Framework Action to Modify Mutton Snapper and Gag Management Measures
 Share
The version of the browser you are using is no longer supported. Please upgrade to a supported browser.Dismiss

 
View only
 
 
Still loading...
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
1
TimestampEnter your full nameemail addressCity, State, Zip CodeCheck all that applyComments
2
8/23/2016 8:35:40Test TestTesting@123.comTesting, FL 55555OtherTest. This is a test.
3
8/23/2016 8:37:38Test twotesttwo@testing.comtest, fl 55555Private Recreational AnglerThis is test number two.
4
12/21/2016 13:39:20Samuel H. Youngyoung456@aol.comMarco Island, FL, 34145Private Recreational Angler, Charter/Headboat For-Hire
2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag

Of the two known spawning aggregation sites, FWC and NOAA need to get on the same page. At all the hearings up and down the coast, with the exception of Key West, everyone agreed to close the 1 sq. mile of Riley's Hump from fishing during the spawning months of May, June and July. The economics of the Key West based commercial, charter, and head boat 's outweighed the science of protecting the breed stock; a tragedy in my opinion which should be rectified so we don't have to deal with additional rules as set forth; 2.1 thru 2.5

5
12/21/2016 14:05:22Jerry Keyesjkeyes3548@gmail.comNaples, FL 34113Private Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag

Of the two known spawning aggregation sites, FWC and NOAA need to get on the same page. At all the hearings up and down the coast, with the exception of Key West, everyone agreed to close the 1 sq. mile of Riley's Hump from fishing during the spawning months of May, June and July. The economics of the Key West based commercial, charter, and head boat 's outweighed the science of protecting the breed stock; a tragedy in my opinion which should be rectified so we don't have to deal with additional rules as set forth; 2.1 thru 2.5
6
12/21/2016 14:24:52Mike Larsenmike_larsen@keysight.comMarco Island, FLPrivate Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag
7
12/21/2016 14:35:08Howard Laskauhlaskau@comcast.netMarco island, FL 34145Private Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag


Of the two known spawning aggregation sites, FWC and NOAA need to get on the same page. At all the hearings up and down the coast, with the exception of Key West, everyone agreed to close the 1 sq. mile of Riley's Hump from fishing during the spawning months of May, June and July. The economics of the Key West based commercial, charter, and head boat 's outweighed the science of protecting the breed stock; a tragedy in my opinion which should be rectified so we don't have to deal with additional rules as set forth; 2.1 thru 2.5
8
12/21/2016 14:41:07Connell doughertyConnell564@aol.comMarco island, florida 34145Private Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag

Of the two known spawning aggregation sites, FWC and NOAA need to get on the same page. At all the hearings up and down the coast, with the exception of Key West, everyone agreed to close the 1 sq. mile of Riley's Hump from fishing during the spawning months of May, June and July. The economics of the Key West based commercial, charter, and head boat 's outweighed the science of protecting the breed stock; a tragedy in my opinion which should be rectified so we don't have to deal with additional rules as set forth; 2.1 thru 2.5
9
12/21/2016 15:44:46Charles Schwaljec.schwalje@comcast.netMarco Island, FL 34145Private Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag

Of the two known spawning aggregation sites, FWC and NOAA need to get on the same page. At all the hearings up and down the coast, with the exception of Key West, everyone agreed to close the 1 sq. mile of Riley's Hump from fishing during the spawning months of May, June and July. The economics of the Key West based commercial, charter, and head boat 's outweighed the science of protecting the breed stock; a tragedy in my opinion which should be rectified so we don't have to deal with additional rules as set forth; 2.1 thru 2.5
10
12/21/2016 16:04:56Paul MiliciPaul.milici@gmail.comMarco Island, FL,34145Private Recreational Angler, Charter/Headboat For-Hire, Commercial FisherFailure to close the one square mile Rileys Ridge during the spawning season is irresponsible.
11
12/21/2016 16:57:35Jon Kramerjnkramer84@aol.comNAPLES FL 34113Private Recreational AnglerOf the two known spawning aggregation sites, FWC and NOAA need to get on the same page. At all the hearings up and down the coast, with the exception of Key West, everyone agreed to close the 1 sq. mile of Riley's Hump from fishing during the spawning months of May, June and July. The economics of the Key West based commercial, charter, and head boat 's outweighed the science of protecting the breed stock; a tragedy in my opinion which should be rectified so we don't have to deal with additional rules as set forth; 2.1 thru 2.5
12
12/21/2016 18:17:07John W Jonesjwjones2@live.com34145Private Recreational Angler
2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag
13
12/21/2016 19:35:31Tony . SAPUTOsaputotc@comcast.netMarco IslandPrivate Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1 no action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5 per person year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish per person per day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" total length
2.5 Alternative 2 24" total length for commercial gag
14
12/22/2016 9:25:35Joel Rohletterjoel.rohletter@gmail.comMarco IslandPrivate Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag
15
12/22/2016 11:21:55david hoydjameshoy@aol.comMarco IslandPrivate Recreational Angler2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag
16
12/29/2016 11:15:50Kevin grieffKgrieff2012@gmail.comNaples fl 34109Private Recreational Angler
2.1 Alternative 1, No Action
2.2 Alternative 4d 5/person/year round
2.3 Alternative 3c 5 fish/person/day
2.4 Alternative 3 18" Total Length
2.5 Alternative 2, 24" Total Length for Commercial Gag

Of the two known spawning aggregation sites, FWC and NOAA need to get on the same page. At all the hearings up and down the coast, with the exception of Key West, everyone agreed to close the 1 sq. mile of Riley's Hump from fishing during the spawning months of May, June and July. The economics of the Key West based commercial, charter, and head boat 's outweighed the science of protecting the breed stock; a tragedy in my opinion which should be rectified so we don't have to deal with additional rules as set forth; 2.1 thru 2.5
17
3/16/2017 5:14:24Calvin G. Douglascalvindouglas42@gmail.comSt. PetersburgPrivate Recreational Angler After reading the draft on Mutton Snapper I think that including mutton's in the snapper aggregate bag limit in the northern gulf counties (Sarasota county Northward) is unfair to recreational fisherman simply because mutton snappers are a rear catch this far north. I have fished the inshore and offshore waters of Sarasota, Manatee,and Pinellas county out to 40 miles for the past 20 years and I have only caught one mutton snapper. I have spoken to many for-hire captains and crew as well as fellow recreational fisherman and only a hand full have ever caught a mutton in this region. I have viewed thousands of hours of film footage via the internet and television for this region to include the middle grounds and the mutton snapper is a very rear catch. This suggest to me that they do not migrate to this region nor do we see evidence of large concentration of resident fish on the wrecks and reefs in the region. I
recommend the snapper aggregate be separated:

(Cat 1) Mutton snapper (Cat 2) Gray snapper
Cubera snapper Yellowtail snapper
Queen snapper Silk snapper
Blackfin snapper
Wenchman snapper

These two categories of snapper with it's own 10 fish bag limit for the northern Gulf region of the State is my recommendation . I think this is a fair to the recreation fisherman simply because Cat 1 snapper is rear in our region and found primarily in deep water.
Thank you for allowing the general public to voice there opinion. I hope me recommendation is taken seriously and included in the draft as Alternative 4.
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
Loading...
 
 
 
Form Responses 1