Novice Intel 2019-2020

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K
1	School	Plan	Adv 1	Adv 2	Adv 3	Neg Args	T	DA	CP	K	Case

2	ADL	Taiwan, Saudi, Israel					T-Reduce, T-Subs, T-FMS/DCS	DIB
3	Bogan
4	Berkeley Prep	USFG will prohibit arms sale to Taiwan (rough--NDCA packet aff) / Human Rights	China Relations	Intervention				Politics Fill In DIB Allies	Conditions EUM Consult NATO	Security Militarism Weaponitis
5	Blue Valley North	The United States federal government should substantially reduce the sale of arms from the United States by reducing its Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales to Taiwan. The United States federal government should substantially reduce its Foreign Military Sales and Direct Commercial Sales of arms to Saudi Arabia on the grounds that the War Powers Resolution requires Congressional authorization for military intervention into hostilities.	Taiwan- 1st advantage is Taiwan War; f16 anger China, causing a cross strait crisis. Arms sales will push US China relations over the brink, causing China aggression and Taiwan Independence leading to Nuclear war 2nd advantage is US-Sino Relations; Right now, trump want arms control with Russia and CHina. China not agreeing because of Taiwan. Chinese modernization, leading to miscalc, where Taiwan is Flashpoint, goes nuclear	Saudi Arabia- 1st advantage is Yemen War; Solving the genocide Yemen war, preventing Saudi Iran war escalation 2nd advantage is War Powers; Trump vetoed the restriction of arms sales to Saudi Arabia the supreme court will rule that this is an unconstitutional abrogation of the wpr. This solves broader congressional oversight which solves extinction and nuclear miscalc.				DIB Fill In Relations Prolif	Conditions		Oil Turn, HR Abuse turn
6	Chicago HS Ag Sciences
7	Detroit Country Day
8	H.H. Dow	Israel (Soft Left)
9	Dowling
10	East Kentwood
11	Evanston
12	GBN	Plan: The United States federal government should debar Foreign Military Sales and/or Direct Commercial Sales offset by compensatory procurement arrangements lacking real-time, itemized reporting.	Corruption	Sustainability		Prolif Good by accident?	-T Substantial is 2.7% -T Reduce means permanent -T Reduce means immediate -ASPEC -T And/Or -Vagueness	-Appeasement DA -Allies DAs specific to the different affs -Deterrence DA -CMR DA (Circumvention) -Iran Revisionism DA -Russia Fill-In DA -Troop Shift DA -SAFE Banking -Pompeo DA -Litigation DA (Vagueness)	States/Lopez CP Climate Offsets+Suspend Deliveries CP MESA CP		Circumvention
13	GBS	Plan Text: The United States federal government should substantially reduce Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of arms from the United States to The Republic of China.	China/Taiwan War	US/China relations (global warming scenario)			T - Reduce is not future sales T - Substantial is 2.7% Effects T T - Suspend does not equal reduce	Alliances DAs - specifically Saudi, East Asia Houthi Victory DA China Containment DA Defense Industrial Base DA Russia Fill In DA Terror Turn on Case	Consult Nato China Conditions
14	Grand Rapids
15	Groves	Ukraine	Russia War	Moral Obligation					Conditions CP	SetCol K
16	Iowa City	Saudi Arabia	Stability (Saudi-Iran war)	Humanitarian (Moral Obligation)			T-Reduce	Rusisa Fill In Allied Prolif DA Saudi Alliance DA	Conditions CP	Militarism K
17	Iowa City West	Saudi Arabia	Stability (Saudi-Iran war)	Humanitarian (Moral Obligation)			T-Subs 2.7% T-Reduce T-Reduce (Pearson)	-DIB -Russia Fill In -Saudi Relations -U.S withdrawl bad vs Saudi -USMCA	Saudi Conditions	Militarism K
18	Jones
19	Kenwood
20	Lane Tech	The United States Federal Government should substantially reduce Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of arms to Saudi Arabia	Yemen	Leadership	Framing			Allies Fill-In DIB 2020	Conditions CP	Black T	Heg Bad
21	Lansing	The United States federal government should substantially reduce Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of arms from the United States to the Republic of China.	Crisis Instab	Trade War				Fill In Econ Prolif USMCA Intervention Prez Powers Relations	Conditions Deterrence Grand Bargain
22	Lindblom
23	Little Rock Central	The United States federal government should substantially reduce Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of arms from the United States to Taiwan.	Relations	Retaliation				Tsai Allied Prolif MBS China Rise		Cap K	Circumvention
24	Maine East	Plan: The United States federal government should substantially reduce Foreign Military Sales and Direct Commercial Sales licenses to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.	Yemen	Iran			-T Substantial is 2.7% -T Reduce means permanent -ASpec -T Reduce means immediate	-Appeasement DA -Japan Alliance DA -CMR DA -Iran Revisionism DA -Russia Fill-In DA -impact turns- prolif good, dedev	Consult Nato Consult Japan
25	Marquette	Plan: The United States federal government should substantially reduce Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of small arms and light weapons from the United States.	Violnece	Cartels				Russia DA
26	Meadows	The United States federal government should substantially reduce its Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of arms to the Republic of China.	War	Relations				-DIB -Allies -Russia -Houthi Victory	Conditions CP	Militarism K
27	Northview
28	New Trier	Plan: The United States federal government should bar Foreign Military Sales and suspend Direct Commercial Sales licenses relating to air-to-ground strike capabilities for operations in Yemen.	Yemen, civilian casualties and terror	entrapment, Saudi-Iran war			-T-Reduce -T-Substantial	-Russia Fill-In DA -Assurance DA -Allies DA (Saudis, Japan) -Deterrence DA (Iran, Russia, China) -DIB DA	Consult NATO CP	Security K
29	Niles North	Plan Text: The United States federal government should substantially reduce its Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of arms to the Republic of China.	Relations	Deterrence			T -Subs (2.7%)	Defense Industrial Base DA Japan Alliance DA Russia Fill In DA Appeasement DA Oil DA USMCA DA	Consult NATO CP
30	Niles West	The United States federal government should bar foreign military sales and suspend direct commercial sales licenses relating to air-to-ground strike capabilities for operations in Yemen.	Yemen	Iran			-T-Reduce -T-Substantial	-Russia Fill-In DA -Assurance DA -Saudi Alliance DA -Iran Deterrence DA -Russia Deterrence DA -DIB DA -China Appeasement DA	Conditions CP Pressure CP Consult NATO CP	Security K
31	North Broward	Plan: The United States federal government should substantially reduce Foreign Military Sales of arms provided by private military companies to Nigeria from the United States.	Structural Violence				T-Body Politics T-Reduce	Investor Confidence DA	Consult JCS CP	Black Baudrillard
32	Northside
33	Oakland	Taiwan					T-Reduce	2020	XO
34	Okemos							China Appeasement Iran DA
35	OPRF	The Plan: The United States federal government should substantially reduce Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of arms to the Republic of China.	Taiwan Independence	Trade			T Substantial--2.7% T Reduce Not Future Sales	Defense Base DA Russia Fill In DA China Fill In DA Alliances DA (both Saudi and Japan versions) Appeasement DA	EUM Reform CP Coexist CP vs Taiwan Contain China CP Yemen Negotiated Settlement CP Consult ICJ CP
36	Padre Pio Academy
37	Pine Crest	Drones	China	DIB
38	Solorio	Plan: The United States federal government should end its arms sales to Taiwan.	Taiwan Crisis, ends in a pretty terrible piece of Glaser 11 evidence that talks about escalation of a US-China tensions < - ALL NOVICE	Relations are key to solve global warming. <- Preferably few			T - Substantial is 2.7%	Defense Industrial Base DA Japan Alliance DA Saudi Alliance DA Russia Fill In DA Appeasement DA Elections DA (Trump Good) Elections DA (Trump Bad) Exec Flex USMCA	Consult Nato CP
39	St. John's Jesuit
40	Traverse City Central
41	UC Lab	Plan: The USFG should substantially reduce DCS and FMS relating to air-to-ground strike capabilities in Yemen.	Entrapment	Yemen			substantial = over 50% reduce ≠ subsets FMS/DCS ≠ commerce control	DIB Fill in: Russia, China Appeasement Allies DA			camp case-neg file args general impact defense impact turns: heg bad, prolif good, dedev impact framing args: rescher, et al.
42	Walter Payton
43	Washburn Rural	The United States federal government should substantially reduce Direct Commercial Sales and Foreign Military Sales of offensive lethal weapons to Ukraine.	Russia	Relations				Appeasement Allies Fill In DIB	China QPQ Saudi Escalate
44	Washington	Saudi	Yemen	Iran	Human Rights			Houthi Victory DA Alliance DA
45	West Des Moines Valley	Saudi						DIB	Conditions CP - Peace Settlement, Khashoggi, ILaw
46	Westminster
47	Whitney Young
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100