FAIR,CARE&TRUST

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K	L	M	N	O	P	Q	R	S	T	U	V	W	X	Y	Z	AA	AB	AC	AD	AE	AF	AG	AH	AI
1				FAIR Principles															CARE Principles												TRUST Principles
2				Findable				Accessible				Interoperable			Reusable				Collective Benefit			Authority to Control			Responsibility			Ethics			TRUST Principles
3	Provenance	COUNT X's	Mechanism, Activity	F1. (Meta)data are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier	F2. Data are described with rich metadata (defined by R1 below)	F3. Metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the data they describe	F4. (Meta)data are registered or indexed in a searchable resource	A1. (Meta)data are retrievable by their identifier using a standardised communications protocol	A1.1: The protocol is open, free and universally implementable	A1.2 The protocol allows for an authentication and authorisation procedure, where necessary	A2. Metadata are accessible, even when the data are no longer available	I1. (Meta)data use a formal, accessible, shared, and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.	I2. (Meta)data use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles	I3. (Meta)data include qualified references to other (meta)data	R1. (Meta)data are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes	R1.1. (Meta)data are released with a clear and accessible data usage license	R1.2. (Meta)data are associated with detailed provenance	R1.3. (Meta)data meet domain-relevant community standards	C1 For Inclusive development and innovation	C2 For improved governance and citizen engagement	C3 For equitable outcomes	A1 Recognizing rights and interests	A2 Data for governance	A3 Governance of data	R1 For positive relationships	R2 For expanding capability and capacity	R3 For Indigenous languages and worldviews	E1 For minimizing harm and maximizing benefit	E2 For justice	E3 For future use	Transparency	Responsibility	User Focus	Sustainability	Technology

4	CTS	1	Publicly accessible, easily findable, clearly stated mission statement (see CTS)																												X
5	CTS	1	Publicly accessible, easily findable, clearly stated repository scope (see CTS)																												X
6	CTS	2	Publicly accessible, easily findable, clearly stated terms of use, both for the repository and for the data holdings (see CTS)													x															X
7	CTS	2	Publicly accessible, easily findable, clearly stated minimum digital preservation timeframe for the data holdings (should be greater than at least N years) (see CTS)								x																				X
8	CTS	1	Publicly accessible, easily findable, clearly stated details about pertinent additional features or services, for example the capacity to responsibly steward sensitive data (see CTS)																												X
9	CTS	2	Adherence to community norms (lots of unpacking here...)															x														X
10	CTS	1	manage IP (addresses?), sensitive info, security																													X
11	CTS	1	provide data services																													X
12	CTS	1	Implementing relevant data metrics and making these available to users.																														x
13	CTS	2	Providing (or contributing to) community catalogues to facilitate data discovery.				x																										x
14	CTS	1	Monitoring and identifying evolving community expectations and responding as required to meet these changing needs.																														x
15	CTS	2	Planning sufficiently for risk mitigation, business continuity, disaster recovery, and succession.								x																							x
16	CTS	1	Securing funding to enable ongoing usage and to maintain the desirable properties of the data resources that the repository has been entrusted with preserving and disseminating.																															x
17	CTS	2	Providing governance for necessary long-term preservation of data so that data resources remain discoverable, accessible, and usable in the future.								x																							x
18	CTS	1	Implementing relevant and appropriate standards, tools, and technologies for data management and curation.																																x
19	CTS	1	Having plans and mechanisms in place to prevent, detect, and respond to cyber or physical security threats.																																x
20
21
22	ESIP-sustDM	4	Engage with indigenous communities														x								x	x	x
23	ESIP-sustDM	3	Learn enough to determine if data access restrictions are necessary or for obfuscation of some elements																			x	x	x
24	ESIP-sustDM	2	Understand indigenous legal rights, consequences of publishing these data																				x							x
25	ESIP-sustDM	1	Be aware of changing roles/relationships over time																						x
26	ESIP-sustDM	1	Develop data policies and collection/curation protocols																			x
27	ESIP-sustDM	1	Have contact protocols and follow up processes																x
28	ESIP-sustDM	2	Work with depositors to minimize restrictions							x															x
29	ESIP-sustDM	1	Consider your repository as part of a (broad) community																	x
30	ESIP-sustDM	3	Identify that you hold data related to indigenous peoples		x														x		x
31	ESIP-sustDM	1	Advertise governance protocols																					x
32	ESIP-sustDM	1	Have transparent practices and defensible data management policies																					x
33	ESIP-sustDM	1	Facilitate relationships between data provider and user communities																						x
34	ESIP-sustDM	1	Share material with an indigenous workforce																							x
35	ESIP-sustDM	2	Include indigenous representatives on repository advisory board if relevant																									x	x
36	ESIP-sustDM	2	Enable granular embargoes							x									x
37	ESIP-sustDM	1	Support tracking data provenance																x
38	ESIP-sustDM	1	Link between data and papers, other outcomes																	x
39	ESIP-sustDM	2	Create mechanism to control when/by whom data are accessed							x														x
40	ESIP-sustDM	1	Implement login systems that allow for transference of responsibilities																					x
41	ESIP-sustDM	1	Receive (copies of) agreements between proprietors and package them permanently with data																					x
42	ESIP-sustDM	1	Ensure that rights and restrictions are clearly communicated at deposition																						x
43	ESIP-sustDM	4	Use a metadata format that handles multiple languages		x							x						x									x
44	ESIP-sustDM	3	Keep a list of data “actors” (e.g., by role) and be able to link data to them											x			x										x
45	ESIP-sustDM	4	Work with IPs to develop keywords for their data discovery		x								x							x	x
46	ESIP-sustDM	1	Ensure that depositing researchers have done their due diligence																		x
47	ESIP-sustDM	2	Ensure metadata includes responsibilities of data users													x									x
48	ESIP-sustDM	1	Plan to evolve, in order to remain open and respect changing needs of IP																						x
49	ESIP-sustDM	3	Describe appropriate use or limitations in metadata		x											x									x
50	ESIP-sustDM	2	Allocate educational funds equitably, recognizing diff between “equal” and “equitable”																							x			x
51	ESIP-sustDM	4	Ensure tool design, selection of data formats, and metadata are appropriate for targeted communities and users						x									x									x		x
52	ESIP-sustDM	2	Implement text or badges that clarify types of use, e.g., Biocultural and Traditional Knowledge		x																									x
53	ESIP-sustDM	4	Engage with IP review processes to assist in determining appropriateness of a repository for certain types of data, e.g, data are confidential, sensitive				x																	x				x		x
54
55
56	FAIR maturity model (Bahim et al)	1	Metadata is identified by a persistent identifier	x
57	FAIR MM	1	Data is identified by a persistent identifier	x
58	FAIR MM	1	Metadata is identified by a globally unique identifier	x
59	FAIR MM	1	Data is identified by a globally unique identifier	x
60	FAIR MM	1	Rich metadata is provided to allow discovery		x
61	FAIR MM	1	Metadata includes the identifier for the data			x
62	FAIR MM	1	Metadata is offered in such a way that it can be harvested and indexed				x
63	FAIR MM	1	Metadata contains information to enable the user to get access to the data					x
64	FAIR MM	1	Metadata can be accessed manually (i.e. with human intervention)					x
65	FAIR MM	1	Data can be accessed manually (i.e. with human intervention)					x
66	FAIR MM	1	Metadata identifier resolves to a metadata record					x
67	FAIR MM	1	Data identifier resolves to a digital object					x
68	FAIR MM	1	Metadata is accessed through standardised protocol					x
69	FAIR MM	1	Data is accessible through standardised protocol					x
70	FAIR MM	1	Data can be accessed automatically (i.e. by a computer program)					x
71	FAIR MM	1	Metadata is accessible through a free access protocol						x
72	FAIR MM	1	Use a standard access protocol (OAI, OAIS)						x
73	FAIR MM	1	Repository authenticates users							x
74	FAIR MM	0	Repository has a system to limit used based on authorisation rules
75	FAIR MM	1	Metadata is guaranteed to remain available after data is no longer available								x
76	FAIR MM	1	Metadata uses knowledge representation expressed in standardised format									x
77	FAIR MM	1	Data uses knowledge representation expressed in standardised format									x
78	FAIR MM	1	Metadata uses machine-understandable knowledge representation									x
79	FAIR MM	1	Data uses machine-understandable knowledge representation									x
80	FAIR MM	1	Metadata uses FAIR-compliant vocabularies										x
81	FAIR MM	1	Data uses FAIR-compliant vocabularies										x
82	FAIR MM	1	Metadata includes references to other metadata											x
83	FAIR MM	1	Data includes references to other data											x
84	FAIR MM	1	Metadata includes references to other data											x
85	FAIR MM	1	Data includes qualified references to other data											x
86	FAIR MM	1	Metadata includes qualified references to other metadata											x
87	FAIR MM	1	Metadata include qualified references to other data											x
88	FAIR MM	1	Plurality of accurate and relevant attributes are provided to allow reuse												x
89	FAIR MM	1	Metadata includes information about the licence under which the data can be reused													x
90	FAIR MM	1	Metadata refers to a standard reuse licence													x
91	FAIR MM	1	Metadata refers to a machine-understandable reuse licence													x
92	FAIR MM	1	Metadata includes provenance information according to community-specific standards														x
93	FAIR MM	1	Metadata includes provenance information according to a cross-community language														x
94	FAIR MM	1	Metadata complies with a community standard															x
95	FAIR MM	1	Data complies with a community standard															x
96	FAIR MM	1	Metadata is expressed in compliance with a machine-understandable community standard															x
97	FAIR MM	1	Data is expressed in compliance with a machine-understandable community standard															x
98
99
100