsentinel.com/article/20160308/NEWS/160308960
48
2015OklahomaTulsaBYRON CREECHBraydon Creech (5)17-Mar-151Father charged in death of son, charged with first-degree murder, shooting with intent to kill, kidnapping, second-degree burglary and violating a protective order. Police said the man came to the apartment where his wife and child live, violating a protective order. They said the couple is going through a divorce but have joint custody of the child. He had court-allowed visitation with the boy, police said. Court documents show Creech's wife filed a petition for a protective order in July 2014 after Creech threatened her with a gun. The woman was afraid Creech would hurt her or her son, records say. Officers said Creech broke into the apartment and barricaded himself and the boy inside, but his wife was able to see him remotely through surveillance cameras she installed. In Nov. 2014 Creech was charged with malicious injury to property, a misdemeanor. According to court documents, Creech vandalized his wife's vehicle during a meeting to exchange custody of the child.• Divorce
• Joint Custody
• Court Allowed Visitation
• Wife Filed for Protection Order
•http://www.newson6.com/story/28569941/police-standoff-at-south-tulsa-apartment-complex-continues
•http://m.newson6.com/story.aspx?story=28577508&catId=112042
49
2015TennesseeShelbyTERRY PATTERSONJosiah Patterson (3)Sep-151Father charged with murder in death of his son. He was granted joint custody despite being a convicted felon. His criminal record includes a range of charges; he was convicted twice for statutory rape and is listed as a sex offender. Josiah's mother, Kiera Quin (Kerra Brown), fought for sole custody when boy returned to her with signs of abuse. Numerous complaints to CPS were ignored. Josiah's mother and his father, Terry Patterson, had joint custody and his mother was fighting for sole custody after finding bruises on his body. The state DCS had previous contact with the family in the last three years. WREG has uncovered disturbing details that chronicle the little boy's last moments, along with court records that reveal the custody battle that put him in the hands of a convicted felon. The last filing in juvenile court that awarded joint custody also indicated both parties had five days to request a repeat hearing on the matter. Neither Brown nor Patterson did. Neighbors and family members were still trying to figure out why Patterson was given temporary custody with the court knowing of his violent sexual past. • Custody Battle
• Father w/ Joint Custody had previous conviction for statutory rape
• Mother was fighting for sole custody
• Complaints to CPS Ignored
• DCS
• * Juvenile Court said there was no record of mother objecting joint custody, but other source says mother was fighting for sole custody
• http://wreg.com/2015/09/08/man-told-police-he-punched-beat-son-with-belt-before-he-died/
• http://wreg.com/2015/09/07/father-accused-of-killing-toddler-is-a-sex-offender/
50
2015VirginiaNorfolkJOHN JONASTasha Jonas (11)May-151Father kills daughter in murder-suicide, while out-of-state mother on the phone hearing daughter's last words. A Virginia family court judge granted John Jonas, a high-ranking Army officer serving at Fort Knox, full custody of his daughter following a protracted legal fight. Dad allowed to do moveaway two years ago to Kentucky. Mother has spent last few years trying to regain custody, with hearing scheduled for August. Family friend believes the bloodshed was sparked by a bitter custody battle between the divorced couple. Manojlovic said Karina Jonas was convinced her daughter was in danger and repeatedly attempted to warn lawyers, the military and court officials in Kentucky and Virginia of the perceived threat.• FAMILY COURT in Virginia
• Custody Battle
• Father allowed to move away w/ child
• Mother trying to regain custody
• Upcoming Custody Hearing in VA
• Mother's concerns ignored
• http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3083524/Daddy-daddy-doing-Mother-hears-daughter-s-words-phone-child-s-Army-officer-dad-killed-turned-gun-himself.html
• http://www.wlky.com/news/family-friend-speaks-of-devastation-after-a-father-fatally-shoots-daughter-kills-himself/33010460
• https://www.inquisitr.com/2090198/mom-hears-daughters-last-words-before-she-is-murdered-daddy-daddy-what-are-you-doing/
51
2014: 8 DEATHS / 6 CASES
52
2014CaliforniaFresnoDONALD NELSONZion Nelson (3)Jan-141Custodial dad, girlfriend charged with murder in death of son. Dad had extensive history of domestic violence, and father gained custody despite efforts of protective mother. Mother trying to regain custody of surviving child. • FAMILY COURT
• Dad gained custody despite efforts of protective mom
• Dad-Histoy of DV • Custodial Dad, Girlfriend Charged
•http://abclocal.go.com/kfsn/story?section=news%2Flocal&id=9381194
53
2014CaliforniaLos Angeles*ALAN DEAN EDWARDSErick Dean (9) & Alona Marie Edwards (5)Dec-142Father — in the midst of a divorce and custody dispute — deliberately crashed his car killing himself and his two children. Edwards and his wife were in the middle of a bitter and ugly divorce and fighting over custody of the two children, according to Los Angeles County Sheriff's deputies. LA County social workers fielded repeated reports that Alan Dean Edwards' two children were in danger. Edwards' neighbors say he was on the losing end of a nasty custody battle over his children with his estranged wife and was being forced out of his home. Authorities said Edwards, of Lancaster, picked up his son Eric & daughter Alona on Dec. 5, a Friday, as part of a custody agreement with his estranged wife. The inquiries into the children's welfare were part of a flurry of reports received beginning in April, when allegations arose that the father was physically abusing the children. Since 2003, the family was reported to the child abuse hotline 13 times, according to county records. The father and mother had previously been under investigation by the department in 2007 and 2003. Officials with the Department of Children and Family Services are now reviewing whether Antelope Valley social workers could have done more to prevent the tragedy. • Divorce
• Custody Battle
• System Failure - State involvement prior to deaths
• Child abuse allegations/reports-ignored
• DCFS, social workers
• Appears that there was FAMILY COURT involvement
• http://www.latimes.com/local/countygovernment/la-me-dcfs-murder-suicide-20141218-story.html
• http://ktla.com/2014/12/09/grapevine-crash-that-left-father-2-children-dead-investigated-by-homicide-detectives/
• http://sacramento.cbslocal.com/2014/12/09/police-man-in-custody-battle-deliberately-hit-truck-in-wreck-that-killed-him-2-children/
• http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/calif-man-kills-kids-slamming-car-truck-article-1.2040694
• http://abc7.com/news/2-kids-man-killed-in-castaic-lake-crash-identified/428513/
54
2014CaliforniaSanta BarbaraNICOLAS HOLZER Sebastian (13), Vincent Holzer (10), his mother & father 11-Aug-142Father stabbed to death his elderly father, then killed his two young sons, his mother and finally the family dog. He then "called 911 and in a calm and matter of fact manner told a dispatcher that he had killed his family.” Holzer told detectives he had killed his family to fulfill what he believed was his destiny. Court records show Nicolas Holzer and his ex-wife divorced in 2006 • Court file chronicles the custody battle, replete with accusations of mental illness, aggressive and controlling behavior, and sexual abuse. • The court ultimately granted Holzer full custody of their children, and largely cut off Juana from contact with the two boys. They had lived with Nicolas Holzer’s parents for the last seven years. Mother’s fiancé said that she had not been in touch with the children for a number of years because the court order had become so restrictive “it pretty much eliminated all contact.” The file depicts a mother who had little recourse or money to fight a financially secure father in the court battle, and who gradually lost more and more contact with her sons. A judge-appointed psychologist, paid by Holzer, performed a child custody evaluation and recommended the father get custody. Juana maintained that her ex-husband had mental-health problems and was aggressive and controlling toward her and the children, but the psychiatrists report indicates that “these allegations were not born out by the investigation.”• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Dad Granted Full Custody
• Abuse Allegations Ignored by Court
• Court Orders Restricted Contact w/ Mother
• Custody Evaluator
• Psychiatrists Report denied mothers allegations
• http://www.noozhawk.com/article/nicolas_holzer_family_mass_murder_case_20140824
• http://www.independent.com/news/2014/aug/21/court-records-shed-light-holzer-murders/
• http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2014/08/13/man-admits-killing-family/13989425/
• http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/calif-man-stabbed-death-parents-young-sons-cops-article-1.1901379
55
2014New HampshireHillsboroughKatlyn Marin Brielle Gage (3) 25-Nov-141Mother charged in blunt force trauma death of her daughter Brielle Gage (3). Brielle's biological father, William Boucher, had been seeking custody. He and his mother, Sharon Boucher, jointly petitioned the Nashua family court. Boucher said the court system and the DHHS failed her granddaughter — said Brielle was returned to her mother last summer by family court — while child abuse charges were still pending against the mother and her live-in boyfriend Michael Rivera. Just 6 months earlier, Marin and Rivera, were arrested after at least two boys in the home showed signs of abuse (4 of the 5 children had bruises - including a baby (9mos)) and told authorities said they were beaten with a belt and starved. Family court allowed mother access while child abuse charges were still pending against her and her boyfriend. 'We want to bring awareness to the issue of child abuse and how the DHHS and the court system failed my granddaughter,' she wrote. • FAMILY COURT
• Dad, grandma petitioned court for custody
• Family court returned child to mother
• Child abuse
• Court & DHHS failed
•http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2897619/Mother-25-beat-three-year-old-daughter-death-six-months-arrested-abusing-two-children.html#ixzz4RLbwd240
•http://www.unionleader.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20150104/NEWS03/150109866/1006/NEWS03#sthash.ngEeNY28.dpuf
•http://www.unionleader.com/crime/trial-begins-for-nashua-mom-accused-of-killing-daughter-3--20160815#sthash.gNxfktdN.dpuf
•https://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2015/01/03/nashua-mother-charged-death-year-old-daughter/OCZXbkyJvN1x86irNPNRSM/story.html •http://www.newhampshire.com/state-government/Lawmakers-react-to-alarming-report-on-DCYF-child-abuse-cases-10272016#sthash.S17G9HVI.dpuf
•http://www.unionleader.com/crime/3-year-old-brielle-gage-sustained-50-injuries-prior-to-death--20160815
56
2014New JerseyUnion JENS ELBERLINGThomas Eberling (11)6-Sep-141Father shot and killed son in muder-suicide, was embroiled in a contentious custody battle that included months of disagreements with his estranged wife over the upbringing of their son, according to court papers and acquaintances of the couple. The couple had shared custody of the son under a court order issued after Chou filed for divorce last May. The parents clashed over a number of issues that spilled over into their son’s chess competitions, brought police to their home several times and created controversy about custody that had to be decided by the courts. History of DV is listed in divorce court papers. • FAMILY COURT
• Contentious Custody Battle
• Wife filed for divorce
• shared custody under court order
• History of DV
•http://www.nj.com/union/index.ssf/2014/09/slain_scotch_plains_son_at_center_of_custody_dispute_parents_torn_of_his_schooling.html
57
2014New YorkOnondagaGLENN COLLINSGabriella (6), Jaidon Collins (14) injured29-Aug-141Father with criminal record is charged with manslaughter in the death of his daughter, Gabriella (6) – she was killed by carbon monoxide poisoning during visit with father. His son, Jaidon (14) was injured but survived. The children's mother, Steinbrecher, was required by court order to allow her daughter to visit Glenn Collins. *Father had court-ordered visitation despite a history of drug abuse, child neglect, and a criminal record. The protective mother's concerns were ignored, especially concerning the children being left unsupervised with father. "I had petitioned to end visitation after that weekend, I was worried about my daughter," Steinbrecher said. She says she was worried about Gabriella's safety because she was aware the child had been placed in a vehicle by Collins without a required child safety seat. "Gabriella hated going to his house," Steinbrecher recalls, but she said that she made sure her daughter did visit Collins because it was the order of the court.
• Child Custody
• Court-Ordered Visitation
• Dad w/ criminal record, DV, child neglect, substance abuse
• Protective mom's concerns ignored
• Child killed during dads court-ordered visitation
- http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2014/11/how_a_6-year-old_girl_came_to_die_in_the_care_of_a_non-custodial_convicted_felon.html
- http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2014/10/mother_of_6-year-old_girl_killed_in_carbon_monoxide_poisoning_had_fought_with_fa.html#incart_story_package
58
2013: 6 DEATHS / 6 CASES
59
2013CaliforniaSacramento PHILLIP HERNANDEZMatthew Hernandez (9)Feb-131Custodial father charged with murder. Judge Sharon Lueras granted father custody despite father's history of domestic violence, drug abuse. Protective mother's concerns ignored.• FAMILY COURT
• Dad-history of DV & Drug Abuse granted custody
• Protective Mom's Concerns Ignored
• Judge Sharon Lueras
•http://www.kcra.com/news/Mother-of-slain-child-blames-judge-for-death/19142228?item=0#!VBs0x
•http://www.kcra.com/article/records-show-mother-of-slain-natomas-boy-feared-for-his-safety/6402817
60
2013New YorkNew York DMITRY KANARIKOVKirill Kanarikov (3)21-Dec-131Father had history of domestic violence, suicidal threats, yet was granted unsupervised visitation. During first visit, father threw son off high rise building in murder-suicide. Mother had been nervous and wanted supervised visits, but after her court appearance she relented.• FAMILY COURT
• Dad w/ history of DV granted unsupervised visitation
• Mom- wanted supervised visits, but relented in court
• http://www.freep.com/usatoday/article/4187515
• http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/family-rallies-behind-mom-dad-throws-son-roof-article-1.1556324
61
2013PennsylvaniaHuntingdon KENNETH AYERSMichael Ayers (2)Mar-131Father shot and killed son during custody exchange, he also wounded his estranged wife and child's mother, Hollie Jo, before killing himself. He was found dead hours later. Father was subject to a protection from abuse order filed by his wife but was still permitted visits with his son, Michael. Hollie's frustration has her looking at all of the ways the mental health system and court system can be more effective. • FAMILY COURT
• Custody Exchange
• Dad- visitation rights despite order of protection by mom
• http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2298676/Kenneth-Ayers-shooting-Father-shoots-dead-son-2-injures-estranged-wife-killing-woods.html
• http://www.wearecentralpa.com/news/special-report-fatal-custody-exchange-michael-ayers-story
• http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/father-fatally-shoots-2-year-old-son-wounds-estranged-wife-killing-article-1.1298451
62
2013South DakotaMeadeEllen Cain, Warren Earl TrippTucker Wimpee (13)Nov-161Ellen Cain, 42, her live-in boyfriend - Warren Earl Tripp, 50, and Cain's son (13 years) all died of gunshot wounds. Father of son: Phil Wimpee. Court documents shed some light on a bitter custody battle over the years between Phil Wimpee and Ellen Cain. In 2010 Wimpee tried to get sole custody of Tucker and his older sister. At one point there was an emergency protective order issued for the children to keep them away from their mother's boyfriend, Tripp. In an affidavit, the children's father said he worried Tripp had the potential of mentally and emotionally affecting them for the rest of their lives. In 2006, Tripp was charged with menacing Court documents reveal a contentious history between Tripp. He was ordered to stay at least 500 feet from Wimpee and to not be present during the exchange of children for visitation.• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Emergency Protection Order Against Moms BF
• Fathers sought sole custody - not granted
• http://www.wave3.com/story/23982715/victims-of-meade-county-shooting-identified
63
2013TexasPalm BeachPamela BrooksAlexandra Brooks (10)Sep-161Mother killed her daughter Alexandra (10 years) in murder suicide. She was embroiled in a bitter custody dispute & had alcoholism and depression. Bradley Brooks drove to his ex-wife’s West Palm Beach home on Sept. 12 to pick up their 10-year-old daughter, Alexandra, as part of the couple’s custody agreement. When he couldn’t make contact with his daughter or ex-wife, he called police. Pamela Brooks’ control was threatened by the prospect of her ex-husband getting custody of their daughter, Cohen said. The Brooks murder-suicide came after a custody battle that lasted years. Bradley Brooks, fearing Pamela Brooks would hurt Alex, tried several times to gain full custody. In late May, a judge ordered if Pamela drank again, Bradley would get full custody.• FAMILY COURT
• Bitter Custody Battle
• Protective dad tried to gain full custody, feared for child's safety
• mom- substance abuse, mental illness
• http://www.mypalmbeachpost.com/news/news/police-holding-4-pm-news-conference-about-deaths-o/nbK9Q/
• http://www.wpbf.com/article/lawsuit-filed-in-murder-suicide-case/1325317
• http://www.mypalmbeachpost.com/news/news/crime-law/two-west-palm-mothers-who-killed-kids-selves-had-m/ncsyH/
64
2013VermontEssexLUDWIG “SONNY” SCHUMACHER Gunnar Schumacher (14)Dec-131Father killed his 14-year-old son before taking his own life. Sonny Schumacher was going through a bitter divorce with his wife. And court papers reveal allegations that Schumacher abused her and their kids, physically attacking Gunnar and flipping furniture on multiple occasions. "There was no complaint of domestic violence ever made to the police department," LaRose said. The allegations were handled in family court. But an Essex police officer served Schumacher with a temporary relief from abuse order back in July. WCAX News obtained multiple police reports filed by Christina Schumacher outlining a pattern of fear. In July, an Essex police officer served Sonny with a temporary relief from abuse order. That same month, Christina's brother came to the police department, concerned Sonny had violated the order. In August, Christina called the police to report a suspicious van outside her home, telling police her husband had made threats to her safety if she ever "crossed him." And in October, police were called to Christina's home to stand guard as Sonny removed personal items from the home. Officers said Christina seemed "nervous." Essex police withheld two additional police reports Christina Schumacher made, saying they directly relate to the ongoing murder-suicide investigation. • FAMILY COURT
• Bitter Divorce
• Abuse Allegations Handled in Family Court
• Dad Served Temporary Relief from Abuse Order
• http://www.wcax.com/story/24266870/father-accused-in-murder-suicide-leaves-letter-for-law-enforcement
• http://www.wcax.com/story/24388868/court-records-reveal-trouble-before-essex-murder-suicide
• http://archive.burlingtonfreepress.com/article/20140211/NEWS02/302110012/Ludwig-Sonny-Schumacher-rewrote-will-before-murder-suicide-Gunnar-Christina-Essex-Vermont
65
2012: 10 DEATHS / 7 CASES
66
2012ColoradoLa PlataMARK REDWINEDylan Redwine (13)18-Nov-121Father charged with murder and child abuse in the 2012 blunt force trauma death of his son Dylan Redwine (13). At the time, Mark Redwine and his ex-wife Elaine were involved in a heated divorce and custody case regarding the boy. Mark's July 2017 arrest comes nearly five years after his son vanished during a court-ordered visit in Colorado. Dylan was last seen alive on Nov. 18, 2012, during a contentious visit for Thanksgiving. Mark had been named a person of interested in the case two years ago. Dylan, who lived with his mother, had said he did not want to visit father. For months Dylan said “he was upset with Mark Redwine, that he did not want to visit and was uncomfortable with Mark Redwine,” the murder indictment says. Elaine said that she suspected her ex-husband was involved and that he was upset she had received primary custody of Dylan. Within days of Dylan's dissapearance investigators interviewed Redwine’s ex-wife, Betsy Horvath who told police that she thought Redwine might have hurt the boy. She is not Dylan’s mother, but she shared other children with Redwine. During their divorce and custody battle, she claims Redwine told her he would "kill the kids before he let her have them.” The Redwines do have some history of family violence. Dylan's older brother Cory claimed that several years ago "[Mark] took me and Dylan once or twice and would not tell us where my mom was at," Cory said. Mark Redwine's first wife Elizabeth made similar accusations, 9News obtained a police report from 1990, which alleges Mark failed to return their kids on time after visitation and claims he made statements about not returning the children. La Plata Sheriff's officials say they are aware of the old claims, and they say these kinds of things are common during custody disputes. in 2013, Elaine & Mark both appeared on the Dr. Phil show about their son's death. They eventually filed lawsuits against each other connected to Dylan’s death, though both eventually were dismissed. Dylan's visit was the result of a court order by 6th Judicial District Judge David Dickinson, who said he is restricted from commenting on the order or the parenting plan. According to CNN, his mother was awarded full custody in September and then his father was awarded visitation on certain days. • FAMILY COURT
• Divorce
• Custody Case
• Child killed during court ordered out-of-state visit w/dad
• Mom expressed concerns during divorce/custody battle
• Case requires further review -- possible that mom-awarded full custody in Sept. & dad-awarded visitation
• Both parents appeared on Dr. Phil Show
• Dad not charged until Jul-2017
•http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/father-of-dylan-redwine-arrested_us_5974b53ee4b09e5f6ccfedcb
•https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2017/07/23/four-years-after-13-year-old-dylan-redwine-disappeared-his-father-is-charged-with-murder/?utm_term=.73aa39d5e4ee
•https://durangoherald.com/galleries/698-timeline-in-dylan-redwine-case
•http://www.oxygen.com/blogs/dad-charged-with-teen-sons-2012-murder-after-disturbing-comments-to-ex-wife-revealed#/.WXZAXtZYfzI.facebook
•http://www.koat.com/article/dylan-redwine-timeline-of-events/10352304
•Blog w/ KUSA article text: http://statementanalysisjodi.blogspot.com/2013/02/dylan-redwine-father-denial.html
67
2012FloridaHighlandCHRISTOPHER KINGAmelia King (2)Sep-121Father left his 2-year-old daughter to die in a car overnight. He plead no contest to aggravated manslaughter. Appears that custody/visitation arrangement was court-ordered; mom's previous concerns regarding father's drug usage, child neglect dismissed. Father eventually pleaded guilty to aggravated manslaughter.• FAMILY COURT - Custody Battle
• Court-ordered custody/visitation
• Mom's previous concerns re neglect & drug abuse ignored
• http://highlandstoday.com/hi/local-news/concerns-raised-about-father-before-daughter-died-in-car-20130728/
• http://www.tbo.com/news/crime/father-pleads-guilty-in-death-of-daughter-20131030/
68
2012FloridaOrange WILFRED EXILASSEElijah Exilasse (4)Sep-121Mother had moved to Colorado, father filed custody petition demanding visitation. Three weeks into summer visitation, boy died from blunt force trauma. Father had previously been granted shared custody of boy but lost it due to neglect. Father charged with "aggravated child abuse" though son's death has been ruled a homicide. Father finally charged with 1st-degree murder in March 2013.• Father gained access through custody petition
• Father had previouslty lost joint custody due to neglect
• *Look into where family court took place - Family court? or just agency?
• http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2012-10-07/news/os-fatal-child-abuse-mom-speaks-20121007_1_share-custody-relationship-dcf
• http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2013-03-13/news/os-child-abuse-charges-upgraded-murder-20130313_1_child-abuse-charges-child-abuse-face-murder-charges
69
2012MarylandMontgomeryJOAQUIN S. RAMSPrince McCleod Rams (2 mos)Oct-121Father in "bitter custody battle" with mother. Despite mother's repeated concerns which were expressed to the courts, son was beaten to death during father's fourth session of unsupervised visitation. Disturbing details about the father’s background raised questions about the decision of a Montgomery County judge to grant unsupervised access. He is "now" suspected in earlier murder of ex-girlfriend and apparent "suicide" of his own mother. In July 2013, prosecutor stated that may seek the death penalty. Update: The mother filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against the psychologist who sanctioned the visitation - Margaret Wong.• FAMILY COURT - Custody Battle
• Mom's concerns ignored by court
• Dad granted unsupervised visits
• Child murdered during visit
• Mom filed wrongful death lawsuit against the Psychologist who sanctioned visits, Margaret Wong
• http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/search-for-answers-in-toddlers-death-must-continue/2013/01/04/5b3bbe5c-55d3-11e2-bf3e-76c0a789346f_story.html
70
2012OregonYamhillRANDALL ENGELSBailey (13), Jackson Engels (11), their motherJul-122Despite father's history of domestic violence, Judge Cal Tichenor denied mother's request for emergency sole custody of the children in May 2012. Randall Engels killed his two children and his estranged wife before killing himself - triple murder took place the day after his wife told him she wanted to go ahead with the divorce. The last post on his Facebook page read: "If she's gone i can't go on." • Wife wanted divorce
• Father had history of DV, but Judge Cal Tihenor denied mothers request for emergency sole custody in May 2012
• Murders took place the day after she wanted to continue divorce
• *Did she file for divorce & ask for custody in May?
• http://seattletimes.com/html/nationworld/2018609748_apusoregonfamilykilling.html
71
2012VirginiaHanover ROBERT D. KINGTwin daughters Caroline (3) & Madison King (3)Jan-122Father in "bitter custody battle" with children's mother stabbed twin daughters, then gassed them to death with carbon monoxide. Father had weekend visitation at time of murders. Protective mother's concerns ignored by authorities. Rob King killed himself that same night. Kristi had offered joint custody of the three-year-olds. Rob wanted the girls to himself. • FAMILY COURT - Custody Battle
• Dad granted weekend visitation
• Protective mom's concerns ignored by authorities
• Mom had offered joint custody
• http://archive.wusa9.com/news/article/275306/373/Father-kills-twin-daughters-in-bitter-custody-battle
• http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2094359/Robert-King-kills-twin-daughters-3-murder-suicide-following-bitter-custody-battle.html
72
2012WashingtonPierceJOSHUA POWELLCharlie Powell (7), Braden Powell (5)Feb-122Father killed sons in murder-suicide during CPS supervised visitation at his home. Boys suffered hatchet wounds before house consumed by arson. Before the deaths, Susan's parents, Chuck and Judy Cox, wrangled with Josh Powell over custody of the boys and had just won custody. Chuck Cox, said he told CPS that his grandchildren were in danger from Josh two days before their horrific slayings. Father had lost bid to regain child custody from maternal grandparents just days before. Originally lost custody in fall 2011 when paternal grandfather (with whom father and sons were living) arrested for child porn. Father only “person of interest” in mother’s disappearance (presumed murder) in December 2009. In May 2014, investigators alleged that father also sexually abused the boys. Mother Susan Cox Powell “disappeared” in 2009. Father only “person of interest” in her disappearance. Courts ruling in lawsuit against state in death of Charlie and Braden: “The social workers are not liable to Cox for their recommendations to the court or their facilitation of the Powell family’s court-ordered visitation.” • Custody Battle (b/t father & grandparents)
• Dad lost custody
• Granted CPS Supervised Visitation, during which the murders took place
• Sexual Abuse Allegations
• Dad "person of interest" in wifes disspearance
• Dad previously lost custody when his own father/roommate was arrested for child porn
• http://q13fox.com/2015/09/17/susan-powells-family-says-cps-could-have-prevented-her-sons-death-wants-federal-judge-to-hold-state-accountable/
• http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2640959/Josh-Powell-sexually-abused-two-sons-mother-vanished-butchered-boys-hatchet.html
• http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/02/07/10342362-powell-driven-by-revenge-in-killing-sons-himself
• Court ruling re lawsuit following deaths: http://www.thenewstribune.com/news/local/crime/article38004309.html#storylink=cpy
73
2011: 2 DEATHS / 2 CASES
74
2011CaliforniaSacramento MOURAD “MONI” SAMAANMadeline Layla Samaan-Fay (2)Aug-111Father killed daughter in murder-suicide. Incident followed an award of custody to the girl’s mother, Marcia Ann Fay. She is well-known as a deputy to state Attorney General Kamala Harris. Mother's request for father’s access to be limited to supervised visitation was denied by family court judge James Mize. Daughter killed in murder-suicide that was declared an act of “justice” by father’s surviving brother. Madeline’s official cause of death is still listed as pending until toxicology reports can determine whether she died of carbon monoxide poisoning before being shot. • FAMILY COURT - Custody Battle
• mom-awarded custody
• Mom requested dad's access be limited to supervised visits
• Family Cout Judge James Mize denied request
• http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/tragic_death_of_tot_after_hard-fought_custody_case_leads_to_call_for_disbar/
• http://sacramento.cbslocal.com/2011/08/17/gunshot-wounds-found-in-missing-father-daughter/
• http://www.examiner.com/article/the-murder-of-madeline-samaan-fay-by-her-father
75
2011New JerseyMonmouthARTHUR MORGAN IIITierra Morgan-Glover (2)Nov-111Despite history of domestic violence, father obtained court-ordered visitation. Father killed daughter after picking her up from her mother for the court-approved visitation. Father accused of murdering daughter by throwing her off bridge into creek. Father later arrested in California after disappearing. • FAMILY COURT
• Father w/ history of DV granted visitation
• Father killed daughter during court-ordered visitation
• Did mother try to contest this decision?
• http://wall.patch.com/groups/police-and-fire/p/dyfs-failed-to-see-red-flags-in-tierra-morgan-glover-s-case
• http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2011/12/nj_father_charged_with_murder.html
• http://www.ahherald.com/newsbrief/law-and-order/17144-jury-selection-begins-in-trial-of-father-accused-of-murdering-2-year-old-daughter
76
2010: 9 DEATHS / 7 CASES
77
2010CaliforniaRiverside ALEXANDRO BAEZAIsaac Gallegos (2)Apr-101Father charged with murder in the death of son, who was killed during weekend visitation with the father. Parents had never been married and had been in a “custody dispute” for the past year. The “family” had a history with CPS. Father had shown zero interest in the baby for the first year. And yet the judge--in this case Judge John M. Pacheco--awarded the father twice-a-week visitation anyway. He then proceeded to ignore the mother's concerns regarding the child's injuries and signs of psychological trauma. In fact, he threatened to strip the mother of custody for bringing up her concerns. In December 2010, father ordered to trial. Father found guilty of 2nd-degree murder in September 2011. • Custody Dispute - Parents never married
• Dad granted 2X a week visitation by Judge John M. Pacheco, despite zero prior involvement in child's life
• Judge ignored mom's concerns regarding child's injuries & psychological trauma
• Judge threatened to strip her of custody for bringing up concerns
• Family had history with CPS
• http://www.pe.com/articles/baeza-629294-isaac-gallegos.html
78
2010CaliforniaSan Bernardino STEPHEN CHARLES GARCIAWyatt Garcia (9 mos)Jan-101Father killed son in murder-suicide during court-ordered visitation. Parents never married. Mother had pleaded with 3 judges regarding father's violence, threats. three different judges refused multiple requests by the child’s mother for restraining orders to protect her child, despite police reports and documented death threats by the father in text messages and on Facebook. (Mountain News: “This newspaper also obtained from Tagle's family a copy of a court document which suggests Wyatt might still be alive had a judge ruled differently on a petition Tagle filed in a Victorville court just 10 days before the murder-suicide.”) • FAMILY COURT
• Murder-suicide during court-ordered visitation
• Mom pled w/ judges re dad's violence/threats, multiple requests for restraining orders to protect her child
• Judges refused requests despite police reports & documented death threats by dad
•http://www.mountain-news.com/news/localnews/article_cc943125-4c0f-5433-a680-07bc5ef75515.html
79
2010MissouriJackson CLINTON GALLAGHERAlex Gallagher (6)Dec-101Father killed son in murder–suicide after judge ignored mother’s request for order of protection, temporary custody. Court records show Gallagher pled guilty to domestic violence involving his wife in 2009. Six months ago, Gallagher successfully sued the Jackson County Sheriff's Office to get his concealed weapon permit reissued. • FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody
• Judge ignored mom's req. for order of protection & temp. custody
• Dad-history of DV
• Dad lost weapon permit-recently reissued
•http://www.pitch.com/FastPitch/archives/2010/12/16/clinton-gallaghers-wife-feared-for-her-life-gallagher-identified-in-lone-jack-killings
80
2010PennsylvaniaDauphin STEPHEN S. DIXONJayahn Cox-Phoenix (3)May-101Father convicted in death of his son (drowning/severe brain injury). Parents had no formal custody agreement. Father played no role in child’s life until January 2010. Father allowed visitation by mother. In March 2010, father refused to return child or allow maternal contact. Mom’s early May 2010 petition for emergency custody denied by Judge Andrew Dowling despite allegations of child abuse. Custody hearing set for June 2010. Child dies before then of traumatic brain injury. Grandmother plans lawsuit against county Children and Youth. • FAMILY COURT
• No formal custody agreement, mom allowed visit for unknown reasons
• Allegations of child abuse
• Petition for emergency custody denied
• Judge Andrew Dowling
•http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2010/09/swatara_township_boys_death_ru_1.html
81
2010TexasHarris MOHAMMAD GOHERSaeed (12), Saedah (14), Aisha (7)Sep-103Despite an extensive history of domestic violence, father granted unsupervised visitation. Children shot to death while sleeping. Father charged with capital murder. "I have documents of everything, all the abuse, and I showed it to everyone, but no one believed me, and they still made me send my kids to him every weekend," the mother. The gun he used was returned to him by the legal system. Update Jan. 2014: Goher admitted his guilt in exchange for a sentence of life without parole. The gun he used was returned to him by the legal system (abc13). • FAMILY COURT
• Dad- extensive history of DV
• Mom- documented abuse ignored bt courts
• Father Granted Unsupervised visitation
•http://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/article/Harris-Co-mom-Warnings-unheeded-before-kids-1702519.php
•http://abc13.com/archive/7683866/
82
2010UtahDavisStephanie SloopEthan Stacy (4)May-101Mother & stepfather, Nathaniel Sloop, charged in death of son, Ethan Stacy. Son was 4 years old when his father (Joe Stacy) had to turn him over to the estranged mother for visitation rights. After a custody fight, a judge ordered summer visitation with the boy's mother and Ethan's father, Joe Stacy, had to comply. Joe Stacy, had expressed concerns about sending him to Utah, saying in court documents that the boy's mother was "unstable" and he feared she would "take him and I'll never see him again." Ethan didn't want to go with his mother as he didn't want anything to do with her-- he was scared of her and he thought she had abandoned him. The father had to make him go or else he would go to jail for contempt of court. Ethan flew from Florida to Utah to be with his mother on April 30, 2010. He was reported missing 2 weeks later, and then the mother confessed that her new husband (Nathan Sloop) beat and abused him to death. Mother helped hide the boy's body and lied to police, Rawlings said. They used a hammer to beat the boy's face so that the police wouldn't be able to identify him.• FAMILY COURT
• Custody Battle
• Judge ordered summer visitation w/ mom
• Dad's concerns ignored
•http://www.deseretnews.com/article/865576852/Witnesses-describe-ugly-abuse-before-4-year-olds-death.html?pg=all
•http://thequeenandking.blogspot.com/2010/06/borderline-mother-charged-with.html
•http://www.cbsnews.com/news/utah-mom-pleads-guilty-sentenced-to-at-least-20-years-in-sons-death/
83
2010UtahSalt LakeCLINTON HARTVanessa Hart (4)Jun-101Father and his girlfriend, Marina Navarro, charged in death of daughter. Father and the girl's mother, Stephanie Alfaro, had been undergoing a divorce for the past three years, they both had legal custody to their two children. Father took children from Oregon to Utah and denied mother contact. She said she contacted multiple police agencies, in addition to the courts, to try and track them down. One and a half years later, father charged with felony murder. • FAMILY COURT
• Divorce
• Both parents had legal custody
• Father denied mother contact
•http://www.deseretnews.com/article/700042094/Kearns-father-girlfriend-charged-in-4-year-olds-death.html?pg=1
•http://www.deseretnews.com/article/705389937/Kearns-woman-who-beat-boyfriends-daughter-to-death-sent-to-prison.html?pg=all
84
2009: 4 DEATHS / 3 CASES
85
2009CaliforniaSanta ClaraMARK EDWARD MESITIAlycia Mesiti-Allen (14)Mar-091Father with a lengthy criminal record charged with murder -- allegedly drugged and sexually abused his daughter Alycia (14) before killing her and burying her in the backyard of their home, just months after family court judge Chiarello in Santa Clara County granted him custody of her & her brother. Alycia and her brother lived with Mark Edward Mesiti for nine months before she disappeared, despite repeated warnings filed by police authorities and child welfare workers. Court appointed lawyers recommended only temporary placement with Mesiti due to 'sufficient issues and risks to these minors.' The children's mother, Roberta Allen, said she also reported that the children were often hungry, subject to abuse, and unable to call their mother despite her court-ordered visitation and contact rights. Court records show, Mesiti had been convicted of state and federal charges. He also was charged with domestic violence and after failing to comply with court orders he landed in prison for violating probation. A court investigator described the children's mother, Roberta Allen, as an unfit mother who had battled with depression. Roberta Allen described her years-long legal battle as “very angled toward Mark. I couldn’t afford an attorney. Parents had gone through mediation, counseling and psychological evaluations.He had one.” Parents had gone through mediation, counseling and psychological evaluations. *NOTE: Alycia vanished in August 2006, but the Social Security Death Index has her official date of death as March 25, 2009, which is the date she was found. *Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty against Mesiti, who is charged with murder and more than 40 counts of sexually abusing his daughter, as well as sexual abuse charges involving two other girls, according to the indictment. Mesiti's case remains stalled by legal challenges & the defendants requests for new attorneys. • FAMILY COURT
• Custodial dad-lengthy crim record
• Dad- history of DV
• Mom- alleged depression
• Child abuse
• Mom's concerns ignored
• Child welfare/authorities ignored
• Court-ordered visitation
• Family court judge Chiarello
• Court appointed lawyer
• Protective mom, grandma
•http://www.mercurynews.com/2009/05/13/may-2009-tragic-santa-clara-county-custody-case-dad-suspected-in-girls-death/
•http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2114526/Death-penalty-sought-man-accused-raping-killing-14-year-old-daughter.html#ixzz4qTVdhLeo
•http://www.modbee.com/news/local/crime/article15199466.html
86
2009IllinoisMcLean MICHAEL CONNOLLYDuncan (9) & Jack Leichtenberg (7)Mar-092Father killed sons in murder-suicide during court-ordered visitation. Mother had extensive involvement with the courts trying to prevent contact with father. A court order had barred Connolly from contact with Leichtenberg, according to her attorney, Helen Ogar. The order also initially prevented Connolly from seeing his sons. Connolly was allowed to start keeping his children overnight without supervision in December, Ogar said. Before the weekend during which the boys disappeared, Leichtenberg did not want to turn them over to their father, her lawyer said. "She was contacted by the Leroy police and told that she had to send them, that it was an arrestable offense (if she did not)," Ogar said. The judge told this mother that he just wanted her ex out of his courtroom. • FAMILY COURT
• Court-Ordered Visitation
• Protective Mother's efforts to prevent contact were unsuccessful
•http://web.utsandiego.com/news/2009/Mar/30/father-sons-killed-033009/?#article-copy
87
2009TexasGuadalupe DAVID BRASSESarah Brasse (8)Feb-091Custodial dad & stepmother, Britain, accused of medical neglect in death of daughter. Mother had been trying to regain custody since 2007. When Sarah Brasse died of untreated appendicitis in 2009, alone in her soiled bed in Schertz, her father and stepmother had already been investigated multiple times by CPS over allegations they were neglecting her and her siblings. Their mother JoAnne Guerrero had supervised visits at KidShare. Local child-care professionals at KidShare contacted CPS three times in 2007- the staff also raised concerns that Sarah and her younger brother might be physically abused. Mother claims that she has been fighting for custody of Sarah and her two brothers since 2007 - Soon after Sarah died, Guerrero regained custody of her two sons, which she maintains. Police calling for CPS reform after this incident. UPDATE: After Sarah died, a Guadalupe County jury convicted Brasse and Britain of manslaughter, but an appeals court threw out both verdicts for insufficient evidence in December 2012.• FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody
• Custodial dad, mom- supervised visits
• Mom was trying to regain custody
• Abuse allegations ignored
• Multiple investigations by CPS
• Father, step convicted, but in 2012 appeals court threw out verdicts for insufficient evidence
• http://www.expressnews.com/news/local/article/Records-missing-from-the-CPS-file-on-girl-who-5301017.php
• http://www.kens5.com/home/Father-accused--104023194.html
• http://www.kens5.com/news/Schertz-Police-calling-for-reform-at-Child-Protective-Services-93642944.html
• http://www.dreamindemon.com/2009/02/12/sarah-brasse-was-sick-and-ignored/
• http://www.expressnews.com/news/local/article/Mother-state-senator-blast-state-investigation-5846136.php
88
2008: 5 DEATHS / 3 CASES
89
2008ColoradoEl PasoHANIF SIMS, Monique LynchGenesis Sims (9)Dec-081Father and her stepmother, Monique Lynch, are charged in death of Genesis Sims (9). Father obtained custody in New Jersey. Mother told the station that she lost custody of her daughter in October 2007. “I wasn’t told of the court date,” she said. “I kept trying to get some court dates so I could get custody of her back.” Girl’s remains found in former home’s crawl space in May 2010. In November 2010, father, girlfriend both charged in girl’s death, ordered to trial. Father pleaded guilty to child abuse in daughter’s death in January 2012. Sentenced to 40 years in prison in April 2012.Sources confirmed that New Jersey child protection authorities filed a neglect and dependency case against Genesis father. New Jersey officials were about to take Genesis away from the couple, but they moved to Colorado. The details of the New Jersey actions were reported to El Paso County, but it is unclear why El Paso County did not act. There was also an Oct. 2, 2008, complaint of abuse in El Paso County. CPS went to the house & interviewed children, complaint was deemed “inconclusive” and El Paso County officials did not open a case. • FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody
• Mom- lost custody & was trying to regain custody
• Prior CPS involvement
• Dad, step charged
• http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/couple-we-buried-9-year-old-girl-in-basement
• http://www.thedenverchannel.com/news/sheriff-seeks-dna-samples-to-help-id-body-found-in-crawl-space
• Original link for other article is broken, read full text here: http://dastardlydads.blogspot.com/2010/05/sexually-abusive-father-jails-mom-on.html
• http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2010/07/body_of_girl_found_in_colorado.html
90
2008MarylandMontgomery MARK CASTILLOAnthony Castillo (6), Austin Castillo (4), Athena Castillo (2)Mar-083Father drowned his three children. Mother had tried to stop father from having access, but blocked by courts. Children murdered during court-ordered visitation. After 10 years of marriage, the Castillos wound up in a bitter divorce with Amy Castillo fighting unsuccessfully to persuade the courts to keep her children away from their father for their safety. Father pleaded guilty in October 2009, and sentenced to three consecutive life sentences without possibility of parole. • FAMILY COURT
• Divorce
• Court-ordered visitation
• Mom's concerns for safety ignored by courts
• http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/baltimore-city/bal-md.castillo15oct15,0,3175966,full.story
91
2008OregonClatsop ROCKLAND STEPHENSShane Davis (10)Mar-081Father and son dead in apparent murder suicide. The deaths reportedly come shortly after events connected to a child custody battle. Police say Stephens had his son, Shane, for the weekend and was supposed to return the boy to his mother's house in St. Helens but never showed up. During a Jan. 22 hearing, Davis told Columbia County Judge Steve Reed that Stephens had threatened to kill her, an allegation Stephens denied in court, according to a recording of the hearing. Davis also accused Stephens of fleeing to Fiji with another child, who is now an adult, in order to prevent her from having custody. -- The judge told them it was a classic "he said, she said" but that the alleged threats were very serious, the recording showed. Despite that, Reed increased the amount of visitation granted to Stephens, allowing alternate weekend visitations. When Davis said she was concerned he might take off with the child, the judge told her the FBI would track him down, the recording revealed. • FAMILY COURT
• Child Custody Battle
• Visitation
• Judge ignored mom's concerns - increased dads visitation time
• http://www.komonews.com/news/local/16841611.html
• http://www.foxnews.com/us/2012/02/07/incidents-killings-in-child-custody-disputes/
92
93
Murder-Suicide Cases (2008-2017)
94
Some of these require more research. Initial media reports were often unclear.
*Totals do not include murder-suicides above
95
TOTAL DEATHS: 264
96
TOTAL CASES: 153
97
98
YearStateCounty(Alleged) KillerChild Victim(s) / Age(s)Date (if known)Kid VicsCircumstancesTagsSource Article Links
99
2017: 24 DEATHS / 16 CASES
100
2017ArkansasPulaskiROBERT MANGANCatherine (4), Joseph Mangan (5) 20-Aug-172Arkansas father killed his four-year-old daughter Catherine and five-year-old son Joseph before taking his own life. The children's mother, Lindsay Mangan, told police that the couple had recently separated and were “having problems,” which could account for motive, authorities have noted. According to police reports, authorities had documented multiple domestic disputes involving the couple. A court had ordered Robert Mangan to not contact his wife, according to a document issued earlier this month. Arrest records show Mangan had been arrested three times since May of last year. He was arrested twice for domestic battery in the third degree, once in May 2016 and a second time on August 5 this year. He was arrested another time in September 2016 for a violation of protection order. Cause of death has not been released, but officers said there were no obvious signs of trauma on the children. • Recent separation
• Dad- criminal record
• Protection order
•http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4810588/Arkansas-police-checking-suicide-call-man-2-kids-dead.html
•https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cops-man-two-young-kids-found-dead-in-bed-in-murder-suicide/
•http://www.crimeonline.com/2017/08/21/mom-comes-home-to-find-her-husband-has-killed-himself-and-their-two-young-children-police/
•http://www.arkansasonline.com/news/2017/aug/20/little-rock-police-investigating-double-homicide-b/?f=crime
•http://m.arkansasonline.com/news/2017/aug/22/father-id-d-in-2-kids-deaths-20170822/
Loading...
 
 
 
CJE's Child Murder Master Database (2008-2017)