Post Dear-Colleague Letter, College/University Setbacks

	A	B	C	D	E
1	Case	Date	Judge	Court	disposition
2	Thomas Rossley, Jr. v. Drake University	12-Oct-18	Rebecca Ebinger	U.S. District Court, Iowa	university motion for summary judgment denied (TIX, breach of contract) (granted on ADA, promissory estoppel claims) (MTD previously denied, 11 Aug. 2017)
3	John Doe v. Regents of the University of California, et al. (UCSB)	9-Oct-18	Arthur Gilbert	California Appeals Court, Second District, Division Six	writ of mandate (reversed superior court)
4	John Doe v. Belmont University, et al.	27-Sep-18	Waverly Crenshaw	U.S. District Court, Tennessee, Middle Dist.	judgment on pleadings (promissory estoppel only)
5	John Doe v. University of LaVerne*	27-Sep-18	Mary Strobel	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
6	John Doe v. University of Southern Mississippi, et al.	26-Sep-18	Keith Starrett	U.S. District Court, Mississippi, Southern Dist.	preliminary injunction
7	John Doe v. Timothy White, et al. (Cal Poly)	21-Sep-18	Mitchell Beckloff	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
8	J. Lee v. University of New Mexico, et al.	20-Sep-18	James Browning	U.S. District Court, New Mexico	MTD
9	John Doe v. Syracuse University	16-Sep-18	Thomas McAvoy	U.S. District Court, New York, Northern Dist.	MTD
10	John Doe v. David Baum	7-Sep-18	Amul Thapar	U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit	MTD (petition for en banc hearing denied)
11	John Doe v. Brown University	27-Aug-18	John McConnell	U.S. District Court, Rhode Island	MTD
12	John Doe v. Penn State University et al.	21-Aug-18	Matthew Brann	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Middle Dist.	MTD
13	John Doe v. Timothy White (Cal St.-Long Beach)	14-Aug-18	James Chalfant	Los Angeles (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
14	John Doe v. George Washington University	14-Aug-18	Rosemary Collyer	U.S. District Court, District of Columbia	partial summary judgment (flawed appeals procedures) (preliminary injunction denied 25 Apr. 2018)
15	John Doe v. Claremont McKenna College	8-Aug-18	Helen Bendix	California Appeals Court, Second District, Division One	writ of mandate (reverses superior court)
16	John Doe v. University of Mississippi, et al.	24-Jul-18	Daniel Jordan, III	U.S. District Court, Mississippi, Southern Dist.	MTD (motion for preliminary injunction denied, 17 Aug. 2018)
17	Jeremy Rowles v. Curators of the University of Missouri, et al.*	16-Jul-18	Brian Wimes	U.S. District Court, Missouri, Western Dist.	MTD
18	John Doe v. Timothy White, et al. (Cal Poly)	12-Jul-18	James Chalfant	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
19	John Doe v. University of Michigan, et al.	6-Jul-18	Arthur Tarnow	U.S. District Court, Michigan, Eastern Dist.	preliminary injunction/TRO (appealed to CA6)
20	John Doe, et al. v. Boston College, et al.	8-June-18	Juan Torruella	U.S. Court of Appeals, First Circuit	denial of summary judgment to university, reversed district court
21	John Doe v. Trustees of the California State University, et al.	30-May-18	James Chalfant	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
22	John Doe v. Johnson & Wales University	14-May-18	John McConnell	U.S. District Court, Rhode Island	MTD (TIX, university conceded breach of contract for purposes of motion)
23	John Doe v. Philip DiStefano	7-May-18	William Martinez	U.S. District Court, Colorado	MTD (due process; previously had granted MTD for TIX claim)
24	Christian Werner et al. v. Albright College	2-May-18	Edward Smith	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Eastern Dist.	MTD (case was then settled)
25	John Doe v. Ohio State University, et al.	24-Apr-18	James Graham	U.S. District Court, Southern Dist., Ohio	university motion for summary judgment rejected, student's claim of right to witness testimony reconsidered (MTD previously denied, 7 Nov. 2016) (TRO previously denied, 22 Jan. 2016)
26	Jane Roe v. Javaune Adams-Gaston, et al.	17-Apr-18	Edmund Sargus, Jr.	U.S. District Court, Southern Dist, Ohio	preliminary injunction
27	John Doe v. Regents of the University of California (UCLA)	4-Apr-18	James Chalfant	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	motion for stay
28	In the Matter of Hall v. Hofstra University	3-Apr-18	Randy Sue Marber	Nassau County (NY) Supreme Court	Article 78, disciplinary record expunged
29	Caleb Elmore v. Bellarmine University	29-Mar-18	Joseph McKinley	U.S. District Court, Kentucky, Western Dist.	preliminary injunction
30	John Doe v. University of Oregon, et al.	26-Mar-18	Ann Aiken	U.S. District Court, Oregon	MTD
31	Troy Daly v. Emory University	March-17	Charles Seeliger	DeKalb (GA) Superior Court	motion for stay, renewed August 2017 (https://emorywheel.com/27356-2/)
32	In the Matter of Jason West v. SUNY-Buffalo	16-Mar-18	per curiam`	Appellate Division (NY) Fourth Department	Art. 78, disciplinary record expunged
33	John Doe v. Marymount University, et al.	15-Mar-18	T.S. Ellis, III	U.S. District Court, Eastern Dist., Virginia	MTD, case was then settled
34	Jason Schaumleffel v. Muskingum University, et al.	6-Mar-18	George Smith	U.S. District Court, Southern District, Ohio	MTD
35	Marvin Powell v. St. Joseph's University, et al.	16-Feb-18	Jan DuBois	U.S. District Court, Pennsylvania, Eastern Dist.	MTD, case was then settled
36	John Doe v. Duke University	13-Feb-18	Orlando Hudson	Durham County (NC) Superior Court	injunction, guilty finding overturned
37	John Doe v. Miami University	9-Feb-18	Karen Moore	U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit	MTD (reversed district court opinion)
38	Tyler Gischel v. University of Cincinnati, et al.	23-Jan-18	Susan Dlott	U.S. District Court, Southern Dist., Ohio	MTD
39	John Doe v. Rider University	17-Jan-18	Brian Martinotti	U.S. District Court, New Jersey	MTD
40	Matthew Jacobson v. Butterfly Blaise	11-Jan-18	Michael Lynch	Appellate Division (NY) Third Department	Article 78, remanded to SUNY-Plattsburgh for new hearing
41	John Doe v. Penn State University et al.	8-Jan-18	Matthew Brann	U.S. District Court, Middle Dist. Pennsylvania	MTD (TRO previously granted, 18 Aug. 2017)
42	John Doe v. Regents of the University of California, et al. (UCSB)	22-Dec-17	Donna Geck	Santa Barbara County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (university later held in contempt for not following order in good faith)
43	John Doe v. Ainsley Carry, et al.	20-Dec-17	Elizabeth White	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
44	John Doe v. Westmont College, et al.	12-Dec-17	Thomas Anderle	Santa Barbara County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
45	Kathak Saravanan v. Drexel University	24-Nov-17	Mark Kearney	U.S. District Court, Eastern Dist., Pennsylvania	MTD, case was then settled
46	John Doe v. Regents of the University of California	15-Nov-17	Tom Rogers	Alameda County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate, disciplinary record expunged
47	Kyle Carrington v. Liberty University	15-Nov-17	Norman Moon	U.S. District Court, Western Dist., Virginia	MTD, case was then settled
48	In the Matter of John Doe v. RPI	6-Nov-17	Raymond Elliott, III	Rensselear County (NY) Supreme Court	Art. 78, disciplinary record expunged
49	Gregory Painter v. Jonathan Adams, et al.	17-Oct-17	Max Cogburn	U.S. District Court, West. District, North Carolina	university motion for summary judgment rejected, case was then settled
50	John Doe v. Samuel Glick (Pomona College)	16-Oct-17	Mary Strobel	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate (new court challenge after Pomona put student through new hearing)
51	John Doe v. St. Mary's (MD) College	2-Oct-17	Sean Wallace	St. Mary's County (MD) Circuit Court	vacating disciplinary finding, case was then settled
52	John Doe v. University of Cincinnati	25-Sep-17	Paul Griffin	U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit	preliminary injunction (affirmed district court granting of preliminary injunction, 20 Nov. 2016) (district court subsequently denied MTD, 28 March 2018)
53	John Doe v. University of Chicago	20-Sep-17	Edmond Chang	U.S. District Court, Northern Dist., Ohio	MTD, case was then settled
54	Matthew Rolph v. Hobart and William Smith Colleges	20-Sep-17	Elizabeth Wolford	U.S. District Court, Western Dist., New York	MTD
55	John Doe v. Ainsley Carry	15-Sep-17	Richard Fruin, Jr.	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
56	John Doe v. University of Pennsylvania	13-Sep-17	John Padova	U.S. District Court, Eastern Dist., Pennsylvania	MTD, case was then settled
57	John Doe v. Case Western Reserve University, et al.	01-Sep-17	Donald Nugent	U.S. District Court, Northern Dist., Ohio	MTD, case was then settled
58	Frank Gulyas v. Appalachian State, et al.	28-Aug-17	Richard Voorhees	U.S. Distict Court, West. District, North Carolina	MTD (motion for reconsideration denied) (case then was settled)
59	John Nokes v. Miami University	25-Aug-17	Michael Barrett	U.S. District Court, Southern Dist., Ohio	preliminary injunction, case was then settled
60	Cameron Jackson v. Liberty University, et al.	03-Aug-17	Norman Moon	U.S. District Court, Western Dist. Virginia	MTD, case was then settled
61	Nicholas Mancini v. Rollins College	20-Jul-17	Roy Dalton	U.S. District Court, Middle Dist. Florda	MTD, case was then settled
62	In the Matter of John Doe v. Skidmore College	13-Jul-17	Elizabeth Garry	Appellate Division (NY) Third Department	college directed to re-admit student & expunge his record
63	Koh Tsuruta v. Augustana University	16-Jun-17	Karen Schreier	U.S. District Court, South Dakota	MTD, case was then settled (judge had previously denied motion for preliminary injunction)
64	Connor Culiver et al. v. United States of America et al. (USMMA)	15-Jun-17	Leonard Wexler	U.S. District Court, New York, Eastern Dist.	order allowing plaintiffs to participate in graduation, receive notice of charges (case was then settled)
65	John Doe v. La Sierra University	08-Jun-17	Irma Asbery	Riverside Co. (CA) Superior Court	petition for writ of mandate
66	John Doe v. University of Notre Dame	08-May-17	Philip Simon	U.S. District Court, Northern Dist. Indiana	TRO/preliminary injunction, case was then settled
67	John Doe v. Williams College	28-Apr-17	Michael Ponsor	U.S. District Court, Massachusetts	MTD
68	John Doe v. University of California Santa Barbara et al.	21-Mar-17	Thomas Anderle	Santa Barbara County (CA) Superior Court	petition for writ of mandate (appeal dropped by University of California)
69	John Doe v. Ohio State University	10-Mar-17	George Smith	U.S. District Court, Northern Dist., Ohio	MTD
70	John Doe v. University of St. Thomas	01-Mar-17	John Tunheim	U.S. District Court, Minnesota	MTD
71	John Doe v. Amherst College	28-Feb-17	Mark Mastroianni	U.S. District Court, Massachusetts	MTD, case was then settled
72	Grant Neal v. Colorado State University-Pueblo	16-Feb-17	Craig Schaffer	U.S. District Court, Colorado	MTD, case was then settled
73	John Doe v. Eric Rivera (San Diego State University)	01-Feb-17	Joel Wohlfiel	San Diego County (CA) Superior Court	vacated disciplinary finding against accused student, case was then settled
74	In the Matter of John Doe v. Cornell University	20-Jan-17	Eugene Faughnan	Tompkins County (NY) Supreme Court	Article 78, req'd complaint against Cornell process to be investigated
75	John Doe v. Lynn University	19-Jan-17	Robin Rosenberg	U.S. District Court, Southern Dist. Florida	MTD, case was then settled
76	John Doe v. Western New England University	11-Jan-17	Michael Ponsor	U.S. District Court, Massachusetts	MTD, case was then settled
77	John Doe v. Jonathan Alger, et al.	23-Dec-16	Elizabeth Dillon	U.S. District Court, Western Dist. Virginia	summary judgment in favor of accused student (MTD had previously been denied on 31 March 2016)
78	John Doe v. University of Oregon	13-Dec-16	Curtis Conover	Lane County (OR) Circuit Court	vacated disciplinary judgment against accused student
79	Abdullatif Arishi v. Washington State University	01-Dec-16	Laurel Siddoway	Division III, Washington Court of Appeals	vacated disciplinary judgment against accused student
80	Garrett Collick et al. v. William Patterson University, et al.	17-Nov-16	Kevin McNulty	U.S. District Court, New Jersey	MTD (CA3 rejected interlocutory appeal on qualified immunity grounds, 26 Oct. 2017)
81	John Doe v. Brown University	28-Sep-16	William Smith	U.S. District Court, Rhode Island	bench trial, judge vacated disciplinary finding against accused student
82	John Doe v. Case Western Reserve University, et al.	1-Aug-16	Jose Villanueva	Cuyahoga County (OH) Court of Common Pleas	MTD (case was then settled)
83	John Doe v. Columbia University	29-Jul-16	Pierre Laval	U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit	reversed district court, case was then settled
84	Samuel Ritter v. Oklahoma City University	22-July-16	Joe Heaton	U.S. District Court, Western Dist. Oklahoma	MTD (preliminary injunction granted 17 July 2016) (case was then settled)
85	John Doe v. Cornell University (Weill Medical School)	20-May-16	William Pauley, III	U.S. District Court, Southern Dist. New York	TRO, case was then settled
86	John Doe v. Board of Regents, Univ. of Georgia	19-Apr-16	Steve Jones	U.S. District Court, Northern Dist., Georgia	MTD, case was then settled (motion for preliminary injunction previously denied, 16 Dec. 2015)
87	John Doe v. University of Southern California	05-Apr-16	Aubrey Collins	CA Court of Appeals Second District, Division Four	vacated disciplinary judgment against accused student
88	John Doe v. Brandeis University	31-Mar-16	F. Dennis Saylor	U.S. District Court, Massachusetts	MTD, plaintiff then withdrew lawsuit to pursue OCR complaint
89	Jeremiah Marshall v. Indiana University	15-Mar-16	Tanya Walton Pratt	U.S. District Court, Southern Dist. Indiana	MTD, case was then settled
90	John Doe v. The Rectors and Visitors of George Mason Univ.	25-Feb-16	T.S. Ellis, III	U.S. District Court, Eastern Dist. Virginia	summary judgment in favor of accused student (MTD had previously been denied on 16 Sept. 2015)
91	Vito Prasad v. Cornell University	24-Feb-16	Thomas McAvoy	U.S. District Court, Northern Dist. New York	MTD, case was then settled
92	John Doe v. Brown University	22-Feb-16	William Smith	U.S. District Court, Rhode Island	MTD, case was then settled with a judicial decree expunging record & declaring Brown breached contract
93	Michigan St. Univ. Student #A44797612 v. Michigan St. Univ.	17-Feb-16	Clinton Canady	Ingram County (MI) Circuit Court	expulsion overturned, student allowed to graduate
94	John Doe v. The Pennsylvania State University	06-Nov-15	Matthew Brann	U.S. District Court, Middle Dist. Pennsylvania	TRO, case was then settled & Penn State changed its procedures as court outlined
95	John Doe v. UCLA	15-Oct-15	James Chalfant	Los Angeles County (CA) Superior Court	writ of mandate
96	John Doe v. Donald Dudley	22-Sep-15	Timothy Fall	Yolo County (CA) Superior Court	TRO, case was then settled
97	John Doe v. Middlebury College	16-Sep-15	J. Garvan Murtha	U.S. District Court, Vermont	preliminary injunction, case was then settled
98	John Doe et al. v. Salisbury University et al.	21-Aug-15	James Bredar	U.S. District Court, Maryland	MTD, case was then settled
99	John Doe v. Washington and Lee University	05-Aug-15	Norman Moon	U.S. District Court, Western Dist. Virginia	MTD, case was then settled
100	Corey Mock v. University of Tennessee at Chattanooga	04-Aug-15	Carol McCoy	Davidson Co. (TN) Chancery Court	reinstated UTC's initial finding of not guilty