| A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Number | Error | Suggested Edit | Reasoning | Model & Version | Section | Status | Endorsed Correction | Edited in | Comment | ||||||||||||
2 | 1 | In cases where substance from an instance of E64 Persistent Item continues to exist in a new form | In cases where substance from an instance of E77 Persistent Item continues to exist in a new form | Wrong class code | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | E64 End of Existence | Resolved | In cases where substance from an instance of E77 Persistent Item continues to exist in a new form | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
3 | 2 | E95 - - Spaceime Primitive | E95 - - Spacetime Primitive | Typo in the word "Spacetime" | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | CIDOC CRM Class Hierarchy | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Previously resolved; not present in v.7.1.2 | ||||||||||||
4 | 3 | P174 starts before (starts after the start of): E2 Temporal Entity | P174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of): E2 Temporal Entity | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | E2 Temporal Entity | Resolved | P174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of): E2 Temporal Entity | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
5 | 4 | P175 starts before or with the start of (starts with or after the start of): E2 Temporal Entity | P175 starts before or with the start of (starts after or with the start of): E2 Temporal Entity | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | E2 Temporal Entity | Resolved | P175 starts before or with the start of (starts after or with the start of): E2 Temporal Entity | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
6 | 5 | P182 ends before or with the start of (starts with or after the end of): E2 Temporal Entity | P182 ends before or with the start of (starts after or with the end of): E2 Temporal Entity | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | E2 Temporal Entity | Resolved | P182 ends before or with the start of (starts after or with the end of): E2 Temporal Entity | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
7 | 6 | Sir Ian McKellan (E21) | Sir Ian McKellen (E21) | Typo in the name "McKellen" | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | E39 Actor | Resolved | Typo in the name "McKellen" | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
8 | 7 | The more specific criteria that determine the identity of instances of subclasses of E77 Persistent Item may vary considerably and are described of referred to in the respective scope notes. | The more specific criteria that determine the identity of instances of subclasses of E77 Persistent Item may vary considerably and are described or referred to in the respective scope notes. | Typo in the word "or" | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | E77 Persistent Item | Resolved | The more specific criteria that determine the identity of instances of subclasses of E77 Persistent Item may vary considerably and are described or referred to in the respective scope notes. | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
9 | 8 | relevant characteristics use to be sufficiently similar to recognize the instance for some substantial period of time. | relevant characteristics used should be sufficiently similar to recognize the instance for some substantial period of time. | Missing verb | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | E77 Persistent Item | Resolved | relevant characteristics used should be sufficiently similar to recognize the instance for some substantial period of time. | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
10 | 9 | E13 Attribute Assignment P177 assigned property of type: E55 Type | E13 Attribute Assignment. P177 assigned property of type: E55 Type | Missing dot | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | P2 has type (is type of) | Resolved | E13 Attribute Assignment. P177 assigned property of type: E55 Type | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
11 | 10 | E13 Attribute Assignement | E13 Attribute Assignment | Typo in the word "Assignment" | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchy | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Previously resolved; not present in v.7.1.2 | ||||||||||||
12 | 11 | E15 Identifier Assignement | E15 Identifier Assignment | Typo in the word "Assignment" | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchy | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Previously resolved; not present in v.7.1.2 | ||||||||||||
13 | 12 | E15 Identifier Assignement | E15 Identifier Assignment | Typo in the word "Assignment" | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchy | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Previously resolved; not present in v.7.1.2 | ||||||||||||
14 | 13 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1 | Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchy | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
15 | 14 | P151 was formed from: E74 Group | P151 was formed from (participated in): E74 Group | Missing inverse property | CRMbase in English v.7.1.1 | E66 Formation | Resolved | P151 was formed from (participated in): E74 Group | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
16 | 15 | the instance of E7 Event it is intended to be preparation for. | the instance of E5 Event it is intended to be preparation for. | Wrong class code | CRMbase in English v.7.1.1 | P20 had specific purpose (was purpose of) | Resolved | the instance of E5 Event it is intended to be preparation for. | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
17 | 16 | life-span and can infer, that they must | life-span and can infer that they must | No need to include a comma | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P93 took out of existence (was taken out of existence by) | Resolved | life-span and can infer that they must | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
18 | 17 | The instance of P21 Person being born | The instance of E21 Person being born | Wrong class code | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P96 by mother (gave birth) | Resolved | The instance of E21 Person being born | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
19 | 18 | P79(x,y) ⇒ E52 (x) | P79(x,y) ⇒ E52(x) | No space | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P79 beginning is qualified by | Resolved | P79(x,y) ⇒ E52(x) | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
20 | 19 | the UK to the USA. (Wildfang, 2005) | the UK to the USA (Wildfang, 2005) | No period in the examples | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E9 Move | Resolved | the UK to the USA (Wildfang, 2005) | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
21 | 20 | 2nd November 2019. | 2nd November 2019 | No period in the examples | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E9 Move | Resolved | 2nd November 2019 | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
22 | 21 | The direction of the assigned property type | The direction of the assigned property of type | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P177 assigned property of type | Resolved | The direction of the assigned property of type | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
23 | 22 | silver cup February 1997 (E13) assigned property type P52 has former | silver cup February 1997 (E13) assigned property of type P52 has former | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P177 assigned property of type | Resolved | silver cup February 1997 (E13) assigned property of type P52 has former | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
24 | 23 | the silver cup donated by Martin Doerr (E15) assigned property type P48 has preferred identifier | the silver cup donated by Martin Doerr (E15) assigned property of type P48 has preferred identifier | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P177 assigned property of type | Resolved | the silver cup donated by Martin Doerr (E15) assigned property of type P48 has preferred identifier | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
25 | 24 | Sinai Greek 418 (E13) assigned property type binding structure type (E55) | Sinai Greek 418 (E13) assigned property of type binding structure type (E55) | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P177 assigned property of type | Resolved | Sinai Greek 418 (E13) assigned property of type binding structure type (E55) | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
26 | 25 | MS Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property type damage (E55.) [‘damage’ | MS Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type damage (E55.) [‘damage’ | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P177 assigned property of type | Resolved | MS Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type damage (E55.) [‘damage’ | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
27 | 26 | Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property type quality (E55). [‘quality’ refers | Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type quality (E55). [‘quality’ refers | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P177 assigned property of type | Resolved | Sinai Greek 418 (E14) assigned property of type quality (E55). [‘quality’ refers | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
28 | 27 | querying for the above presented five properties will provide answer to all | querying for the five high-level properties in figure 1 will provide answer to all | Unclear reference to properties - narratively incorrect | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Relations with Events | Resolved | querying for the five high-level properties in figure 1 will provide answer to all | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
29 | 28 | 1689 (Gleick,2003) | 1689 (Gleick, 2003) | Missing space | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E85 Joining | Resolved | 1689 (Gleick, 2003) | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
30 | 29 | 0,n P2 is type of 0,n | 0,n P2 has type 0,n | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Figure 1 | Resolved | 0,n P2 has type 0,n | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
31 | 30 | 0,n P7 took place on or within (witnessed) 0,n | 0,n P8 took place on or within (witnessed) 0,n | Wrong property code | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Figure 4 | Resolved | 0,n P8 took place on or within (witnessed) 0,n | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
32 | 31 | Scope N/note: | Scope Note: | Consistency | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Multiple throughout | Resolved | Scope note: | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Sentence capitalization | ||||||||||||
33 | 32 | ...may all be members of instances of E74 Group.An instance of E74 Group... | ...may all be members of instances of E74 Group. An instance of E74 Group... | Space needed before "An" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P107 has current or former member | Resolved | ...may all be members of instances of E74 Group. An instance of E74 Group... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
34 | 33 | Instances of E74 Group and E21 Person, may all be members... | Instances of E74 Group and E21 Person may all be members... | Comma grammatically incorrect | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P107 has current or former member | Resolved | Instances of E74 Group and E21 Person may all be members... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
35 | 34 | The painting of the Sistine Chapel (E7) carried out by Michaelangelo Buonaroti | The painting of the Sistine Chapel (E7) carried out by Michelangelo Buonaroti | Typo in name "Michelangelo" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P14 performed | Resolved | The painting of the Sistine Chapel (E7) carried out by Michelangelo Buonaroti | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
36 | 35 | ...extracted from different items of jewellry... | ...extracted from different items of jewellery... | Typo in word "jewellery" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E80 Part Removal | Resolved | ...extracted from different items of jewellery... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
37 | 36 | ...discourse the CIDOC CRM aims to define and analyze. | ...discourse the CIDOC CRM aims to define and analyse. | American spelling | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E59 Primitive Value | Resolved | ...discourse the CIDOC CRM aims to define and analyse. | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
38 | 37 | fr [French] (Rickard, 1974) | fr [French] (Rickard, 1974) | Extra space between "fr" and "[French]" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E56 Language | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Previously resolved; not present in v.7.1.2 | ||||||||||||
39 | 38 | el [Greek] (Palmer, 1980) | el [Greek] (Palmer, 1980) | Extra space betweel "el" and "[Greek]" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E56 Language | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Previously resolved; not present in v.7.1.2 | ||||||||||||
40 | 39 | [24.75 million GBP (Brithish Pounds)] | [24.75 million GBP (British Pounds)] | Typo in the word "British" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E54 Dimension | Resolved | [24.75 million GBP (British Pounds)] | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
41 | 40 | the vertical height of the statue of David by Michaelangelo | the vertical height of the statue of David by Michelangelo | Typo in name "Michelangelo" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E54 Dimension | Resolved | the vertical height of the statue of David by Michelangelo | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
42 | 41 | resulting from the particular method or calculation. | ...resulting from the particular method of calculation. | Typo - "of" not "or" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E54 Dimension | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Previously resolved; not present in v.7.1.2 | ||||||||||||
43 | 42 | ...the surface of the Eearth... | ...the surface of the Earth... | Typo in the word "earth" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E53 Place | Resolved | ...the surface of the Earth... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
44 | 43 | [Identifier for “The Unesco courier (Print)”] | [Identifier for “The UNESCO Courier (Print)”] | UNESCO is an acronym; journal title is capital | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E42 Identifier | Resolved | [Identifier for “The UNESCO Courier (Print)”] | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
45 | 44 | Postal addresses, telephone numbers, urls and e-mail addresses... | Postal addresses, telephone numbers, URLs and e-mail addresses... | URL is an acronym | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E42 Identifier | Resolved | Postal addresses, telephone numbers, URLs and e-mail addresses... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
46 | 45 | ‘Cereus hildmannianus K.Schumann’, July 2003 | ‘Cereus hildmannianus K. Schumann’, July 2003 | Space missing between "K." and "Schumann" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E17 Type Assignment | Resolved | ‘Cereus hildmannianus K. Schumann’, July 2003 | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
47 | 46 | (Honey & Pickwoad , 2010) | (Honey & Pickwoad, 2010) | Extra space between name and comma | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E13 Attribute Assignment | Resolved | (Honey & Pickwoad, 2010) | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
48 | 47 | ...may be analyzed into component phenomena | ...may be analysed into component phenomena | American spelling | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E5 Event | Resolved | ...may be analysed into component phenomena | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
49 | 48 | ...not further analyzed in the CIDOC CRM | ...not further analysed in the CIDOC CRM | American spelling | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Spatiotemporal Relations | Resolved | ...not further analysed in the CIDOC CRM | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
50 | 49 | ...which may continued to be used... | ...which may continue to be used... | Typo on "continue" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Temporal Relations | Resolved | ...which may continue to be used... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
51 | 50 | ...not further analyzed in the CIDOC CRM | ...not further analysed in the CIDOC CRM | American spelling | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Spatial Relations | Resolved | ...not further analysed in the CIDOC CRM | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
52 | 51 | ...events can be instances of combinations of these and others classes... | ...events can be instances of combinations of these and other classes... | Typo on "other" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Relations with Events | Resolved | ...events can be instances of combinations of these and other classes... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
53 | 52 | ...intended scope can be increased on demand without loosing compatibility: | ...intended scope can be increased on demand without losing compatibility: | "Lose" not "loose" | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Exensions of the CRM | Resolved | ...intended scope can be increased on demand without losing compatibility: | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
54 | 53 | ...utterances, behavior and products. | ...utterances, behaviour and products. | American spelling | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Reality, Knowledge Bases and CIDOC CRM | Resolved | ...utterances, behaviour and products. | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
55 | 54 | ...such as the center of Earth or the sun... | ...such as the centre of Earth or the sun... | American spelling | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Reality, Knowledge Bases and CIDOC CRM | Resolved | ...such as the centre of Earth or the sun... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
56 | 55 | Person is both, an Actor and a Biological Object | Person is both an Actor and a Biological Object | Comma grammatically incorrect | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Terminology | Resolved | Person is both an Actor and a Biological Object | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
57 | 56 | ...and other collections... | ...and other collections... | Extra space | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Scope of the CRM | Resolved | ...and other collections... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
58 | 57 | ...starting from well-understood, actually and widely used concepts ... | ...starting from well-understood, actual, and widely used concepts ... | Grammatic error | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Scope of the CRM | Resolved | ...starting from well-understood, actual, and widely used concepts ... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
59 | 58 | The reasons for this distinctions... | The reasons for these distinctions... | Grammatic error | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | Scope of the CRM | Resolved | The reasons for these distinctions... | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
60 | 59 | Joining events allow for describing people becoming members of a group | Joining events allow for describing actors becoming members of a group | Too specific word according to the ontology (not sure if it's a "small edit") | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | P143 joined (was joined by) | Resolved | Joining events allow for describing actors becoming members of a group | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Also corrected in P144 (v. 7.2.2) | ||||||||||||
61 | 60 | Denmark and Greenland February 1. 1985 | Denmark and Greenland February 1ˢ ͭ 1985 | Wrong data format | CRMbase in English v.7.2 | E86 Leaving | Resolved | Denmark and Greenland February 1ˢ ͭ 1985 | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
62 | 61 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E3 Condition State | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
63 | 62 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E61 Time Primitive | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
64 | 63 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E61 Time Primitive | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
65 | 64 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E93 Presence | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
66 | 65 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P1 is identified by (identifies) | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
67 | 66 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P170 defines time (time is defined by) | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
68 | 67 | E52 Time Span | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P170 defines time (time is defined by) | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
69 | 68 | E52 Timespan | E52 Time-Span | Typo in the word "Time-Span" (missing "-") | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E92 Spacetime Volume | Resolved | E52 Time-Span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
70 | 69 | P173 starts before or with the end of (ends with or after the start of) | P173 starts before or with the end of (ends after or with the start of) | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E2 Temporal Entity | Resolved | P173 starts before or with the end of (ends after or with the start of) | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
71 | 70 | P173 starts before or at the end of | P173 starts before or with the end of | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P174 starts before the end of (ends after the start of) | Resolved | P173 starts before or with the end of | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
72 | 71 | P182 ends before or at the start of | P182 ends before or with the start of | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P183 ends before the start of (starts after the end of) | Resolved | P182 ends before or with the start of | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
73 | 72 | P182 ends before or at the start of | P182 ends before or with the start of | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P185 ends before the end of (ends after the end of) | Resolved | P182 ends before or with the start of | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
74 | 73 | P182 ends before or at the start of | P182 ends before or with the start of | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Table 4: CIDOC CRM Property Hierarchy | Resolved | P182 ends before or with the start of | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
75 | 74 | P182 ends before or at the start of | P182 ends before or with the start of | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P176 starts before the start of (starts after the start of) | Resolved | P182 ends before or with the start of | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
76 | 75 | E92 Space Time Volume | E92 Spacetime Volume | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E93 Presence | Resolved | E92 Spacetime Volume | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
77 | 76 | The painting known as the “The Mona Lisa” is an instance of the class Human Made Object. | The painting known as the “The Mona Lisa” is an instance of the class E22 Human-Made Object. | Wrong class label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Terminology | Resolved | The painting known as the “The Mona Lisa” is an instance of the class E22 Human-Made Object. | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
78 | 77 | Human Made Object | Human-Made Object | Wrong class label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Introduction to the basic concepts | Resolved | Human-Made Object | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
79 | 78 | P4 has time span | P4 has time-span | Wrong property label | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Spatiotemporal Relations | Resolved | P4 has time-span | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
80 | 79 | "time span" / "timespan" | "time-span" | Consistency | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Multiple throughout | Resolved | "time-span" | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
81 | 80 | "February 1st 1985" vs. "1st of February 1985" vs. "1st February 1985" | Day Month Year - eg. "1st February 1985" | Consistency | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Multiple throughout | Resolved | Day Month Year - eg. "1st February 1985" | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
82 | 81 | P184 ends before or with the end of (ends with or after the end of) | P184 ends before or with the end of (ends after or with the end of) | Consistency with other related time properties (eg. P173-176, P182-185) | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P184 ends before or with the end of (ends with or after the end of) | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Could be made an issue; decision to leave (March 2022) | ||||||||||||
83 | 82 | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 19 755 until 9th April 1768 | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768 | Error in date | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P167 was within (includes) | Resolved | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768 | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
84 | 83 | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 19 755 until 9th April 1768 | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768 | Error in date | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P195 was a presence of (had presence) | Resolved | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768 | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
85 | 84 | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 19 755 until 9th April 1768 | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768 | Error in date | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | P197 covered parts of (was partially covered by) | Resolved | Johann Joachim Winkelmann’s whereabouts from 19th November 1755 until 9th April 1768 | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
86 | 85 | "In First Order Logic" not mentioned in CIDOC CRM Class Declarations section | The line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the class in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notation | All other sections are mentioned | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | CIDOC CRM Class Declarations | Resolved | The line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the class in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notation | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Discussed over email (March 2022) | ||||||||||||
87 | 86 | "In First Order Logic" not mentioned in CIDOC CRM Property Declarations section | The line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the property in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notation | All other sections are mentioned | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | CIDOC CRM Property Declarations | Resolved | The line “In First Order Logic:” expresses the formal constraints of the property in terms of logical axioms in a First Order Logic notation | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Discussed over email (March 2022) | ||||||||||||
88 | 87 | "Subproperty of" not mentioned in CIDOC CRM Property Declarations section | The line “Subproperty of:” is a cross-reference to any superproperties the property may have | All other sections are mentioned | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | CIDOC CRM Property Declarations | Resolved | The line “Subproperty of:” is a cross-reference to any superproperties the property may have | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | Discussed over email (March 2022) | ||||||||||||
89 | 88 | many to one, necessary (1,n:0,n) | many to many, necessary (1,n:0,n) | Wrong quantification text | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 | P81 ongoing throughout | Rejected | N/A | N/A | This has been vetted by CEO | ||||||||||||
90 | 89 | one to many, necessary (1,n:0,n) | many to many, necessary (1,n:0,n) | Wrong quantification text | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 | P99 dissolved (was dissolved by) | Rejected | N/A | N/A | This has been vetted by CEO | ||||||||||||
91 | 90 | one to many, necessary, dependent (1,n:0,n) | many to many, necessary (1,n:0,n) | Wrong quantification text | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 | P161 has spatial projection (is spatial projection of) | Rejected | N/A | N/A | This has been vetted by CEO | ||||||||||||
92 | 91 | be described by the property P177 assigned property type: E55 Type. | be described by the property P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned): E55 Type. | Missing word in the property label AND Missing the inverse label | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 | E13 Attribute Assignment | Resolved | be described by the property P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned): E55 Type. | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
93 | 92 | should be documented using P177 assigned property type. | should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned). | Missing word in the property label AND Missing the inverse label | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 | P140 assigned attribute to (was attributed by) | Resolved | should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned). | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
94 | 93 | should be documented using P177 assigned property type. | should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned). | Missing word in the property label AND Missing the inverse label | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 | P141 assigned (was assigned by) | Resolved | should be documented using P177 assigned property of type (is type of property assigned). | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
95 | 95 | Kira Weber working in glass art from 1984 to 1993 Kira Weber working in oil and pastel painting from 1993 | Add citations | Citations missing from these examples; is there a source to point to? | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | E7 Activity | Resolved | Weber, 2012 | CRMbase in English v.7.2.2 | |||||||||||||
96 | 99 | Figure 1 (page 35), "P2 is type of" | "P2 is type of" must be "P2 has type" in the figure, since the arrow starts from E1 and points to E55 | Minor change | CRMbase in English v.7.1.1 | Figure 1: High Level Properties and Classes of CIDOC CRM | Rejected | N/A | N/A | Already fixed - See Edit 29 | ||||||||||||
97 | 100 | In the Terminology section of the CIDOC CRM document, the entry "multiple inheritance" mentions classes but not properties. Although this is mentioned already in the entries "subclass" and "subproperty", it should be added here as well. | would be more systematic | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 | Terminology | Resolved | The same logic holds in an analogous manner for properties, instead of classes, with multiple immediate superproperties. | CRMbase in English v.7.2.2 | ||||||||||||||
98 | 101 | An instance of E16 Measurement may "us" simple counting or tools | An instance of E16 Measurement may "be" simple counting or tools | typo | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 (CIDOC CRM main documentation) | E16 Measurement - Scope Note | Resolved | An instance of E16 Measurement may "use" simple counting or tools | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
99 | 102 | whereas basic techniques such as "carbon 14" dating should be encoded | whereas basic techniques such as "carbon-14" dating should be encoded | typo | CRMbase in English v.7.2.1 (CIDOC CRM main documentation) | E16 Measurement - Scope Note | Resolved | whereas basic techniques such as "carbon-14" dating should be encoded | CRMbase in English v.7.1.2 | |||||||||||||
100 | 103 | This "is" email will also be used to contact you if the editors have questions regarding your proposal. | This email will also be used to contact you if the editors have questions regarding your proposal. | typo | "CIDOC CRM - Small Edits" form | Introduction | Resolved | This email will also be used to contact you if the editors have questions regarding your proposal. | "CIDOC CRM - Small Edits" form |