ABCD
1
DateVoting matter at handResult of the voteAddendum or notes
2
25-03-2020Move King application starting date to 27-3 from 29-3?Yes, change it-
3
26-03-2020What claim hindrance should be maintained on a player, if any?Barred from King and HL claimsCan be relaxed further in the future, depending on conduct
4
26-03-2020Clarify rules re: removing app-based claimantYes, clarify the ruleFirst: always need 3/4ths of the mod team. Now: only need a majority if only <4 mods can vote
5
26-03-2020Length of King Claims Staying Open72 hours-
6
26-03-2020Who is to become owner of the discord server?Dasplatzchen-
7
26-03-2020Time limit on mod votes48 hoursMods will have 48 hours from tag to vote; yet uncast votes will be counted as abstensions
8
26-03-2020Should moderators be automatically removed for missing votes?Yes, they shouldUpon missing 3 of the last 7 mod votes, a mod will be automatically removed from the team
9
26-03-2020Are PCs from landed House claims allowed to form organizations?No, they are not-
10
26-03-2020Allowed to smut on other peoples' threads?No, not allowedRequired to create a new thread and move here for this purpose
11
29-03-2020Word limit for question portion of HL/L apps500 words-
12
29-03-2020Word limit for sample writing portion of HL/L apps500 words-
13
29-03-2020How long should HL/L apps stay open?48 hoursLeaves 48 hours for deliberation
14
29-03-2020Make changes to HL/L apps questions/word limit?Yes. 750 word limit for question portionIn addition, the question specifically for HLs was scrapped
15
31-03-2020Trigger permaban vote for the sub if permabanned on Discord?Yes-
16
31-03-2020First-come-first-serve claim possibility after apps?YesTo be held 10 PM UTC, 4th of april
17
01-04-2020Ban user from sub?Yes-
18
02-04-2020Ban or limit SCs from Kingdom's Appointed Council positions?Yes, ban SCs from Appointed Council positions.-
19
02-04-2020Accept draft claim list?Accept-
20
02-04-2020Referring to above vote on a user ban, temporary or permanent ban?Permanent ban-
21
02-04-2020Do widow(er)s count towards the initial marriage limit?No-
22
03-04-2020How many Houses can be listed in the FCFS thread?ThreeFCFS = First-Come-First-Serve
23
03-04-2020Allow fifth marriage tie to be used solely for FCFS houses?YesFCFS = First-Come-First-Serve
24
04-04-2020Accept /u/Iron_Fang as Arryn coclaimantYes-
25
05-04-2020Should PCs count as MaA in movement orders?YesMaA = men at arms, PC = Primary Character (this includes naval movement)
26
05-04-2020Do pregame bastards count toward relationship limit?Yes-
27
05-04-2020What claim hindrance should be maintained on a player, if any?Barred from King and HL claims-
28
05-04-2020Should PC's count as MaA for battles?YesLimit needs further discussion, like children
29
05-04-2020Should SC's count as MaA for battles and untrained for duelsYesLimit needs further discussion, like children, maesters etc
30
05-04-2020When dueling, MaA have no skill and levies have a malus of -5Yes-
31
07-04-2020Revote on bastards at start of gameNeither should count-
32
09-04-2020Should Dornish parties treat desert tiles as grasstiles?Yes-
33
09-04-2020Should Dornish parties get a bonus to retreat rolls?No-
34
10-04-202070% of the army is required to be of a specific culture for non-movement cultural bonus?Yes-
35
10-04-2020
100% of the army is required to be of a specific culture to get a movement cultural bonus?
No-
36
11-04-2020Changing capacity of II longships from 40 to 30?No-
37
11-04-2020Change II River speed? Lower it from 2x speed to 1.5x speed-
38
11-04-2020Change the battle bonuses given to II, Arbor and Dragon Isles?All bonuses cut-
39
11-04-2020Make it easier to detect portaging troops?YesGive detection rolls for portaging troops a +2
40
11-04-2020Can Mini Kingdom have Council Positions?YesLimited to 3 (MoC, MoW, Master of War/Ships; no HotK and no custom spot) with halved salaries
41
11-04-2020Can a PC be transferred to another claim in the event of an unclaiming?Modify rules-
42
12-04-2020Host new mod apps?Yes-
43
12-04-2020Vote on to ban player due to behavior on the Discord server?YesVote for length will be held
44
14-04-2020When should players get word of their fisheries being raided?Similar rolls to hamlets-
45
14-04-2020Should players be able to raise MaA when under siege?Yes, up until their MaA are 60% raised-
46
14-04-2020Shoud players be able to raise levies when under siege?No-
47
15-04-2020What happens when one occupies a hamlet of another claim?Gold & food income can be siphonedLevies can only be raised after a 'peace deal' where hamlet changes hands
48
15-04-2020Should people be able to use constructed languages in game?Yes, with a translation in the post/comment.-
49
16-04-2020Can moderators handle their own modmails for simple, non-conflict things?No-
50
16-04-2020Should casualties be rounded up or down?Down-
51
17-04-2020Adopt Alchemist Guild proposal?YesMechs found under organisation rules
52
17-04-2020How much food does a castle have avaiable to it in a siege?See notes --->
food storages + (x/12)(food production - food consumption of the year the siege started) with x being the month before the siege started
53
17-04-2020Metagaming complaintWarnings-
54
17-04-2020Should org bases be visible on the main map?Yesplayers can opt to have their rural base hidden but only if it is in a forest, mountain, desert or swamp tile, or in the stepstones.
55
18-04-2020What should happen if a character is erroneously eliminated from a tournament?Move on & award major succ. they would've had-
56
21-04-2020What happens if a bridge holdfast is besieged from mult. sides & sallies against one?They'll instantly teleport back into castleAs such, the other besieging army can not assault the holdfast while the garrison is in the sally battle
57
22-04-2020Should teleportation in the RL be banned?Yes-
58
22-04-2020What happens to PCs over the 12 start cap if one coclaimant unclaims?Nothing, remaining claimant keeps all-
59
22-04-2020Reclaim exemptionGranted-
60
23-04-2020Age maluses for young age?ImplementedSee character mechanics rules
61
24-04-2020Metagaming complaintWarning-
62
26-04-2020Should smut be moved away from public threads, even if it's their own thread?Yes-
63
26-04-2020Should user be banned?Permanent ban-
64
26-04-2020Should commander bonuses casualty reductions be changed?YesSee character mechanics rules
65
26-04-2020Should there be a minimum cost for poisons to count as a major success?Yes, 9k-
66
26-04-2020Should major injuries impact dueling skill?YesSee character mechanics rules
67
26-04-2020How should food available in sieges be rounded?Fraction rounded down-
68
26-04-2020Accept timeframe of major injury maluses?Accepted-
69
27-04-2020Remove Hand as a mandatory council position?Removed, added another custom spot-
70
27-04-2020Change Death Cap and Wolfsbane poison costs?Change to 10k-
71
27-04-2020Urban organisation's trade rangeGet trade range of all their bases' towns/cities-
72
28-04-2020Assaulting keeps clarificationMust wait 48 hoursAn army that assaults a keep and fails to take it must wait 48 hours before assaulting it again
73
02-05-2020Do captured ports count as friendly ports for open water rolls resetting? Yes-
74
02-05-2020Do hostile fleets initiate siege as soon as they take harbor?YesThe 60% MaA raising cap and starvation penalties apply upon ship arrival
75
02-05-2020Naval death rollsSee notes --->Death rolls exclusively determined by deciding which PCs are on a ship beforehand; if ship sinks, PCs die.
76
02-05-2020Disable automod ping?YesAutomod ping broken; subsequently it has been disabled and all orders require modmails.
77
07-05-2020Rolling mod applications?YesDue to being short-staffed, mod applications have been changed to a rolling basis. they are always open
78
08-05-2020Harsher unlanding penalties?Inconclusive-
79
08-05-2020TP BansSee notes --->RL TP ban lifted; North TP banned; II TP banned
80
09-05-2020White Harbor and Faircastle allowed to build longships?Yes-
81
09-05-2020Should lower the # of ships required to patrol a port town hub?YesReduced to 5
82
09-05-2020Character death roll exception requestRejected-
83
10-05-2020Terrain modifier changeAcceptedSee land combat page
84
12-05-2020SC Bodyguard Stat AdjustmentAcceptedSC Bodyguards have a 30% chance of protecting the character they are guarding
85
13-05-2020Limiting SC BodyguardsAcceptedSC Bodyguards are limited to 1 per PC
86
13-05-2020Metagaming complaintWarnings-
87
15-05-2020OOC/IC conduct complaintNo Action-
88
18-05-2020VS/Artifact Competition VotesSee notes --->Houses/orgs chosen for VS/artifact public vote
89
18-05-2020Plagiarism complaintWarning & deletion of post-
90
18-05-2020Player over word limit for VS entryDisqualified-
91
19-05-2020Metagaming complaintWarning-
92
20-05-2020Reclaim exemptionGranted-
93
20-05-2020Claim removalYes-
94
20-05-2020Metagaming complaintWarning-
95
22-05-2020Should the game be frozen until further notice?YesAll time and mech orders paused.
96
22-05-2020Should new threads be temporarily disallowed?YesCan only post threads on sub if an approved user.
97
over several daysJoint InvestigationPunishments -->Warnings, temp bans, and perma bans issued.
98
25-05-2020Vote reformSee notes --->Informal warnings removed. Strike system implemented (every 3rd warning = temp ban, 3rd temp ban = perma ban).
99
28-05-2020Scene retconApproved-
100
28-05-2020Reclaim exemptionGranted-