1 | Name: | Date: | Score: | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | ||||||
3 | Exceeds Standard [10] | Meets Standard [8] | Nearly Meets Standard [6] | Does Not Meet Standard [<6] | Score | |
4 | Summary: You read and understood the paper | You clearly and concisely overview the main methods, contributions, and results presented in the paper | You overview most of the main methods, contributions, and results in the paper | You overview some of the main methods, contributions, and results in the paper | It is clear you did not read or understand the paper, even at a basic level | |
5 | Critique: Your opinion of the work | More than one opinion presented and backed up with reasonable justification | An opinion is presented with some justification | An opinion is weakly presented | No opinion of the work | |
6 | Questions: What else you want to know about the work | Several valid and important questions raised about the work | Several valid questions about the work | At least one valid question about the work | No question or questions that are already answered in the paper |