A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Tier 1: BEEM Rater Scale | Score | Tier 2: Content accuracy | Score | Tier 3: Educational Utility | Score | Tier 4: EBM | Score | Tier 5: Referenced | Score |
2 | Assuming that the results of this article are valid, how much does this article impact on EM clinical practice? | Do you have any concerns about the accuracy of the data presented or conclusions of this article? | Are there useful educational pearls in this article for residents? | Does this article reflect evidence based medicine (EBM)? | Are the authors and literature clearly cited? | |||||
3 | Useless information | 1 | Yes, many concerns due to many inaccuracies found | 1 | Not required knowledge for a competent EP | 1 | Not EBM based, only expert opinion | 1 | No | 1 |
4 | Not really interesting, not really new, changes nothing | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | ||||
5 | Interesting and new, but doesn't change practice | 3 | Yes, a major concern about a few inaccuracies | 3 | Yes, but there are only a few (1-2) educational pearls that will make the EP a better pracitioner to know or multiple (>=3) educational pearls that are interesting or potentially useful, but rarely required or helpful for the daily practice of an EP. | 3 | Minimally EBM based | 3 | 3 | |
6 | Interesting and new, has the potential to change practice | 4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | Yes, authors and general references are listed (but no in-line references) | 4 | |||
7 | New and important: this would probably change practice for some EPs | 5 | Minimal concerns, only minor inaccuracies found | 5 | Yes, there are several (>=3) educational pearls that will make the EP a better practitioner to know, or a few (1-2) every competent EP must know in their practice | 5 | Mostly EBM based | 5 | 5 | |
8 | New and important: this would change practice for most EPs | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | ||||
9 | This is a "must know" for EPs | 7 | No concerns, no inaccuracies found | 7 | Yes, there are multiple educational pearls that every competent EP must know in their practice | 7 | Yes exclusively EBM based | 7 | Yes, authors and in-line references are provided | 7 |
10 | Your Score | |||||||||
11 | ||||||||||
12 | ||||||||||
13 | ||||||||||
14 | ||||||||||
15 | ||||||||||
16 | ||||||||||
17 | ||||||||||
18 | ||||||||||
19 | ||||||||||
20 | ||||||||||
21 | ||||||||||
22 | ||||||||||
23 | ||||||||||
24 | ||||||||||
25 | ||||||||||
26 | ||||||||||
27 | ||||||||||
28 | ||||||||||
29 | ||||||||||
30 | ||||||||||
31 | ||||||||||
32 | ||||||||||
33 | ||||||||||
34 | ||||||||||
35 | ||||||||||
36 | ||||||||||
37 | ||||||||||
38 | ||||||||||
39 | ||||||||||
40 | ||||||||||
41 | ||||||||||
42 | ||||||||||
43 | ||||||||||
44 | ||||||||||
45 | ||||||||||
46 | ||||||||||
47 | ||||||||||
48 | ||||||||||
49 | ||||||||||
50 | ||||||||||
51 | ||||||||||
52 | ||||||||||
53 | ||||||||||
54 | ||||||||||
55 | ||||||||||
56 | ||||||||||
57 | ||||||||||
58 | ||||||||||
59 | ||||||||||
60 | ||||||||||
61 | ||||||||||
62 | ||||||||||
63 | ||||||||||
64 | ||||||||||
65 | ||||||||||
66 | ||||||||||
67 | ||||||||||
68 | ||||||||||
69 | ||||||||||
70 | ||||||||||
71 | ||||||||||
72 | ||||||||||
73 | ||||||||||
74 | ||||||||||
75 | ||||||||||
76 | ||||||||||
77 | ||||||||||
78 | ||||||||||
79 | ||||||||||
80 | ||||||||||
81 | ||||||||||
82 | ||||||||||
83 | ||||||||||
84 | ||||||||||
85 | ||||||||||
86 | ||||||||||
87 | ||||||||||
88 | ||||||||||
89 | ||||||||||
90 | ||||||||||
91 | ||||||||||
92 | ||||||||||
93 | ||||||||||
94 | ||||||||||
95 | ||||||||||
96 | ||||||||||
97 | ||||||||||
98 | ||||||||||
99 | ||||||||||
100 |