PB_2011_Vote_Values_f
 Share
The version of the browser you are using is no longer supported. Please upgrade to a supported browser.Dismiss

 
View only
 
 
Still loading...
ABCDEFGHI
1
Participatory Budget Votes in Chicago 2011$480,000was available.4,884votes were cast.
2
The values of votes in the 49th Ward. by Robert LoringAbout 1000 voters cast ballots.$98for each vote cast
3
Up to 6 votes per ballot. No Cumulative Voting eg. 6 votes for 1 item.
4
CV could require a voter give costly items more votes, so votes are equal.
5
Loser 2, 3, 6 or 8 is more cost effective at getting votes than winner 4, 5 or 17.
6
The STV voting rule is more efficient and fair: Each item needs enough votes to pay its cost.STV introduction.STV for projects.
7
For approx. equal ≈ votes, divide budgets by$12,000
8
#Project TitleProposed BudgetVotes CastRankWinner$/Vote≈ Votes
9
16Bike Racks$12,0003883WonOne vote for every $311
10
1Metra Underpass Renovation at Birchwood, Touhy & Estes$15,0003594WonOne vote for every $421
11
2Neighborhood Kiosks$15,00018912One vote for every $791
12
6Additional Funds for Pottawatomie Park Dog Park$45,0002977One vote for every $1524
13
15Improve the Intersection of Ridge, Touhy and Rogers$75,0004941WonOne vote for every $1526
14
3Decorative Light Poles$25,00014816One vote for every $1692
15
8Police Cameras at Lunt & Paulina, and Touhy & Sheridan$40,00018713One vote for every $2143
16
17Rogers Park Bike Network, Phase 2$90,0004072WonOne vote for every $2218
17
7Police Cameras outside the Loyola Park Fieldhouse and at Rogers & Damen and Estes & Glenwood.$60,0002538One vote for every $2375
18
18New Canopy at Rogers Park Metra Station$50,00020510One vote for every $2444
19
14Install handicapped ramps and paint crosswalks at Ridge Blvd. and Chase Ave.$40,00014717One vote for every $2723
20
4Beach Path Extensions at Jarvis, Touhy and Morse$105,0003256WonOne vote for every $3239
21
21Sidewalk Repairs: 1944-46 W Touhy, 1901 and 2001 blocks of W Lunt, and 1247-65 W Columbia$55,00011619One vote for every $4745
22
5New Playground at Touhy Park$175,0003495WonOne vote for every $50115
23
11New Residential Street Lights: Morse Ave., from Ravenswood Ave. to Clark St. and Sherwin Ave., from Sheridan Rd. to the Lake.$120,00019811One vote for every $60610
24
10Additional Residential Street Lighting: Chase Ave & Birchwood Ave, from Ridge Blvd to Damen Ave.$60,0009820One vote for every $6125
25
19Sidewalk Repairs: 7201 W Claremont Ave, 2301 W Chase and 2101 W Fargo$145,0002129One vote for every $68412
26
20Sidewalk Repairs: 7202 N Hamilton Ave, 1147-51 W Pratt, 7300 N Rogers Ave and 1250 W Sherwin$95,00012618One vote for every $7548
27
12New Residential Street Lights: Estes Ave., from Asland Blvd. to Glenwood Ave.$120,00015314One vote for every $78410
28
9New Residential Street Lights: Juneway Terr, from Asland Ave. to Sheridan Rd$130,00014915One vote for every $87211
29
13Ashland and Greenleaf Traffic/Pedestrian Signal$320,0008421One vote for every $3,81027
35
TOTALS$1,792,0004,884A total of$472,000
36
supported by2322
37
Anyone who voted for all six winners won $1,031.average winning vote$203
38
Anyone who voted for six "losers" such as 2, 3, 6, 7, 8, funded nothing $0.ballot with 6 winners$1,218
39
Voting based on transferable votes is much more fair.So it is worth your time to vote!
40
41
If we combine projects 2 and 6, we might get a project worth 486 votes for $60,000.*
42
According to voters, this is a much better use of money than project 5.
43
*But a voter who had voted for both is not allowed to give 2 votes to the new proposal.
44
45
If we combine projects 2, 3 and 6, we may get a project worth 634 votes for $85,000.*
46
That is half the cost of project 5 and almost twice the votes.
47
48
If we combine projects 2, 3, 6 and 8, we get a project worth 821 votes for $125,000.*
49
That still costs less than project 5.
50
51
The 10 most popular losers got 1542 votes for $330000.
52
53
https://spreadsheets.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AmxLFEkJdvAHdGhJSGU2aXU5OE40cnhlbFFjby1OVnc&hl=en_US
Loading...
 
 
 
Sheet1
Sheet2
Sheet3