ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABAC
1
CLGroupRuleSpecVoiceSubrules
Paragraph
CommentIDs
2
RhythmRhythmBeginning is non-standard1/8 note18230
3
Misuse of restrest inside18517
4
Misuse of rest
wrong starting rest
late entrance18This rule is ignored if there is no cantus firmus138527
5
Missing rest/no starting rest18This rule is ignored if there is no cantus firmus237
6
Simultaneous entries of voices/simultaneous18This rule is ignored if there is no cantus firmus530
7
Same rhythm in adjacent measures/same23247
8
Identical rhythm in two parts/same23549
9
Identical rhythm in all parts/same23For any species except species 1215
10
Non-permitted rhythm51/2. downbeat1/2. upbeat1/4 syncope21For species 5233234235
11
Non-permitted rhythm
rhythm stagnation
long inside
full-measure note inside
17236160266
12
Wrong usage of eighth notes51st beat2nd beat3rd beat4th beatisolated1/8 syncope>2 x 1/8leap2122622722822923123225588
13
Anapaest5tie forwardinside211/2 after 1/4 or 1/8 in measure239240
14
Wrong note value for this species/value17
Please see link to table with allowed note values near this mistake
514
15
Wrong time signature for this species/measure len17525
16
Wrong positioning of note for this species12340/position17
Please see link to table with allowed positionings of notes near this mistake
515
17
Note lasts for too many measures>21741
18
The length of last note is not full measure1230
/not full measure
19306
19
Wrong suspension rhythm
sus wrong length
prep < sus
prep wrong length
63Suspension preparation and suspension244427274
20
Need more suspensionseach 3 meas.341
21
Too many notes in one measure55 notes after sus.
5 notes without sus.
>5 notes21301245246
22
Repeats and tiesNote repeatcantus
:inside measure
2130516
23
Notes repeat in all parts1/multivoice31557
24
Note is repeated: in 10 notes10once2 times>2 times31Note repeat happens several times939495
25
Note repeat2345/any31Note is repeated261
26
Frequent interruption of syncopation: within 10 notes4once2 times>2 times17
Except interruption of syncopation between penultimate and last measure
188189190
27
MelodyBorderLeading tone is unresolved12345/unresolved6197
28
Compensated leap8ve compensated only to 4th8ve25304
29
Uncompensated leap: compensation deviation to 2nd123403rd4th5th6th8velate >3>5th long25
Compensation can be deviated one 2nd interval above last leap note
100101102103104191386
30
Uncompensated leap: compensation deviation to 2nd53rd4th5th6th8velate >3>5th long25
Compensation can be deviated one 2nd interval above last leap note
100101102103104191386
31
Uncompensated leap: compensation deviation to 3rd1403rd4th5th6th8velate >325
Compensation can be deviated one 3rd interval above last leap note
105106107108109192
32
Uncompensated leap: compensation deviation to 3rd2353rd4th5th6th8velate >325
Compensation can be deviated one 3rd interval above last leap note
105106107108109192
33
Compensation after 3rd3rd4th5th6th8ve25
Compensation has a gap of one 3rd below last leap note
110111112113114
34
Compensated to 3rd prepared-4th5th6th8ve25Prepared within 5 notes115116117118119
35
Compensated to 3rd-4th5th6th8ve25120121122123124
36
Aggregated compensation+precompensation to 3rd5--5th6th8ve25
Distance between precompensation and compensation is not greater than a 3rd
125126127128129
37
C5P last 3 measures, 8 notes3rd4th5th6th8ve25Compensated to 5th, precompensated within 6 notes130131132133134
38
Uncompensated leapUncompensated leap: precompensated123503rd4th5th6th8ve25140141142143144
39
Uncompensated leap: precompensated43rd4th5th6th8ve25140141142143144
40
Precompensated last 2 leaps3rd4th5th6th8ve25Leap within last XX notes in cantus/counterpoint145146147148149
41
Uncompensated child leap3rd4th5th6th8ve25After longer leap or before longer/same leap.203204205206207
42
Uncompensated leap in last 2 measures3rd4th5th6th8ve25
Leap between penpenultimate and penultimate measure is not included in this rule.
267268269270271
43
Uncompensated leap12303rd4th5th6th8veborder 4th25If no other uncompensated rules worked.2772782792802811
44
Uncompensated leap43rd4th5th6th8veborder 4th25If no other uncompensated rules worked.2772782792802811
45
Uncompensated leap53rd4th5th6th8veborder 4th25If no other uncompensated rules worked.2772782792802811
46
Change of melodic direction around leapNo change of direction after the leap: close + neigh13rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is immediate melody direction change before leap. After leap there is neighbor tone, then ending leap note repeats and then there is movement inside leap.
296297298299300
47
No change of direction after the leap: close + 1skip13rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is immediate melody direction change before leap, but after leap melody direction changes only after one note, which goes in the same direction as leap
315316317318319
48
No change of direction after the leap: close + 2skip13rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is immediate melody direction change before leap, but after leap melody direction changes only after two notes, which go in the same direction as leap
327328329330331
49
No change of direction after the leap: close + >2skip13rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is immediate melody direction change before leap, but after leap melody direction changes after more than two notes, which go in the same direction as leap
336337338339340
50
No change of direction before the leap: neigh + close13rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is immediate melody direction change after leap. Before leap there is neighbor tone, then ending leap note repeats and then there is movement inside leap.
351352353354355
51
No change of direction before the leap: 1skip + close13rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is immediate melody direction change after leap, but before leap melody direction changes after one note, which goes in the same direction as leap
389390391392393
52
No change of direction before the leap: >1skip + close13rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is immediate melody direction change after leap, but before leap melody direction changes after more than one note, which go in the same direction as leap
394395396397398
53
No change of direction before and after the leap: 1skip + 1skip123503rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is one note going in the same direction before and after leap
414415416417418
54
No change of direction before and after the leap: 1skip + >1skip123503rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is one note going in the same direction before leap and more than one note going in the same direction after leap
421422423424425
55
No change of direction before and after the leap: >1skip + 1skip123503rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is more than one note going in the same direction before leap and one note going in the same direction after leap
438439440441442
56
No change of direction before and after the leap: >1skip + >1skip123503rd4th5th6th8ve25
There is more than one note going in the same direction before leap and more than one note going in the same direction after leap
443444445446447
57
No change of direction before and after the leap: neigh + neigh353rd4th5th6th8ve25
Before and after leap there is neighbor tone, then ending leap note repeats and then there is movement inside leap.
448449450451452
58
No change of direction before the leap between measures: 1skip + close123503rd4th5th6th8ve26
There is immediate melody direction change after leap, but before leap melody direction changes after one note, which goes in the same direction as leap (allowed between harmonies with same root except I or I6 -> I64, allowed between I64 -> V)
453454455456457
59
No change of direction before the leap between measures: >1skip + close123503rd4th5th6th8ve26
There is immediate melody direction change after leap, but before leap melody direction changes after more than one note, which go in the same direction as leap (allowed between harmonies with same root except I or I6 -> I64, allowed between I64 -> V)
459460461462463
60
No change of direction before the leap between measures: 1skip + 1skip123503rd4th5th6th8ve26
Turns around leap on measure border. There is one note going in the same direction before and after leap (allowed between harmonies with same root except I or I6 -> I64, allowed between I64 -> V)
464465466467468
61
No change of direction before the leap between measures: 1skip + >1skip123503rd4th5th6th8ve26
Turns around leap on measure border. There is one note going in the same direction before leap and more than one note going in the same direction after leap (allowed between harmonies with same root except I or I6 -> I64, allowed between I64 -> V)
469470471472473
62
No change of direction before the leap between measures: >1skip + 1skip123503rd4th5th6th8ve26
Turns around leap on measure border. There is more than one note going in the same direction before leap and one note going in the same direction after leap (allowed between harmonies with same root except I or I6 -> I64, allowed between I64 -> V)
474475476477478
63
No change of direction before the leap between measures: >1skip + >1skip
123503rd4th5th6th8ve26
Turns around leap on measure border. There is more than one note going in the same direction before leap and more than one note going in the same direction after leap (allowed between harmonies with same root except I or I6 -> I64, allowed between I64 -> V)
506507508509510
64
Leap back<=6th>6thoverflow82258
65
LeapsNon-permitted melodic interval: ascending:m6:maj6:m7:maj7:8ve
:greater than 8ve
27175176177178179180
66
Non-permitted melodic interval: descending:m6:maj6:m7:maj7:8ve
:greater than 8ve
27181182183184185186
67
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 9 notes0>7 leaps>30 leaped>8 leaps>36 leaped25493494495496
68
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 9 notes1>6 leaps>30 leaped>8 leaps>36 leaped25493494495496
69
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 9 notes2>6 leaps>22 leaped>7 leaps>30 leaped25493494495496
70
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 9 notes3>6 leaps>22 leaped>7 leaps>30 leaped25493494495496
71
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 9 notes4>7 leaps>30 leaped>8 leaps>36 leaped25493494495496
72
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 9 notes5>7 leaps>30 leaped>8 leaps>36 leaped25493494495496
73
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 14 notes0>9 leaps>40 leaped>10 leaps>46 leaped25497498499500
74
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 14 notes1>8 leaps>40 leaped>10 leaps>46 leaped25497498499500
75
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 14 notes2>8 leaps>32 leaped>9 leaps>34 leaped25497498499500
76
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 14 notes3>8 leaps>32 leaped>9 leaps>34 leaped25497498499500
77
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 14 notes4>9 leaps>40 leaped>10 leaps>46 leaped25497498499500
78
Abuse of disjunct motion: within 14 notes5>9 leaps>40 leaped>10 leaps>46 leaped25497498499500
79
Consecutive leaps2303more than 3251x3rd ignored501502
80
Consecutive leaps143more than 3252x3rd ignored501502
81
Consecutive leaps54more than 4251x3rd ignored501502
82
Consecutive unidirectional leaps23Two 3rdsThree 3rdsTwo >3rds25503504505
83
Consecutive unidirectional leaps4510Two 3rdsThree 3rdsTwo >3rds25503504505
84
Stepwise motionAbuse of stepwise motion0>7 in any direction24
There are more than AA notes going stepwize in the same direction in this cantus firmus
302
85
Abuse of stepwise motion14>10 in any direction24302
86
Abuse of stepwise motion2>14 in any direction24302
87
Abuse of stepwise motion35>14 in any direction24302
88
Abuse of unidirectional stepwise motion0>4 in one direction24303
89
Abuse of unidirectional stepwise motion14>7 in one direction24303
90
Abuse of unidirectional stepwise motion2>7 in one direction24303
91
Abuse of unidirectional stepwise motion3>9 in one direction24303
92
Abuse of unidirectional stepwise motion5>7 in one direction24303
93
Melodic repeatsRepetition - 2 notes are repeated: immediate104uniformsame rhythmany rhythm32Two adjacent notes are immediately repeated402403404
94
Repetition - 2 notes are repeated: immediate3uniformsame rhythmany rhythm32Two adjacent notes are immediately repeated402403404
95
Repetition - 2 notes are repeated: immediate2uniformsame rhythmany rhythm32Two adjacent notes are immediately repeated402403404
96
Repetition - 2 notes are repeated: immediate IM23uniformsame rhythmany rhythm32
Two adjacent notes are immediately repeated inside one measure
411412413
97
Repetition - 2 notes are repeated: immediate5uniformsame rhythmany rhythm32Two adjacent notes are immediately repeated402403404
98
Repetition - 2 notes are repeated: immediate IM5uniformsame rhythmany rhythm32
Two adjacent notes are immediately repeated inside one measure
411412413
99
Repetition - 3 notes are repeated 2 timesadjacentsymmetric32
Repeat with the same rhythm (last note length is ignored)
311405
100
Repetition - 3 notes are repeated 3 timesadjacentsymmetric32
Repeat with the same rhythm (last note length is ignored)
313407