|Tipping Point Graphic Design Rubric|
|Realism and Adherence to Theme (25%)||- There is no apparent connection between the submission, and the details from the prompt or the established DB/SW canon. |
- The contents make no sense in the context presented and are not properly represented.
- Language used in the product is not appropriate for the Star Wars universe.
|- Some content from the product makes sense, where it's clear from the details it is in fact to carry out stated objectives, and appears to take place in Star Wars. |
- Little effort is given to the distinguishing characteristics of factions, forces, or individuals.
|- The product clearly meets the stated objective and everything makes sense within the Star Wars universe. |
- The units, factions, or individuals described feel vibrant and distinct.
- There are some minor exceptions within the product that break overall realism or DB/SW realism.
|- The product delivers exactly what was asked for in the prompt, and is clearly within the Dark Brotherhood universe.
- Not only do the groups or individuals described feel distinct and fleshed out, but the finish product feels like it was tailored specifically for the audience mentioned in the prompt.
|Graphical Elements (35%)||- The product is roughly composed, its elements are poorly drawn, copy/pasted or utilized, and there is no clear composition or direction|
- Elements are obviously artificial and poorly drawn, and the use of color or grayscale is inferior
- Elements used were not credited in the submission
- The design shows low effort and detail work
- Details are very few and far inbetween and the image looks fairly flat despite elements having volume
|- The product is a finished work whose shapes paint a clear, but very rough picture |
- Composition and direction choices are fairly good
- Artificial elements are few but obvious, and color or grayscale are rough, sloppy and in need of further balancing, but are done well enough to understand the image.
- The product shows a modicum of effort and detail work
- Details are well done but fairly obvious
- The image isn't flat but is obviously visually fake
|- The product is a finished work with few obvious errors|
- Elements look to be used with a good sense of direction and composition
- Colors or grayscale are well placed, well done, complementary to the image and well balanced. The composition if good and executed well.
- The product shows good effort and detail work
- The images are accurate to the subject matter, but the details are still obvious and add value to the overall image
- The product has good volume and depth
|- The product shows great effort and detail work|
- Details are abundant, subtle and add a richness and value to the overall image
- The product is visualy pleasing and "spot on" the subject matter
- It has excellent volume and depth and is overall superbly balanced.
|Textual Elements (30%)||- Spelling errors and mechanics of the written portions of the product have numerous errors. |
- The content is terribly formatted and presented and difficult to understand.
- No effort was made to improve the presentation.
|- Some spelling errors and mechanical issues in the plan distract from the message, but it is still clearly understood. |
- There is some semblance of format, though it still doesn't appear well thought out.
|- Only minor spelling errors and mechanical issues in the written portions of the product exist, allowing the focus to remain on the content and not the issues.
- There is a clear structure to the product that helps to convey everything going on to anyone reading it that assists in understanding.
- The message the creator intended to convey is clearly communicated.
|- There are few to no errors in the written portions of the product, with clean mechanics that make it easy to read.
- The product's message is clear and persuasive.
- The voice and diction help immerse the reader in the Dark Brotherhood setting.
- While the plan itself is well formatted with visual presentation done in a way that significantly aids in catching the attention of anyone reviewing it for understanding.
|Personal artistic preference (10%)||Don't like it at all||Don't like it||Like it||Love it|