ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABACADAEAFAGAHAIAJAK
1
Helen Keller InternationalHelen Keller InternationalHelen Keller InternationalNutrition International
2
Burkina FasoCameroonCôte d'IvoireDRCGuineaKenyaMadagascarMaliNigerNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaNigeriaAngolaChadTogoUganda
3
unittypeOverallAdamawaAkwa IbomAnambraBenueDeltaEbonyiEdoEkitiImoKogiNasarawaOgunOsunRiversTaraba
4
Simple CEA
5
6
Grant
7
Grant size$input$1,000,000----------------------------
8
9
Under-five mortality benefits
10
Cost per person under age five reached$input-$1.34$1.46$1.28$1.28$1.82$1.28$1.28$0.99$1.07$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$2.14$2.14$1.53$1.42
11
Number of people under age five reached#calc-744,706687,004779,777779,777550,904779,777779,7771,013,443936,448779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777468,083468,083655,609702,125
12
Proportion of reached children who would have received VAS in the absence of the program%input-25%25%25%25%25%25%44%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%
13
Number of additional children receiving VAS as a result of the program#calc-558,530515,253584,833584,833413,178584,833436,675760,082702,336584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833351,062351,062491,707526,594
14
Mortality rate among people under age five%input-1.54%0.76%0.78%0.65%1.28%0.35%0.69%1.59%1.76%1.41%0.56%0.40%0.88%0.74%0.92%0.56%0.66%0.39%0.48%0.88%0.58%0.36%0.77%1.54%0.56%1.59%0.75%0.60%
15
Effect of VAS on under-five mortality%input-6.4%10.8%5.3%9.7%5.9%6.3%12.1%7.3%11.9%6.1%3.3%2.6%4.4%2.9%6.0%2.9%3.7%3.5%3.7%5.5%3.5%2.9%4.1%7.5%7.2%12.0%11.3%5.7%
16
Number of deaths averted among people under age five#calc-5534242393713131283658781,47550310860227127319951437910328311860184676141670416179
17
18
Initial cost-effectiveness estimate
19
Cost per under-five death averted$calc-$1,807$2,359$4,176$2,694$3,190$7,786$2,740$1,140$678$1,988$9,220$16,742$4,410$7,899$3,135$10,575$7,007$12,598$9,685$3,529$8,471$16,599$5,431$1,479$7,086$1,493$2,404$5,580
20
Moral value of averting the death of a person under age fiveUoVinput119----------------------------
21
Initial cost-effectiveness in terms of multiples of our benchmark
xbenchmark
calc-19.715.18.513.211.24.613.031.352.617.93.92.18.14.511.43.45.12.83.710.14.22.16.624.15.023.914.86.4
22
26
Percentage of program impact coming from different benefits
27
Mortalities averted for people under age five%input-80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%
28
Developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input-20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%
29
30
Supplemental adjustments
31
Adjustment for additional program benefits and downsides%input-67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%
32
Adjustment for grantee-level factors%input--22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-24%-24%-24%-24%
33
Adjustment for leverage%input--2%-2%-4%-3%-3%-8%-3%-1%-1%-2%-11%-20%-5%-9%-4%-13%-8%-15%-11%-4%-10%-20%-6%-2%-5%-1%-2%-4%
34
Adjustment for funging%input--27%-33%-35%-18%-37%-27%-21%-34%-29%-24%-19%-13%-22%-19%-23%-18%-20%-16%-18%-23%-19%-13%-21%-24%-24%-46%-35%-33%
35
36
Final cost-effectiveness estimate
37
Final cost-effectiveness in terms of multiples of our benchmark
xbenchmark
calc-22.615.98.516.910.94.815.932.859.321.54.42.39.55.213.53.85.93.24.212.04.82.37.729.05.620.114.96.3
38
Final cost per life saved$calc-$3,222$4,578$8,529$4,306$6,662$15,181$4,577$2,218$1,227$3,391$16,500$31,579$7,643$14,011$5,387$19,102$12,354$23,077$17,389$6,081$15,084$31,277$9,475$2,515$12,941$3,619$4,890$11,541
39
40
25th percentile values (from sensitivity analysis)
41
42
Under-five mortality benefits
43
Cost per person under age five reached$input-$0.77$0.85$0.73$0.73$1.10$0.73$0.73$0.54$0.59$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$0.73$1.33$1.33$0.90$0.82
44
Proportion of reached children who would have received VAS in the absence of the program%input-15%15%15%15%15%15%30%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%15%
45
Mortality rate among people under age five%input-1.22%0.57%0.59%0.48%1.00%0.25%0.52%1.26%1.41%1.11%0.41%0.29%0.67%0.56%0.70%0.41%0.49%0.28%0.35%0.67%0.43%0.26%0.58%1.22%0.41%1.26%0.56%0.45%
46
Effect of VAS on under-five mortality%input-1.20%3.30%0.80%2.70%1.00%1.20%4.00%1.60%3.80%1.10%0.20%0.00%0.50%0.10%1.00%0.10%0.30%0.20%0.30%0.80%0.20%0.10%0.40%1.70%1.60%4.30%3.50%0.90%
47
48
Adjustments for other benefits
49
Adjustment to account for developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input-5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%5%
50
51
Supplemental adjustments
52
Adjustment for additional program benefits and downsides%input-51%49%49%49%48%49%49%50%48%50%47%49%51%50%49%48%48%48%49%62%62%63%61%61%61%62%63%49%
53
Adjustment for grantee-level factors%input--40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-40%-43%-43%-43%-43%
54
Adjustment for funging%input-----------------------------
55
56
75th percentile values (from sensitivity analysis)
57
58
Under-five mortality benefits
59
Cost per person under age five reached$input-$2.68$2.89$2.57$2.57$3.50$2.57$2.57$2.04$2.19$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$2.57$4.02$4.02$3.01$2.82
60
Proportion of reached children who would have received VAS in the absence of the program%input-45%45%45%45%45%45%55%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%45%
61
Mortality rate among people under age five%input-1.90%0.97%1.00%0.84%1.60%0.46%0.89%1.96%2.16%1.75%0.73%0.53%1.12%0.95%1.17%0.73%0.85%0.51%0.63%1.12%0.75%0.47%0.99%1.90%0.73%1.96%0.96%0.78%
62
Effect of VAS on under-five mortality%input-9.70%15.00%8.20%15.00%9.00%9.50%15.00%10.90%15.00%9.30%5.30%4.20%6.90%4.70%9.10%4.70%5.90%5.60%5.90%8.40%5.60%4.70%6.50%11.20%10.80%15.00%15.00%8.70%
63
64
Adjustments for other benefits
65
Adjustment to account for developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input-60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%60%
66
67
Supplemental adjustments
68
Adjustment for additional program benefits and downsides%input-84%86%85%85%84%84%85%84%85%85%85%85%84%85%84%84%84%84%84%94%93%93%93%93%93%94%94%84%
69
Adjustment for grantee-level factors%input--10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-10%-11%-11%-11%-11%
70
Adjustment for funging%input-----------------------------
71
72
Copy of simple CEA (for sensitivity analysis)
73
74
Grant
75
Grant size$input-$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000$1,000,000
76
77
Under-five mortality benefits
78
Cost per person under age five reached$input-$1.34$1.46$1.28$1.28$1.82$1.28$1.28$0.99$1.07$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$1.28$2.14$2.14$1.53$1.42
79
Number of people under age five reached#calc-744,706687,004779,777779,777550,904779,777779,7771,013,443936,448779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777779,777468,083468,083655,609702,125
80
Proportion of reached children who would have received VAS in the absence of the program%input-25%25%25%25%25%25%44%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%
81
Number of additional children receiving VAS as a result of the program#calc-558,530515,253584,833584,833413,178584,833436,675760,082702,336584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833584,833351,062351,062491,707526,594
82
Mortality rate among people under age five%input-1.54%0.76%0.78%0.65%1.28%0.35%0.69%1.59%1.76%1.41%0.56%0.40%0.88%0.74%0.92%0.56%0.66%0.39%0.48%0.88%0.58%0.36%0.77%1.54%0.56%1.59%0.75%0.60%
83
Effect of VAS on under-five mortality%input-6.4%10.8%5.3%9.7%5.9%6.3%12.1%7.3%11.9%6.1%3.3%2.6%4.4%2.9%6.0%2.9%3.7%3.5%3.7%5.5%3.5%2.9%4.1%7.5%7.2%12.7%11.3%5.7%
84
Number of deaths averted among people under age five#calc-5534242393713131283658781,47550310860227127319951437910328311860184676141712416179
85
86
Initial cost-effectiveness estimate
87
Cost per under-five death averted$calc-$1,807$2,359$4,176$2,694$3,190$7,786$2,740$1,140$678$1,988$9,220$16,742$4,410$7,899$3,135$10,575$7,007$12,598$9,685$3,529$8,471$16,599$5,431$1,479$7,086$1,405$2,404$5,580
88
Moral value of averting the death of a person under age fiveUoVinput119----------------------------
89
Initial cost-effectiveness in terms of multiples of our benchmark
xbenchmark
calc-19.715.18.513.211.24.613.031.352.617.93.92.18.14.511.43.45.12.83.710.14.22.16.624.15.025.414.86.4
90
91
Adjustments for other benefits
92
Adjustment to account for developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input-25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%25%
93
94
Percentage of program impact coming from different benefits
95
Mortalities averted for people under age five%input-80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%80%
96
Developmental benefits (long-term income increases)%input-20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%
97
98
Supplemental adjustments
99
Adjustment for additional program benefits and downsides%input-67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%67%
100
Adjustment for grantee-level factors%input--22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-22%-24%-24%-24%-24%
101
Adjustment for leverage%input--2%-2%-4%-3%-3%-8%-3%-1%-1%-2%-11%-20%-5%-9%-4%-13%-8%-15%-11%-4%-10%-20%-6%-2%-5%-1%-2%-4%
102
Adjustment for funging%input--27%-33%-35%-18%-37%-27%-21%-34%-29%-24%-19%-13%-22%-19%-23%-18%-20%-16%-18%-23%-19%-13%-21%-24%-24%-46%-35%-33%
103