Charter scoring - Wikimedia Summit Statements (shared with participants)

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G	H	I	J	K
1	#	Summit Statements - Deal Breakers	Support by Summit participants	Oppose by Summit participants	No Response at the Summit	Weight at the Summit (you can make a copy and add your own data on your preferences)	Final Charter	Score	Comments	# of participants	Participants who expressed support or opposition

2	1	1. The Global Council must have directly managed staff, which must report directly to the Global Council Board.	94	6	6	88,00	no	0		106	100
3	2	2. For resource distribution, there must be ‘full transparency’ added as a value at every level, for all parties, and to the criteria for decision-making.	91	8	7	82,17		0		106	99
4	3	3. There must be a process for the Global Council to be held accountable to the movement. The Charter must address how the Global Council’s work is evaluated by stakeholders.	87	4	15	75,53		0		106	91
5	4	4. There must be a clear separation of powers (e.g. decision-making and resource distribution) between the Global Council and Wikimedia Foundation. This must include a roadmap for transferring those powers over time, with an operational plan.	86	7	13	73,47		0		106	93
6	5	5. There must be clarity about Global Council Assembly composition and how its representatives are elected in the Charter from the outset.	83	10	13	67,89		0		106	93
7	6	6. There must be a more clearly expressed purpose of the Global Council which addresses strategy, finance and structure to improve decision-making in and for the movement.	83	5	17	68,64		0		105	88
8	7	7. There must be a regional budget for grant making that is equitable.	82	9	15	66,43		0		106	91
9	8	8. There must be an allowance for thematic organisations and chapters that cannot incorporate locally to operate with fiscal sponsors.	81	12	13	64,17		0		106	93
10	9	9. The Movement Charter must make it clear that fundraising is desirable but always optional for all movement bodies including Hubs and Movement partners.	81	6	19	65,25		0		106	87
11	10	10. We must have tangible commitments and actions to ensure that equity is central (such as training, peer support and capacity building), in order that the Movement embodies the world’s best examples of Human Rights.	80	6	20	63,64		0		106	86
12	11	11. Hubs and affiliates must have a right to participate in developing core technology.	78	12	16	59,40		0		106	90
13	12	12. The Global Council must be guaranteed an independent budget, separate from the Wikimedia Foundation’s general budget, which the Global Council handles autonomously. The Global Council’s budget has to be approved by its members.	72	17	17	48,95		0		106	89
14	13	13. Supplementary documents must have official status. They can be amended by simple resolution of the Global Council or one of its bodies.	70	15	21	46,75		0		106	85
15	14	14. The Global Council must be the highest decision-making body in the movement on strategy and budget.	66	19	21	39,95		0		106	85
16	15	15. There must be a cap so that no gender has more than 70% representation in Hub governing bodies.	64	26	16	34,20	no	0		106	90
17	16	16. There must be an increase in the baseline requirement to start a Hub. Minimum of three founding affiliate members. External organizations can join as a fourth founding member.	63	26	17	32,93		0		106	89
18	17	17. The Charter must develop a statement on the ‘basic right’ of all movement bodies to fundraise using ALL methods in accordance with the fundraising policy to be developed by the Global Council.	58	15	33	31,39		0		106	73
19	18	18. We must move the requirement for Hubs and Affiliates to participate in collaborations and partnerships to become only a right.	57	15	34	30,24		0		106	72
20	19	19. Processes must ensure that unorganized volunteers are significantly represented in regional batches of seats.	56	31	18	21,75		0		105	87
21	20	20. There must be clear differentiation of core and non-core spendings: Global Council must decide the non-core part, and governance structure of core spending must be evolved.	55	12	39	28,81		0		106	67
22	21	21. Processes must ensure that at least 40% of Global Council Assembly seats are occupied by non-male.	51	38	17	11,57		0		106	89
23						1101,13		0	0,00%
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100