S3XMODITMANIA8 R1VOTE

	A	B	C	D	E	F	G
1	dangus	technique	spirit	enjoyment	composite	comment	author

2	infomercial wonderland.it	8	7	8	123	winnerstyle. good mixing & use of the weird samples. kind of repeaty but it's r1
3	The Lick Rangers.mptm	6	6	8	112	working with the hard samples. yasui vibes in the middle. buildup is nice but wish there was more section repeats (it's just like ABCDA), the only revisited theme is lick hidden in the melody?
4	cherry_blue.it	6	7	7	109	pro chords. feels beyond my understanding maybe because the phrases are all asymmetric lengths and there's no repeats (lol) arrangement is kind of bland like oops all organs
5	Third in Line.it	6	7	7	109	good atmosphere
6	phoinky.it	4	8	7	108	The Hihat Is Too Loud (also the kick is too long, the bass is too quiet). the rest is incredible though
7	appleworm.it	8	7	6	107	good variations on the "theme". too short pls make long next time. note scientists will be analyzing the chords in ptn5 for decades	keffie
8	Cave Waltz.it	6	6	7	104	respectable "humble vgm style, not compo winner style" (esp. first half), also good "phrygian major scale trope but not beating you over the head with it". not a waltz,
9	e-z.mptm	6	6	7	104	good buildup from "oh great, they just used the loops as-is" to "actually good arrangement", i wonder how many people missed the awesome ending since it looks like a loop.... just repeat the orderlist
10	Short Chillin.it	6	6	7	104	great entry from carly rae jepsen featuring toby fox
11	End of a Journey.it	8	6	6	102	the intro is totally on point but why does the payoff have to be... eurovision disco? it would be funny if it went right into the mario kart section and ended at ptn58. or actually some interesting edm bass instead of the disco octaves	mad
12	Outside is restricted.mptm	6	7	6	101	interesting harmony. taking the difficult path dealing with the jazz chords sample. probably too loopy & the second half is too loud (like, every channel and instrument is at max volume)
13	summer drive.it	6	7	6	101	13/8... kind of feels like it gave away everything by pattern 5. ok for background vgm style
14	heptagon industries.xm	6	6	6	96	always happy to hear the "tracker IDM" genre, and the pacing and atmosphere are legit. leans really heavily on chipping a sample down to a single square wave though... wish it used more of the samplepack
15	Butterfly Database.it	5	6	6	93	cute anime-ish. pretty hard to hear the harmony with no bass support. weird delay technique lol
16	thought library.it	6	7	4	85	interesting ideas here, although just seems like 2 unrelated songs (actually the first section is probably "2 unrelated songs at the same time"). sq wave lead near the end is way too loud...
17	desperate.mptm	5	4	6	83	the final section before the outro is nice. although between that and the intro it's just like this two-chord buildup with not a lot of interesting textures, particularly because the bass is just "square wave plus...stuff i can't hear"
18	Aeolian.xm	2	6	5	76	on the 3rd listen i think i got the VI-VII-i "hook". what are these drums though. the middle section that repeats at increasing tempo doesn't really work for me either
19	O Astronauta Drogado.it	5	3	5	70	essentially 1 pattern, classic OHC style. if you heard this in a c64 game in the 80s you'd get totally pogged up. but nothing really to remember here besides the drums
20	ancientsanctum.it	2	5	4	63	there are some parts with good harmony (ptn 0) but the rest i am not convinced any of the voices relate to each other in any way. the drum line rhythm (by itself, of course) got interesting towards the end
21	Hop-Along.it	5	3	4	62	this is like either a badly-remembered or copyright-avoiding cover of Jazz Jackrabbit Menu so it's hard to judge it on its own (considering the original makes sense harmonically and this one doesn't). most of the channels sound ok in isolation where some technical effort was clearly put in but the overall arrangement doesn't work
22	Blue Warbler.it	3	4	4	61	i get the concept but it's like when you have to play some public-domain blues song arranged for middle school band. (ptn 28) trumpet chords -> can't help but think of Minor Key Twinkle Twinkle Little Star
23	what did you just say to me.mptm	-1	-1	-1	-16	i like the cut-short cadences. feels slightly cookie-cutter for authorcore. i guess i usually counter weird samples w/safe composition
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100