ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ
1
CATEGORY: SONG
2
VALUATION CRITERIA/ MARKING1= Basic2= Average3= Good4= Very Good5= Excellent
3
Music Composition
4
MelodySimplistic, uninspiredMonotonous without purpose or a faithful reproduction of a melody from an app or another electronic source throughout the entire piece.It supports the lyrics with few interesting momentsOriginal, easily memorable to the listener, and perfectly highlights the lyrics.Excellent and full melody that stays with the listener
5
RhythmSimplistic or a faithful reproduction of a rhythm from an app or another electronic source throughout the entire piecePredictable or mismatched with the melodyRhythm that supports the song, without peculiaritiesA rhythm that perfectly supports the melody and the meaning of the lyricsComplex and original rhythm that enriches the song
6
HarmonyHarmonization inconsistent with the lyrics or melodyUnmatched harmony with the style of the music and the meaning of the lyricsIndifferent harmonization that somewhat highlights the lyricsInteresting harmonization that greatly highlights the lyricsOriginal and creative harmony
7
StructureSimple and predictable structureStructure without cohesionGood structure, with logical developmentComplex and interesting structureOriginal structure that surprises the listener
8
Lyrics
9
QualityLyrics simplisticLyrics without particular poetic valueVerses with proper meter and meaning but poor vocabularyLyrics that make the listener think and move with rich vocabulary and metaphorsLyrics with high poetic value and originality
10
DepthLyrics superficial and without meaningLyrics with few and simple ideasLyrics that touch some feelingsLyrics with depth and meaning that cause reflectionLyrics that touch deep existential issues
11
OriginalityLyrics commonplace and repetitiveLyrics without originalityLyrics with some original ideasLyrics with original images and metaphorsLyrics with completely original themes and expression
12
MeaningLyrics without meaningLyrics with vague or meaningless meaningLyrics with meaning that is understoodLyrics with meaning that provokes thoughts and feelingsLyrics with deep and multifaceted meaning
13
Performance
14
Vocal PerformanceDissonant performance of the songNot a completely tonally correct song, which has some expressive momentsCorrect tonal performance without musicality and expressionCorrect tonal expressive performance of the song with a nice voice timbreExcellent vocal performance with unique timbre and expressiveness
15
Musical DexteritySimplistic performanceMonotonous performance without skillWell performed with satisfactory techniqueDexterous performance with impressive momentsExcellent craftsmanship that elevates the song
16
ExpressivenessIndifferent and inexpressive performanceTypical unemotional performancePerformance with some emotional expressionExpressive and passionate performanceExceptionally expressive and moving performance
17
Creativity and Originality
18
New IdeasIndifferent, commonplace ideasCommon ideas delivered in a beautiful wayOriginal ideas without general meaningOriginal ideas with nice content and emotionCompletely pioneering and innovative ideas
19
InfluencesA faithful copy of a well-known song with a different verseObvious influence from a well-known song with some personal elementsCreative incorporation of influencesOriginal and creative synthesis of influencesCreation of a new and unique style based on the influences
20
Production
21
Sound QualityPoor sound quality with noise and distortionsModerate sound quality without clarityGood sound quality with clarity and balanceVery good sound quality with rich and clear soundExcellent sound quality that highlights the details of the song
22
Sound MixingSimple and careless sound mixingSound mixing without balanceSatisfactory sound mixingGood and balanced sound mixingArtful and creative sound mixing that highlights the elements of the song
23
Overall Impact
24
InfluenceSong without particular influence or appealSong with little influence on few listenersSong that touches some listenersSong with great influence and appeal to the publicSong that inspires and deeply affects listeners
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100