ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZAA
1
Research focus
2
This systematic mapping aims to explorer what are the state-of-the-art processes and methodologies for publishing linked open government data
3
4
Research questions
5
R1 - What are the common steps among the different methodologies proposed?
6
R2 - How were the methodologies evaluated empirically?
7
R3 - What steps were described with accompanying tools to support the task?
8
R4 - What kinds of validations were employed to assure better data quality practices?
9
10
Search string# studies
Date: 05/abr/2019
29/02/2020Comments
11
Scopus:39( TITLE-ABS-KEY ( ( process OR methodology OR pipeline OR guideline OR "best practices" OR framework ) ) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY ( ( publishing OR publication OR production OR release ) ) AND TITLE-ABS-KEY ( ( "linked government data" OR "linked open government data" OR "government linked data" OR "government open linked data" OR ( "open government" AND ( "linked data" OR "linked open data" ) ) ) ) )
12
ACM:25( process OR methodology OR pipeline OR guideline OR "best practices" OR framework ) AND ( publishing OR publication OR production OR opening ) AND ( "linked government data" OR "linked open government data" OR "government linked data" OR "government open linked data" OR ( "open government" AND ( "linked data" OR "linked open data" ) ) )ACM Digital Library does not support long queries anymore. Thus, we performed the query on the left considering only one field at a time: title, abstract, author keywords, and used their intersection. The field 'Abstract' returned all of the papers.TitleAbstractAuthor keywords
13
IEEE Explorer: 6(("Abstract":process OR "Abstract":methodology OR "Abstract":pipeline OR "Abstract":guideline OR "Abstract":"best practices" OR "Abstract":framework ) AND ("Abstract":publishing OR "Abstract":publication OR "Abstract":production OR "Abstract":release) AND ("Abstract":"linked government data" OR "Abstract":"linked open government data" OR "Abstract":"government linked data" OR "Abstract":"government open linked data" OR ("Abstract":"open government*" AND ("Abstract":"linked data" OR "Abstract":"linked open data") ) ))

OR ( ("Document Title":process OR "Document Title":methodology OR "Document Title":pipeline OR "Document Title":guideline OR "Document Title":"best practices" OR "Document Title":framework ) AND ("Document Title":publishing OR "Document Title":publication OR "Document Title":production OR "Document Title":release) AND ("Document Title":"linked government data" OR "Document Title":"linked open government data" OR "Document Title":"government linked data" OR "Document Title":"government open linked data" OR ("Document Title":"open government*" AND ("Document Title":"linked data" OR "Document Title":"linked open data") )))
14
Science Direct: 2(publishing OR publication OR production OR opening) ( "linked government data" OR "linked open government data" OR "government linked data" OR "government open linked data" OR ( "open government" ( "linked data" OR "linked open data" ) ) )The search restricts up to 8 booleans in the string, so we adapted the search: title-abstract-keywords use the terms on the left and we manually filtered for the other terms.
15
ISI Web Of Knowledge24TI=( ( process OR methodology OR pipeline OR guideline OR "best practices" OR framework ) AND ( publishing OR publication OR production OR release ) AND ( "linked government data" OR "linked open government data" OR "government linked data" OR "government open linked data" OR ( ("open government" OR "open governmental") AND ("linked data" OR "linked open data") ) ) )

TS=( ( process OR methodology OR pipeline OR guideline OR "best practices" OR framework ) AND ( publishing OR publication OR production OR release ) AND ( "linked government data" OR "linked open government data" OR "government linked data" OR "government open linked data" OR ( ("open government" OR "open governmental") AND ("linked data" OR "linked open data") ) ) )
We combined two different searches and used their intersection: one using TI (Title) and the other using TS (Topic), in "Advanced search". The results were: TI=0 and TS=24.
16
SpringerLink462( process OR methodology OR pipeline OR guideline OR "best practices" OR framework )
AND ( publishing OR publication OR production OR release )
AND ( "linked government* data" OR "linked open government* data" OR "government* linked data" OR "government* open linked data"
OR ("open government*" AND ("linked data" OR "linked open data")) )		SpringerLink only supports full-text search.
17
Google Scholar100(methodology OR process OR pipeline OR guideline OR "best practices" OR framework AND (publishing OR publication OR production OR opening) AND ("linked government data" OR "linked open government data" OR "government linked data" OR "government open linkeddata" OR ("open government" AND ("linked data" OR "linked open data") ) )I only used the first ten pages
18
19
20
Inclusion criteria
21
IC1-The study presents a publishing methodology for LOGD as main contribution
22
23
Exclusion criteria
24
CE1- The study does not present a process or method for producing LOGD
25
CE2- The study's language is English
26
CE3- The study is a short version or previous study of another one in the list
27
CE4- The study focuses in a particular application, without presenting a generic process
28
CE5- The file is not available for download
29
CE6- The study investigates just a phase of the process, not it as a whole
30
CE7- The study does not investigate linked data
31
CE8- The study is not from a conference, journal, book chapter or workshop
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100