ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAAABAC
1
536BPM1M2M2B293turquoise highlight: request audio editing for improvements
abbreviations
36028169500153106abbreviationsabbreviations154104536
2
Editor Columns2nd Reviewer Columns
3
# Hymn TitleBrisbane YouTubeBrisbanePacificaMVP '13MVP '21 ChMVP '21 EnBrisbane '21USAChCh# of VersesEn# of VersesComments: please only add new comments about the new recordings and do not delete old commentsRecommended versionRecommended Ready to PublishRe-Recording Chinese Version Comments (Lines/Measures based on Chinese version hymnbook)Chinese Version Re-Recording m4a donePre-Mastered Project Files UploadedMastered Project File UploadedEnglish m4aChinese m4asource of En m4asource of Ch m4aReviewed official En m4a: CLEANReviewed official Ch m4a: CLEANReviewer initials: deliverable with no major issues
4
1Holy, Holy, Holyhttps://youtu.be/Q-DAQeoFt-khttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1L80SYZlN7d4MkbzX_GaMAMDMA6GyBE5h/view?usp=sharing3At m.5 in verse 2,the second beat( -ing) of the alto joins late. B2 version is beautiful and clean with some background breathing soundsB/B2BJY
5
2Hallelujah, Praise the Fatherhttps://youtu.be/3_nONLaP4Lohttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1SD6MwINW6Tr73lI6a5te-j2ycL-Lo5fw/view?usp=sharing4The last note is cut off. Need to add rit. at the end. Both B and B2 strong; B has cleaner instrument. I think Alan used the original not-cut-off fileBBJY
6
3The God of Abraham Praisehttps://youtu.be/2M1aZNyGze0https://drive.google.com/file/d/1t4ztq7GUqh-PaSYWW-8bFD40f320dcMo/view?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1xxxBZ5oqWI_w667pdnx0D5GmLr1Ucb-i/view?usp=sharing3The last note is cut off. Need to add rit. at the end. B audio quality is stronger than B2; Alan picked B, the original file that is not cut offBBJY
7
4I Love Thy Kingdom, Lordhttps://youtu.be/exloILjs_TQhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/16Qbrh3k1c5I64xxPJEFbPt_rDt_Ddils/view?usp=sharing65Wrong chord at beat 2 (-est), in m.5 verse 5. The last note is cut off. Need to add rit. at the end. En m4a: also has a wrong note v5, m5. Ch m4a version has wrong note in v6, m5 at 2:00 in. B2 solid, use B2 insteadB2M2M2JY11/24/2021
8
5This is My Father's Worldhttps://youtu.be/r3md0vsAh8A3Beautiful phrasing and left hand accompaniment. There's a rubato at the intro. If it's not a concern, this recording is ready to publish. En m4a: Prefer a little bit less reverb (Orig B version bc reverb sounds a little shakey)BM1JY11/18/2021
9
6
The Spacious Firmament on High
https://youtu.be/XnKjOIjvTx43Add more rit. at the end will be better. En m4a: this reverb didn't bother me maybe bc orig B didn't have reverb addedBBJY
10
7Joyful, Joyful, We Adore Theehttps://youtu.be/_fEiNiClqJkhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ui2dQOv2tppk_08fsHhE3-1DrqkntQPo/view?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1wju2_0eKEwRv_slTYHqiqvp1LX-wuZz_?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1wju2_0eKEwRv_slTYHqiqvp1LX-wuZz_?usp=sharing4Background noise. Too many wrong notes. Need to be rerecorded. M1: lively, clean, light breathing. Nice rit at ends of verses; applicable for this hymn. Wrong notes in v3 m11 at 2:12. B2: clean and some breathing. Use B2B2B2JY11/18/2021
11
8
O Come and Sing Unto the Lord
https://youtu.be/5l2p7D5hIIk25En m4a: beautiful, clean. Ch m4a editing cut is audible but useableBJY
12
9
All People That on Earth Do Dwell
https://youtu.be/fSibjOBlywkRecorded 2110193Noise in the background. Unclean pedal. Is it required to rest after every fermata note? En m4a: the fermata is blurred into the next note, a bit jarring if singing to it bc we won't hear the attack of the note after the fermata, but I think it's still useable. 10.19 B2 strongB2B2JY11/16/2021
13
10Glory to Jesushttps://youtu.be/IKeHD9Ldf3Q3wrong notes in LH. Not consistent in tempo. M1 solid; 2024 suggest new recording to improve sound qualityM1JY
14
11
I Rejoice, for Jesus Walketh by My Side
https://youtu.be/eWe05CWcAXERecorded 2110194Need to be recorded again. Tempo is too slow. Wrong notes. Too much noise. En m4a: 16th notes can be more crisp. Missing harmonies at the end of each verse. 10.19 B2 strong; 2024 suggest slower; 2024 is around 110 bpmB2B2JY11/16/2021
15
12
When I Can Read My Title Clear
https://youtu.be/Ndgpo3VCsfMhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1pmPZadzlvVF5fr4l0_f3CgKmP-0b-_4n/view?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1pFoeuyHSg8QKDNSLqsWkzrFV-VATtnPw?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1pFoeuyHSg8QKDNSLqsWkzrFV-VATtnPw?usp=sharing4Need to be recorded again. Tempo is not consistent. Wrong notes. Unclear pedal. En m4a: is M1, 3rd line 2nd measure sixteenth is played as eighth. Useable but should be rerecorded to fix wrong rhythms. B2: clear sound, beautiful. B2The "6th" (note E) note is missing in line 3, but it's played in line 1B2JY11/16/2021
16
13No, Not Onehttps://youtu.be/4tu85FSNgjk4Unconsistency in tempo. Dotted 8th note rhythm was wrong at verse 3. pedal noise. En m4a: cleanM1JY
17
14Welcome, Delightful Mornhttps://youtu.be/NBs5rtmxgEkRecorded 21101943Too much noise in the background & wrong notes in LH accompaniment. En/Ch m4a: last line has wrong harmonies each time, but useable. 10/19 B2 beautiful. En/Chm4a: cleanB2B2B2JY11/30/2021
18
15Ye Servants of Godhttps://youtu.be/05HrJOFURmAhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1YxXPaMON8J_Nn5kcvMPHoyibt7f9SPqv/view?usp=sharing4Need to record again. Too much noise in the background. Too many wrong notes. Not consistent in the tempo. En m4a audio skips at 00:41. B2/Enm4a pretty goodB2B2JY
19
16
All Hail the Power of Jesus' Name
https://youtu.be/wf4A3ysZ0-w4Need to record again. Too much noise in the background. Wrong notes. Not consistent in the tempo. En m4a: cleanM1JY
20
17The Half Has Never Been Toldhttps://youtu.be/xKjBTrtyQqY34Need to record again. Got cut off at the beginning of the first verse. Background noise. Wrong notes in both hands. Beautiful LH accompaniment though. En/Ch m4a: cleanM1JY
21
18When We All Get to Heavenhttps://youtu.be/rwogkLzedMU34The last note is cut off. Add more rit. at the end will be better. En/Ch m4a: instruments sounds very artificial, but otherwise clean.JY
22
19Thine is the Gloryhttps://youtu.be/dq9pZO606e43The ending just need to slow down " a bit," not too much. En m4a: cleanJY
23
20
All Hail the Power of Jesus' Name
https://youtu.be/_zYrvyPkUwE34En/Ch m4a: clean. Seems louder than other recordingsBJY
24
21Fairest Lord Jesushttps://youtu.be/QFbkfdWOdEY4Redo. Too many wrong notes. Unclear pedal. Poor audio quality. En m4a: clean; 2024 suggest redo for pedal clarity; 9/30/2024 goodJY
25
22There Is a Fountain Dearhttps://youtu.be/EW7tblM86rI5Redo. Wrong LH notes at the end of V1. Wrong rhythm at the last measure (played only 2 beats between verse 2 & 3). Backgound noise. Enm4a: cleanJY
26
23
Oh, That the Lord Would Guide My Ways
https://youtu.be/zedWGPHbR1E54Beautiful playing. There's a typo on the slide: verse 4, delightful "rod"? Should be delightful "road"; En m4a clean. Ch m4a cleanBJY11/18/2021
27
24Wonderful Words of Lifehttps://youtu.be/cAQSd_8FfS8https://drive.google.com/file/d/1I03zkAJJRznsJEmZIkOzYl-6SpN76KFL/view?usp=sharing43Everything is good except for the last note is cut off. Can add more rit at the end. En/Ch m4a:cleanB/B2BJY
28
25
God's Law is Perfect and Gives Life
https://youtu.be/87wNAGMNhhE3Solid. Can consider to speed up by using audio editing tools? But it also needs to add a rit. at the end of the song. En m4a: cleanJY
29
26The Quiet Hourhttps://youtu.be/UGmj1MDQBmk35Everything is accurate. It will be even better if add some dynamics. En m4a: clean; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound qualityJY
30
27Jesus Loves Even Mehttps://youtu.be/zJC7tm_NwC44En m4a: cleanBJY
31
28
Through the Love of God Our Saviour
https://youtu.be/zOgVNAYu_1Yhttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1cEDqYgZrVCOSQk49kQ9M-lPHkMQ2PeJP?usp=sharing43Wrong note at m.14 in v1. D; En m4a: wrong harmonies verse 1 m.11, 13 missing passing tones throughout, and m6 missing F natural throughout. Otherwise it has 3 verses. Redo recording. Ch m4a: missing passing tones, wrong harmonies in v1 m.11, 13, v2 m13, and m6 missing F natural throughout. Redo recording. En/Chm4a: cleanB2B2B2JY11/24/2021
32
29The Ninety and Ninehttps://youtu.be/WfpAkIdfaH4Recorded 211127https://drive.google.com/file/d/19wsXNoorMUu5SwJCVnrbp-m5hfh7_8UI/view?usp=share_link5Wrong note at m.11 v4 B. En m4a: is M1, useable, but slight inaccuries throughout for ex added C note in GM chords. Suggest redo but not urgent. B2=clean. Enm4a:clean. Chm4a version cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
33
30In Tenderness He Sought Mehttps://youtu.be/DWfggDt139Ehttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1wAFR5GgasYmSNnrNfM6TD4SgGe2pW3Xv?usp=sharing45En m4a: character can be more gentle. Some chords are awkward and should be voiced with attention to the suspensions and resolutions m.6 otherwise it can be unsettling. Suggest redo esp to address the character. B2 intro, 1st verse, last verse recorded. Needs editing. En/Chm4a clean.B2B2B2JY11/24/2021
34
31Seeking for Mehttps://youtu.be/QElqfLzwDkw4Can add more phrasing, especially at the end. En m4a: clean; 2024 suggest redo for piano sound quality; 9/30/24 goodJY
35
32Christ Receiveth Sinful Menhttps://youtu.be/gwP2eHq5ibkhttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1wyRs0PETz52r9DjCQL5ZddWLKNc4aA5R?usp=sharing4The sound is muffled. 8th notes are too short. Wrong notes in alto at the refrain part. En/Ch m4a same comments as before. Recommend redo if possible. Try stitching B2 together. Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
36
33Sweeping Through the Gateshttps://youtu.be/lRRtZWIYm-YRecorded 21102245Sound is muffled. Refrain: unclear 8th notes at beat 2 in m.9 and 10. En m4a: same comments as before. B2: very clean! 5 verses, so need to edit to extract Ch version. En/Chm4a clean; 2024 maybe suggest slower tempoB2B2B2JY11/18/2021
37
34Jesus Is Tenderly Callinghttps://youtu.be/CaF1qD_NrEg4Redo. Inconsistency in tempo. Wrong notes at m.2 in verse 2, m.7 & m.13 in verse 4. Refrain: mistakes in rhythm. En m4a: clean. Didn't hear rhythm mistake in the refrain; 2024 suggest redo for piano sound qualityJY
38
35Joy Cometh in the Morninghttps://youtu.be/DSz_i8Eg5103Too slow. Current recording=82, hymnbook=100. Speed up slightly and publish. En m4a clean. Rhythm unsteady at timesJY
39
36Whispering Hopehttps://youtu.be/f0hHDlzEefchttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1PggfjFllo89CfejolkyaWAQRYOlluaZo/view?usp=sharing2Redo. m.32 in V1 missing one beat. No need to slow down at the end of V1. En m4a waltz pattern beats 2 and 3 too heavy, causing awkward clunkiness. B2: Good and clear. Enm4a: clean. Some uneven piano actionB2B2JY11/18/2021
40
37
Though Your Sins Be as Scarlet
https://youtu.be/vFAcPfdMvcohttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1__f5Acsn2HrXUPwChWttrGHh7NmdwH5t/view?usp=sharing3Instrument quality can be improved, otherwise ready to publish. En m4a rhythm doesn't differentiate between triplets and dotted eighths, otherwise clean. Instrument quality was ok B2: Clear and steady tempo. Enm4a:cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
41
38
I Heard the Voice of Jesus Say
https://youtu.be/zZXK5vx7r30https://drive.google.com/file/d/11QgNGlu4GNpl-zfKZOTYbpKAC2BMVlmw/view?usp=sharing3The last note is cut off. En m4a has wrong chord in the 2nd chord of the 2nd last measure, for verses 1-2. Recommend rerecording if possible. B2:the recording is great, but is that possible to make some echo or something to make the sound more rich not so artificial? Otherwise it's clear.B2B2JY11/26/2021
42
39Nothing but the Bloodhttps://youtu.be/wYsU549fX9Q4The last note is cut off. En m4a clean. Ending was ok since 2 beats only; 2024 suggest redo for piano sound quality; 2024 Enm4a cleanJY
43
40I Will Praise Himhttps://youtu.be/Fq81UsdINoE34The last note is cut off. En/Ch m4a clean; 2024 suggest redo to slow down and improve piano sound quality. 9/6/24 new recording is an improvement. Needs a Ch versionJY
44
41There is Power in the Bloodhttps://youtu.be/uTUXy1_6SZ44m.1-2 of v1-3 was faster than the rest of the piece. The last note is cut off. En m4a: clean; 2024 suggest redo to make tempo consistent and improve piano sound quality; 9/25/2024 review clean. 16th notes a little soggy; 11/18/2024 fineJY
45
42Blessed Be the Fountainhttps://youtu.be/69mdGiC41r83Tempo might be too fast for congregations or the elderly? En m4a: a bit fast but clean; 2024 suggest redo to slow down and improve piano sound qualityJY
46
43Are You Washed in the Blood?https://youtu.be/4f0LjuQqyCc4Tempo might be a bit too fast for the elderly. The last note is cut off. En m4a: the last note is faded out but otherwise clean; 2024 suggest redo to slow down and improve piano sound quality; 2024 Enm4a cleanJY
47
44Weeping Will Not Save Me!https://youtu.be/ujiRxB-ydcY4En m4a: clean; 2024 suggest redo to slow down and improve piano sound quality; 2024 Enm4a cleanBJY
48
45
Come, Ye Sinners, Poor and Needy
https://youtu.be/u3WbW3rlTHA4Tempo can be a bit slower, from the current 114 bmp to 108bmp? En m4a: a bit too fast for the character, and the last note is faded out, but otherwise clean; 2024 suggest redo to slow down and improve piano sound quality; 9/6/24 new version is an improvementJY
49
46Jesus Christ Healed My Sighthttps://youtu.be/r7W37rSTAP03There's a rit. at the end of verse 1, which is not necessary. En m4a: same comment as before, 1st verse ending rit not necessary. Otherwise clean; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound quality; 2024 Enm4a cleanJY
50
47Jesus, I Comehttps://youtu.be/rFXqHsRT2b8https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1oP524L-JMU4e7Yia1OAk8thilX9KpVB1?usp=sharing34The last note is cut off. Need clean pedal between different chords between dotted quarter and 8th notes. En m4a is M1, two wrong harmonies in every verse. Suggest redo. Ch m4a: two wrong harmonies in every verse. Suggest redo. Try stitching 47 together; En/chm4a at times the tempo is slightly unstable due to the slightly delayed 2nd beat, but it shouldn't affect the singers since all parts hold at that time. CleanB2B2B2JY12/1/2021
51
48Near the Crosshttps://youtu.be/BepRWUcBeKM4Depending on the conductor, this hymn can be slower or keep the way it is. Pedal sounds are heard and needs to have more clarity. En m4a: Currently dotted quarter=40; scored for 46; suggest hymnbook tempo edit to eighth note=115-120, which is around dotted quarter=38-40, esp if used for Holy Communion; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound quality and consider slowing down a little but still in 2. 9/6/24 new recording is an improvementJY
52
49All the Way to Calvaryhttps://youtu.be/cq3FlsYPbzUhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1WyFMqXB6qFhHB3bytRziprOpBdRZJxNq/view?usp=sharing3At m.10 and m.11, the eight notes are too short. They sound more like 16th notes. En m4a: dotted eighths are short, creating a triplet pattern. Redo recording. Besides rhythm, the notes are clean B2: The sixth notes are clear. Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
53
50Jesus Only Is Our Messagehttps://youtu.be/gQL1nm94FD44The last note is cut off. Watch for pedal clarity. En m4a: pedal not the clearest but okay. Last note is faded out. Otherwise clean; 2024 suggest redo to slow down and improve piano sound quality; 2024 Enm4a cleanJY
54
51ARock of Ageshttps://youtu.be/t45oGBYcEjEhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1xlq1f7vRc_KWb5ClsDL0x0o0qBAEGywm/view?usp=drive_link3Need to be re-recorded. Left hand is too loud and choppy. There are some notes that are not accurate. En m4a version: clean; 7/18/2023 new USA version; En/chm4a clean 10/27/23JY10/27/2023
55
51BRock of Ages-https://drive.google.com/file/d/1SASEa8Q2xm8-CjjttFtrU6_ubs0ny4j2/view?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1J7fL-PKH_Upw_EJZNc2J72jjDtHaPV0s/view?usp=sharing3Beautiful phrasing and dynamics. The F7 chord at 1:17 can be more clear. M2 has breaths and is a bit more embellished with dynamics. 16th notes slightly off. B2 is straightforward, clean, no breaths. Pick B2 over M2 but both are fine; En m4a is cleanM2/B2M2ZY
56
52Jesus Paid It Allhttps://youtu.be/61d9BR5YYoo45Plan to use for VHR (Alan); Both En/Ch m4a chords aren't played together but it should be okay with voices layered on top. The beginning and ends are slightly faded in/out. En m4a is cleanBZY
57
53God Is Lovehttps://youtu.be/wGEBWKUInxIhttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1HqkxPpV6IvIEZ0TB72EBYFDMp1OvngV1?usp=sharing34many of the chords sound "rolled" bc the notes aren't played together; redo if possible. En m4a is M1, very rolled chords are distracting, and some harmonies are early, otherwise it's useable. Stitch together B2. En/Chm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
58
54From Darkness into the Lighthttps://youtu.be/rPhXsJhyklc3At the beginning of verse 2, the tempo was rushing. But it might not matter, depending on the conductor. En m4a version: maybe it's a diff version, but did not hear rushing at beginning of 2nd verse. Has early harmony at the end of each verse. Clean; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound quality; 9/6/24 new recording is similar in playing but the sound quality did improve. Thank youJY
59
55Jesus Frees Mehttps://youtu.be/NG5B6H69J2w3At 2:28, the fermata note can be longer. En m4a: fermata can be longer or stay the same, otherwise clean; 2024 suggest redo to address fermatas and improve piano sound quality;

8/26/2024 Review: 1:57 a slight mistouch. The hymn has mismatched word stresses compared to the meter, which makes it awkward to sing in English. There was something done post-production that made the piano unable to sustain its long notes, which I think is not as favorable. The playing here is more mechanical than the current version. Compared to 55 to the current version in https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1r3r2ycG7324nKclK45Wz4Y_XJQYELLSc
I think the current version sounds more natural, even with the less preferable piano quality.		JY
60
56Blow Ye the Trumpet, Blowhttps://youtu.be/qkK56CMZFVMhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1zIjSZmI-IEhYny6MaNv1CC1uxjlLyApR/view?usp=sharing46m.6 rhythm mistake. Dotted half note is played half note; En/Ch m4a is M1, has same rhythm mistake otherwise clean. B2: Nice, steady temple ready to use. En/Chm4a: cleanB2B2B2JY11/18/2021
61
57Just as I Am, Without One Pleahttps://youtu.be/RQ5DUddYTn846The first chord comes in early (or because it's played as a rolling chord?) between verses. I think when the voices are added on top of it, the problem should be easily covered. En/Ch m4a version: no rhythm issue. Early harmony at the end of the 2nd line, otherwise clean; 2024 suggest redo to address background noise and piano sound qualityJY10/27/2023
62
58He Leadeth Me!https://youtu.be/DfZJujJ8Ihkhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1pEiB7rMyTRENxwOtMgBhblYN9-Hv2W7M/view?usp=sharing4Plan to use for VHR (Alan) At the end of verse 1, DM is played less than 3 beats, while all the other notes with fermata are played 3 beats. Depending on conductor, it might not be an issue. En m4a: early harmonies at the end of the 2nd and 4th lines. Otherwise clean. B2: All the fermata notes are 3 beats. Musical and ready to publish. New Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY11/18/2021
63
59
Guide Me, O Thou Great Redeemer
https://youtu.be/LF7Bg-CaGAw3Tempo was rushing in some measures. En m4a is clean; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound qualityJY
64
60Let Him Leadhttps://youtu.be/ZXmiUMhIVe84En m4a is clean; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound qualityBZY
65
61Lead, Kindly Lighthttps://youtu.be/YBDW-EmImxkhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1r70sa1yn4KX6S8gJ0mdNaQTSwu_-fz4i/view?usp=sharing3dotted 8th note is played dotted 4th note in m.1 & m.5, which is from M1. Need a new recording B2: Clear ,simple, and musical. Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
66
62The Saviour with Mehttps://youtu.be/Zk6hjEyo_PoRecorded 211127backup: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ONODLj5qp8qqO3eo4gnbnpfBpFsV6lLH/view?usp=sharing4Unclear rhythm between dotted quarter and dotter 8th notes, played as triplets. This is from M1. Rerecord. B2=clean. Some clicking noises in the background but not too much; Enm4a: cleanB2USAjY12/7/2021
67
63Tarry with Mehttps://youtu.be/lO6X-eOWCrw34At the refrain part in verse 4, quarter note is played too short. En/Ch m4a: clean; 2024 suggest redo to address piano sound quality and add interpretationJY
68
64Heavenly Sunlighthttps://youtu.be/-R01bxZYdRE3This recording sounds beautiful, however, the last note is cut off. Use M1 and can extend last note slightly. It's currently at 2.5ish beats and needs 3. There is already a rit. Enm4a: beautifulM1M1JY12/1/2021
69
65Close to Theehttps://youtu.be/UN6xoV_HTu0https://drive.google.com/file/d/1K9RCKD9zlHr7wmLaYuyGPASJQsWRDL4B/view?usp=sharing3B=M1 the dotted eighth to sixteenths are played as triplets. Rerecord. B2: The sixteenths are clear. B2B2JY12/7/2021
70
66
Lord, My Soul Will Wait for Thee
https://youtu.be/E7D4ipjW3No4B=M1. The last note in verse is was too short, which means the Eb Major chord from the next verse comes in too early. Can it be edited? Enm4a: cleanM1JY12/16/2021
71
67Teach Me Thy Way, O Lordhttps://youtu.be/-ddjxlRWSpY34Plan to use for VHR (Alan). Comment: pedal sound is heard in the recording. The conductor can decide if (s)he'd like to extend the fermata note at m.8. Currently it's about 2.5 beats. En/Ch m4a: clean, some early harmonies but can be counted as anticipatory non-chord-tones in this case; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound quality and early non-chord-tonesJY
72
68Hold Thou My Handhttps://youtu.be/7A2l146dfiwhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/106EJ0Fb1siOuQ-tYaLOPglxVzwlSn_-g/view?usp=sharing4B=M1Tempo is not consistent, but useable. It gets slow down at some places, some NCT harmonies that aren't the best choice. B=M1. suggest rerecord if possible. B2: Clear recording and musical. B2B2JY12/7/2021
73
69Jesus, Saviour, Pilot Mehttps://youtu.be/Ia6oTGmpKH4https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Db-o-ixCYg_6hZJH5UoEQ1a2WR4NuoLC/view?usp=sharing3Needs more clarity in pedal. B=M1; useable but really should rerecord because of overpedaling. B2: Nice and clear. Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
74
70None but Christ Can Satisfyhttps://youtu.be/TZM-v80XR4MRecorded 2111274The FM chord at the end of verse 3 is too short. The fermata note is played 3 beats, except for the last one in verse 4, which is played more than 3 beats. I think maybe it's because there's a rit. right after the note? It's up to the conductor if (s)he wants to use this version or not. B=M1 useable recommend rerecord because of overpedaling. B2=clean but some light pedal thumps; Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
75
71Jesus, Thy Name I Lovehttps://youtu.be/ZrO3TIvMiYghttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ci9gUeWQbTHCXSL4cER8nvEtE46DDym6/view?usp=sharing4The lyrics of verse 2 is different from the hymn book. The last note is cut off. B2: very clean and straightforward. Can have a nice rit at the end since the hymn is so straightforward. Enm4a: cleanB2JY12/16/2021
76
72The Great Physicianhttps://youtu.be/dc_PrquDWJgRecorded 2111274The dotted quarter note is rushing a bit at m. 8, so do the first three notes at m.9. But it can considered a way to make the music move forward? We can perhaps leave it to the conductor's discretion. B=M1 agree with previous comments. Useable but rerecord if possible. B2=clean. Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
77
73
Saviour, Like a Shepherd Lead Us
https://youtu.be/WwWBztRbMxs34En/Ch m4a: cleanBJY
78
74Hark the Herald Angels Singhttps://youtu.be/oqTLGGP0OzUhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1IPx6-4BAvGIRA1A5KIiXhigw6JnAklKX/view?usp=sharing3B=M1. Enm4a: are there wrong notes in the last line?B/M1ZY1/11/2022
79
75In Israel, the Angels Did Sayhttps://youtu.be/C91vJBiUurshttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1UOQ8iIM10pNvO7cmCZjd5tgzNR6t9toQ/view?usp=sharing34Different lyrics at the refrain. B2: beautiful. Last verse's strength can start from meas1 since it's an exhortation! En m4a beautiful and beautiful instrumentB2B2B2JY11/18/2021
80
76At the Crosshttps://youtu.be/lVMLwJ5e3q4https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1YdkZbP5J3-D5vPX-rLnli5LoJo-L-VBJ?usp=sharing41. Different rhythm at m.11 (bur-den) and m.13 (by). I think the pianist played this hymn using the Chinese hymn book because the rhythm is the same as the one in Chinese hymn book. 2. Wrong chord at m.14 (-ceived) in verse 3. M1 is clean but has some fading in/out from editing. Recommend rerecording if possible since this is a frequently used hymn. B2: stitch together. Enm4a: nice rumbly sound, clean. But only 3 verses?B2JY1/9/2022
81
77The Old Rugged Crosshttps://youtu.be/0DRuxQchfhshttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1Oj8fEF-8crjO-EmNm6Lxps6b7Z0_hAqQ/view?usp=sharing24Plan to use for VHR (Alan). Comment: there's a short rest (less than a 8th rest) after each verse). Leave it to conductor's discretion to use it or not. The last note was cut off. En/Ch m4a: cleanM1M1JY
82
78Low in the Grave He Layhttps://youtu.be/td5RUhYeQH03at m.17 and some measures in the refrain part, the 16th note(He-a) comes in too early. M1 is great but stopped playing at 2:45. Enm4a: clean; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound qualityJY
83
79Christ the Lord Is Risen Todayhttps://youtu.be/muQ1nzrBiKYhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ph4ccEmcnkSoyr_cQe9yqiwikhXN2bO4/view?usp=sharing4Each verse ends abruptly which causes verse 2 comes in earlier than it supposed to be. I supposed this was copied and pasted because every verse sounds the same with a rit. at the end. B=M1, which may be editable. The issue isn't a huge one, but can be improved esp if recording vocals on top. B2: Clear, stable recording, ready to use.B2JY1/5/2022
84
80The Strife Is O'erhttps://youtu.be/cY1zxsIiVtAhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1nqZH8zptWEvz15MkVO6eehOpQiiMkMXD/view?usp=sharing4The first note of left hand(D2) is not clear, which might be difficult for congregation to know when to start singing. Wrong note at m.11and m.19 ( should be A). Verse 1 slides might be confusing, I suggest add another slide right after verse 1 slide with no introduction part (m.1-7). B2: beautiful, sensitive. Sometimes the stretched time before downbeats happens too regularly and is less effective. Enm4a: cleanB2JY12/16/2021
85
81
On the Mountain's Top Appearing
https://youtu.be/zPHhPN4Who84at 1:32 & 1:40. the 16th note comes out too early. B=M1. I think the issue mentioned previously is the faster tempo in the last verse. I think it is okay as is. Enm4a: clean. Last verse is slightly faster. 2024 suggest redo to address piano sound quality and tempo inconsistencyM1JY 12/22/2021
86
82I Am Praying for Youhttps://youtu.be/6_f5DNBW-X434recording=96, hymnbook=104. Need more dynamics and phrasing if use tempo 96, or it sounds dragging. The chorus part slide of verse 4 was marked "3".The end is faded out, but it’s useable. En/Ch m4a: some audible fading in/out from editing, otherwise clean. 2024 suggest redo to address editing fading sound in and outJY
87
83There'll Be No Dark Valleyhttps://youtu.be/_CJq0QeeNXYhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1GdkLKkiKQ9y7J27b2xDWZRGeQbv6FLzb/view?usp=sharing4At the end of verse 2, the FM(home) is not long enough. the end is faded out, but it’s useable; B2: solid. Can add a bit more character. Enm4a: cleanB2JY12/22/2021
88
84
Rejoice! Rejoice! Our King is Coming
https://youtu.be/vaP69FoUYmk3Plan to use for VHR (Alan). Comment: verse 2 ends ealier (1 second?), though it's not so noticeable. B=M1, agree with previous comment; is useable. Would be great to find the original files and restitch the verses together. En m4a clean; 2024 prefer more phrasingJY 12/22/2021
89
85He's Coming Soonhttps://youtu.be/4pzIIIlvmh4https://drive.google.com/file/d/1o2W74JNMxF4ji9QAAW_5sr_QtirqLOTw/view?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1bVo5QMR_lXrCgoF7iNHt_b0p6M-4HH8T/view?usp=sharing4Between the intro to verse 1, there is a delay. It's probably due to the audio editing. Would be great to find the original files and restich the verses. B=M1. B2: Smoothly and nice!B2JY1/5/2022
90
86My Soul, Be on Thy Guardhttps://youtu.be/9mZdD2O24UE54En/Ch m4a: straightforward, clean; 2024 suggest redo to improve piano sound qualityBJY
91
87There's a Great Day Cominghttps://youtu.be/vZRpeSjrW1ohttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1Ty64UKZ2v1OSFmJoQDvtDEO1VE9Qhm8T?usp=sharing3En m4a stylistic and clean; Oct 2024 USA recording uploadedBJY
92
88One Dayhttps://youtu.be/J6WcKaGhhNohttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1sUvj8VqbJOgoGq155tSJKentZpFcSVN9?usp=sharing45At the end of verse 3 & 4, the last DM chord wasn't long enough. Every verse sounds the same so I think it's due to the copying and pasting by the audio editor? En/Ch m4a is the same as M1, 3rd line, first measure has a possible unintended appoggiatura but it works. Enm4a 05:12 mistouch, Ch m4a 04:05 mistouch, otherwise clean. Suggest rerecording. Sorry! B2: stitch together. En/Chm4a: cleanJY12/22/2021
93
89His Grace Aboundeth Morehttps://youtu.be/zALAZV3e9ughttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1CsykuHsxDRDGL8q3Vi6dUWGiQRSfFVMUhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/19hvlmg5ADQjn8BRBfZPokjpmL2BG9kby/view?usp=sharinghttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1URWDgI5AszOUZ0TfQfS15mbGWfMAZTIT/view?usp=sharing45No fermata. suggest to record again (Comment from Lina, posted by Alan). Yes, please rerecord. M1: has fermata and slightly overpedaled with some some chords not lining up. M2: has fermata but tempo slightly unshakey; instrument tone artificial. M1 is strongest but only has 4 verses. En/Ch m4a: same as M1, a few rolled chords, but not a dealbreaker; clean. M1 for Ch/EnM1M1JY
94
90Count Your Blessingshttps://youtu.be/p7D15lwRbNghttps://drive.google.com/file/d/17AXjjX3GBuUWYFpYf2dGbU3V6CQI3Mde/view?usp=sharing4Fermata in chorus can be one beat longer. Tempo from last line of chorus ("a tempo") to begining of next verse should be consistent (m. 1-2 of every verse is always faster than rest of hymn). B=M1: useable. If possible, extend fermatas as noted in previous comment. B2: top right corner of the 2nd page: alto should be Bb instead of D(Because Alto and Tenor are the same note B flat, yt's ok to add a D there.) B2: Energic and smooth. B2JY1/5/2022
95
91Thy Love, Jesushttps://youtu.be/KSVbCibCubUhttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1pxLET8vUq9KAzuJZVlZhAktjiqM5UMqt?usp=sharing3Wrong chord in m.7 ("from", "-fering", "on-"), should be V7; B=M1
v.2 last chord is slightly cut off (2.5 beats?). B2: stitch together. Enm4a: clean		JY
96
92I Am Coming to the Crosshttps://youtu.be/ubyNabaueCs5v.1-4 last chord slightly cut off B=M1. Would be great to restitch verses together from M1. Enm4a clean; 2024 suggest redo to address loud notes and improving piano sound qualityJY12/22/2021
97
93Sometimes a Light Surpriseshttps://youtu.be/hYINAHOUyDI4v.2 and v.3 last chord slightly cut off (not very noticeable). B=M1. Would be great to restitch verses together from M1. Enm4a clean; 2024 suggest redo to address piano sound qualityJY12/22/2021
98
94Thank the Fatherhttps://youtu.be/tLeEi9XDHuIhttps://drive.google.com/file/d/1zGiy5L519C0iaTTFuxhkpAQPuO6OIB04/view?usp=sharing2m.7 wrong rhythm: missing one beat B=M1 needs rerecording. B2: clean. No rit at the end of the first verse. Enm4a: cleanB2B2JY12/7/2021
99
95What a Friend Thou Art to Mehttps://youtu.be/Ds1klb9SPcERecorded 211019 - not great, might redo3B=M1. Quarter rests are artificially created; a bit awkward but useable. Recommend rerecording for more natural sound, and accompaniment doesn't necessarily have to take the rest, just the melody or if singers are encouragedd to take a breath. 10/19 B2 beautifulB2B2JY5/6/1900
100
96Amazing Gracehttps://youtu.be/e06718qHHRUhttps://drive.google.com/drive/folders/19ACLedleA0T3E8eZS2R8hFyrCQftI6Jo?usp=sharing56v.2 last chord cut off 1 beat early; v.4, v.5 last chord slightly cut off. En m4a missing. Ch m4a: has fading in/out from editing, a bit choppy at the end. Otherwise clean. B2: Clear and ready to publish. En/Chm4a: clean; piano action is a little uneven in the EnglishB2B2B2JY11/18/2021