3. FrequencySeverity Pervasive Game Elements.xlsx

	C	D	E	F	G
1
2		Dear Expert: When the set of evaluators have identified the various potential problems, all of these problems should be consolidated into this document. This document is then sent back to the evaluators to determine the severity and frequency of each of the problems. Severity: Indicates the level of impact the problem has on the game experience: (4) Castatrophic - (3) High - (2) Low - (1) Cosmetic - (0) Not a problem Frequency: Indicates how often the indicated problem occurs: (4) >90% - (3) 51% to 90% - (2) 11% to 50% - (1) 1% to 10% - (0) <1%
3
4
5	Problem definition	Comments/Explanations	Heuristics	Severity	Frequency
6	Application executes an action different from the purpose of the selected one.	In the number of players per team, press the button 3 persons and mark 2.	E05
7	Monotonous sounds	Sounds are monotonous during the course of the game	E02
8	No configuration of visual elements	Although there is a configuration button, it does not show elements to change the visual elements.	E01
9	Inability to change name after wrong name entry	Once a game has started it is not possible to change the name entered, this may be a mistake considering the physical abilities of some older adults. The impossibility of solving a problem that is present throughout the game can lead to feelings of frustration.	E03
10	Confrontational questions	The incorporation of historical questions referring to the political ideals of some participants can result in debates that break up the experience. This problem may be related to the age range and background of the participants.	E09
11	Missing demonstrative tutorial	The tutorial offered by the application shows the elements of the game, but does not indicate how to interact with them. An example of this is a demo with simple animations.	E04
12	No feedback between questions	The unanticipated appearance of alternatives after a loading period may cause a participant to select a response involuntarily.	E04
13	Distractors between questions	Between questions, distracting elements (player's name, timeline) can be displayed, which disappear and are relocated when the alternatives appear.	E01
14	No feedback on responses	The incorporation of a brief explanation of incorrect/correct answers would avoid discussion among participants and the feeling of frustration when answering incorrectly.	E09
15	Delayed reward	There is only one final reward and no intermediate reward after progressing through the questions.	E04
16	Limited auditory feedback	No sound is delivered if a question is answered right or wrong.	E02
17	Does not work Configuration	The game cannot be configured to change aspects such as "font size" or "brightness".	E03
18	Difficulty in date selection	To select the date, type the date digit by digit.	E07
19	Text size in selection options	The size of the text that appears in the selection options is very small in relation to its color container.	E01
20	The game design is repetitive	Answering questions with the same format and without any differentiation falls into repetition.	E01
21	No use of icons	It does not make use of icons to familiarize the user with the menu functions.	E01
22	No quick start	There is no shortcut to quickly start a game alone. A new user must register each time.	E07
23	The color of the chest lights is not distinguishable.	The color of the lights when approaching a card to the chest of memories is not distinguishable in bright ambient light.	E04
24	Progress is not shown	There is no board that allows you to see the progress a player has made over several games.	E05
25	Difficulty cannot be changed	It is not possible to change the difficulty of the game.	E06
26	Questions are not supported by an image	The questions are text only and are not supported by images or multimedia.	E01
27	No default avatar	When the avatar is not selected, only the name in text is displayed in the progress bar.	E08
28	No indication of the start of the round of questions is given	Once the game is finished being configured, the first question starts immediately. No screen is provided for the user to prepare to start.	E04
29	Button incorrect operation	The buttons on the setting screens do not respond as expected.	E07
30	In-game animations	It is not possible to see that the user's avatar or name moves forward when answering a question correctly. An animation is needed to visualize when the user advances in the timeline.	E06
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100