ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAEAFAG
1
This spreadsheet has been used for manual tracking; a form and capture spreadsheet is now ready to go
2
Form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdfuoTDMU9MUl3i81DzzgVNIC4WN0bO5l5O58g-cbogOWiohA/viewform?usp=sf_link
3
Capture spreadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1v8X13-6qooNspW25_xkWbnK60Ic_4im2iL_YZFK0k_Y
4
#ErrorSuggested CorrectionReasonClass/Property/Section/DiagramFieldPage numberVersionLanguageFound by (name)Found by (email)Recording dateResolvedRejectedEndorsed CorrectionEdited inEdited by (name)Edited by (email)Editing dateComment
5
1In cases where substance from an instance of E64 Persistent Item continues to exist in a new formIn cases where substance from an instance of E77 Persistent Item continues to exist in a new formWrong class codeE64 End of ExistenceScope note397.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-02-02In cases where substance from an instance of E77 Persistent Item continues to exist in a new form7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
6
2E95 - - Spaceime PrimitiveE95 - - Spacetime PrimitiveTypo in the word "Spacetime"CIDOC CRM Class Hierarchyxxxvi7.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-04-14EC: I do not see this error in 7.1.2
7
3P174 starts before (starts after the start of): E2 Temporal EntityP174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of): E2 Temporal EntityWrong property labelE2 Temporal EntityProperties37.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-04-19P174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of): E2 Temporal Entity7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
8
4P175 starts before or with the start of (starts with or after the start of): E2 Temporal EntityP175 starts before or with the start of (starts after or with the start of): E2 Temporal EntityWrong property labelE2 Temporal EntityProperties37.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-04-19P175 starts before or with the start of (starts after or with the start of): E2 Temporal Entity7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
9
5P182 ends before or with the start of (starts with or after the end of): E2 Temporal EntityP182 ends before or with the start of (starts after or with the end of): E2 Temporal EntityWrong property labelE2 Temporal EntityProperties37.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-04-19P182 ends before or with the start of (starts after or with the end of): E2 Temporal Entity7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
10
6Sir Ian McKellan (E21)Sir Ian McKellen (E21)Typo in the name "McKellen"E39 ActorExamples287.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-04-26Typo in the name "McKellen"7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
11
7The more specific criteria that determine the identity of instances of subclasses of E77 Persistent Item may vary considerably and are described of referred to in the respective scope notes.The more specific criteria that determine the identity of instances of subclasses of E77 Persistent Item may vary considerably and are described or referred to in the respective scope notes.Typo in the word "or"E77 Persistent ItemScope note457.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-04-26The more specific criteria that determine the identity of instances of subclasses of E77 Persistent Item may vary considerably and are described or referred to in the respective scope notes.7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
12
8relevant characteristics use to be sufficiently similar to recognize the instance for some substantial period of time.relevant characteristics used should be sufficiently similar to recognize the instance for some substantial period of time.Missing verbE77 Persistent ItemScope note457.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-04-26relevant characteristics used should be sufficiently similar to recognize the instance for some substantial period of time.7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22
13
9E13 Attribute Assignment P177 assigned property of type: E55 TypeE13 Attribute Assignment. P177 assigned property of type: E55 TypeMissing dotP2 has type (is type of)Superproperty of607.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-05-18E13 Attribute Assignment. P177 assigned property of type: E55 Type7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
14
10E13 Attribute AssignementE13 Attribute AssignmentTypo in the word "Assignment"Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchyxxxix7.1EnglishStephen Hartstephen.hart2@pch.gc.ca2021-05-20EC: I do not see this error in 7.1.2
15
11E15 Identifier AssignementE15 Identifier AssignmentTypo in the word "Assignment"Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchyxxxix7.1EnglishStephen Hartstephen.hart2@pch.gc.ca2021-05-20EC: I do not see this error in 7.1.2
16
12E15 Identifier AssignementE15 Identifier AssignmentTypo in the word "Assignment"Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchyxxxix7.1EnglishStephen Hartstephen.hart2@pch.gc.ca2021-05-20EC: I do not see this error in 7.1.2
17
13E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchyxxxvii7.1EnglishStephen Hartstephen.hart2@pch.gc.ca2021-05-20E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
18
14P151 was formed from: E74 GroupP151 was formed from (participated in): E74 GroupMissing inverse propertyE66 FormationProperties957.1.1EnglishStephen Hartstephen.hart2@pch.gc.ca2021-06-23P151 was formed from (participated in): E74 Group7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
19
15the instance of E7 Event it is intended to be preparation for.the instance of E5 Event it is intended to be preparation for.Wrong class codeP20 had specific purpose (was purpose of)Scope note1267.1.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-09-17the instance of E5 Event it is intended to be preparation for.7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
20
16life-span and can infer, that they mustlife-span and can infer that they mustNo need to include a commaP93 took out of existence (was taken out of existence by)Scope note1627.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-11-16life-span and can infer that they must7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
21
17The instance of P21 Person being bornThe instance of E21 Person being bornWrong class codeP96 by mother (gave birth)Scope note1647.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2021-11-16The instance of E21 Person being born7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
22
18P79(x,y) ⇒ E52 (x)P79(x,y) ⇒ E52(x)No spaceP79 beginning is qualified byIn First Order Logic1577.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-01-17P79(x,y) ⇒ E52(x)7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
23
19the UK to the USA. (Wildfang, 2005)the UK to the USA (Wildfang, 2005)No period in the examplesE9 MoveExamples657.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-01-28the UK to the USA (Wildfang, 2005)7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
24
202nd November 2019.2nd November 2019No period in the examplesE9 MoveExamples657.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-01-282nd November 20197.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
25
21The direction of the assigned property typeThe direction of the assigned property of typeWrong property labelP177 assigned property of typeScope note2077.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-04The direction of the assigned property of type7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
26
22silver cup February 1997 (E13) assigned property type P52 has formersilver cup February 1997 (E13) assigned property of type P52 has formerWrong property labelP177 assigned property of typeExamples2087.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-04silver cup February 1997 (E13) assigned property of type P52 has former7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
27
23the silver cup donated by Martin Doerr (E15) assigned property type P48 has preferred identifierthe silver cup donated by Martin Doerr (E15) assigned property of type P48 has preferred identifierWrong property labelP177 assigned property of typeExamples2087.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-04the silver cup donated by Martin Doerr (E15) assigned property of type P48 has preferred identifier7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
28
24Sinai Greek 418 (E13) assigned property type binding structure type
(E55)		Sinai Greek 418 (E13) assigned property of type binding structure type
(E55)		Wrong property labelP177 assigned property of typeExamples2087.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-04Sinai Greek 418 (E13) assigned property of type binding structure type
(E55)		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
29
25MS Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property type damage (E55.) [‘damage’MS Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type damage (E55.) [‘damage’Wrong property labelP177 assigned property of typeExamples2087.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-04MS Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type damage (E55.) [‘damage’7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
30
26Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property type quality (E55). [‘quality’ refersSinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type quality (E55). [‘quality’ refersWrong property labelP177 assigned property of typeExamples2087.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-04Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type quality (E55). [‘quality’ refers7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
31
27querying for the above presented five properties will provide answer to allquerying for the five high-level properties in figure 1 will provide answer to allUnclear reference to properties - narratively incorrectRelations with Events357.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-17querying for the five high-level properties in figure 1 will provide answer to all7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022
32
281689 (Gleick,2003)1689 (Gleick, 2003)Missing spaceE85 JoiningExamples1067.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-181689 (Gleick, 2003)7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
33
290,n P2 is type of 0,n0,n P2 has type 0,nWrong property labelFigure 1357.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-230,n P2 has type 0,n7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022EC: Font issue in image file
34
300,n P7 took place on or within (witnessed) 0,n0,n P8 took place on or within (witnessed) 0,nWrong property codeFigure 4387.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-02-230,n P8 took place on or within (witnessed) 0,n7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022EC: Font issue in image file
35
31Scope N/note:Scope Note:ConsistencyMultiple throughoutScope note7.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01Scope Note:7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22
36
32...may all be members of
instances of E74 Group.An
instance of E74 Group...		...may all be members of
instances of E74 Group. An
instance of E74 Group...		Space needed before "An"P107 has current or former memberScope note1717.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...may all be members of
instances of E74 Group. An
instance of E74 Group...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
37
33Instances of E74 Group and
E21 Person, may all be
members...		Instances of E74 Group and
E21 Person may all be
members...		Comma grammatically
incorrect		P107 has current or former memberScope note1717.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01Instances of E74 Group and
E21 Person may all be
members...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
38
34The painting of the Sistine
Chapel (E7) carried out by
Michaelangelo Buonaroti		The painting of the Sistine
Chapel (E7) carried out by
Michelangelo Buonaroti		Typo in name "Michelangelo"P14 performedExamples1247.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01The painting of the Sistine
Chapel (E7) carried out by
Michelangelo Buonaroti		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
39
35...extracted from different
items of jewellry...		...extracted from different
items of jewellery...		Typo in word "jewellery"E80 Part RemovalScope note1047.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...extracted from different
items of jewellery...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
40
36...discourse the CIDOC CRM
aims to define and analyze. 		...discourse the CIDOC CRM
aims to define and analyse. 		American spellingE59 Primitive ValueScope note927.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...discourse the CIDOC CRM
aims to define and analyse. 		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
41
37fr [French] (Rickard, 1974)fr [French] (Rickard, 1974)Extra space between "fr"
and "[French]"		E56 LanguageExamples917.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01EC: I do not see this error in 7.1.2
42
38el [Greek] (Palmer, 1980)el [Greek] (Palmer, 1980)Extra space betweel "el"
and "[Greek]"		E56 LanguageExamples917.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01EC: I do not see this error in 7.1.2
43
39[24.75 million GBP (Brithish Pounds)][24.75 million GBP (British Pounds)]Typo in the word "British"E54 DimensionExamples897.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01[24.75 million GBP (British Pounds)]7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
44
40the vertical height of the statue of David by Michaelangelothe vertical height of the statue
of David by Michelangelo		Typo in name "Michelangelo"E54 DimensionExamples897.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01the vertical height of the statue
of David by Michelangelo		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
45
41resulting from the particular
method or calculation.		...resulting from the particular
method of calculation.		Typo - "of" not "or"E54 DimensionScope note897.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01EC: I do not see this error in 7.1.2
46
42...the surface of the Eearth......the surface of the Earth...Typo in the word "earth"E53 PlaceScope note887.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...the surface of the Earth...7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
47
43[Identifier for “The Unesco
courier (Print)”]		[Identifier for “The UNESCO
Courier (Print)”]		UNESCO is an acronym;
journal title is capital		E42 IdentifierExamples867.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01[Identifier for “The UNESCO
Courier (Print)”]		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
48
44Postal addresses, telephone
numbers, urls and e-mail
addresses...		Postal addresses, telephone
numbers, URLs and e-mail
addresses...		URL is an acronymE42 IdentifierScope note867.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01Postal addresses, telephone
numbers, URLs and e-mail
addresses...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
49
45‘Cereus hildmannianus
K.Schumann’, July 2003		‘Cereus hildmannianus
K. Schumann’, July 2003		Space missing between
"K." and "Schumann"		E17 Type AssignmentExamples727.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01‘Cereus hildmannianus
K. Schumann’, July 2003		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
50
46(Honey & Pickwoad , 2010)(Honey & Pickwoad, 2010)Extra space between
name and comma		E13 Attribute AssignmentExamples687.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01(Honey & Pickwoad, 2010)7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
51
47...may be analyzed into
component phenomena		...may be analysed into
component phenomena		American spellingE5 EventScope note617.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...may be analysed into
component phenomena		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
52
48...not further analyzed in the
CIDOC CRM		...not further analysed in the
CIDOC CRM		American spellingSpatiotemporal Relations407.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...not further analysed in the
CIDOC CRM		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
53
49...which may continued to
be used...		...which may continue to
be used...		Typo on "continue"Temporal Relations407.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...which may continue to
be used...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
54
50...not further analyzed in the
CIDOC CRM		...not further analysed in the
CIDOC CRM		American spellingSpatial Relations377.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...not further analysed in the
CIDOC CRM		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
55
51...events can be instances of
combinations of these and
others classes...		...events can be instances of
combinations of these and
other classes...		Typo on "other"Relations with Events357.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...events can be instances of
combinations of these and
other classes...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
56
52...intended scope can be
increased on demand without
loosing compatibility:		...intended scope can be
increased on demand without
losing compatibility:		"Lose" not "loose"Exensions of the CRM277.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...intended scope can be
increased on demand without
losing compatibility:		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
57
53...utterances, behavior and
products.		...utterances, behaviour and
products.		American spellingReality, Knowledge Bases and
CIDOC CRM		257.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...utterances, behaviour and
products.		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
58
54...such as the center of Earth
or the sun...		...such as the centre of Earth
or the sun...		American spellingReality, Knowledge Bases and
CIDOC CRM		257.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...such as the centre of Earth
or the sun...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
59
55Person is both, an Actor and
a Biological Object		Person is both an Actor and
a Biological Object		Comma grammatically
incorrect		Terminology167.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01Person is both an Actor and
a Biological Object		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
60
56...and other collections......and other collections...Extra spaceScope of the CRM107.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...and other collections...7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
61
57...starting from well-
understood, actually and
widely used concepts ...		...starting from well-
understood, actual, and
widely used concepts ...		Grammatic error Scope of the CRM107.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01...starting from well-
understood, actual, and
widely used concepts ...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
62
58The reasons for this
distinctions...		The reasons for these
distinctions...		Grammatic error Scope of the CRM107.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-01The reasons for these
distinctions...		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
63
59Joining events allow for describing people becoming members of a groupJoining events allow for describing actors becoming members of a groupToo specific word according to the ontology (not sure if it's a "small edit")P143 joined (was joined by)Scope note1887.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-15Joining events allow for describing actors becoming members of a group7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
64
60Denmark and Greenland February 1. 1985Denmark and Greenland February 1ˢ ͭ 1985Wrong data formatE86 LeavingExamples1067.2EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-15Denmark and Greenland February 1ˢ ͭ 19857.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
65
61E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")E3 Condition StateScope note7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
66
62E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")E61 Time PrimitiveScope note7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
67
63E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")E61 Time PrimitiveProperties7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
68
64E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")E93 PresenceProperties7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
69
65E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")P1 is identified by (identifies)Superproperty of7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
70
66E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")P170 defines time (time is defined by)Range7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
71
67E52 Time SpanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")P170 defines time (time is defined by)Scope note7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
72
68E52 TimespanE52 Time-SpanTypo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-")E92 Spacetime VolumeScope note7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E52 Time-Span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
73
69P173 starts before or with the end of (ends with or after the start of)P173 starts before or with the end of (ends after or with the start of)Wrong property labelE2 Temporal EntityProperties7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17P173 starts before or with the end of (ends after or with the start of)7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
74
70P173 starts before or at the end of P173 starts before or with the end of Wrong property labelP174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of)Subproperty of7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17P173 starts before or with the end of 7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
75
71P182 ends before or at the start of P182 ends before or with the start of Wrong property labelP183 ends before the start of (starts after the end of)Subproperty of7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17P182 ends before or with the start of 7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
76
72P182 ends before or at the start of P182 ends before or with the start of Wrong property labelP185 ends before the end of (ends after the end of)Superproperty of7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17P182 ends before or with the start of 7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
77
73P182 ends before or at the start of P182 ends before or with the start of Wrong property labelTable 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchy7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17P182 ends before or with the start of 7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
78
74P182 ends before or at the start of P182 ends before or with the start of Wrong property labelP176 starts before the start of (starts after the start of)Superproperty of7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17P182 ends before or with the start of 7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
79
75E92 Space Time VolumeE92 Spacetime VolumeWrong property labelE93 PresenceProperties7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17E92 Spacetime Volume7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
80
76The painting known as the “The Mona Lisa” is an instance of the class Human Made Object.The painting known as the “The Mona Lisa” is an instance of the class E22 Human-Made Object.Wrong class labelTerminology7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17The painting known as the “The Mona Lisa” is an instance of the class E22 Human-Made Object.7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
81
77Human Made ObjectHuman-Made ObjectWrong class labelIntroduction to the basic concepts7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17Human-Made Object7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
82
78P4 has time spanP4 has time-spanWrong property labelSpatiotemporal Relations7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17P4 has time-span7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17
83
79"time span" / "timespan""time-span"ConsistencyMultiple throughout7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17"time-span"7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22
84
80"February 1st 1985" vs. "1st of February 1985" vs. "1st February 1985"Day Month Year - eg. "1st February 1985"ConsistencyMultiple throughout7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17Day Month Year - eg. "1st February 1985"7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22
85
81P184 ends before or with the end of (ends with or after the end of)P184 ends before or with the end of (ends after or with the end of)Consistency with other related time properties (eg. P173-176, P182-185)P184 ends before or with the end of (ends with or after the end of)7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-17Could be made an issue;
decision to leave (March 2022)
86
82Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 19 755 until 9th April 1768Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768Error in dateP167 was within (includes)Examples7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 17687.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22
87
83Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 19 755 until 9th April 1768Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768Error in dateP195 was a presence of (had presence)Examples7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 17687.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22
88
84Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 19 755 until 9th April 1768Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768Error in dateP197 covered parts of (was partially covered by)Examples7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 17687.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22
89
85"In First Order Logic" not mentioned in CIDOC CRM Class Declarations sectionThe line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the class in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notationAll other sections are mentionedCIDOC CRM Class Declarations7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22The line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the class in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notation7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022Discussed over email (March 2022)
90
86"In First Order Logic" not mentioned in CIDOC CRM Property Declarations sectionThe line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the property in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notationAll other sections are mentionedCIDOC CRM Property Declarations7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22The line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the property in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notation7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022Discussed over email (March 2022)
91
87"Subproperty of" not mentioned in CIDOC CRM Property Declarations sectionThe line “Subproperty of:” is a cross-reference to any superproperties
the property may have		All other sections are mentionedCIDOC CRM Property Declarations7.1.2EnglishErin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.ca2022-03-22The line “Subproperty of:” is a cross-reference to any superproperties
the property may have		7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022Discussed over email (March 2022)
92
88many to one, necessary (1,n:0,n)many to many, necessary (1,n:0,n)Wrong quantification textP81 ongoing throughoutQuantification1637.2.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-30This has been vetted by CEO
93
89one to many, necessary (1,n:0,n)many to many, necessary (1,n:0,n)Wrong quantification textP99 dissolved (was dissolved by) Quantification1717.2.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-30This has been vetted by CEO
94
90one to many, necessary, dependent (1,n:0,n)many to many, necessary (1,n:0,n)Wrong quantification textP161 has spatial projection (is spatial projection of)Quantification1977.2.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-31This has been vetted by CEO
95
91be described by the property P177 assigned property type: E55 Type.be described by the property P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned): E55 Type.Missing word in the property label AND Missing the inverse labelE13 Attribute AssignmentScope note697.2.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-31be described by the property P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned): E55 Type.7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022
96
92should be documented using P177 assigned property type.should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned).Missing word in the property label AND Missing the inverse labelP140 assigned attribute to (was attributed by)Scope note1877.2.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-31should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned).7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022
97
93should be documented using P177 assigned property type.should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned).Missing word in the property label AND Missing the inverse labelP141 assigned (was assigned by)Scope note1887.2.1EnglishPhilippe Michonphilippe.michon@pch.gc.ca2022-03-31should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned).7.1.2Erin Canningerin.canning@mail.utoronto.caApril 19, 2022
98
99
100